Corporate Hedging and Shareholder Value

Aretz, Kevin and Bartram, Söhnke M. (2009): Corporate Hedging and Shareholder Value.

Abstract

According to financial theory, corporate hedging can increase shareholder value in the presence of capital market imperfections such as direct and indirect costs of financial distress, costly external financing, and taxes. This paper presents a comprehensive review of the extensive existing empirical literature that has tested these theories, documenting overall mixed empirical support for rationales of hedging with derivatives at the firm level. While various empirical challenges and limitations advise some caution with regard to the interpretation of the existing evidence, the results are, however, consistent with derivatives use being just one part of a broader financial strategy that considers the type and level of financial risks, the availability of risk-management tools, and the operating environment of the firm. In particular, recent evidence suggests that derivatives use is related to debt levels and maturity, dividend policy, holdings of liquid assets, and the degree of operating hedging. Moreover, corporations do not just use financial derivatives, but rely heavily on pass-through, operational hedging, and foreign currency debt to manage financial risk.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Corporate finance, risk management, exposure, foreign exchange rates, derivatives
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F4 - Macroeconomic Aspects of International Trade and Finance; F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance

References

Adam, T., and C.S. Fernando 2006. “Hedging, Speculation and Shareholder Value.” Journal of Financial Economics 81:2: 283-309.

Allayannis, G., and A. Mozumdar 2004. “The Impact of Negative Cash Flow and Influential Observations on Investment-Cash Flow Sensitivity Estimates.” Journal of Banking and Finance 28:5: 901-930.

Allayannis, G., and E. Ofek. 2001. “Exchange Rate Exposure, Hedging, and the Use of For-eign Currency Derivatives.” Journal of International Money and Finance 20: 273-296.

Allayannis, G., and J.P. Weston 2001. “The Use of Foreign Currency Derivatives and Firm Market Value.” Review of Financial Studies 14:1: 243-276.

Allayannis, G., G.W. Brown, and L.F. Klapper 2003. “Capital Structure and Financial Risk: Evidence from Foreign Debt Use in East Asia.” Journal of Finance 58:6: 2667-2710.

Allayannis, G., U. Lel, and D. Miller 2004. “Corporate Governance and the Hedging Pre-mium Around the World.” Darden School Working Paper.

Altman, E. 1983. Corporate Financial Distress. John Wiley, New York, NY.

Asquith, P., and D.W. Mullins, Jr. 1986. “Equity Issues and Offering Dilution.” Journal of Financial Economics 15:1:/2: 61-89.

Bartram, S.M. 2000. “Corporate Risk Management as a Lever for Shareholder Value Crea-tion.” Financial Markets, Institutions, and Instruments 9:5: 279-324.

Bartram, S.M. 2002. “Enhancing Shareholder Value with Corporate Risk Management.” Corporate Finance Review, Vol. 7 (3), November/December, 7-12.

Bartram, S.M. 2006. “The Use of Options in Corporate Risk Management.” Managerial Fi-nance 32:2: 160-181.

Bartram, S.M., and G.M. Bodnar 2007. “The Foreign Exchange Exposure Puzzle.” Manage-rial Finance 33 (9), 642-666.

Bartram, S.M., G.W. Brown and B. Minton 2009. “Resolving the Exposure Puzzle: The Many Facets of Foreign Exchange Exposure.” Journal of Financial Economics, forthcoming.

Bartram, S.M., G.W. Brown and J. Conrad 2006. “The Effects of Derivatives on Firm Risk and Value,” Lancaster University and University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Working paper.

Bartram, S.M., G.W. Brown, and F. Fehle 2009. “International Evidence on Financial De-rivatives Usage.” Financial Management, Vol. 38 (1), Spring 2009, 185-206.

Bartram, S.M., G.W. Brown, and J.E. Hund 2007. “Estimating Systemic Risk in the Interna-tional Financial System.“ Journal of Financial Economics 86(3), December, 835-869.

