Clean Vehicle Incentives and Urban Air Quality: Evidence from Italy

Baraldi, Anna Laura and Cantabene, Claudia and De Iudicibus, Alessandro (2026): Clean Vehicle Incentives and Urban Air Quality: Evidence from Italy.

Abstract

Governments increasingly rely on purchase incentives for electric and hybrid vehicles to address both climate change and local air pollution. This paper provides new causal evidence on the environmental effectiveness of sub-national vehicle purchase incentives in Italy. Exploiting rich spatial and temporal variation in regional and municipal policies across Italian provincial capitals between 2013 and 2023, we show that the introduction of purchase incentives leads to statistically and economically significant reductions in traffic-related air pollution, measured by maximum annual concentrations of nitrogen dioxide (NO2). These effects are robust across multiple specifications and placebo tests and are primarily driven by direct cash subsidies, while purely fiscal incentives do not generate detectable improvements in air quality. To uncover the underlying mechanisms, we document that incentives substantially increase the adoption of electric and hybrid vehicles and accelerate the phase-out of diesel cars, having an effect on investment in active mobility infrastructure and on changes in selected forms of electric micro-mobility. A decomposition exercise shows that technological substitution within the vehicle fleet is the main channel through which incentives reduce NO2 concentrations. Overall, the results highlight the importance of incentive design and provide policy-relevant evidence on the role of demand-side policies in improving urban air quality.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Vehicle purchase incentives, Urban air pollution, Electric and hybrid vehicles, Difference-in-differences
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H20 - General; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy

References

Bergantino, A. S., M. Intini, and M. Percoco (2021). New car taxation and its unintended environmental consequences. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 148, 36–48.

Bjerkan, K. Y., T. E. Nørbech, and M. E. Nordtømme (2016). Incentives for promoting battery electric vehicle (bev) adoption in Norway. Transportation research part D: transport and environment 43, 169–180.

Chandra, A., S. Gulati, and M. Kandlikar (2010). Green drivers or free riders? An analysis of tax rebates for hybrid vehicles. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 60(2), 78–93.

Cincotta, C., F. Vona, and D. Popp (2025). Evaluating electric vehicle incentives: Evidence from Norway. Energy Economics. forthcoming.

Clinton, B. C. and D. C. Steinberg (2019). Providing the spark: Impact of financial incentives on battery electric vehicle adoption. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 98, 102255.

Danielis, R., L. Rotaris, M. Giansoldati, and M. Scorrano (2020). Drivers’ preferences for electric cars in Italy. evidence from a country with limited but growing electric car uptake. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 137, 79–94.

DellaValle, N. and A. Zubaryeva (2019). Can we hope for a collective shift in electric vehicle adoption? testing salience and norm-based interventions in South Tyrol, Italy. Energy Research & Social Science 55, 46–61.

Diamond, D. (2009). The impact of government incentives for hybrid-electric vehicles: Evidence from us states. Energy policy 37(3), 972–983.

Donateo, T., F. Licci, A. D’elia, G. Colangelo, D. Laforgia, and F. Ciancarelli (2015). Evaluation of emissions of CO2 and air pollutants from electric vehicles in italian cities. Applied Energy 157, 675–687.

Durrmeyer, I. (2021). The distributional effects of environmental policy: Evidence from the French feebate scheme. Energy Economics 102, 105505.

Gallagher, K. S. and E. Muehlegger (2011). Giving green to get green? incentives and consumer adoption of hybrid vehicle technology. Journal of Environmental Economics and management 61(1), 1–15.

Gibson, M. and M. Carnovale (2015). The effects of road pricing on driver behavior and air pollution. Journal of Urban Economics 89, 62–73.

Grigolon, L., N. Leheyda, and F. Verboven (2016). Scrapping subsidies during the financial crisis—evidence from Europe. International Journal of Industrial Organization 44, 41–59.

Hardman, S. (2019). Understanding the impact of reoccurring and non-financial incentives on plug-in electric vehicle adoption–a review. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 119, 1–14.

