Successful tax reform: the experience of value added tax in the United Kingdom and goods and services tax in New Zealand

James, Simon and Alley, Clinton (2008): Successful tax reform: the experience of value added tax in the United Kingdom and goods and services tax in New Zealand. Published in: Journal of Finance and Management in Public Services , Vol. 8, No. 1 (2008): pp. 35-47.

Abstract

Tax reform provides many examples of failures - where reforms did not achieve their objectives successfully and sometimes even had to be reversed. However, value added tax (VAT) in the UK and goods and services tax (GST) in New Zealand have survived successfully for many years. This paper describes the nature and brief history of VAT and GST and then assesses the factors that contributed to their success. A key factor is the process of implementation both in allowing effective prior consultation to identify possible problems and improvements as well as preparing the taxpaying public for change. It is also important that the reform was seen to be fair, that there were gains as well as losses and the change was a net improvement. In assessing how the arguments for the introduction of VAT/GST turned out in practice, it is clear that this is a robust form of taxation and has been well able to accommodate the different political pressures in the UK and New Zealand.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: value added tax; goods and services tax; tax reform
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H20 - General

References

Aaron, H. J. (ed.) (1981) The Value-Added Tax: Lessons from Europe, Brookings Institution, Washington.

Alley, C.R. and Bentley, D. (2005) “Tax Design Principles: Remodelling Adam Smith”, Australian Tax Forum, Vol. 20, pp. 579-624.

Bird, R.M. and Oldman, O. (1990) Taxation in Developing Countries, 4th ed., Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.

Burchell, S, Clubb, C. and Hopwood, A.G. (1985) “Accounting in its Social Context: Toward a History of Value Added in the United Kingdom”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 10, No. 4, pp. 381–413.

Cnossen, S. (2002) “Evaluating the National Retail Sales Tax from a VAT Perspective”, in G. R. Zodrow and P. Mieszkowski (eds), United States Tax Reform in the 21st Century, Cambridge University Press, pp. 215-244.

Cullen, Hon Dr Michael. (2007) Key Facts For Taxpayers; Budget 2007, Government Printer, Wellington.

Davies, E.H. and Kay, J.A. (1985) “Extending the VAT Base: Problems and Possibilities”, Fiscal Studies, Vol. 9, pp. 1-16.

Dickson, I. (2007) “The NZ GST Policy Choice: an Historical Perspective” In Krever, R. and White, D. (eds.) GST in Retrospect and Prospect, Thomson Brookers, Wellington, pp. 45-63.

Douglas, R. (1984) Budget 1984, Financial Statement, Government Printer, Wellington.

Douglas, Hon Sir Roger. (2007) “The New Zealand GST Policy Choice and its Political Implications”. In Krever, R. and White, D. (eds.) GST in Retrospect and Prospect, Thomson Brookers, Wellington, pp. 3-11.

Graetz, M.J. (2007) 100 Million Unnecessary Returns: A Simple Fair, and Competitive Tax Plan for the United States, Yale University Press.

Green Paper (1971) Value Added Tax, Cmnd. 4621, HMSO, London.

Green, R. (2007) “Consulting the Public in Developing a GST”, in Krever, R. and White, D. (eds.) GST in Retrospect and Prospect. Thomson Brookers, Wellington, pp. 13-25.

Harris, L. (1996) “Indirect Taxation and the Single Market”, in M. Gammie (ed.) Striking the Balance: Tax Administration, Enforcement and Compliance in the 1990s. Institute for Fiscal Studies, London, pp. 161-170.

Hegel, G.W.F. (1837) The Philosophy of History, trans. J. Sibree, Colonial Press, New York.

James, S. (2000) “VAT/GST: The UK Experience Revisited”, Revenue Law Journal, 10, 72-87.

James, S. and Edwards, A. (2008) “Developing Tax Policy in a Complex and Changing World”, Economic Analysis and Policy, Vol. 38, No. 1, pp. 35-53.

James, S. and Edwards, A. (2007) “A Strategic Approach to Personal Income Tax Reform”, Australian Tax Forum, Vol. 22, No. 2, pp. 105-126.

James, S and Nobes, C. (2008) The Economics of Taxation: Principles, Policy and Practice, 8th ed., Fiscal Publications, Birmingham.

Kay, J. A. and King M. A. (1990) The British Tax System, 5th ed., Oxford University Press.

Lindholm, R. W. (1980) The Economics of VAT: Preserving Efficiency, Capitalism and Social Progress, Lexington Books, Lexington (Mass).

McLeod, R. Patterson, D. Jones, S. Chatterjee, S. and Sieper, E. (2001) E. Tax Review 2001, Issues Paper New Zealand Treasury, Wellington June. http://www.treasury.govt.nz/taxereview2001/issuespaper/index.html

Meade Committee (1978) The Structure and Reform of Direct Taxation, Institute for Fiscal Studies, London.

Mirrlees Review (forthcoming 2009) Tax by Design, Oxford University Press.

Nana, G. and Philpott, B. (1985) “Macroeconomic and Sectoral Implications of GST”, project on Economic Planning Occasional Paper No. 86 Victoria University of Wellington.

National Audit Office (1994) HM Customs and Excise: Costs to Business of Complying with VAT Requirements, HMSO, London.

National Economic Development Office (1971) Value Added Tax, 2nd ed., HMSO, London.

Prest, A.R. (1980) Value Added Taxation: The Experience of the United Kingdom, American Enterprise Institute, Washington DC.

Prest, A. R. and Barr, N. A. (1985) Public Finance in Theory and Practice, 7th ed., Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London.

Reddaway, W.B. (1970) Effects of the Selective Employment Tax, First Report, HMSO, London.

Reddaway, W.B. (1973) Effects of the Selective Employment Tax, Final Report, Cambridge University Press.

Sandford, C. Godwin, M. and Hardwick P. (1989) Administrative and Compliance Costs of Taxation, Fiscal Publications, Bath.

Sandford, C., Godwin, M., Hardwick, P. and Butterworth, I. (1981) Costs and Benefits of VAT, Heinemann, London.

Sandford, C. and Hasseldine, J. (1992) The Compliance Costs of Business Taxes in New Zealand, Institute of Policy Studies, Wellington.

Sullivan, C.K. (1965) The Tax on Value Added, Columbia University Press, New York.

Todd, J. (2007) “Implementing GST – Information, Education, Co-ordination”, In Krever, R. and White, D. (eds.) GST in Retrospect and Prospect. Thomson Brookers, Wellington, pp. 27-43.

Webber, C. and Wildavsky, A. (1986) A History of Taxation and Expenditure in the Western World, Simon and Schuster, New York.

Wells, G. and Fraser, K. (1986) The Tax Mix Switch and the CPI, Institute of Policy Studies, Wellington.

White Paper (1972) Value Added Tax, Cmnd. 4929, HMSO, London.