Berger, P.G., and E. Ofek 1995. “Diversification’s Effect on Firm Value.” Journal of Finan-cial Economics 37:1: 39-65.

Berkman, H., and M.E. Bradbury 1996. “Empirical Evidence on the Corporate Use of De-rivatives.” Financial Management 25:2: 5-13.

Bessembinder, H. 1991. “Forward Contracts and Firm Value: Investment Incentive and Con-tracting Effects.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 26:4: 519-532.

Black, F., and M. Scholes 1973. “The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities.” Journal of Political Economy 81:3: 637-654.

Block, S.B., and T.J. Gallagher 1986. “The Use of Interest Rate Futures and Options by Cor-porate Financial Managers.” Financial Management 15:3: 73-78.

Bodnar, G.M., A. de Jong, and V. Macrae 2003. “The Impact of Institutional Differences on Derivatives Usage: A Comparative Study of U.S. and Dutch Firms.” European Fi-nancial Management 9: 271-297.

Bodnar, G.M., and G. Gebhardt 1999. “Derivatives Usage in Risk Management by U.S. and German Non-financial Firms: A Comparative Survey.” Journal of International Fi-nancial Management & Accounting 10:3: 153-188.

Bodnar, G.M., B. Dumas, and R.C. Marston 2002. “Pass-through and exposure.” Journal of Finance 57:1: 199-231.

Bodnar, G.M., C. Tang, and J. Weintrop 1997. “Both Sides of Corporate Diversification: The Value Impacts of Geographic and Industrial Diversification.” NBER Working Paper Series.

Bodnar, G.M., G.S. Hayt, and R.C. Marston 1998. “1998 Wharton Survey of Financial Risk Management by US Non-Financial Firms.” Financial Management 27:4: 70-91.

Borokhovich, K., K. Brunarski, C. Crutchley, and B. Simkins 2004. “Board composition and Corporate Use of Interest Rate Derivatives.” Journal of Financial Research 27:2: 199-126.

Breeden, D., and S. Viswanathan 2006. “Why Do Firms Hedge? An Asymmetric Information Model.” Duke University Working Paper.

Brown, G. 2001. “Managing Foreign Exchange Risk with Derivatives.” Journal of Financial Economics 60:2/3: 401-449.

Brown, G. W. and K. B. Toft 2002. “How Firms Should Hedge.” Review of Financial Studies 15, 1283-1324.

Brown, G., P. Crabb, and D. Haushalter 2006. “Are Firms Successful at Selective Hedging?” Journal of Business, 79:6: 2925-2949.

Browning, S.J., and L. Jereski 1997. “In the Money: Firms with Sagging Stocks Set New ‘Repricing’ of Executive Options.” Wall Street Journal June 11th: C1-C2.

Campbell, T.S., and W.A. Kracaw 1987. “Optimal Managerial Contracts and the Value of Corporate Insurance.” Journal of Financial Quantitative Analysis 22:3: 315-328.

Campbell, T.S., and W.A. Kracaw 1990. “Corporate Risk Management and Incentive Effects of Debt.” Journal of Finance 45:5: 1673-1686.

Carter, D.A., D. Rogers, and B.J. Simkins 2006. “Does Hedging Affect Firm Value? Evi-dence from the US Airline Industry.” Financial Management 35:1: 53-87.

Chang, C. 2000. “Does Corporate Hedging Aggravate or Alleviate Agency Problems? A Managerial Theory of Risk Management.” University of Minnesota Working Paper.

Comment, R., and G.A. Jarrell 1995. “Corporate Focus and Stock Returns.” Journal of Fi-nancial Economics 37:1: 67-87.

Copeland, T., and M. Copeland 1999. “Managing Corporate FX Risk: A Value Maximizing Approach.” Financial Management 28:3: 68-75.

Core, J.E., W.R. Guay, and S.P. Kothari 2002. “The Economic Dilution of Employee Stock Options: Diluted EPS for Valuation and Financial Reporting.” Accounting Review 77:3: 627-653.

