Do Demonstration Effects Catalyse Private Investment in Infrastructure? Evidence from the African Water Sector

Leigland, James (2025): Do Demonstration Effects Catalyse Private Investment in Infrastructure? Evidence from the African Water Sector.

Abstract

Demonstration effects play a perplexing role in the theories of change adopted by development banks and donors. Such effects are said to be important but cannot be measured or their mechanics fully explained. They are important because these organizations do not have enough funding to help developing countries fully cover the costs of achieving ambitious targets like the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), they must try to mobilize the balance of needed investment from the private sector. Some forms of direct mobilization are measurable, but demonstration effects are indirect and almost impossible to quantify. In theory, they occur when the success of a project supported by a development partner encourages replication by others using less concessional support. The importance of demonstration effects has grown as it has become clear that measurable types of mobilization account for far less private investment than is needed to achieve targets like the SDGs. Development partners repeatedly affirm this importance by routinely invoking these effects to justify subsidization of private investment projects. But proof of their existence—and importance—remains elusive. This paper uses a literature review and a case study of a notable public-private water sector investment project in Rwanda to evaluate the performance of demonstration effects in mobilizing private investment in infrastructure. Although the many development partners who supported this project confidently claimed that its demonstration effects were powerful and would prompt replication elsewhere, this investigation concludes that the project would most likely discourage replication by reasonably knowledgeable observers. Such conclusions suggest the need to better understand the nature of demonstration effects, why their existence is so widely taken for granted, as well as the wisdom of setting highly ambitious development targets like the SDGs which cannot be reached without significant levels of private investment.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: demonstration effects; public-private partnerships; infrastructure; SDGs; blended finance; PIDG; World Bank; IFC; private investment
• Subjects: O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O16 - Financial Markets ; Saving and Capital Investment ; Corporate Finance and Governance; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O19 - International Linkages to Development ; Role of International Organizations

References

AfDB – Africa Development Bank. 2013. “Africa50: Questions and Answers.” Memorandum to the AfDB Board of Directors from Secretary General, C. Akintomide, July 16.

AfDB – Africa Development Bank. 2015. “Project Brief: Kigali Bulk Water Supply Project.” Dec. 15. https://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Documents/Project-and-Operations/Project_Brief_Bulk_Water_Supply_Project_Rwanda_2015.pdf

AfDB – Africa Development Bank. 2017. “Rwanda Sustainable Water Supply and Sanitation Program Appraisal Report,” November. https://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Documents/Boards-Documents/Rwanda__AR-_Sustainable_Water_Supply_and_Sanitation_Program.pdf

Afri Fund Capital. 2025. “Case Study: Kigali Bulk Water PPP Project – Replicable Success Factors,” April 1. https://afrifundcapital.com/kigali-bulk-water-ppp-project-replicable-success-factors/

African Review of Business and Technology. 2017. “Rwanda and Metito announce financial close of water supply PPP Project,” Nov. 27. https://africanreview.com/manufacturing/water-a-environment/rwanda-and-metito-announce-financial-close-of-water-supply-ppp-project

Attridge, S. and L. Engen. 2019. Blended Finance in the Poorest Countries: The Need for a Better Approach. London: Overseas Development Institute, April. https://www.odi.org/sites/odi.org.uk/files/resource-documents/12666.pdf

Bhattacharya, A., M. Romani, and N. Stern. 2012. “Infrastructure for Development: Meeting the Challenge.” Policy paper sponsored by The Centre for Climate Change Economics and Policy, the Grantham Research Institute on Climate Change and the Environment, in collaboration with the Intergovernmental Group of Twenty-Four on International Monetary Affairs and Development (G-24) (June).

Business Daily. 2023. “Roadmap for Successful Public Private Partnerships on Water,” September 20. https://www.businessdailyafrica.com/bd/data-hub/road-to-successful-water-provision-partnerships--4375288

Castalia Strategic Advisors. 2011. “Evaluation of the Demonstration Effect of IFC’s Involvement in Infrastructure in Africa, Final Report.” Report commissioned and funded by the IFC and the Private Infrastructure Development Group through DevCo, February. https://studylib.net/doc/18349592/evaluation-of-the-demonstration-effect-of-ifc-s-involveme...

