The Governance of Migration Policy

Hanson, Gordon H. (2009): The Governance of Migration Policy. Published in: Human Development Research Paper (HDRP) Series , Vol. 02, No. 2009

Abstract

In this paper, I examine high-income country motives for restricting immigration. Abundant evidence suggests that allowing labor to move from low-income to high-income countries would yield substantial gains in global income. Yet, most high-income countries impose strict limits on labor inflows and set their admission policies unilaterally. A core principle underlying the World Trade Organization is reciprocity in tariff setting. When it comes to migration from poor to rich countries, however, labor flows are rarely bidirectional, making reciprocity moot and leaving labor importers with all the bargaining power. One motivation for barriers to labor inflows is political pressure from groups that are hurt by immigration. Raising immigration would depend on creating mechanisms to transfer income from those that immigration helps to those that it hurts. Another motivation for immigration restrictions is that labor inflows from abroad may exacerbate distortions in an economy associated with redistributive tax and transfer policies. Making immigration more attractive would require creating mechanisms that limit the negative fiscal impacts of labor inflows on natives. Fiscal distortions create an incentive for receiving countries to screen immigrants according to their perceived economic impact. For high skilled immigrants, screening can be based on educational degrees and professional credentials, which are relatively easy to observe. For low skilled immigrants, illegal immigration represents an imperfect but increasingly common screening device. For policy makers in labor-importing nations, the modest benefits freer immigration brings may simply not be worth the political hassle. To induce high-income countries to lower border barriers, they need to get more out of the bargain.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: international migration, labor mobility, political economy, illegal migration
• Subjects: Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology; K - Law and Economics > K0 - General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O15 - Human Resources ; Human Development ; Income Distribution ; Migration

References

Acosta, Pablo, Pablo Fajnzylber, and Humberto Lopez. 2007. “How Important are Remittances in America?” In Pablo Fajnzylber and Humberto Lopez, eds., Close to Home, Washington, DC: The World Bank, forthcoming.

Antecol, Heather, Deborah A. Cobb-Clark, Stephen J. Trejo. 2003. “Immigration Policy and the Skills of Immigrants to Australia, Canada, and the United States.” Journal of Human Resources. 38(1): 192-218.

Åslund, Olof, Per-Anders Edin and Peter Fredriksson. 2001. Settlement Policies and the Economic Success of Immigrants. IZA Discussion Paper No. 2730.

Auerbach, Alan J., and Philip Oreopoulos. 1999. “Analyzing the Fiscal Impact of U.S. Immigration.” American Economic Review. Papers and Proceedings, 89(2), pp. 176-180.

Autor, David. 2008. Studies in Labor Market Intermediation. University of Chicago Press, forthcoming.

Benhabib, Jess. 1996. “On the Political Economy of Immigration.” European Economic Review, 40: 1737-1743.

Bertocchi, Graziella, and Chiara Strozzi. 2006. “The Evolution of Citizenship: Economic and Institutional Determinants.” IZA Discussion Paper No. 2510.

Bisin, Alberto, Eleonora Patacchini, Thierry Verdier, and Yves Zenou. 2008. “Are Muslim Immigrants Different in Terms of Cultural Integration?” Journal of the European Economic Association, 6(2-3), 445 - 456.

Boeri, Tito, and Herbert Brücker. 2005. “Migration, Co-ordination Failures, and EU Enlargement.” Economic Policy, 20(44), 629-703.

Boeri, Tito, Barry McCormick, and Gordon H. Hanson. 2002. Immigration Policy and the Welfare State. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Borjas, George J. Heaven’s Door: Immigration Policy and the American Economy. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1999.

Borjas, George J. “The Labor Demand Curve Is Downward Sloping: Reexamining the Impact of Immigration on the Labor Market,” Quarterly Journal of Economics 118 (November 2003): 1335-1374.

Borjas, George J., and Lynette Hilton. 1996. “Immigration and the Welfare State: Immigrant Participation in Means-Tested Entitlement Programs” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 111(2): 575-604.