Culp, C.L., D. Furbush, and B.T. Kavanagh 1994. “Structured Debt and Corporate Risk Management.” Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 7:3: 73-84.

Cutler, D., and L. Summers 1988. “The Cost of Conflict Resolution and Financial Distress: Evidence from the Texaco-Pennzoil Litigation.” Lawrence H. Rand Journal of Eco-nomics 19:2: 157-172.

DaDalt, P., G. Gay, and J. Nam 2002. “Asymmetric Information and Corporate Derivatives Use.” Journal of Futures Markets 22:3: 241-267.

DeMarzo, P.M., and D. Duffie 1991. “Corporate Financial Hedging with Proprietary Infor-mation.” Journal of Economic Theory 53:2: 261-286.

DeMarzo, P.M., and D. Duffie 1995. “Corporate Incentives for Hedge and Hedge Account-ing.” Review of Financial Studies 8:3: 743-771.

Demsetz, H., and K. Lehn 1985. “The Structure of Corporate Ownership: Causes and Conse-quences.“ The Journal of Political Economy 93:6: 1155-1177.

Dionne, G., and M. Garand 2003. “Risk Management Determinants Affecting Firm’s Values in the Gold Mining Industry: New empirical results.” Economics Letters 79: 43-52.

Dionne, G., and T. Triki 2004. “On Risk Management Determinants: What Really Matters?” HEC Montréal Working Paper.

Dionne, G., and T. Triki 2005. “Risk Management and Corporate Governance: The impor-tance of Independence and Financial Knowledge for the Board and the Audit Com-mittee.” HEC Montréal Working Paper.

Dolde, W. 1993. “The Trajectory of Corporate Financial Risk Management.” Continental Bank Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 6:3: 33-41.

Dolde, W. 1995. “Hedging, Leverage and Primitive Risk.” Journal of Financial Engineering 4:2: 187-216.

Dolde, W., and D. Mishra 2007. “Firm Complexity and FX Derivatives Use.” Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics 46:4: 3-23.

Dufey, G., and S.L. Srinivasulu 1983. “The Case for Corporate Risk Management of Foreign Exchange Risk.” Financial Management 12:4: 54-62.

Fama, E.F. 1980. “Agency Problems and the Theory of the Firm.” Journal of Political Econ-omy 88:2: 288-307.

Faulkender, M. 2005. “Hedging or Market Timing? Selecting the Interest Rate Exposure of Corporate Debt.” Journal of Finance 60: 931-962.

Fite, D., and P. Pfleiderer 1995. “Should Firms Use Derivatives to Manage Risk?” In: Bea-ver, W., and G. Parker (eds.). Risk Management: Problems and Solutions. McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, 139-169.

Fok, R.C.W., C. Carroll, and M.C. Chiou 1997. “Determinants of Corporate Hedging and Derivatives: A Revisit.” Journal of Economics and Business 49: 569-585.

Francis, J., and J. Stephan 1990. “Characteristics of Hedging Firms: An Empirical Examina-tion.” In: Schwartz, R.W., and C.W. Smith, Jr. (eds.). Advanced Strategies in Finan-cial Risk Management. New York Institute of Finance, New York, 615-35.

Froot, K.A., D.S. Scharfstein, and J.C. Stein 1993. “Risk Management: Coordinating Corpo-rate Investment and Financing Policies.” Journal of Finance 48:5: 1629-1658.

Froot, K.A., D.S. Scharfstein, and J.C. Stein 1994. “A Framework for Risk Management.” Harvard Business Review 72:6: 91-102.

Gay, G. D., J. Nam and M. Turac 2003. “On the Optimal Mix of Corporate Hedging Instru-ments: Linear Versus Non-linear Derivatives.” Journal of Futures Markets 23:3: 217-239.

