Practical training and the audit expectations gap: The case of accounting undergraduates of Universiti Utara Malaysia

Ali, Azham and Lee, Teck Heang and Yusof, Nor Zalina and Ojo, Marianne (2008): Practical training and the audit expectations gap: The case of accounting undergraduates of Universiti Utara Malaysia.

Abstract

The accounting profession has long faced the issue of an audit expectations gap; being the gap between the quality of the profession’s performance, its objectives and results, and that which the society expects. The profession believes that the gap could be reduced over time through education. Studies have been carried out overseas and in Malaysia to determine the effect of education in narrowing the audit expectations gap. Extending the knowledge acquired, this paper investigates whether academic internship programs could reduce the audit expectations gap in Malaysia. Using a pre-post method, the research instrument adapted from Ferguson et al. (2000) is administered to the Universiti Utara Malaysia’s accounting students at the beginning and end of their internship program. The results show there is a significant change in perceptions among students after the internship program. However, changes in perceptions do not warrant an internship program as a means of reducing the audit expectations gap as misperceptions are still found among respondents on issues of auditing after the completion of the internship program. Nevertheless, an internship program can still be used to complement audit education in a university as it is an ideal way to expose students to professional issues and enables them to have a better insight of the actual performance and duties of auditors.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Audit expectations gap; accounting internship; undergraduate; Malaysia
• Subjects: M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing

References

Arens, A., Elders, R., Beasley, Amran, A., Fadzil, F., Mohammad Yusof, N., Mohammad Nor, A. and Shafie, R., (2006), Auditing and Asurance Services in Malaysia, Prentice Hall, Selangor, Malaysia.

Beck, G.W., (1974), Public Accountants in Australia – Their Social Role, Australian Accounting Research Foundation, Melbourne.

Benau, M.A.G., Humphrey, C., Moizer, P. and Turley, S., (1993), “Auditing Expectations and Performance in Spain and Britain: A Comparative Analysis”, The International Journal of Accounting, 28, pp. 281-307.

Best, P.J., Buckby, S. and Tan, C., (2001), “Evidence of the Audit Expectation Gap in Singapore”, Managerial Auditing Journal, Vol. 16, No. 3, pp. 134-144.

Castellano, J.G., (2002), Chair’s Corner, AICPA, September, available at http://www.aicpa.org/pubs/cpaltr/sept2002/chair.htm

Cohen Commission: Commission on Auditors’ Responsibilities, (1978), Report, Conclusions and Recommendations, New York, AICPA.

Darnill, A., (1992), “The Profession and the Public”, Singapore Accountant, March, pp 23-25.

De Beelde, I., Cooreman, S. and Leydens, H., (N.D), “Expectation of Users of Financial Information with Regard to the Tasks Carried Out by Auditors”, University of Ghent, Belgium, available at: www.fetew.ugent.be/fac/research/WP/Papers/wp_99_75.pdf.

Eden, Y., Ovadia, A. and Zuckerman, B.A., (2003), “Rethinking Sarbanes-Oxley: Why the Act Doesn’t Serve the Interests of the Industry or the Markets”, CMA Management, May, pp 32-35.

Epstein, M. and Geiger, M., (1994), “Investor Views of Audit Assurance: Recent Evidence of the Expectation Gap”, Journal of Accountancy, Vol.177, No 1, pp. 60-66.

Fadzly, A.N. and Ahmad, Z., (2004), “Audit Expectation Gap – The Case of Malaysia”, Managerial Auditing Journal, Vol. 19, No. 7, pp. 897-915.

Ferguson, C.B., Richardson, G.D. and Wines, G., (2000), “Audit Education and Training: The Effect of Formal Studies and Work Experience”, Accounting Horizons, Vol. 14, No.2, June, pp 137-167.

Frank, E.K., Lowe, D.J. and Smith, J.K., (2001), “The Expectation Gap: Perceptual Differences between Auditors, Jurors and Students”, Managerial Auditing Journal, Vol.16, Issue 3, pp. 145-149.

Frontline: Bigger than Enron: Accounting Lesson, (n.d.), available at http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/regulation/lessons/

"In the Public Interest", Journal of Accountancy, Online Issues, January 2006, available at http://www.aicpa.org/pubs/jofa/jan2005/index.htm

Gramling, A., Schatxberg, J. and Wallace, A., (1996), “The Role of Undergraduate Auditing Coursework in Reducing Audit Expectation Gap”, Issues in Accounting Education, Spring, pp. 131-146.

