Civic Culture and Economic Transition in Russia

Polterovich, Victor (2000): Civic Culture and Economic Transition in Russia.

Abstract

In this paper we try to describe the main feature of Russian civic culture that could influence the outcome of the reform, initiated in 1992, and discuss channels through which the influence was realized. We begin with consideration of paternalism and what we call “habitual deviationism”, ordinary and routine deviation from official rules and laws. Both features were inherited from the Soviet period. Paternalism and habitual deviationism determine a system of people’s attitudes towards the state, the law, the property, and the liberal values. It will be demonstrated that this system entails an adversarial (using a Stiglitz’s term) style of governance and the opportunism and corruptibility of the ruling elite. It is argued that “shock therapy” may be destructive under this cultural environment and result in strong initial distortions since fast liberalization and privatization release a huge volume of rent and strengthen incentives for rent seeking activity. It is further argued that a good reform strategy should take civic culture into account and not put forward overly ambitious tasks. One has to build a sequence of interim institutions which would be more congruent to the initial cultural and institutional environment, facilitate the adaptation of the people, and stimulate modernization of cultural norms to reach an effective market system with time.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Civic culture; economic transition; Russia
• Subjects: P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P16 - Political Economy

References

Almond, Gabriel A., and Sidney Verba (1963). The Civic Culture. Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five Nations. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 562 pp.

Almond, Gabriel A. (1989). The Intellectual History of the Civic Culture Concept. In: Almond, Gabriel A., and Sidney Verba (eds.). The Civic Culture Revisited. Newbury Park. Sage Publications. 1-56.

Almond, Gabriel A., and Sidney Verba (eds.) (1989). The Civic Culture Revisited. Newbury Park. Sage Publications. 1-56.

Bruno, Michael (1993). Crisis, Stabilization and Economic Reform. Clarendon Press, 1993, 300pp.

Casson, M. (1993). Cultural Determinants of Economic Performance. Journal of Comparative Economcs, 17, 418-442.

Cazes, B. (1990). Indicative Planning in France. Journal of Comparative Economics 14 (4), 607-620.

Conradt, David P. Changing German Political Culture (1989). In: Almond, Gabriel A., and Sidney Verba (eds.). The Civic Culture Revisited. Newbury Park. Sage Publications. 212- 272.

De Melo, Martha De Melo, Martha, Cevdet Denizer, Alan Gelb (1995). From Plan to Market: Patterns of Transition. XIth World Congress of the International Economic Association. Tunis. 34 pp.

De Melo, Martha, Cevdet Denizer, Alan Gelb and Stoyan Tenev (1997) Circumstance and choice: the role of initial conditions and policies in transition economies, The World Bank. 44 pp.

Dolgopyatova, Tatiana (1995). Rossiyskiye Predpriyatiya v Perehodnoy Ekonomike: Ekonomicheskiye Problemy i Povedeniye. Moskva: Delo Ltd. 285 pp (in Russian).

Dubin, Boris (1999). Religiosnaya vera v Rossii 90-yh godov. (Religious Faith in Russia of the 1990s). Monitoring obschestvennogo mneniya, (The Russian Public Opinion Monitor), No.1(39), Jan.-Feb.1999. 31-38 (in Russian).

Economic Survey of Europe (2001). No. 1. Economic Commission for Europe. United Nations : N. Y. and Geneva..

Economic Survey of Europe (2002). No. 1. Statistical Appendix. Economic Commission for Europe. United Nations : N. Y. and Geneva. 216- 246.

Fang, H. ( 2001). Social Culture and Economic Performance. The American Economic Review, 91, N.4, 924-937.

Fridman, L.A. Essays on economic and social development of Central Asia countries after disintegration of the USSR. Moscow: “Gumanitarij”. 211 pp. (in Russian).

Gromova, Regina (1998). A Comparative Analysis of the Typical Forms of Social Mobility in the Russian Society before and after 1985. The Russian Public Opinion Monitor, 1 (33), 18-26 (in Russian).

Gudkov, Lev (1999). Rossiya v ryadu drugih stran: k probleme nazional’noi identichnosti. (Russia amidst Other Countries: Concerning the Problem of National Identity). Monitoring obschestvennogo mneniya, (The Russian Public Opinion Monitor), No.1(39), Jan.-Feb.1999. 39-46 (in Russian).

Gaidar, Egor (1996). Dni porazhenij i pobed. M.: Vagrius. 367 pp (in Russian).

Haarland, Hans-Peter, and Hans-Ioahim Niessen .1999. Barometer of Transformation in Eastern Europe in 1999. The Russian Public Opinion Monitor, 6 (44), 13-17 (in Russian).

Hellman J.S., Jones G., Kaufmann D., and Schankerman M. (2000). Measuring Governance, Corruption, and State Capture. Policy Research Working Paper, No.2312, The World Bank Institute, April.

Hellman, J. and M.Schankerman. (2000). Intervention, Corruption and Capture. The nexus between enterprises and the state. Economics of Transition, vol.8(3), 545-576.