Holland, S. P., E. T. Mansur, N. Z. Muller, and A. J. Yates (2019). Distributional effects of air pollution from electric vehicle adoption. Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists 6(S1), S65–S94.

Huse, C. and C. Lucinda (2014). The market impact and the cost of environmental policy: evidence from the Swedish green car rebate. The Economic Journal 124(578), F393–F419.

Invernizzi, G., A. Ruprecht, R. Mazza, C. De Marco, G. Moˇcnik, C. Sioutas, and D. Westerdahl (2011). Measurement of black carbon concentration as an indicator of air quality benefits of traffic restriction policies within the ecopass zone in Milan, Italy. Atmospheric Environment 45(21), 3522–3527.

Jacqz, I. and S. Johnston (2024). Electric vehicle subsidies and urban air pollution disparities. Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists 11(S1), S41–S69.

Jenn, A., K. Springel, and A. R. Gopal (2018). Effectiveness of electric vehicle incentives in the United States. Energy policy 119, 349–356. Kessler, L. (2023). An ex-ante evaluation of the French car feebate. Energy Policy 170, 113201.

Li, S., J. Linn, and E. Spiller (2013). Evaluating “cash-for-clunkers”: Program effects on auto sales and the environment. Journal of Environmental Economics and management 65(2), 175–193.

Marin, G. and R. Zoboli (2020). Effectiveness of car scrappage schemes: Counterfactual-based evidence on the Italian experience. Economics of Transportation 21, 100150.

Martins, E. C. S., J. L´epine, and J. Corbett (2024). Assessing the effectiveness of financial incentives on electric vehicle adoption in Europe: Multi-period difference-in-difference approach. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 189, 104217.

Muehlegger, E., D. Rapson, and J. Li (2022). Subsidizing mass adoption of electric vehicles: Quasi-experimental evidence from California. Journal of Public Economics 206, 104566. Muehlegger, E. and D. S. Rapson (2022). Subsidizing low-and middle-income adoption of electric vehicles: Quasi-experimental evidence from California. Journal of Public Economics 216, 104752.

Percoco, M. (2013). Is road pricing effective in abating pollution? evidence from milan. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment 25, 112–118.

Qiu, Y., P. Zhou, and H. Sun (2019). Assessing the effectiveness of city-level electric vehicle policies in China. Energy Policy 130, 22–31.

Rotaris, L., R. Danielis, E. Marcucci, and J. Massiani (2010). The urban road pricing scheme to curb pollution in Milan, Italy: Description, impacts and preliminary cost–benefit analysis assessment. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 44(5), 359–375.

Sallee, J. M. (2011). The surprising incidence of tax credits for the Toyota Prius. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 3(2), 189–219.

Scorrano, M., R. Danielis, and M. Giansoldati (2020). Dissecting the total cost of ownership of fully electric cars in Italy: The impact of annual distance travelled, home charging and urban driving. Research in Transportation Economics 80, 100799.

Sun, L. and S. Abraham (2021). Estimating dynamic treatment effects in event studies with heterogeneous treatment effects. Journal of Econometrics 225(2), 175–199.

Valeri, E. and R. Danielis (2015). Simulating the market penetration of cars with alternative fuelpowertrain technologies in Italy. Transport Policy 37, 44–56.

Wang, Y. (2025). Air quality impacts of electric vehicle promotion: Evidence from urban China. Research in Transportation Economics. forthcoming.

Wee, S., M. Coffman, and S. La Croix (2018). Do electric vehicle incentives matter? Evidence from the 50 us states. Research Policy 47(9), 1601–1610.

Xing, J., B. Leard, and S. Li (2021). What does an electric vehicle replace? Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 107, 102432.

Xue, C., H. Zhou, Q. Wu, X. Wu, and X. Xu (2021). Impact of incentive policies and other socio-economic factors on electric vehicle market share: A panel data analysis from the 20 countries. Sustainability 13(5), 2928.

Zheng, X., W. Zhang, Y. Yu, and X. Li (2022). An empirical assessment of the impact of subsidies on electric vehicle adoption: Evidence from china. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 155, 186–203.