Cattaneo, E. 2018. “Kigali Water: lessons from one of sub-Saharan Africa’s First water PPPs.” World Bank Blog, March 22. https://blogs.worldbank.org/ppps/kigali-water-lessons-one-sub-saharan-africa-s-first-water-ppps

CCE NEWS. 2017. “Rwanda’s Kigali Bulk Water Supply Project gets impetus,” November 27. https://cceonlinenews.com/news/rwandas-kigali-bulk-water-supply-project-gets-impetus/

CEPA – Cambridge Economic Policy Associates. 2012. "Infrastructure Consortium for Africa (ICA) Assessment of Project Preparation Facilities for Africa." Report to the ICA Secretariat, in association with Nodalis Conseil, September. https://www.icafrica.org/fileadmin/documents/Knowledge/ICA_publications/ICA-PPF-Study%20Report-ENGLISH-VOL%20A.pdf

Collier, P., N. Gregory, and A. Ragoussis. 2019. “Pioneering Firms in Fragile and Conflict-Affected States: Why and How Development Finance Institutions Should Support Them.” World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 8774. Washington DC: World Bank, March.

Compass. 2019. “Mobilising private finance through demonstration effects.” Compass Portfolio Evaluation 2. Final Report, December. https://iati.fcdo.gov.uk/iati_documents/55449840.pdf

Convergence. 2018. “Emerging Africa Infrastructure Fund LTD Case Study.” https://www.convergence.finance/resource/emerging-africa-infrastructure-fund-case-study/view

Cortes, S. 2016. “Blended Finance is a Missing Piece of the Water Puzzle.” Conservation Finance Network, September 28. https://www.conservationfinancenetwork.org/2016/09/28/blended-finance-is-missing-piece-of-the-water-puzzle

Cull, R., I. Gill, A. Pedraza, C. Ruiz-Ortega, and F. Zeni. 2024. “Mobilizing Private Capital for the Sustainable Development Goals.” Policy Research Working Paper 10838. Washington DC: World Bank, July.

De Schepper, S., E. Haeqendonck, and M. Dooms. 2015. “Understanding Pre-Contractual Transaction Costs for Public-Private Partnership Infrastructure Projects.” International Journal of Project Management 33 (4): 932–46.

EBRD – European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. 2012. "Multilateral Development Bank Principles to Support Sustainable Private Sector Operations," April 27. file:///C:/Users/JL/Downloads/MDBs%20Principles%20to%20Support%20Sustainable%20Private%20Sector%20Operations.pdf

Foster, V., C. M. Briceno-Garmendia. 2010. Africa’s Infrastructure: A Time for Transformation. AICD Flagship Report. Washington DC: World Bank.

Ghana Management Contract. 2005. Management Contract for Ghana Urban Water between Ghana Water Company Ltd. and Vitens Rand Water Services BV and Aqua Vita Ltd., October.

GIH – Global Infrastructure Hub. 2018. “Case Study Rwanda: Kigali Water supply Project.” https://cdn.gihub.org/umbraco/media/2330/gih_procurement-report_case-study_rwanda_final_web.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Gray, R.D. and J. Schuster. 1998. “The East Asian Financial Crisis—Fallout for Private Power Projects.” Public Policy for the Private Sector Note No. 146. Washington, DC: World Bank, August.

GWCL – Ghana Water Company Ltd. 2013. “Notice of Dissolution of Ghana Urban Water Ltd.” Public Notice, July 29.

Hutton, G. and M. Varughese. 2016. The Costs of Meeting the 2030 Sustainable Development Goal Targets on Drinking Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene. Washington D.C.: Water and Sanitation Program, World Bank.

IFC – International Finance Corporation. 2001. "OEG Findings: Annual Review of IFC’s Evaluation Findings: FY2000.” Operations Evaluation Group (OEG). Washington, DC: World Bank, July.

