The effects of the enforcement strategy.

Suurmond, Guido (2007): The effects of the enforcement strategy. Published in: Department of Economics Research Memorandum No. 2007.03 (2007): pp. 1-25.

Abstract

The conventional economic literature on law enforcement provides no satisfactory explanation for the enforcement policies in the field of environmental regulation, safety regulation and health regulation. In these fields enforcement usually applies administrative law sanctions and is characterized primarily by advice, persuasion and warnings. This is illustrated for the enforcement of fire safety regulation in bars and restaurants by Dutch municipalities. I demonstrate that economic analyses are well able to explain the benefits and need of an enforcement policy of advice, persuasion and warnings. However, it is also true that in the specific field analyzed a more deterrent policy by more severe punishment will most likely improve compliance. As such, the general economic argument of the benefits of deterrence should not be abandoned.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: (non)compliance, Harrington paradox, compliance strategies, administrative law enforcement
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K4 - Legal Procedure, the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior > K42 - Illegal Behavior and the Enforcement of Law

References

Algemene Rekenkamer [Netherlands Court of Audit], 2005. Handhaven en gedogen [Enforcement and toleration]. The Hague: Sdu Uitgevers.

Ayres, I., and J. Braithwaite, 1992. Responsive regulation: transcending the deregulation debate. New York: Oxford University Press.

Baker, M.J., and T.J. Miceli, 2005. Credible criminal enforcement. European Journal of Law and Economics 20, pp. 5-15.

Bardach, E., and R.A. Kagan, 1982. Going by the book: The problem of regulatory unreasonableness. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.

Becker, G.S., 1968. Crime and punishment: An economic approach. Journal of Political Economy 76 (2), pp. 169-217.

Boadway, R., N. Marceau, and M. Marchand, 1996. Time-consistent criminal sanctions. Public Finance / Finances Publiques 51 (2), pp. 149-165. Committee Alders, 2001. Cafébrand Nieuwjaarsnacht [Cafe Fire New Year’s Eve]. The Hague.

Eckert, H., 2004. Inspections, warnings, and compliance: the case of petroleum storage regulation. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 47, pp. 232-259.

Fenn, P., and C.G. Veljanovski, 1988. A positive economic theory of regulatory enforcement. Economic Journal 98 (393), pp. 1055-1070.

Friesen, L., 2003. Targeting enforcement to improve compliance with environmental regulations. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 46, pp. 72-85.

Friesen, L., 2006. The social welfare implications of industry self-auditing. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 51, pp. 280-294.

Garvie, D., and A. Keeler, 1994. Incomplete enforcement with endogenous regulatory choice. Journal of Public Economics 55, pp. 141-162.

Gneezy, U., and A. Rustichini, 2000. A fine is a price. Journal of Legal Studies 29, pp. 1-17.

Gundelach, J., and F.C.M.A. Michiels, 2003. Ongegronde vrees: een onderzoek naar de rechtspraak inzake handhavingsbesluiten [Unfounded fear]. Deventer: Kluwer.

Harford, J.D., and W. Harrington, 1991. A reconsideration of enforcement leverage when penalties are restricted. Journal of Public Economics 45, pp. 391-395.

Harrington, W., 1988. Enforcement leverage when penalties are restricted. Journal of Public Economics 37 (1), pp. 29-53.

Hawkins, K., and J.M. Thomas (Eds.), 1984. Enforcing Regulation. Boston: Kluwer-Nijhoff Publishing.

Hawkins, K., 1984. Environment and enforcement. Regulation and the social definition of pollution. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Heyes, A.G., 1994. Environmental enforcement when 'inspectability' is endogenous: A model with overshooting properties. Environmental and Resource Economics 4, pp. 479-494.

Heyes, A.G., 2000. Implementing environmental regulation: Enforcement and compliance. Journal of Regulatory Economics 17 (2), pp. 107-129.

Heyes, A.G., and N. Rickman, 1999. Regulatory dealing - revisiting the Harrington paradox. Journal of Public Economics 72 (3), pp. 361-378.

Hutter, B.M., 1997. Compliance: Regulation and environment. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Innes, R., 1999. Remediation and self-reporting in optimal law enforcement. Journal of Public Economics 72, pp. 379-393.

