Agreeing to Disagree: The Economics of Betting Exchanges

Whelan, Karl (2025): Agreeing to Disagree: The Economics of Betting Exchanges.

Abstract

Betting exchanges match people to take opposite sides of a bet. We present a model of a betting exchange in which participants disagree about outcome probabilities but are, on average, correct. Traders maximize subjective expected profits and equilibrium emerges from a simple matching process. The model predicts those who post quotes (Makers) will earn higher returns than those who accept them (Takers) and that loss rates for Takers will rise as the probability of their accepted bet winning falls. Using a large sample of bets on soccer from Betfair Exchange, we implement a transaction-level empirical strategy that identifies Maker and Taker sides of each trade. We show that pre-match and early in-play behavior aligns closely with the model’s predictions. However, as matches progress, behavior shifts: longshot bets generate large, systematic losses even for liquidity providers, and profits emerge for those who accept offers on favorites.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Betting Exchanges, Bid-Ask Spreads, Betfair, Matching, Thick and Thin Markets
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D83 - Search ; Learning ; Information and Knowledge ; Communication ; Belief ; Unawareness; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G14 - Information and Market Efficiency ; Event Studies ; Insider Trading

References

Ali, Mukhtar (1977). ``Probability and Utility Estimates for Racetrack Bettors,'' \textit{Journal of Political Economy}, Volume 85, pages 803-815.

Angelini, Giovanni, and Luca De Angelis (2019). ``Efficiency of Online Football Betting Markets,'' \textit{International Journal of Forecasting}, Volume 35, pages 712–721.

Angelini, Giovanni, Luca De Angelis and Carl Singleton (2022). ``Informational Efficiency and Behaviour Within In-Play Prediction Markets,'' \textit{International Journal of Forecasting}, Volume 38, pages 282-299

Berg, Joyce, Forrest Nelson and Thomas Rietz (2008). ``Prediction Market Accuracy in the Long Run.'' \textit{International Journal of Forecasting}, Volume 24, pages 285-300.

Berg, Joyce, and Thomas Rietz (2019). ``Longshots, Overconfidence and Efficiency on the Iowa Electronic Market,'' \textit{International Journal of Forecasting}, Volume 35, pages 271-287.

Burdett, Ken and Melvyn G. Coles (1997). ``Marriage and Class,'' \textit{Quarterly Journal of Economics}, Volume 112, pages 141–168

B\"{u}rgi, Constantin, Wanying Deng and Karl Whelan (2025). Makers and Takers: The Economics of the Kalshi Prediction Market. University College Dublin School of Economics working paper number 25/19.

Casadesus-Masanell, Ramon and Neil Campbell (2019). ``Platform Competition: Betfair and the UK Market for Sports Betting,'' \textit{Journal of Economics and Management Strategy}, Volume 28, pages 29–40.

Coleman, Thomas and Yuying Li (1996). ``An Interior Trust Region Approach for Nonlinear Minimization Subject to Bounds,'' \textit{SIAM Journal on Optimization}, Volume 6, pages 418-445.

Croxson, Karen and J. James Reade (2013). ``Information and Efficiency: Goal Arrival in Soccer Betting,'' \textit{Economic Journal}, Volume 124, pages 62–91.

Dennis, John and Robert Schnabel (1996). \textit{Numerical Methods for Unconstrained Optimization and Nonlinear Equations}. Philadelphia: Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics (SIAM).

Diamond, Peter (1982). ``Aggregate Demand Management in Search Equilibrium,'' \textit{Journal of Political Economy}, Volume 90, pages 881-894.

Elaad, Guy, J.\ James Reade and Carl Singleton (2020). ``Information, Prices and Efficiency in an Online Betting Market,'' \textit{Finance Research Letters}, Article 101291.

Forsythe, Robert, Forrest Nelson, George Neumann and Jack Wright (1992). ``Anatomy of an Experimental Political Stock Market,'' \textit{American Economic Review}, Volume 82, pages 1143-1161.

Franck, Egon, Erwin Verbeek, Stephan N\"{u}esch (2010). ``Prediction Accuracy of Different Market Structures — Bookmakers versus a Betting Exchange'' \textit{International Journal of Forecasting}, Volume 26, pages 448–459.

