Household Need for Liquidity and the Credit Card Debt Puzzle

Telyukova, Irina A. (2009): Household Need for Liquidity and the Credit Card Debt Puzzle.

Abstract

In the 2001 U.S. Survey of Consumer Finances (SCF), 27% of households report simultaneously revolving significant credit card debt and holding sizeable amounts of liquid assets. These consumers report paying, on average, a 14% interest rate on their debt, while earning only 1 or 2% on their liquid deposit accounts. This phenomenon is known as the “credit card debt puzzle”, as it appears to violate the standard no-arbitrage condition. In this paper, I quantitatively evaluate demand for liquidity as an explanation for this puzzle: households that accumulate credit card debt may not pay it off using their money in the bank, because they expect to use that money in situations where credit cards cannot be used. Using both aggregate and survey data (SCF and CEX), I document that liquid assets are a substantial part of households’ portfolios and that consumption in goods requiring liquid payments appears to have a sizeable unpredictable component. This would warrant holding positive balances in liquid accounts both for transactions and precautionary purposes. I develop a dynamic heterogeneous-agent model of household portfolio choice, where households are subject to uninsurable income and preference uncertainty, and consumer credit and liquidity coexist as means of consumption and saving/borrowing. The calibration of the model parameters is based on the simulated method of moments. The calibrated model accounts for between 85% and 104% of the households in the data who hold consumer debt and liquidity simultaneously, and for between 56 and 62 cents of every dollar held by a median household in the puzzle group. Thus the transactions and precautionary demand for liquidity appear to be a significant factor in accounting for the credit card debt puzzle.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Demand for money; credit card debt; incomplete markets; idiosyncratic risk; precautionary liquidity demand.
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D12 - Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy > E21 - Consumption ; Saving ; Wealth; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates > E41 - Demand for Money; D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D14 - Household Saving; Personal Finance

References

[1] Aiyagari, S. R. and M. Gertler. 1991. “Asset Returns with Transactions Costs and Uninsurable Individual Risk.” Journal of Monetary Economics, 27(3), 311-331.

[2] American Bankers Association / Dove Consulting. “2004 Study of Consumer Payment Preferences”.

[3] Athreya, K. 2004. “Fresh Start or Head Start? Uniform Bankruptcy Exemptions and Welfare.” Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond.

[4] Ausubel, L. 1991. “The Failure of Competition in the Credit Card Market.” The American Economic Review, 81, 50-81.

[5] Bertaut, C. and M. Haliassos, 2002. “Debt Revolvers for Self Control.” University of Cyprus.

[6] Baumol, W.J. 1952. “The Transactions Demand for Cash: An Inventory Theoretic Approach.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 66, 545-556.

[7] Brito, D. and P. Hartley, 1995. “Consumer Rationality and Credit Cards”. Journal of Political Economy, 103(2), 400-433.

[8] Browning, M. and A. Lusardi, 1996. “Household Saving: Micro Theories and Micro Facts.” Journal of Economic Literature, 34, 1797-1855.

[9] Bruce, L. 2002. “A Graphic Look at Deposit Rates, 1998-2002.” bankrate.com.

[10] Budrıa-Rodrıguez, S., J. Dıaz-Gimenez, V. Quadrini and J.V. Rıos-Rull, 2002. “Updated Facts on the U.S. Distributions of Earnings, Income and Wealth”. Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review, 26(3), 2-35.

[11] Cargill, T. and J.Wendel, 1996. “Bank Credit Cards: Consumer Irrationality versus Market Forces?” The Journal of Consumer Affairs, 30, 373-389.

[12] Casta˜neda, A., J. D´ıaz-Gim´enez, and J. V. R´ıos-Rull. 1998. “Exploring the Income Distribution Business Cycle Dynamics”. Journal of Monetary Economics, 42, 93-130.

[13] Chari, V. V., L. Christiano and P. J. Kehoe, 1991. “Optimal Fiscal and Monetary Policy: Some Recent Results”. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 23, 519-539.

[14] Chatterjee, S., D. Corbae, M. Nakajima, J.V. R`ıos-Rull, 2007. “A Quantitative Theory of Unsecured Consumer Credit with Risk of Default.” Forthcoming, Econometrica.

[15] Duca, J. V., and W. C. Whitesell, 1995. “Credit Cards and Money Demand: A Cross-Sectional Study.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 27, 604-623.

[16] Durkin, T., 2000. “Credit Cards: Use and Consumer Attitudes, 1970-2000.” Federal Reserve Bulletin, September.

[17] Durkin, T., 2002. “Consumers and Credit Disclosures: Credit Cards and Credit Insurance.” Federal Reserve Bulletin, April.

[18] Eisfeldt, A., 2003. “Smoothing with Liquid and Illiquid Assets”. Kellogg School of Management.

[19] Erosa, A. and G. Ventura, 2002. “On Inflation as a Regressive Consumption Tax.” Journal of Monetary Economics, May.

[20] Evans, D. and R. Schmalensee, 1999. Paying with Plastic: The Digital Revolution in Buying and Selling. MIT Press.