Briggs, Vernon. 2004. “Guestworker Programs: Lessons from the Past and Warnings for the Future.” Center for Immigration Studies. Butcher, Kristin F. and Anne Morrison Piehl. 1998. “Recent Immigrants: Unexpected Implications for Crime and Incarceration.” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 51: 654-679.

Butcher, Kristin F. and Anne Morrison Piehl. 2006. “Why are Immigrants’ Incarceration Rates so Low? Evidence on Selective Immigration, Deterrence, and Deportation.” Mimeo, Wellesley College and Rutgers University.

Calavita, Kitty. Inside The State: The Bracero Program, Immigration, and The I.N.S. New York, NY: Routledge, 1992.

Camarota, Steven A. The High Cost of Cheap Labor: Illegal Immigration and the Federal Budget. Center for Immigration Studies, 2004.

Camarota, Steven. 2005. Immigration at Mid Decade: A Snapshot of America’s Foreign Born Population in 2005. Center for Immigration Studies.

Camarota, Steven. 2008. “Homeward Bound: Recent Immigration Enforcement and the Decline in the Illegal Alien Population.” Center for Immigration Studies.

Charlton, Andrew, and Joseph Stiglitz. 2005. “A Development-friendly Prioritisation of Doha Round Proposals.” The World Economy, 28(3): 298-312.

Clemens, Michael, Claudio Montenegro, and Lant Pritchett. 2008. “The Great Discrimination: Borders as a Labor Market Barrier.” Mimeo, Center on Global Development.

Collado, M. Dolores, Inigo Iturbe-Ormaetxe, Guadalupe Valera, 2004. “Quantifying the Impact of Spanish Immigration on the Welfare State.” International Tax and Public Finance, 11: 335- 353.

Cortes, Patricia. 2008. “The Effect of Low-Skilled Immigration on U.S. Prices: Evidence from CPI Data.” Journal of Political Economy.

Cox, Adam B. and Eric A. Posner. 2007. “The Second Order Structure of U.S. Immigration Law.” Stanford Law Review, 59(4).

Davila, Alberto, Jose A. Pagan, and Montserrat Viladrich Grau. 1999. “Immigration Reform, the INS, and the Distribution of Interior and Border Enforcement Resources.” Public Choice, 99(3-4): 327-45.

Djajic, Slobodan. 1999. “Dynamics of Immigration Control.” Journal of Population Economics, February 12(1): 45-61.

De Giorgi, Giacomo, and Michele Pellizzari. 2006. “Welfare Migration in Europe and the Cost of a Harmonised Social Assistance.” IZA Discussion Paper No. 2094.

De Melo, Jaime, Jean-Marie Grether and Tobias Müller. 2001. The Political Economy of International Migration in a Ricardo-Viner Model. CEPR Discussion Paper No. 2714.

Docquier, Frederic and Hillel Rapoport. 2008. “Skilled Migration: The Perspective of Developing Countries.” In Jagdish Bhagwati and Gordon Hanson, eds., Skilled Immigration Today: Problems, Prospects, and Policies. Oxford: Oxford University Press, forthcoming.

Dustmann, Christian, and Ian Preston. 2004. “Racial and Economic Factors in Attitudes to Immigration.” Mimeo, University College London.

Epstein, Gil S., Arye L. Hillman, and Avi Weiss. 1999. “Creating Illegal Immigrants.” Journal of Population Economics, 12: 3-21.

Epstein, Gil S., and Avi Weiss. 2001. “A Theory of Immigration Amnesties.” IZA Discussion Paper No. 2830.

Facchini, Giovanni, and Anna Maria Mayda. 2008. “Individual Attitudes towards Immigrants: Welfare-state Determinants across Countries.” Review of Economics and Statistics.

Facchini, Giovanni, Anna Maria Mayda, Prachi Mishra. 2008. “Do Interest Groups Affect Immigration?” Mimeo, Georgetown University and the IMF.

