Regulating non audit services: Towards a principles based approach to regulation

Ojo, Marianne (2009): Regulating non audit services: Towards a principles based approach to regulation.

Abstract

Based on the argument that the benefits conferred through the provision of non audit services by audit firms outweigh the attributed costs of safeguarding the auditor's independence, this paper will not only seek to justify this argument, advance proposals which do not favour an outright prohibition of the provision of non audit services, but also consider means through which non audit services could be regulated in order to facilitate competition in the audit market. At the same time it will consider various legislation which have been introduced in recent years and which are aimed at facilitating greater disclosure of information – hence improving transparency within the audit and financial markets. “Specific measures,” it is contended, “would involve not only the introduction of new standards (for example – the disclosure of client concentration) but also the elimination of current restrictions“. Different types of safeguards which exist in order “to mitigate or eliminate threats” to the auditor’s independence, as a result of the provision of non audit services, will be considered against the regulator’s aim to facilitate competition, enhance disclosure and promote other practices which would advance the regulator’s endeavour to be more “market friendly”.

The consultation on control structures in audit firms and their consequences on the audit market, a consultation which was launched by the European Commission as part of its efforts to create more market players, could be regarded as a response to such proposals to facilitate a more “market friendly” environment and also to concerns that the financial market is already over regulated. Some of the possible ways advanced by the Commission as channels for facilitating greater entry into the international market include the deregulation of the capitalisation of audit firms as a catalyst for facilitating greater entry into the audit market. Deregulation of the capital structure in this sense is considered to be a “modification of Article 3 (4) of the 2006 Directive on Statutory Audit which should however not be to the detriment of robust independence rules.”

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Principles based regulation; audit; directives; regulation; market; NAS (non audit services)
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G18 - Government Policy and Regulation; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M42 - Auditing; G - Financial Economics > G0 - General > G01 - Financial Crises

References

B Arrunada, “The Provision of Non Audit Services by Auditors: Let the Market Evolve and Decide” (1999) International Review of Law and Economics

B Arrunada, “The Economics of Audit Quality: Private Incentives and the Regulation of Audit and Non Audit Services” (1999) Kluwer Academic Publishers

H Ashbaugh, R LaFond and B Mayhew “Do Non Audit Services Compromise Auditor Independence? Further Evidence” (2003) The Accounting Review (78) No 3 611-639

“Audit firms: Commission Consults on Ways to Help Create More Market Players” < http://ec.europa.eu/internal_market/auditing/market/index_en.htm> IP/08/1727

J Bigus and R Zimmerman, ‘Non Audit Fees, Market Leaders and Concentration in the German Audit Market: A Descriptive Analysis’ (2008) International Journal of Auditing Vol 12

J Braithwaite, ‘Meta Risk Management and Responsive Governance’ (2003) Paper to Risk Regulation, Accountability and Development Conference

Code of Ethics for professional Accountants (Revised July 2009) at <http://www.ifac.org/Store/Details.tmpl?SID=1247239521617174&Cart=1247239712617245>

“Economic Crisis in Europe: Causes, Consequences and Responses” Section 3.2.1’ Crisis Resolution Policies: Stress Testing of Banks” http://ec.europa.eu/economy-finance/thematic_articles/article15893_en.htm

„Enhancements to the Basel II Framework“ Basel Committee on Banking Supervision publications July 2009

M Ezzamel, DR Gwilliam and KM Holland, “ The Relationship between Categories of Non Audit Services and Audit Fees: Evidence from UK Companies (2002) International Journal of Auditing (6) 13-35

R Frankel, M Johnson and K Nelson “The Relation Between Auditors’ Fees For Non Audit Services and Earnings Management” (2002) The Accounting Review (77) 71-105

J Gray and J Hamilton, Implementing Financial Regulation : Theory and Practice (2006)

F Haines,‘Regulatory Failures and Regulatory Solutions: A Characteristic Analysis of the Aftermath of Disaster’, Law and Social Inquiry ( 2009) Volume 39

R Johnstone and R Sarre (eds), “Regulation: Enforcement and Compliance” and particularly section 8 by C Parker, “Is there a Reliable Way to Evaluate Organisational Compliance Programs?” Canberra Australian Institute of Criminology 2004 Research and Public Policy Series No 57

GP O’Driscoll and L Hoskins, “The Case For Market Based Regulation” (2006) Volume 26 No 3 Autumn 2006

M Ojo “Regulating the International Audit Market and the Removal of Barriers to Entry: The Provision of Non Audit Services by Audit Firms and the 2006 Statutory Audit Directive”2009

R Quick and B Warming Rasmussen, ‘ Auditor Independence and the Provision of Non Audit Services: Perceptions by German Investors (2009) International Journal of Auditing (13) 141-162 Blackwell Publishing Limited

Statutory Auditor’s Independence in the EU: A Set of Fundamental Principles 2002/590/EC

M Thorn, „The Prudential Supervision of Financial Conglomerates in the EU” ” (2000) North American Actuarial Journal Volume 4 No 3

Treasury Ninth Report, May 2009 Banking Crisis: Reforming Corporate Governance and Pay in the City <http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200809/cmselect/cmtreasy/519/51909.htm#a37>

Up-date on the EU Statutory Audit Directive (2006/43/EC)” <http://www.icaew.com/index.cfm/route/147481/icaew_ga/Technical_Business_Topics/Topics/Audit_and_assurance/Update_on_the_EU_Statutory_Audit_Directive_revised_8th_Company_Law_Audit_and_Assurance_ICAEW/pdf>