Balancing Compliance and Transparency: A Comparative Analysis of Takaful and Conventional Insurance in Pakistan

Iqbal, Hafiz Masood Ahmad and Ali, Amjad and Audi, Marc (2025): Balancing Compliance and Transparency: A Comparative Analysis of Takaful and Conventional Insurance in Pakistan.

Abstract

This research undertakes a comparative analysis of governance practices, transparency, ethical compliance, and consumer protection in both conventional insurance and Islamic insurance (Takaful) within the context of Pakistan from 2016 to 2022 both theoretical frameworks and empirical data for comparative evaluation. Employing a mixed-methods approach, the study evaluates 20 insurance companies, comprising 10 conventional insurers and 10 Takaful operators by analyzing dimensions such as board governance, disclosure transparency, consumer protection mechanisms, and ethical investment practices, through qualitative thematic analysis and quantitative disclosure scoring. The findings indicate that Takaful firms demonstrate stronger performance in governance (e.g., board independence), Shariah compliance (e.g., investment screening), and ethical consumer practices (e.g., dispute resolution and product disclosure), whereas conventional insurers excel in financial transparency, particularly in areas such as profit reporting and financial statement standardization. Despite these strengths, ethical disclosure remains limited within conventional insurance models, while Takaful operators face challenges related to inconsistent surplus distribution reporting. The study recommends policy-level reforms, organizational strategies, and further academic inquiry to promote ethical and inclusive insurance practices in Pakistan. It also underscores the need for standardized regulatory frameworks and enhanced stakeholder stewardship to ensure a balanced and accountable insurance sector.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Islamic Insurance (Takaful), Conventional Insurance, Ethical Compliance, Governance Practices
• Subjects: P - Economic Systems > P4 - Other Economic Systems; P - Economic Systems > P5 - Comparative Economic Systems

References

Abdur-Rauf, I. A., & Raimi, L. (2024). A conceptual discourse on Islamic finance investment modes for established and emerging entrepreneurs: Tripartite implications. Journal of Business and Economic Options, 7(2).

Akram, H. & ur Rahman, K. (2022) ISRA. International Journal of Islamic Finance, 187-192.

Alam, S., & Raza, M. (2018). Corporate governance and performance of life insurance companies in Pakistan. Journal of Finance and Accounting Research, 10(2), 53–66.

Alam, S., & Usman, M. (2019). Corporate governance practices and firm performance in the insurance sector of Pakistan. Pakistan Journal of Commerce and Social Sciences, 13(1), 194–212.

Al-Amri, K., & Hossain, M. (2020). Regulatory frameworks and practices of Takaful operators in the GCC: An overview. International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, 13(4), 735–749.

Al-Darwish, A., Hafeman, M., Impavido, G., Kemp, M., & O'Malley, P. (2011). Possible unintended consequences of Basel III and Solvency II. International Monetary Fund.

Ali, S., & Ramzan, M. (2021). Comparative analysis of corporate governance disclosure in Islamic and conventional insurance firms in Pakistan. Asian Journal of Accounting Research, 6(2), 160–176.

Ali, S., Ramzan, M., & Aslam, F. (2020). Ethical compliance and consumer protection practices in Islamic and conventional insurance firms: Evidence from Pakistan. International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, 13(3), 567–582.

Archer, S., & Karim, R. A. A. (2007). Islamic finance: The regulatory challenge. Wiley Finance.

Archer, S., Karim, R. A. A., & Nienhaus, V. (2009). Takaful Islamic insurance: Concepts and regulatory issues. Wiley Finance.

Audi, M., Sadiq, A., & Ali, A. (2021). Performance Evaluation of Islamic and Non-Islamic Equity and Bonds Indices. Evidence from Selected Emerging and Developed Countries. Journal of Applied Economic Sciences, 16(3).

Ayub, M. (2007). Understanding Islamic finance. John Wiley & Sons.