Facchini, Giovanni, and Gerald Willmann. 2006. “The Political Economy of International Factor Mobility.” Journal of International Economics, forthcoming.

Fix, Michael, and Jeffrey Passel. 2002. “The Scope and Impact of Welfare Reform’s Immigrant Provisions.” Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.

Foreman-Peck, J. 1992. “A Political Economy of International Migration.” The Manchester School, 60: 359-376.

Gathmann, Christina. 2004. “The Effects of Enforcement on Illegal Markets: Evidence from Migrant Smuggling on the Southwestern Border.” IZA Discussion Paper No. 1004.

Hainmueller, Jens, and Michael J. Hiscox. 2004. “Educated Preferences: Explaining Attitudes Toward Immigration in Europe.” Paper prepared for presentation at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association.

Hanson, Gordon H. 2006. “Illegal Migration from Mexico to the United States.” Journal of Economic Literature, 44: 869-924.

Hanson, Gordon H. 2008. “The Economic Consequences of the International Migration of Labor.” Annual Review of Economics, forthcoming.

Hanson, Gordon H., Kenneth Scheve, and Matthew J. Slaughter. 2007. “Local Public Finance and Individual Preferences over Globalization Strategies.” Economics and Politics, 19(2007): 1-33.

Hanson, Gordon H., Raymond Robertson, and Antonio Spilimbergo. 2001. "Does Border Enforcement Protect U.S. Workers from Illegal Immigration?" The Review of Economics and Statistics, 84(2002): 73-92.

Hanson, Gordon H., and Antonio Spilimbergo. 2001 "Political Economy, Sectoral Shocks, and Border Enforcement," Canadian Journal of Economics, 34(2001): 612-638.

Hatton, Timothy J., and Jeffrey G. Williamson. 2004. “Refugees, Asylum Seekers and Policy in Europe.” NBER Working Paper No. 10680.

Huntington, Samuel. 2004. Who Are We? The Challenges to America’s National Identity. New York: Simon and Schuster.

International Organization for Migration. 2003. Labour Migration: Trends, Challenges and Policy Responses in Countries of Origin.

IOM/World Bank/WTO. 2004. “Trade and Migration Background Paper.” IOM, World Bank, and the WTO.

Jandl, Michael. 2003. “Estimates on the Number of Illegal and Smuggled Immigrants in Europe.” International Centre for Migration Policy Development.

Jasso, Guillermina and Mark Rosenzweig. 2005. “Selection Criteria and the Skill Composition of Immigrants: A Comparative Analysis of Australian and US Employment Immigration,” mimeo NYU and Yale University.

Lowell, Lindsay. 2000. “H1-B Temporary Visas: Estimating the Population.” Mimeo, Georgetown University.

Mamdouh, Hamid. 2004. “Movement of Natural Persons under the GATS.” WTO.

Martin, Phillip. 2001. “There is Nothing More Permanent than Temporary Foreign Workers.” Center for Immigration Studies.

Martin, Phillip, and Mark Miller. 2000. “Smuggling and Trafficking: A Conference Report.” International Migration Review, 34(3): 969-975.

Massey, Douglas S. 2004. “International Migration at the Dawn of the Twenty-First Century: The Role of the State.” Population and Development Review, 25(2): 303-322.

Massey, Douglas S., L. Goldring, and Jorge Durand. 1994. “Continuities in Transnational Migration: An Analysis of Nineteen Mexican Communities.” American Journal of Sociology 99(6): 1492-1533.

Mayda, Anna Maria. 2006. “Who is Against Immigration? A Cross Country Investigation of Individual Attitudes towards Immigrants.” Review of Economics and Statistics, 88(3): 510-530.

Mazzolari, Francesca. 2006. “Determinants and Effects of Naturalization: Effects of Dual Citizenship Laws.” Mimeo, UC Irvine.

McKenzie, David, John Gibson, and Steven Stillman. 2006. “How Important is Selection? Experimental versus Non-experimental Measures of the Income Gains from Migration.” Mimeo, The World Bank.

