The Aftermath of the 9/11 Attack in the New York City Office Market: A Review of Key Figures and Developments

Fuerst, Franz (2006): The Aftermath of the 9/11 Attack in the New York City Office Market: A Review of Key Figures and Developments.

Abstract

Although almost eight years have passed since the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, researchers continue to investigate the consequences of this far-reaching event in a variety of scientific disciplines and subject areas. In economic research, a number of more recent publications have added to existing body of literature by elucidating the medium- and long-term impact of the attacks using new methods and/or data. This paper is more modest in scope in that it reviews the impact of the attacks on the Manhattan's office inventory, employment and rents. Overall, there is scant evidence that the attack have had a long-lasting impact on the Manhattan office market. Of the companies that decided not to return to Lower Manhattan after 9/11, the majority relocated to Midtown Manhattan. Taken together, the core markets of Midtown and Downtown Manhattan captured about 80 percent of the stream of displaced tenants after 9/11, while areas outside of these two core clusters captured only 20 percent, which bodes well for Manhattan's ability to remain a prime office location even in the face of a severe crisis. Moreover, the set of so-called "trophy" buildings proved to be less affected by the recession than the general market, a finding that runs counter to initial assumptions about the future of office high-rises. In addition to a drastic reduction in leased space, accommodation of displaced tenants within the existing office space portfolio of large companies contributed further to lower occupancy rates than had been expected after the destruction of 10 percent of the inventory. This phenomenon, also known as backfill, caused overall absorption to be negative in the quarters following 9/11, since the positive demand created by displaced tenants was more than offset by losses incurred in the accelerated recession.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Economics of commercial real estate, September 11 attacks, New York real estate market
• Subjects: R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R3 - Real Estate Markets, Spatial Production Analysis, and Firm Location; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R3 - Real Estate Markets, Spatial Production Analysis, and Firm Location > R33 - Nonagricultural and Nonresidential Real Estate Markets

References

BRAM, J.; ORR, J.; RAPAPORT, C. (2002): Measuring the Effects of the September 11 Attack on New York City. In: Federal Reserve Bank (ed.): New York Fed Economic Policy Review Special Issue: The Economic Effects of September 11. 8:2, 5-20.

COSTAR (2001): The CoStar Office Report – Year-end 2001. New York City Office Market. Research report.

COSTAR (2005): The CoStar Office Report – Mid-year 2005. New York City Office Market. Research report.

DERMISI, S.V. (2007): The Impact of Terrorism Fears on Downtown Real Estate Chicago Office Market Cycles. Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management, 13/1, 57-74.

DRI-WEFA (2002): Financial Impact of the World Trade Center Attack. Report prepared for the.New York State Senate Finance Committee, 01/02.

EVANS, A. (1995): The Property Market: Ninety Nine Per Cent Efficient? Urban Studies, 32, 5-29.

FUERST, F. (2005): Exogenous Shocks and Real Estate Rental Markets: An Event Study of the 9/11 Attacks and their Impact on the New York Office Market. In: Chernick, H. (Ed.): Resilient City, Russell Sage Foundation Publications, New York. available at http://econpapers.repec.org/paper/wpawuwpfi/0509008.htm

GLAESER, E. L.; SHAPIRO, J. M. (2001): Cities and Warfare: The Impact of Terrorism on Urban Form. Harvard Institute of Economic Research Discussion Paper Number 1942.

GRUBB & ELLIS (2001): NYC's office market: assessing the damage. Market report September 2001.

GRUBB & ELLIS (2002): Where permanently displaced tenants have landed. In: New York Construction News (2002): One Year Later…Dawn Breaks. September 2002.

HARRIGAN, J.; MARTIN, P. (2002): Terrorism and the Resilience of Cities. Economic Policy Review, 8:2, 97-116.

HOLUSHA, J. (2003): Some Best-Priced Space Isn't Even on the Market. New York Times Real Estate Section. May 23, 2003.

JONES LANG LASALLE (2001): The Events of September 11: Impact and implications for corporate real estate occupiers. Global Insights 2/2001.

KELLY, H. F. (2002): The New York Regional and Downtown Office Market: History and Prospects after 9/11. Report Prepared for the Civic Alliance. August 9, 2002. The aftermath of 9/11 in the New York office market 32

KALLBERG, J. LIU, C.H., PASQUARIELLO, P. (2008): Updating Expectations: An Analysis of Post-9/11 Returns. Journal of Financial Markets, 11/4, 400-432.

MILLER, N.; MARKOSYAN, S.; FLORANCE, A.; STEVENSON, B.; OP'T VELD, H. (2003): The Effects of 9/11/2001 Impact on Trophy and Tall Office Property. Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management. 9:2, 107-125.

NEW YORK CITY PARTNERSHIP AND CHAMBER OF COMMERCE [NYCPCC] (2001): Economic Impact Analysis of the September 11th Attack on New York City. Working together to accelerate New York's recovery. Research report.

NEWMARK & COMPANY REAL ESTATE INC. (2003): Focus on Lower Manhattan. Research report.

PEIRCE. N. (2001): Skyscrapers: Has Their Era Ended? Washington Post Writers Group. October 21, 2001.

REALTORS COMMERCIAL ALLIANCE [RCA] (2003): The Spectre of Shadow Space. RCA Report Fall 2003. 4:4.

REIS (2003): Reis Insights: Trophy Buildings Sale Sets New Record. October 10, 2003.

RICH, M. (2003): How Companies Account for Vacant Space. The Wall Street Journal. February 19, 2003.

ROSEN, K. T. (1984): Toward a Model of the Office Building Sector. Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association. 12, 261-269.

SHILLING, J. D.; SIRMANS, C.F.; CORGEL, J.B. (1987): Price Adjustment Process for Rental Office Space. Journal of Urban Economics. 22, 90-100.

TORTO WHEATON RESEARCH (2002): Trophy buildings in New York fare well one year later. TWR About Real Estate: November 22, 2002.

WHEATON, W. (1999): Real Estate "Cycles": Some Fundamentals. Real Estate Economics. 27, 209-230.

WHEATON, W.; TORTO, R. (1994): Office Rent Indices and Their Behavior Over Time. Journal of Urban Economics. 35, 121-139.