Federal provincial fiscal arrangements and shared-cost programs in agriculture

Grady, Patrick (1990): Federal provincial fiscal arrangements and shared-cost programs in agriculture. Published in: No. Working Paper 2/91 (1 December 1990): pp. 1-65.

Abstract

Agriculture Canada is concerned about the funding of agricultural programs as the number of shared-cost federal-provincial programs increase and requests from provinces for special assistance proliferate. Many of these requests are justified on the basis that the provinces do not have the ability to pay or the widespread extent of the problem. This raises questions of the appropriate interrelationships between agricultural programs and the federal-provincial fiscal arrangements. This study is designed to gain a better understanding of the principles involved in the federal-provincial fiscal arrangements and their relevance for agriculture and to establish clearer guidelines in responding to provincial requests.

This study examines the basis for federal-provincial fiscal programs and federal transfer programs from a theoretical, legal and historical point of view. It also examines the special case of agriculture and the shared federal-provincial responsibility for agriculture under the constitution. A primary focus is to assess the rationale for special assistance programs for provinces or commodity groups such as those for grain farmers within the context of the overall framework of federal-provincial fiscal relations. The study also examines the fiscal consequences of increasing shared-cost programs in agriculture.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Fiscal arrangements; shared cost programs; agricultural income stabilization
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H59 - Other

References

Boadway, Robin, "Federal-Provincial Transfers in Canada: A Critical Review of the Existing Arrangements," in Mark Krasnick (ed.) Fiscal Federalism, Volume 65, Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1986), pp.1-47.

Boadway, Robin, Intergovernmental Transfers in Canada Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation, 1980).

Breton Albert and Anthony Scott, The Economic Constitution of Federal States (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1978).

British Columbia Court of Appeal, Reference re: Canada Assistance Plan Act [19901 B.C.J. No.1377, June 15, 1990.

Carter, George E., Canadian Conditional Grants Since World War II (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation, 1971).

Conference of Ministers and Deputy Ministers of Agriculture, "Joint Provincial Paper on Federal-Provincial Cost Sharing /Offloading," August 21-23, 1990.

Courchene, Thomas J., Social Policy for the 1990s: Agenda for Reform (Toronto: C.D.Howe Institute, 1987).

Department of Finance, Federal Transfers to Provinces, May 1990.

Department of Finance, Federal-Provincial Relations Division, "The Fiscal Equalization Program," April 1990.

Dupre, J.S., "Contracting Out: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Centennial," Report of the Proceedings of the Eighteenth Annual Meeting (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation, 1965).

Economic Council of Canada, Financing Confederation: Today and Tomorrow, (Ottawa:Minister of Supply and Services, 1982).

Farm Finance and Taxation Division, Policy Branch, Agriculture Canada, Farm Income Financial Conditions and Government Expenditures, July 1990.

Federal-Provincial Relations Office, Federal-Provincial Programs and Activities: A Descriptive Inventory 1989-90, (Ottawa:1990).

Federal-Provincial Safety Net Committee, Report to Ministers of Agriculture, June 30,1990.

Fletcher, Frederick J. and Donald C. Wallace, "Federal-Provincial Relations and the Making of Public Policy in Canada," in Richard Simeon (ed.) Division of Powers and Public Policy, Volume 61, Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1986), pp.125-205.

Gramlich, Edward M., "Federalism and Federal Deficit Reduction," National Tax Journal, Vol.XL, No. 3 (1987), pp.299-313.

Jackson, Robert J. and Doreen Jackson, Politics in Canada, Second Edition(Scarborough: Prentice Hall, 1990).

La Forest, Gerard V., The Allocation of Taxing Power under the Canadian Constitution(Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation, 1967).

Laskin, Bora, Canadian Constitutional Law (Toronto: Carswell, 1966), p.666.

MacEachen, Allan J., "Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements in the Eighties," A Submission to the Parliamentary Task Force on the Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements, April 23, 1981.

Moscovitch, Allan, "The Canada Assistance Plan: A Twenty Year Assessment, 1966-86," in Katherine A. Graham (ed.), How Ottawa Spends 1988/89 (Ottawa: Carleton University Press, 1988).

Oates, Wallace E., Fiscal Federalism (Chicago: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich, 1972).

Parliamentary Task Force on Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements, Fiscal Federalism in Canada, (Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services, 1981).

Perry, D.B., "Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangements for 1982-87," Canadian Tax Journal, Vol. 31 (January-February, 1982), pp.30-41.

Petter, Andrew, "Federalism and the Myth of Federal Spending Power," Canadian Bar Review, 448, (1989), pp.455-63.

Royal Commission on Dominion-Provincial Relations, Report (Ottawa: the Queen's Printer, 1940.

Smiley, Donald V., Conditional Grants and Canadian Federalism (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation, 1963). 57

Simeon, Richard, "Fiscal Federalism in Canada: A Review Essay," Canadian Tax Journal, Vol. 30 (January-February, 1982), pp.41-51.

Trudeau, P.E., Federal Provincial Grants and the Spending Powers of Parliament (Ottawa: Queen's Printer, 1969).

Ward, Norman, Dawson's The Government of Canada, Sixth Edition (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1987).