Gandhi, Amit and Ricardo Serrano-Padial (2015). ``Does Belief Heterogeneity Explain Asset Prices: The Case of the Longshot Bias,'' \textit{Review of Economic Studies}, Volume 82, pages 156-186.

Gautier, Pieter and Coen Teulings (2009). ``Search and the City,'' \textit{Regional Science and Urban Economics}, Volume 39, pages 251-265.

Hegarty, Tadgh and Karl Whelan (2024). ``Comparing Two Methods for Testing the Efficiency of Sports Betting Markets'', \textit{Sports Economics Review}, Volume 8, paper 100042.

Hegarty, Tadgh and Karl Whelan (2025). Market Structure and Prices in Online Betting Markets: Theory and Evidence, forthcoming, \textit{Oxford Economic Papers}.

Kahneman, Daniel (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Lee, Charles, and Mark Ready (1991). ``Inferring Trade Direction from Intraday Data,'' \textit{Journal of Finance}, Volume 46, pages 733–746.

Levitt, Steven (2004). ``Why Are Gambling Markets Organised So Differently From Financial Markets?,'' \textit{Economic Journal}, Volume 114, pages 223-246.

Mincer, Jacob and Arnold Zarnowitz (1969). ``The Evaluation of Economic Forecasts'' in \textit{Economic Forecasts and Expectations: Analysis of Forecasting Behavior and Performance.} New York: National Bureau of Economic Research.

Nelson, Sarah, Timothy Edson, Eric Louderback, Matthew Tom, Alessandra Grossman and Debi LaPlante (2021). ``Changes to the Playing Field: A Contemporary Study of Actual European Online Sports Betting,'' \textit{Journal of Behavioral Addictions}, Volume 10, 396–411.

Odders-White, Elizabeth R. (2000). ``On the Occurrence and Consequences of Inaccurate Trade Classification,'' \textit{Journal of Financial Markets}, Volume 3, pages 259–286.

Ottaviani, Marco and Peter Norman Sørensen (2008). ``The Favorite-Longshot Bias: An Overview of the Main Explanations,'' in \textit{Handbook of Sports and Lottery Markets}, Elsevier.

Ottaviani, Marco and Peter Norman Sørensen (2010). ``Noise, Information, and the Favorite-Longshot Bias in Parimutuel Predictions,'' \textit{American Economic Journal: Microeconomics}, Volume 2, pages 58-85.

Page, Lionel (2012). ```It Ain’t Over Till it's Over' Yogi Berra Bias on Prediction Markets,'' \textit{Applied Economics}, Volume 44, pages 81-92.

Pope, Peter and David Peel (1989). ``Information, Prices and Efficiency in a Fixed-Odds Betting Market,'' \textit{Economica}, Volume 56, pages 223-241.

Savage, Leonard  J.\ (1954). \textit{The Foundations of Statistics}. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Shanaev, Savva and Binam Ghimire (2021). ``Efficient Scholars: Academic Attention and the Disappearance of Anomalies,'' \textit{The European Journal of Finance}, Volume 27, pages 278-304

Shin, Hyun Song (1991). ``Optimal Betting Odds Against Insider Traders,'' \textit{Economic Journal}, Volume 101, pages 1179-1185.

Smith, Michael A.\, David Paton and Leighton Vaughan Williams (2006). ``Market Efficiency in Person-to-Person Betting,'' \textit{Economica}, Volume 73, pages 673–689.

Snowberg, Erik and Justin Wolfers (2008). ``Examining Explanations of a Market Anomaly: Preferences or Perceptions?'' in \textit{Handbook of Sports and Lottery Markets}, Elsevier.

Thaler, Richard and William Ziemba (1988). ``Anomalies: Parimutuel Betting Markets: Racetracks and Lotteries,'' \textit{Journal of Economic Perspectives}, 2, 161-174.

Theissen, Erik (2001). ``A Test of the Accuracy of the Lee–Ready Trade Classification Algorithm,'' \textit{Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money}, Volume 11, pages 147–165.

Whelan, Karl (2023). ``On Prices and Returns in Commercial Prediction Markets,'' \textit{Quantitative Finance}, Volume 23, pages 1699-1712.

Zaremba, Adam, Mehmet Umutlu and Alina Maydybura (2020). ``Where Have the Profits Gone? Market Efficiency and the Disappearing Equity Anomalies in Country and Industry Returns,'' \textit{Journal of Banking and Finance}, Volume 121. Article 105966.