Gay, G.D., and J. Nam 1998. “The Underinvestment Problem and Corporate Derivatives Use.” Financial Management 27:4: 53-69.

Géczy, C., B.A. Minton, and C. Schrand 1997. “Why Firms Use Currency Derivatives.” Journal of Finance 52:4: 1323-1354.

Géczy, C., B.A. Minton, and C. Schrand 2006. “The Use of Multiple Risk Management Strategies: Evidence from the Natural Gas Industry.” The Journal of Risk 8:3: 1-21.

Géczy, C., B.A. Minton, and C. Schrand 2007. “Taking a View: Corporate Speculation, Gov-ernance and Compensation.” Journal of Finance, 62:5: 2405-2443.

Graham, J.R., and C.W. Smith, Jr. 1999. “Tax Incentives to Hedge.” Journal of Finance 54:6: 2241-2263.

Graham, J.R., and C.W. Smith, Jr. 2000. “Tax Progressivity and Corporate Incentives to Hedge.” Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 12:4: 102-111.

Graham, J.R., and D.A. Rogers 2002. “Is Corporate Hedging Consistent with Value Maximi-zation? An Empirical Analysis.” Journal of Finance 57:2: 815-840.

Guay, W.R. 1999. “The Impact of Derivatives on Firm Risk: An Empirical Examination of New Derivatives Users.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 26: 319-351.

Guay, W.R., and S.P. Kothari 2003. “How Much Do Firms Hedge with Derivatives?” Jour-nal of Financial Economics 70: 423-461.

Haushalter, G.D. 2000. “Financing Policy, Basis Risk, and Corporate Hedging: Evidence from Oil and Gas Producers.” Journal of Finance 55:1: 107-152.

Haushalter, G.D. 2001. “Why Hedge? Some Evidence on Oil and Gas Producers.” Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 13:4: 87-92.

Hentschel, L., and S.P. Kothari 2001. “Are Corporations Reducing or Taking Risks with De-rivatives?” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 36: 93-118.

Houston, C.O., and G.G. Mueller 1988. “Foreign Exchange Rate Hedging and SFAS No. 52 – Relatives or Strangers?” Accounting Horizons 2: 50-57.

Howton, S.D., and S.B. Perfect 1998. “Currency and Interest-rate Derivatives Use in U.S. Firms.” Financial Management 27:4: 111-121.

Jensen, M.C., and W.H. Meckling 1976. “Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs and Ownership Structure.” Journal of Financial Economics 3: 305-360.

Jin, Y. and P. Jorion 2006. “Firm Value and Hedging: Evidence from U.S. Oil and Gas Pro-ducers.” Journal of Finance 61:2: 893-919.

Jorion, P. 1990. “The Exchange-Rate Exposure of U.S. Multinationals.” Journal of Business 63: 331-345.

Kale, J.R., and T.H. Noe 1990. “Corporate Hedging under Personal and Corporate Taxation.” Managerial and Decision Economics 11:3: 199-205.

Kedia, S., and A. Mozumdar 2003. “Foreign Currency Denominated Debt: An Empirical Examination.” Journal of Business 76: 521–46.

Knopf, J., J. Nam, and J. Thornton, Jr. 2002. “The Volatility of Price Sensitivities of Mana-gerial Stock Option Portfolios and Corporate Hedging.” Journal of Finance 57:2: 801-813.

Lel, U. 2006. “Currency Hedging and Corporate Governance: A Cross-country Analysis.” University of Indiana Working Paper.

Leland, H.E. 1998. “Agency Costs, Risk Management, and Capital Structure.” Journal of Finance 53:4: 1213-1243.

Lewent, J.C., and A.J. Kearney 1990. “Identifying, Measuring, and Hedging Currency Risk at Merck.” Continental Bank Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 2:4: 19-28.

Lin, C.-M., and S. Smith 2007. “Hedging, Financing and Investment Decisions: A Simulta-neous Equations Framework.” The Financial Review 42: 2: 191-204.