Hillman A.L. (1999). In Transit to the Promised Land: Ten Years in the Wilderness without Moses. Paper presented at 5th Dubrovnik Conference on Transition Economies. 43 pp.

Hillman, A.L. and Ursprung H.W.( 2000). Political Culture and Economic Decline. European Journal of Political Economy . Vol. 16, No. 2. 190- 213.

Houben, Vincent (1999). Economic crisis and the culture of reform in Southeast Asia. European Review, v.7, No.4, 487-496.

Information : Surveys’ Findings. (1999). The Russian Public Opinion Monitor, No.1(39), Jan.-Feb.1999. 60-96 (in Russian).

Information : Surveys’ Findings (2002). The Russian Public Opinion Monitor, No.4(60), 62-98 (in Russian).

Jones, Derek C. (1998). The Economic Effects of Privatization: Evidence from a Russian Panel. Comp. Econ. St. XXXX, 2: 75-102, Summer.

Johnson, Simon, Daniel Kaufmann, Andrei Shleifer (1997). The Unofficial Economy in Transition, Brookings Papers on Economixc Activity, vol. 2, 159- 239.

Kapeljushnikov, R. I. (2001). Russian labor market. Adaptation without restructuring. Moscow: HSE. 308 pp. (in Russian).

Katyshev, P. K., and V. M. Polterovich (2002). Initial conditions, reform policy, and transformational recession. Manuscript (in Russian).

Khakhulina, Ludmila (1999). Social Inequality in Russian Society: opinions and assessments. Barometer of Transformation in Eastern Europe in 1999. The Russian Public Opinion Monitor, 4 (42), 27-30 (in Russian).

Kornai, Janos (1985a). Efficiency and the Principles of Socialist Ethics, In: Contradictions and Dilemmas. Corvina. 124-138.

Kornai, Janos (1985b). Degrees of Paternalism. In: Contradictions and Dilemmas. Corvina. 52-61.

Levada, Yuri (2000). “Homo Praevaricatus” : Russian Double-Think. The Russian Public Opinion Monitor, 1 (45), 19-26 (in Russian).

Levada, Yurij (1998). Reverting to the Problem of Social Elite. Monitoring obschestvennogo mneniya, (The Russian Public Opinion Monitor), No.1 (33), 12-18 (in Russian).

Levada, Yurij (1999). 1989-1998: Desyatiletie vynuzhdennyh povorotov. (Ten Years of Forced Turns). Monitoring obschestvennogo mneniya, (The Russian Public Opinion Monitor), No.1(39), Jan.-Feb.1999. 7-11 (in Russian).

Levada, Yurij (1999a). “Homo Soveticus” Ten Years Later: 1989-1999(Introductory Results of a Comparative Research). Monitoring obschestvennogo mneniya, (The Russian Public Opinion Monitor), No.3 (41), 7-15 (in Russian).

Levada, Yurij (1999b). “Homo Adapticus”. Monitoring obschestvennogo mneniya, (The Russian Public Opinion Monitor), No.5 (43), 7-16 (in Russian).

Lijphart, Arend (1989). The Structure of Inference. In: Almond, Gabriel A., and Sidney Verba (eds.). The Civic Culture Revisited. Newbury Park. Sage Publications. 37-56.

Li, David (1998). Changing Incentives of the Chinese Bureaucracy. AEA Papers and Proceedings. Vol.88, 1998, No. 2, 393-403.

Linz, Susan J. (1998). Job Rights in Russian Firms: Endangered or Extinct Institution? Comp. Econ. St. XXXX, 4: 1-32, Winter.

Magnus Jan, Victor Polterovich, Anatoly Danilov, Alexei Savvateev (2001). Tolerance to Cheating: A Cross Country Analysis. Journal of Economic Education (in print).

McCallum J., Blais A. (1987). Government, special interest groups, and economic growth. Public Choice, 54, 3-18.

Nikitina, Vera (2000). Monitoring obschestvennogo mneniya, (The Russian Public Opinion Monitor), No.1(45), Jan.-Feb.2000. 49-54.

North, D. (1997). Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Olson Mansur Jr., Sarna N. and Swamy A.V. (1998). Governance and growth: A simple hypothesis explaining cross-country differences in productivity growth. Public Choice, 102, 341-364.

Polterovich, Victor (2000). Institutional Traps. In: Lawrence R. Klein and Marshall Pomer (eds.), The New Russia: Transition Gone Awry. Stanford, Stanford University Press. 93-116.

Polterovich, Victor (1998). Factors of Corruption. Economics and Mathematical Methods, 34, No. 3, 30-39 (in Russian).

Polterovich, Victor (1995). Economic reform in Russia in 1992: The Government Battles Labor Collectives.” J. Inter. Comp. Econ. 4:265-287.

Rossiyskiy statisticheskiy ezhegodnik (1996) . Moskva: Goskomstat (in Russian).

Sotsial'no-ekonomicheskoye polozheniye Rossiyskoy Federatsii (1996). No.12. Moskva: Goskomstat Rossiyskoy Federatsii (in Russian).

Shleifer A. (1997). Government in Transition. European Economic Review, v.41, p.385-410.