A Veterinary Misdiagnosis: Analysing the Decision of Ireland’s CCPC in the IVC Evidensia/Old Church Vets Merger.

Massey, Patrick (2026): A Veterinary Misdiagnosis: Analysing the Decision of Ireland’s CCPC in the IVC Evidensia/Old Church Vets Merger.

Abstract

This paper analyses the decision of Ireland’s Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) in relation to a merger between two veterinary practice groups. Several aspects of the CCPC’s analysis in the case are highly unsatisfactory. Based on the information contained in the CCPC Determination, there is a relative high probability that the CCPC decision constitutes a Type II (false positive) error, i.e. the CCPC failed to identify a potentially anti-competitive merger. The CCPC decision in this case adds to list of cases involving potential Type I and Type II errors, raising serious questions about the quality of the CCPC’s merger analysis and internal quality control procedures. It also suggests that lessons have not been learned from previous cases.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Merger Control; Market Definition; Type II error; substantial lessening of competition; Catchment Areas; Closeness of competition.
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law > K21 - Antitrust Law; L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L13 - Oligopoly and Other Imperfect Markets; L - Industrial Organization > L4 - Antitrust Issues and Policies > L40 - General

References

Gorecki, P.K., (2020). The Berendsen (Elis)/King’s Laundry Merger: Three Into Two Won’t Go. Dublin: Department of Economics, Trinity College Dublin. MRPA paper 100477. Gorecki, P.K., (2023). Merger Control in Ireland after the Uniphar/NaviCorp Decision: State of Play Meetings & Market Testing Remedies, MRPA Discussion Paper, 118/88. Gorecki, P.K., (2025). Better Merger Outcomes Due to Increased Scrutiny by Ireland’s NCA? The Q-Park/Tazbell Transaction, MRPA Paper No.127352. Hotelling, H., (1929). Stability in Competition, Economic Journal, 39, 41-57 Massey, P., (2010). Taking Politics Out of Mergers: A Review of Irish Experience. Journal of Competition Law & Economics, 6(4): 853-878. Massey, P., (2011). A Tale of Two Mergers: Irish Merger Policy After the Heineken and Kerry Decisions. World Competition, 34(1): 113-137. Massey, P., (2025). Merger Control in Ireland: An Economic Appraisal, Cork: OakTree Press. Shapiro, C., (2024). Evolution of the Merger Guidelines: Is This Fox Too Clever by Half? Review of Industrial Organization, 65(1): 147-175. Trebilcock, M. & E.M. Iacobucci, (2002). Designing Competition Law Institutions. World Competition, 25(3): 361-394.