Lookman, A. 2003. “Does Hedging Really Affect Firm Value?” Carnegie Mellon University Working Paper.

Mackay, P. and S.B. Moeller 2007. “The Value of Corporate Risk Management.” Journal of Finance 62:3: 1379-1419.

MacKie-Mason, J.K. 1990. “Do Taxes Affect Corporate Financing Decisions?” Journal of Finance 45:5: 1471-1493.

Mardsen, A., and A. Prevost 2005. “Derivatives Usage, Corporate Governance, and Legisla-tive Change: An Empirical Analysis of New Zealand listed Companies.” Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 32:1: 255-295.

Markowitz, H.M. 1952. “Portfolio Selection.” Journal of Finance 7: 77-91.

Mason, S.P., and R.C. Merton 1985. “The Role of Contingent Claims Analysis in Corporate Finance.” In: Altman, E.I., and M.G. Subrahmanyam (eds.). Recent Advances in Cor-porate Finance. Irwin, Homewood, IL, 7-54.

May, D.O. 1995. “Do Managerial Motives Influence Firm Risk Reduction Strategies?” Jour-nal of Finance 50:4: 1291-1308.

Mayers, D., and C.W. Smith, Jr. 1982. “On the Corporate Demand for Insurance.” Journal of Business 55:2: 281-296.

Mayers, D., and C.W. Smith, Jr. 1987. “Corporate Insurance and the Underinvestment Prob-lem.” Journal of Risk and Insurance 54:1: 45-54.

Mayers, D., and C.W. Smith, Jr. 1990. “On the Corporate Demand for Insurance: Evidence from the Reinsurance Market.” Journal of Business 63:1: 19-40.

Mello, A.S., and J.E. Parsons 1999. “Strategic Hedging.” Journal of Applied Corporate Fi-nance 12:3: 43-54.

Mello, A.S., J.E. Parsons, and A. Triantis 1995. “An Integrated Model of Multinational Flex-ibility and Financial Hedging.” Journal of International Economics 39:1, 27-51.

Merton, R. C. 1974. “On the Pricing of Corporate Debt: The Risk Structure of Interest Rates.” Journal of Finance 29:2: 449-470.

Mian, S.L. 1996. “Evidence on Corporate Hedging Policy.” Journal of Financial and Quan-titative Analysis 31:3: 419-439.

Minton, B.A., and C.M. Schrand 1999. “The Impact of Cash Flow Volatility of Discretionary Investment and the Costs of Debt and Equity Financing.” Journal of Financial Eco-nomics 54:3: 423-461.

Modigliani, F., and M.H. Miller 1958. “The Cost of Capital, Corporation Finance, and the Theory of Investment.” American Economic Review 48:3: 261-297.

Moore, J., J. Culver, and B. Masterman 2000. “Risk Management for Middle Market Com-panies.” Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 12:4: 112-119.

Morellec, E., and C.W. Smith, Jr. 2007. “Agency Conflicts and Risk Management.” Review of Finance 11, 1-23.

Myers, S.C. 1977. “Determinants of Corporate Borrowing.” Journal of Financial Economics 5: 147-175.

Myers, S.C. 1984. “The Capital Structure Puzzle.” Journal of Finance 39:3: 575-592.

Myers, S.C. 1993. “Still Searching for Optimal Capital Structure.” In: Stern, J.M., and D.H. Chew, Jr. (eds.). The Revolution in Corporate Finance. Basil Blackwell Ltd., New York, NY, 91-99.

Nain, A., 2004. “The Strategic Motives for Corporate Risk Management.” University of Michigan working paper.

Nance, D.R., C.W. Smith, Jr., and C.W. Smithson 1993. “On the Determinants of Corporate Hedging.” Journal of Finance 48:1: 267-284.

Nguyen, H., and R. Faff 2003. “Are Financial Derivatives Really Value-Enhancing? Austra-lian Evidence.” University of South Australia Working Paper.