Kagan, R.A., and J.T. Scholz, 1984. The "Criminology of the Corporation" and Regulatory Enforcement Strategies, in: Hawkins and Thomas (1984), pp. 67-95.

Khambu, J., 1989. Regulatory standards, noncompliance and enforcement. Journal of Regulatory Economics 1, pp. 103-114.

Kolstad, C.D., T.S. Ulen, and G.V. Johnson, 1990. Ex post liability for harm vs. ex ante safety regulation: Substitutes or complements? American Economic Review 80 (4), pp. 888-901.

Lando, H., and S. Shavell, 2004. The advantage of focusing law enforcement effort. International Review of Law and Economics 24, pp. 209-218.

Leeuw, F.L., and F. Willemsen, 2006. Toezicht en inspectie: trends, kosten en baten [Supervision and inspection: trends, costs and benefits]. Nederlands Juristenblad (37), pp. 1623-1630.

Lin, C.-C., and C.C. Yang, 2006. Fine enough or don't fine at all. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 59, pp. 195-213.

Livernois, J., and C.J. Mckenna, 1999. Truth or consequences: Enforcing pollution standards with self-reporting. Journal of Public Economics 41, pp. 415-440.

Malik, A.S., 1990. Markets for pollution control when firms are noncompliant. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 18, pp. 97-106.

Malik, A.S., 1993. Self-reporting and the design of policies for regulating stochastic pollution. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 24, pp. 241-257.

Mookherjee, D., and I.P.L. Png, 1994. Marginal deterrence in enforcement of law. Journal of Political Economy 102 (5), pp. 1039-1066.

Nadeau, L.W., 1997. EPA effectiveness at reducing the duration of plant-level noncompliance. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 34, pp. 54-78.

Nyborg, K., and K. Telle, 2004. The role of warnings in regulation: keeping control with less punishment. Journal of Public Economics 88 (12), pp. 2801-2816.

Nyborg, K., and K. Telle, 2006. Firms' compliance to environmental regulation: Is there really a paradox? Environmental and Resource Economics 35, pp. 1-18.

Ogus, A., and C. Abbot, 2002. Sanctions for pollution: do we have the right regime? Journal of Environmental Law 14 (3), pp. 283-298.

Pistor, K., and C. Xu, 2003. Incomplete law. N.Y.U. Journal of International Law and Politics 35, pp. 931-1013.

Polinsky, A.M., and S. Shavell, 1998. On offense history and the theory of deterrence. International Review of Law and Economics 18, pp. 305-324.

Polinsky, A.M., and S. Shavell, 2000. The economic theory of public enforcement of law. Journal of Economic Literature 38, pp. 45-76.

Posner, R.A., and E.B. Rasmusen, 1999. Creating and enforcing social norms, with special reference to sanctions. International Review of Law and Economics 19, pp. 369-382.

Ricketts, M., and A. Peacock, 1996. Bargaining and the regulatory system. International Review of Law and Economics 6, pp. 3-16.

Schmitz, P.W., 2000. On the joint use of liability and safety regulation. International Review of Law and Economics 20, pp. 371-382.

Scholz, J.T., 1991. Cooperative regulatory enforcement and the politics of administrative effectiveness. American Political Science Review 85 (1), pp. 115-136.

Shavell, S., 1984. A model of the optimal use of liability and safety regulation. Rand Journal of Economics 15 (2), pp. 271-280.

Shavell, S., 1992a. Liability and the incentive to obtain information about risk. Journal of Legal Studies 21, pp. 259-270.

Shavell, S., 1992b. A note on marginal deterrence. International Review of Law and Economics 12, pp. 345-355.

Shavell, S., 1993. The optimal structure of law enforcement. Journal of Law and Economics 36, pp. 255-287.

Shavell, S., 2004. Foundations of economic analysis of law. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

Telle, K., 2004. Effects of inspections on plants' regulatory and environmental performance - evidence from Norwegian manufacturing industries, Statistics Norway, Research Department, Discussion Papers no. 381.

Veljanovski, C.G., 1984. The economics of regulatory enforcement in: Hawkins and Thomas (1984), pp. 171-188.

VNG, 2002. Model-bouwverordening [Model building by-law]. Den Haag: VNG Uitgeverij.

WRR, 2003. Waarden, normen en de last van het gedrag, appendix 4 [Values, norms and the burden of behavior]. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.