IFC – International Finance Corporation. 2012. "Blended Finance at IFC: IFC’s Approach to Blending Concessional Funds.” Report prepared for the IFC Board of Directors, March 15.

IFC – International Finance Corporation. 2015. “Rwanda: Kigali Bulk Water Project.” Public-Private Partnership Stories. Washington DC: World Bank Group, October. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/747691542225189578

IFC – International Finance Corporation. 2019. "IFC’s Anticipated Impact Measurement and Monitoring (AIMM) System: Project Assessment and Scoring Guidance Note.” Washington DC: IFC, March.

IFC – International Finance Corporation. 2020. Strategy and Business Outlook FY21-FY23: A Focus on Execution. Washington DC: IFC, April 9. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/402581596012370986/pdf/IFC-Strategy-and-Business-Outlook-FY21-FY23-A-Focus-on-Execution.pdf

Inderst, G. 2021. “Financing Development: Private Capital Mobilization and Institutional Investors.” Inderst Advisory - Discussion Paper, March 2021.

InfraPPP. 2017. “The Government of Rwanda and Metito announce the financial close of the Kigali Bulk Water Supply Project,” Nov. 28. https://www.infrapppworld.com/news/megaproject-1058-the-government-of-rwanda-and-metito-announce-the-financial-close-of-the-kigali-bulk-water-supply-project

Kotze, R., A. Ferguson, and J. Leigland. 2000. “Government Facilitation of Public-Private Infrastructure Projects: Lessons from South Africa.” Journal of Project Finance 6 (1): 47–64.

Lee, N. 2019. “Trillions for the SDGs? Time for a rethink.” OECD Development Matters. https://oecd-development-matters.org/2019/01/17/trillions-for-the-sdgs-time-for-a-rethink/

Leigland, J. 2003. "Managing the Threat of MAGA in Emerging PPP Markets: A Case Study from South Africa." The Journal of Structured and Project Finance 8(4):49-54.

Leigland, J. 2018. “Changing Perceptions of PPP Risk and Return: The Case of Brownfield Concessions.” The Journal of Structured Finance 23(4):47-56.

Leigland, J. 2020. Public-Private Partnerships in Sub-Saharan Africa: The Evidence-based Critique. Oxford: Oxford University Press, May.

Leigland, J. 2024. The Rise and Fall of Public–Private Partnerships: Finance, Infrastructure and Developing Countries. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing, November.

Lieberman, M. B. and D.B. Montgomery. 1998. “First-Mover (Dis)Advantages: Retrospective and Link with the Resource-based View.” Strategic Management Journal 19: 1111-1125.

Lin, J. Y., and D. Doemeland. 2012. “Beyond Keynesianism: Global Infrastructure Investments in Times of Crisis.” Policy Research Working Paper 5940. Washington, DC: World Bank.

Lion’s Head. 2018. "Demonstration Effects of EAIF and GuarantCo Transactions on Infrastructure Finance Markets." Final Report prepared for the Private Infrastructure Development Group (PIDG).

Marcelo, D., S. House, C. Mandri-Perrott, and J. Schwartz. 2017. “Do Countries Learn from Experience in Infrastructure PPP? PPP Practice and Contract Cancellation.” Policy Research Working Paper 8054. Washington, D.C.: World Bank, May.

Metito. 2018. Sustainability Report 2017-18. https://www.metito.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Sustainability_Report_2018_Web-Version.pdf

Metito Utilities. 2023. “Africa Receives Investment Boost to Develop Water Infrastructure,” March 15. https://www.metito.com/news-detail/africa-receives-investment-boost-to-develop-water-infrastructure-2/

MIGA – Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency. 2006. “Independent Evaluation Group (MIGA) 2006 Annual Report.” Independent Evaluation Group (MIGA) (IEG-MIGA). Washington, D.C.: World Bank, May 24.