[21] Federal Reserve Board. Statistical Release G.19, Consumer Credit. Various issues.

[22] Fernandez-Villaverde, J. and D. Krueger, 2004. “Consumption over the Life Cycle: Facts from the Consumer Expenditure Survey.” University of Pennsylvania.

[23] Gabriel, P., 2003. “An examination of occupational mobility of full-time workers”. Monthly Labor Review, September.

[24] Gervais, M. and P. Klein. 2006. “Measuring Consumption Smoothing in CEX Data”. Mimeo, University of Western Ontario.

[25] Gourieroux, C. and A. Monfort, 1996. Simulation-Based Econometric Methods, Oxford University Press.

[26] Gross, D. and N. Souleles, 2002. “Do Liquidity Constraints and Interest Rates Matter for Consumer Behavior? Evidence from Credit Card Data.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, February, 149-185.

[27] Gross, D. and N. Souleles, 2001. “An Empirical Analysis of Personal Bankruptcy and Delinquency.” Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.

[28] Haliassos, M. and M. Reiter, 2003. “Credit Card Debt Puzzles.” University of Cyprus. [29] Hayashi, F. and E. Klee, 2003. “Technology Adoption and Consumer Payments: Evidence from Survey Data.” Review of Network Economics, 2, 175-190.

[30] Hopenhayn, H. and E. Prescott. 1992. “Stochastic Monotonicity and Stationary Distributions for Dynamic Economies,” Econometrica, 60(6), 1387-1406.

[31] Jasper, M. 2000. Legal Almanac: Credit Cards and the Law. Oceana Publications, Inc.

[32] Johnson, K.W., 2004. “Convenience or Necessity? Understanding the Recent Rise in Credit Card Debt.” Finance and Economics Discussion Series, Federal Reserve Board.

[33] Krueger, D. and F. Perri, 2003. “On the Welfare Consequences of the Increase in Inequality in the United States”, in NBER Macroeconomics Annual 2003, M. Gertler and K. Rogoff, eds. The MIT Press.

[34] Lacker, J. and S. Schreft. 1996. “Money and credit as means of payment”. Journal of Monetary Economics, 38(1), 3-23.

[35] Laibson, D., A. Repetto and J. Tobacman, 2002. “A Debt Puzzle.” Harvard University.

[36] Lee, D. and M. Wiswald, 2007. “A Parallel Implementation of the Simplex Function Minimization Routine”. Forthcoming, Computational Economics.

[37] Lehnert, A. and D.M. Maki, 2002. “Consumption, Debt and Portfolio Choice: Testing the Effect of Bankruptcy Law.” Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve Bank.

[38] Lucas, R., E. Prescott and N. Stokey, 1989. “Recursive Methods in Economic Dynamics”. Harvard University Press.

[39] Meisenheimer, J. and R. Ilg, 2000. Looking for a ’Better Job’: The Job Search Activity of the Employed. Monthly Labor Review, September.

[40] Nelder, J. A., and R. Mead. 1965. “A Simplex Method for Function Minimization”. The Computer Journal.

[41] Prescott, E.S. and D.D. Tatar, 1999. “Means of Payment, the Unbanked, and EFT’99.” Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond Economic Quarterly, 85, 49-70.

[42] Quadrini, V. and J.-V. R´ıos-Rull, 1997. Understanding the U.S. Distribution of Wealth.” Quarterly Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, spring, 22-36.

[43] Schreft, S. 1992. “Transaction Costs and the Use of Cash and Credit”. Economic Theory, 2(2), 283-96.

[44] Shimer, R. 2005. “The Cyclical Behavior of Equilibrium Employment and Vacancies.” American Economic Review, 95(1), 25-49.

[45] Stavins, J., 2000. “Credit Card Borrowing, Delinquency, and Personal Bankruptcy.” New England Economic Review, July/August.

[46] Storesletten, K., C. I. Telmer and A. Yaron, 2004a. “Consumption and Risk Sharing Over the Life Cycle”. Journal of Monetary Economics, 51, 609-633.

[47] Storesletten, K., C. I. Telmer and A. Yaron, 2004b. “Cyclical Dynamics in Idiosyncratic Labor-Market Risk”. Journal of Political Economy, 112, 695-717.

[48] Tauchen, G., 1986. “Finite State Markov-Chain Approximations to Univariate and Vector Autoregressions”. Economics Letters, 20, 177-181.

[49] Telyukova, I.A. and L. Visschers, 2009. “Precautionary Demand for Money in a Monetary Business Cycle Model”. Mimeo, UCSD.

[50] Telyukova, I. A. and R. Wright, 2008. “A Model of Money and Credit, with Application to the Credit Card Debt Puzzle.” Review of Economic Studies, 75(2), 629-647.

[51] U.S. Census Bureau, 2003. Statistical Abstract of the United States.

[52] Yoo, P.S., 1998. “Still Charging: The Growth of Credit Card Debt Between 1992 and 1995.” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review, January/February.

[53] Zinman, J., 2006. “Household Borrowing High and Lending Low under No-Arbitrage”. Dartmouth University.