Comparative performance of UK mutual building societies and stock retail banks: further evidence: a comment

Batiz-Lazo, Bernardo and Billings, Mark (2009): Comparative performance of UK mutual building societies and stock retail banks: further evidence: a comment.

Abstract

Shiwakoti et al. (2008) concluded that four of the largest UK mutual societies which converted to listed bank status in 1997 outperformed, on a variety of measures, those societies which did not convert in the four-year periods both before and after conversion. All four converting societies have since been subject to ownership change, suggesting that this out-performance failed to persist, or was perhaps illusory. We do not criticise the results obtained by the authors, but suggest that they leave unanswered important questions, such as how to measure ‘superior’ performance and the appropriate time frame over which to evaluate this.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Building societies; Banks; Demutualization; Performance; UK
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N2 - Financial Markets and Institutions > N24 - Europe: 1913-; N - Economic History > N8 - Micro-Business History > N84 - Europe: 1913-; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G21 - Banks ; Depository Institutions ; Micro Finance Institutions ; Mortgages

References

Drake, L., 2003, Costs and Efficiency in Banking: A Survey of the Evidence from the US, the UK and Japan, pp. 283-324 in A.W. Mullineux and V. Murinde (eds.), Handbook of International Banking, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Haynes, M. and S. Thompson, 1999, The Productivity Effects of Bank Mergers: Evidence from the UK Building Societies, Journal of Banking and Finance, 23, 825-846.

KPMG, 2009, Building Societies Database 2009, Leeds: KPMG LLP.

Schrand, C. and H. Unal, 1998, Hedging and Coordinated Risk Management: Evidence from Thrift Conversions, Journal of Finance, 53, 979-1015.

Shiwakoti, R.K., J.K. Ashton and K. Keasey, 2004, Conversion, Performance and Executive Compensation in UK Building Societies, Corporate Governance, 12, 361-370.

Shiwakoti, R.K., K. Keasey and R. Hudson, 2008, Comparative Performance of UK Mutual Building Societies and Stock Retail Banks: Further Evidence, Accounting and Finance, 48, 319-336.

Thompson, S., 1997, Takeover Activity Among Financial Mutuals: An Analysis of Target Characteristics, Journal of Banking and Finance, 21, 37-53.

Valnek, T., 1999, The Comparative Performance of Mutual Building Societies and Stock Retail Banks, Journal of Banking and Finance, 23, 925-938.