MIGA – Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency. 2015. “Kigali Water Project,” November 17. https://www.miga.org/project/kigali-water-project

MIGA – Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency. 2018. “Kigali Bulk Water Supply Project.” https://www.miga.org/project/kigali-bulk-water-supply-project

Mishra, A. 2023. “The infrastructure catalyst: Analysing the impact of development finance institutions on private infrastructure financing in developing countries.” Centre for the Study of African Economies (CSAE) Working Paper, University of Oxford. https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:55236a2e-8783-4402-afbd be85561af571/files/s44558f965

ODI – Overseas Development Institute. 2018. Clean energy project preparation facilities: Mapping the global landscape. Research report prepared by D. Nassiry, S. Pickard, S. Whitley, A. Scott. London: ODI. https://odi.org/en/publications/clean-energy-project-preparation-facilities/

OECD – Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. 2015. Blended Finance: Mobilising resources for sustainable development and climate action in developing countries. OECD Policy Perspectives, October.

OECD – Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. 2017. Blended Finance Vol. 1: A Primer for Development Finance and Philanthropic Funders. OECD Policy Perspectives, July.

OECD – Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. 2018. Measuring mobilisation: Briefing on efforts to harmonise OECD and MDB measurement methodologies. https://one.oecd.org/document/DCD/DAC(2018)25/REV1/En/pdf

OECD – Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. 2019. Making Blended Finance Work for Water and Sanitation: Unlocking Commercial Finance for SDG 6. OECD Studies on Water. Paris, OECD Publishing.

Open Africa. 2019. “The Challenges of Funding Power and Water Projects in Africa: Round Table Discussion White Paper,” Nov. 6. http://www.kigaliwater.com/assets/Open_Africa_White_Paper_Rwanda_Digital.pdf

PIDG – Private Infrastructure Development Group. 2012. Annual Report 2012. London: Private Infrastructure Development Group. https://www.pidg.org/

PIDG – Private Infrastructure Development Group. 2019a. Annual Review 2019. London: Private Infrastructure Development Group. https://www.pidg.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/PIDG-Annual-Review-2019-digital-Final.pdf

PIDG – Private Infrastructure Development Group. 2019b. Results Monitoring Handbook. London: Private Infrastructure Development Group. https://data.pidg.org/ugc-1/1/2/0/RM%20Handbook%20April%202019%20final.pdf

PPIAF – Public-Private Infrastructure Advisory Facility. 2015. “PPIAF Helps the Government of Rwanda Manage Private Sector participation in the Water Sector.” Washington DC: World Bank.

Republic of Rwanda. 2018. Public-Private Partnership Guidelines. Official Gazette n°29bis of 16/07/2018.

Republic of Rwanda. 2021. “Report of the Auditor General of State Finances for the Year ended 30 June 2020.” Kigali, Rwanda: Office of the Auditor General of State Finances.

Republic of Rwanda. 2023. “Report of the Auditor General of State Finances for the Year ended 30 June 2022.” Kigali, Rwanda: Office of the Auditor General of State Finances.

Rwahigi, M. 2015. “Rwanda signs water purchase agreement with Metito to increase access to clean safe water.” Hope Magazine, April 1.

Saldinger, A. 2020. “Why blended finance hasn’t taken off.” Devex Blog. February 24. https://www.devex.com/news/why-blended-finance-hasn-t-taken-off-96612

SDIP – Sustainable Development Investment Partnership, United States Trade Development Agency (USTDA), and Development Bank of Southern Africa (DBSA). 2018. Insights on Project Preparation and Development Capital in Africa and the ASEAN Region. Midrand, South Africa: Development Bank of Southern Africa. https://www.dbsa.org/sites/default/files/media/documents/2021-03/DBSA%20SDIP%20insights%20into%20Project%20Preparations%20in%20Africa%20and%20ASIAN%20regions.pdf

Spratt, S. and L.R. Collins. 2012. “Development Finance Institutions and Infrastructure: A Systematic Review of Evidence for Development Additionality.” Report prepared for the Private Infrastructure Development Group, January. https://www.gov.uk/research-for-development-outputs/development-finance-institutions-and-infrastructure-a-systematic-review-of-evidence-for-development-additionality

Suarez, F.F. and G. Lanzola. 2005. “The Half-Truth of First-Mover Advantage.” Harvard Business Review, April. https://hbr.org/2005/04/the-half-truth-of-first-mover-advantage