Mishra, Prachi. 2007. “Emigration and Wages in Source Countries: Evidence from Mexico.” Journal of Development Economics, 82(1): 180-199.

OECD. 2004. Migration for Employment - Bilateral Agreements at a Crossroads. OECD: Paris.

OECD. 2008. International Migration Outlook. OECD: Paris. Orrenius, Pia M. and Madeline Zavodny. 2005. “Self-Selection among Undocumented Immigrants from Mexico.” Journal of Development Economics, October 78(1): 215-240.

Ortega, Francesc. 2004. “Immigration Policy and the Welfare State.” Mimeo, New York University.

Parsons, Christopher, Ronald Skeldon, Terrie Walmsley, and L. Alan Winters. 2007. “Quantifying International Migration: A Database of Bilateral Migration Stocks.” World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 4165.

Passel, Jeffrey S. 2006. “Size and Characteristics of the Unauthorized Population in the US: Estimates from the March 2005 Current Population Survey.” Pew Hispanic Center.

Poutvaara, Panu. 2005. “Social Security Incentives, Human Capital Investment and Mobility of Labor.” IZA Discussion Paper No. 1729.

Ratha, Dilip, and William Shaw. 2007. “South-South Migration and Remittances.” Mimeo, The World Bank.

Razin, Asaf, and Efraim Sadka. 1999. “Migration and Pensions with International Capital Mobility.” Journal of Public Economics, 74: 141-150.

Razin, Asaf, Efraim Sadka, and Phillip Swagel. 2002. “Tax Burden and Migration: Political Economy Theory and Evidence.” Journal of Public Economics 85: 167-190.

Rosenzweig, Mark. 2007. “Education and Migration: A Global Perspective.” Mimeo, Yale.

Rupert, Elizabeth. 1999. “Managing Foreign Labor in Singapore and Malaysia: Are There Lessons for GCC Countries?” The World Bank, Policy Research Working Paper Series: 2053.

Saiz, Albert. 2007. “Immigration and Housing Rents in American Cities.” Journal of Urban Economics. 61: 345-371.

Scheve, Kenneth F., and Matthew J. Slaughter. 2001. "Labor-Market Competition and Individual Preferences Over Immigration Policy." Review of Economics and Statistics, 83(1): 133-145.

Schiff, Maurice. 2007. “Optimal Immigration Policy: Permanent, Guest-worker, or Mode IV?” Mimeo, World Bank. Scholten, Ulrich, and Marcel Thum. 1996. “Public Pensions and Immigration Policy in a Democracy.” Public Choice, 66: 347-361.

Shah, Nasra. 2006. “Restrictive Labour Immigration Policies in the Oil Rich Gulf.” UN Population Division. Smith, James P. and Barry Edmonston, eds. The New Americans: Economic, Demographic, and Fiscal Effects of Immigration. Washington, DC: National Academy Pres, 1997.

Storesletten, Kjetil. 2000. “Sustaining Fiscal Policy Through Immigration.” Journal of Political Economy, 108(2): 300-323.

Storesletten, Kjetil. 2003. “Fiscal Implications of Immigration: A Net Present Value Calculation.” Mimeo, Stockholm University.

Walmsley, Terrie L. and L. Alan Winters. 2005. “Relaxing the Restrictions on the Temporary Movement of Natural Persons: A Simulation Analysis.” Journal of Economic Integration, 20(4): 688-726.

Wellisch, Dietmar, and Uwe Walz. 1998. “Why Do Rich Countries Prefer Free Trade over Free Immigration? The Role of the Modern Welfare States.” European Economic Review, 42: 1595- 1612.

Winckler, Onn. 1999. “The Immigration Policy of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) States.” In Tim Niblock and Rodney Wilson, eds. The political economy of the Middle East. Northampton, MA: Elgar Reference Collection.

Yang, Dean. 2007. “International Migration, Remittances, and Household Investment: Evidence from Philippine Migrants’ Exchange Rate Shocks.” Economic Journal, forthcoming.