Petersen, M.A., and S.R. Thiagarajan 2000. “Risk Measurement and Hedging: With and Without Derivatives.” Financial Management 29:4: 5-30.

Rajgopal, S., and T. Shevlin 2002. “Empirical Evidence on the Relation between Stock Op-tion Compensation and Risk Taking.” Journal of Accounting and Economics 33:2: 146-171.

Raposo, C.C. 1999. “Corporate Hedging: What have we learnt so far?” Derivatives Quarterly 5:3: 41-51.

Rawls, S.W., and C.W. Smithson 1990. “Strategic Risk Management.” Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 2:4: 6-18.

Rogers, D. 2002. “Does Executive Portfolio Structure Affect Risk Management? CEO Risk Taking Incentives and Corporate Derivatives Usage.” Journal of Banking and Fi-nance 26:2: 271-295.

Santomero, A.M. 1995. “Financial Risk Management: The Whys and Hows.” Financial Markets, Institutions & Instruments 4:5: 1-14.

Smith, C.W., Jr. 1995. “Corporate Risk Management: Theory and Practice.” Journal of De-rivatives 2:4: 21-30.

Smith, C.W., Jr., and J.B. Warner 1979. “On Financial Contracting: An Analysis of Bond Contracting.” Journal of Financial Economics 7:2: 117-161.

Smith, C.W., Jr., and R.L. Watts 1992. “The Investment Opportunity Set and Corporate Fi-nancing, Dividend, and Compensation Policies.” Journal of Financial Economics 32:3: 263-292.

Smith, C.W., Jr., and R.M. Stulz 1985. “The Determinants of Firms’ Hedging Policies.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 20:4: 391-406.

Smith, C.W., Jr., C.W. Smithson, and D.S. Wilford 1990. “Financial Engineering: Why Hedge?” In: Smith, C.W., Jr., and C.W. Smithson (eds.). The Handbook of Financial Engineering. Harper Business Books, Grand Rapids, 126-137.

Spanò, M. 2001. “Investment, Debt and Risk Management in a Context of Uncertain Returns to Investment.” University of York Working Paper.

Stulz, R.M. 1984. “Optimal Hedging Policies.” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analy-sis 19:2: 127-140.

Stulz, R.M. 1990. “Managerial Discretion and Optimal Hedging Policies.” Journal of Finan-cial Economics 26:1: 3-27.

Stulz, R.M. 1996. “Rethinking Risk Management.” Bank of America Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 9:3: 8-24.

Stulz, R.M. 2000. “Diminishing the Threats to Shareholder Wealth.” Financial Times, Series Mastering Risk, April 25, 2000: 8-10.

Stulz, R.M. 2001. “Creating Value with Risk Management.” In: Stulz (eds.). Derivatives, Risk Management and Financial Engineering. Southwestern College Publishing Co., Cincinnati, Chapter 3.

Tufano, P. 1996. “Who Manages Risk? An Empirical Examination of the Risk Management Practices in the Gold Mining Industry.” Journal of Finance 51:4: 1097-1137.

Tufano, P. 1998. “Agency Costs of Corporate Risk Management.” Financial Management 27:1: 67-77.

Vassalou, M., and Y. Xing 2004. “Default Risk in Equity Returns.” Journal of Finance 59:2: 831-868.

Visvanathan, G. 1998. “Who uses Interest Rate Swaps? A Cross-sectional Analysis.” Journal of Accounting, Auditing, and Finance 13:3: 173-200.

Warner, J.B. 1977a. “Bankruptcy, Absolute Priority, and the Pricing of Risky Debt Claims.” Journal of Financial Economics 4: 239-276.

Warner, J.B. 1977b. “Bankruptcy Costs: Some Evidence.” Journal of Finance 32:2: 337-347.

Weiss, L.A. 1990. “Bankruptcy Resolution: Direct Costs and Violation of Priority Claims.” Journal of Financial Economics 27:2: 285-314.