Bhatty, A. J. (2010). A primer on takaful: Islamic insurance. Norton Rose Fulbright.

Billah, M. M. (2003). Islamic insurance: Theory and practice. Islamic Banking and Finance Institute Malaysia.

Carroll, A. B. (1991). The pyramid of corporate social responsibility: Toward the moral management of organizational stakeholders. Business Horizons, 34(4), 39–48.

Davis, J. H., Schoorman, F. D., & Donaldson, L. (1997). Toward a stewardship theory of management. Academy of Management Review, 22(1), 20–47.

Dusuki, A. W. (2008). Understanding the objectives of Islamic banking: A survey of stakeholders’ perspectives. International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, 1(2), 132–148.

Dusuki, A. W., & Abdullah, N. I. (2007). Maqasid al-Shari’ah, maslahah, and corporate social responsibility. The American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences, 24(1), 25–45.

Eccles, R. G., & Krzus, M. P. (2010). One report: Integrated reporting for a sustainable strategy. Wiley.

El Qorchi, M. (2005). Islamic finance gears up. Finance & Development, 42(4), 46–50.

El-Gamal, M. A. (2006). Islamic finance: Law, economics, and practice. Cambridge University Press.

Ernst & Young. (2016). Global Takaful Insights 2016: Unlocking the potential of Takaful through innovation. EYGM Limited.

Etikan, I., Musa, S. A., & Alkassim, R. S. (2016). Comparison of convenience sampling and purposive sampling. American Journal of Theoretical and Applied Statistics, 5(1), 1–4.

Fama, E. F., & Jensen, M. C. (1983). Separation of ownership and control. Journal of Law and Economics, 26(2), 301–325.

Freeman, R. E. (1984). Strategic management: A stakeholder approach. Pitman.

Haniffa, R., & Hudaib, M. (2007). Exploring the ethical identity of Islamic banks via communication in annual reports. Journal of Business Ethics, 76(1), 97–116.

Hasan, A., Wahid, H., & Noor, M. (2021). Comparative analysis of Shariah disclosures in Takaful and conventional insurance firms: Evidence from emerging markets. International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, 14(3), 451–470.

Hess, D. (2019). The transparency trap: Non-financial disclosure and the responsibility of business to respect human rights. American Business Law Journal, 56(1), 5–53.

Hsieh, H. F., & Shannon, S. E. (2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research, 15(9), 1277–1288.

IAIS (International Association of Insurance Supervisors). (2018). Annual report 2018. Basel: Bank for International Settlements.

IFSB (Islamic Financial Services Board). (2015). Core principles for Islamic finance regulation (insurance segment). Kuala Lumpur: IFSB.

Iqbal, M., & Lewis, M. K. (2009). An Islamic perspective on governance. Edward Elgar Publishing.

Iqbal, T., & Nasir, S. (2018). Integrating national professional standards with Islamic teachings: A path to educational excellence in Pakistan. Journal of Policy Options, 1(4).

Ismail, M., Alhabshi, S. O., & Bacha, O. I. (2011). Organizational form and efficiency: The coexistence of family Takaful and life insurance in Malaysia. Journal of Global Business and Economics, 3(1), 122–137.

Ismail, H., & Saeed, A. (2019). Islamic banking and finance in Pakistan: Growth trends, outlook, and strategic imperatives. Journal of Policy Options, 2(4).

Ismail, M., Yusof, M. A., & Muda, R. (2011). Takaful: A review on performance, issues and challenges in Malaysia. International Journal of Business and Social Research, 1(3), 100–110.

Kamla, R., & Haque, F. (2019). Islamic accounting, neo-imperialism and identity staging: The accounting disclosure practices of Takaful companies. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 62, 1–20.

Karim, R. A. A., Archer, S., & Al-Deehani, T. (2010). Financial contracting, governance structures and the accounting regulation of Islamic banks: An analysis in terms of agency theory and transaction cost economics. Journal of Management & Governance, 14(2), 149–176.