Thomson Reuters. 2018. “Africa’s First Water PPP.” Project Finance International (PFI) Yearbook 2018. http://www.pfie.com/africas-first-water-ppp/21320834.fullarticle

UNCDF – United Nations Capital Development Fund. 2018a. Strategic Framework, 2018-2021. New York: UNCDF. https://sdgs.un.org/un-system-sdg-implementation/united-nations-capital-development-fund-uncdf-24513

UNCDF – United Nations Capital Development Fund. 2018b. Blended Finance in the Least Developed countries: Case Study 4, Kigali Bulk Water Supply PPP. New York: UNCDF.

UNCTAD – United Nations Conference on Trade and Development. 2014. World investment report 2014: Investing in the SDGs. New York and Geneva: United Nations Conference on Trade and Development. https://www.unctad.org/en/PublicationsLibrary/wir2014_en.pdf

UNDP – United Nations Development Programme. 2024. Africa Green Business and Financing Report 2024, May 21. https://www.undp.org/africa/publications/africa-green-business-and-financing-report

WaterWorld. 2017. “Kigali Bulk Water Supply Project in Rwanda Kickstarts Water PPPs in Sub-Saharan Africa,” Nov. 27. https://www.waterworld.com/drinking-water-treatment/distribution/article/16203048/kigali-bulk-water-supply-project-in-rwanda-kickstarts-water-ppps-in-sub-saharan-africa

World Bank. 2003. Private Sector Development in the Electricity Sector: A Joint OED/OEG/OEU Review of the World Bank Group’s Assistance in the 1990s. World Bank Operations Evaluation Department, IFC Operations Evaluation Group, MIGA Operations Evaluation Unit. Washington, DC: World Bank, July 21.

World Bank. 2005. Private Solutions for infrastructure in Rwanda: A Country Framework Report. Washington DC: World Bank. https://ppiaf.org/

World Bank. 2002. “Private Sector Development Strategy: Directions for the World Bank Group.” Board Report No. 44933. Washington DC: World Bank, January.

World Bank. 2015. “World Bank Group Support to Public-Private Partnerships: Lessons from Experience in Client Countries, FY02–12.” Independent Evaluation Group (IEG). Washington DC: World Bank. http://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/405891468334813110/pdf/93629-REVISED-Box394822B-PUBLIC.pdf

World Bank. 2017. Doing Business 2017. Washington DC: World Bank.

World Bank. 2018a. Joint MDB reporting on private investment mobilisation: Methodology reference guide. Washington DC: World Bank. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/495061492543870701/pdf/114403 REVISED-June25-DocumentsPrivInvestMob-Draft-Ref-Guide-Master-June2018 v4.pdf

World Bank. 2018b. Mobilization of private finance by multilateral development banks and development finance institutions 2017. Technical report. Washington DC: World Bank.

World Bank. 2019. Doing Business 2019. Washington DC: World Bank.

World Bank. 2020a. “World Bank Group Approaches to Mobilize Private Capital for Development, an Independent Evaluation.” Independent Evaluation Group (IEG). Washington DC: World Bank, July 20.

World Bank. 2020b. Benchmarking Infrastructure Development 2020. Washington DC: World Bank.

World Bank. 2025. PPI Project Database. https://ppi.worldbank.org/en/ppi

World Bank Group. 2015. From Billions to Trillions: MDB Contributions to Financing for Development. Joint statement by the African Development Bank, the Asian Development Bank, the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, the European Investment Bank, the Inter-American Development Bank, the International Monetary Fund, and the World Bank Group. Washington DC: World Bank Group, July. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/602761467999349576/pdf/98023-BR-SecM2015-0233-IDA-SecM2015-0147-IFC-SecM2015-0105-MIGA-SecM2015-0061-Box391499B-OUO-9.pdf

Zawya. 2015. “New Bulk Water PPP to Meet 40% of Kigali, Rwanda's Potable Water Needs,” April 2. https://www.zawya.com/en/press-release/new-bulk-water-ppp-to-meet-40-of-kigali-rwandas-potable-water-needs-aedl8iz7