An Evaluation of Crisis-Intervention Team Training

Nemschoff, Danielle (2026): An Evaluation of Crisis-Intervention Team Training.

Abstract

Police officers in the United States are often the first responders to mental health crises, despite growing concerns about whether traditional policing is well-suited to these encounters. One response has been crisis-intervention team (CIT) training for police. Unlike alternatives such as unarmed responders or co-responder models, CIT seeks to improve outcomes by training officers to de-escalate mental health crises themselves. This paper provides causal evidence on whether CIT training reduces police use of force and arrests during mental health incidents. I construct a comprehensive administrative dataset linking calls for service, police reports, use-of-force records, officer demographics, and detailed training records from the New Orleans Police Department from 2017 through 2023. To estimate the causal effect of CIT training, I use a difference-in-differences framework that exploits variation in the timing of training across officers. Specifically, I compare changes in propensity to use force and make an arrest for officers before and after they receive training to those of officers who are not-yet-trained but will be trained in the future. I find no evidence that CIT training reduces officers’ use of force or likelihood of making an arrest in mental health incidents. I also find no spillover effects on officer behavior in other types of calls. Importantly, officers who select into training are officers who are already less likely to use force even prior to training, indicating strong positive selection. Taken together, these results suggest that voluntary training programs, as currently implemented, may not meaningfully change officer behavior and instead primarily attract officers who are already less prone to use force.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: policing; crisis-intervention; mental health; police; use of force; arrest; crisis response; CIT
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J0 - General; K - Law and Economics > K0 - General

References

Amy C. Watson, Anjali J. Fulambarker (2012). "The Crisis Intervention Team Model of Police Response to Mental Health Crises: A Primer for Mental Health Practitioners". In: PubMed Central.

Bocar A. Ba, Emily Owens (2021). "The Economics of Policing and Public Safety". In: Journal of Economic Perspectives.

Chandon Adger, Matthew Ross, CarlyWill Sloan (2022). "The Effect of Field Training Officers on Police Use of Force". In: Working Paper.

Clement de Chaisemartin, Xavier D'Haultfoeuille (2022). "Two-Way Fixed Effects and Difference-in-Differences with Heterogeneous Treatment Effects: A Survey". In: Journal of Econometrics.

Department, New Orleans Police (2022). NOPD Policy Manual. url: https : / / www.nola.gov/nopd/policies/.

Goodman-Bacon, Andrew (2021). "Difference-in-Differences with Variation in Treatment Timing". In: Journal of Econometrics.

Grogger, Jeffrey and Greg Ridgeway (2006). "Testing for Racial Pro ling in Traffic Stops From Behind a Veil of Darkness". In: Journal of the American Statistical Association.

Jakiela, Pamela (2021). \"Simple Diagnostics for Two-Way Fixed Effects". In: Working Paper.

John Knowles, Nicola Persico, Petra Todd (2001). "Racial Bias in Motor Vehicle Searches: Theory and Evidence". In: Journal of Political Economy.

Julie Tate, Jennifer Jenkins, Steven Rich (2022). "Police Shootings Database 2015-2022". In: The Washington Post.

Liyang Sun, Sarah Abraham (2021). "Estimating dynamic treatment effects in event studies with heterogeneous treatment effects". In: Journal of Econometrics.

Manasi Desphande, Yue Li (2019). "Who Is Screened Out? Application Costs and the Targeting of Disability Programs". In: AEA.

Mark Hoekstra, CarlyWill Sloan (2022). "Does Race Matter for Police Use of Force? Evidence from 911 Calls". In: American Economic Review 112.3.

Memphis CIT Center, The University of (2022). About CIT. url: http://www.cit.memphis.edu/aboutCIT.php.

Mental Illness, National Alliance on (2022). Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) Programs. url: https://www.nami.org/Advocacy/Crisis-Intervention/Crisis-Intervention-Team-(CIT)-Programs.

Oeindrila Dube Anuj K. Shah, Sandy Jo MacArthur (2022). "Training to Meet the Cognitive Demands of Policing". In: Working Paper.

Reckdahl, Katy (2021). "Help, not handcuffs: New Orleans Looks for a Better Way to Respond to Mental Health Crises on its Streets". In: NOLA news.

Office of Research and Public Affairs (2016). "Serious Mental Illness in Prevalence in Jails and Prisons". In: Background Paper.

Roland G. Fryer, Jr. (2019). "An Empirical Analysis of Racial Differences in Police Use of Force". In: Journal of Political Economy.

Thomas S. Dee, Jaymes Pyne (2022). "A community response approach to mental health and substance abuse crises reduced crime". In: Science Advancement.