Khan, T., & Bhatti, M. I. (2008). Developments in Islamic banking: A financial risk-allocation approach. The Journal of Risk Finance, 9(1), 40–51.

Khan, T., Ahmad, R., & Zaman, S. (2020). Developing a disclosure index to measure ethical reporting in Islamic financial institutions. Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, 11(2), 289–310.

KPMG. (2022). Pakistan insurance industry: Regulatory overview and market insights. Karachi: KPMG Pakistan.

Maali, B., Casson, P., & Napier, C. (2006). Social reporting by Islamic banks. Abacus, 42(2), 266–289.

Mahmood, Z., Kouser, R., & Ali, W. (2019). Symbolic or substantive legitimacy: The case of corporate social responsibility in Pakistan. Social Responsibility Journal, 15(8), 1084–1100.

McHugh, M. L. (2012). Interrater reliability: The kappa statistic. Biochemia Medica, 22(3), 276–282.

Obaidullah, M. (2005). Islamic financial services. Islamic Economics Research Center, King Abdulaziz University.

OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). (2021). The digital transformation of insurance: A global review. Paris: OECD Publishing.

OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development). (2017). G20/OECD principles of corporate governance. Paris: OECD Publishing.

Olorogun, L., & Othman, J. (2021). Exploring ethical dimensions of Islamic insurance: Implications for market acceptance in Malaysia. Journal of Business and Economic Options, 4(1).

Omri, M. B. (2022). Understanding the relationship between liquidity and banking financial stability in Islamic and conventional banks. Journal of Business and Economic Options, 5(1).

Outreville, J. F. (2013). The relationship between insurance and economic development: 85 empirical papers for a review of the literature. Risk Management and Insurance Review, 16(1), 71–122.

Rahman, A. R. A., & Bukair, A. A. (2015). The influence of the Shariah supervisory board on corporate social responsibility disclosure by Islamic banks of Gulf Co-operation Council countries. Social Responsibility Journal, 11(1), 109–130.

Raza, M., Yousaf, S., & Saeed, A. (2021). Shariah governance and transparency in Takaful: Evidence from Pakistan. Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, 12(4), 578–596.

Raza, Z., & Khan, K. (2023). Determinants of expected service quality in conventional and Islamic banking in Pakistan. Journal of Policy Options, 6(1).

Rejda, G. E., & McNamara, M. J. (2017). Principles of risk management and insurance (13th ed.). Pearson.

Scott, W. R. (2003). Organizations: Rational, natural, and open systems (5th ed.). Prentice Hall.

SECP (Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan). (2022). Takaful Rules (Amendment), 2020 and Shariah Governance Regulations. Islamabad: SECP Publications.

SECP (Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan). (2023). Annual report 2022–2023. Islamabad: Insurance Division, SECP.

Shafii, Z., & Salleh, S. (2010). Enhancing transparency and accountability in Islamic financial institutions through Shariah governance. ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance, 2(1), 59–78.

Shafii, Z., Abid, M. A., & Salleh, S. (2010). Shariah compliance process in Islamic financial institutions: A review of issues and challenges. ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance, 2(1), 123–145.

Stubbs, W., & Higgins, C. (2018). Stakeholders, legitimacy and social and environmental reporting: Evidence from the Australian mining industry. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 31(3), 750–785.

Suchman, M. C. (1995). Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches. Academy of Management Review, 20(3), 571–610.

Swiss Re Institute. (2020). World insurance: Riding out the 2020 pandemic storm. Zurich: Swiss Re.

Tavakol, M., & Dennick, R. (2011). Making sense of Cronbach’s alpha. International Journal of Medical Education, 2, 53–55.

Ustaoglu, M., & Yildiz, B. (2023). Balancing tradition and modernity in Turkey's Islamic finance landscape. Journal of Business and Economic Options, 6(4).