Guy, D.M. and Sullivan, J.D., (1988), “The Expectation Gap Auditing Standards”, Journal of Accountancy, April, pp 36-44.

Humphrey, C., Moizer, P. and Turley, S., (1993), “The Audit Expectations Gap in Britain: An Empirical Investigation”, Accounting and Business Research, Vol. 23, No. 91A, pp. 395-411.

Kasim, M.A and Mohd-Hanafi, S.R., (2005), “An Empirical Study on the Effect of Undergraduate Auditing Course in Reducing Audit Expectation Gap at Universiti Tenaga Nasional (UNITEN)”, paper presented at the AAAA Conference, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Koh, H. and Woo, W. (1998), “The Expectation Gap in Auditing”, Managerial Auditing Journal, Vol. 13, pp. 147-154.

Kolins, W., (1988), “The New Auditing Standards”, The Financial Manager, November/December, pp. 24-30. Kranacher, M-J., (2006), “Regulating the Accounting Profession: What Distinguishes a CPA from an Accountant?” The CPA Journal, April, available online at http://www.cpajournal.com/ Lee, T. and Palaniappan, A., (2006), “Audit Expectation Gap: An Empirical Study in Malaysia”, paper presented in The Malaysian Finance Association’s 8th Annual Conference at University Malaysia Sabah, Kota Kinabalu.

Liggio, C., (1974), “The Expectation Gap: The Accountant’s Waterloo”, Journal of Contemporary Business, Vol. 3, pp. 27-44.

Lim, H., (1993), Address by the ICPAS President, Mr Lim Hock San, at the ICPAS’ 30th Anniversary Dinner held at the Neptune Theatre Restaurant on 6 March 1993, Singapore Accountant, Vol. 9, pp 9.

Lim, J., (2006), “When Practical Training Falls Short”, New Strait Times, 9 April, Malaysia

Lowe, D.J., (1994), “The Expectation Gap in the Legal System: Perception Differences between Auditors and Judges”, Journal of Applied Business Research, Vol. 10, Summer, pp. 39-44.

Management Accounting, (1985), “Accountants Must Clean Up Their Act – Rep. John Dingell Speaks Out”, May, pp 21-56.

Martens, S.C. and McEnroe, J.E., (1991), “Inter-professional Struggles over Definition: Lawyers, Accountants and Illegal Acts”, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 2, pp 375-384.

Minai, B., Mustapha, M. and Saleh, A., (2005), “An Empirical Investigation of Perceived Benefits of Practical Training Using Factor Analysis”, paper presented at the 6th Asian Academy of Management Conference, Perak, Malaysia, pp. 671-679.

Mohamed, S. and Muhamad_Sori, Z., (2002), “Audit Expectation Gap – The Malaysian Experience”, The Chartered Secretary Malaysia, January, pp. 12-15.

Monroe, G.S. and Woodliff, D.R., (1993), “The Effect of Education on the Audit Expectation Gap”, Accounting and Finance, May, pp 61-78.

Moussalli, S., (2005), “Accounting for the Journal’s First 100 Years: A Timeline From 1905 to 2005”, Journal of Accountancy, Online Issue, October, available at: http://www.aicpa.org/pubs/jofa/oct2005/index.htm

Pierce, B. and Kilcommins, M., (1996), “The Audit Expectation Gap: The Role of Auditing Education”, DCUBS Research Paper Series, No. 13, DCUBS Dublin, available at: http://www.dcu.ie/dcubs/research_papers/index.shtml

Porter, B. and Gowthorpe, C., (2001), The Audit Expectation-Performance Gap: Some New Evidence from the United Kingdom, paper presented at the National Auditing Conference, Leicester, March 2001.

Porter, B., (1993), “An Empirical Study of the Audit Expectation-Performance Gap”, Accounting and Business Research, Vol. 24, No. 93, pp. 49-68.

Porter, B., Simon, J. and Hatherly, D., (2005), Principles of External Auditing, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Power, M., (1993), “The Politics of Financial Auditing”, The Political Quarterly Publishing Co. Ltd., Oxford, UK

Reiter, S.A. and Williams, P.F., (n.d), “The History and Rhetoric of Auditor Independence Concepts”, available at http://lesl.man.ac.uk/ipa/papers/44.pdf

Russell, G. (1986), “All Eyes on Accountants”, Time, 21 April. pp. 58.

Sikka, P., Puxty, A., Willmott, H. and Cooper, C., (1998), “The Impossibility of Eliminating the Expectation Gap: Some Theory and Evidence”, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 9, pp. 299-330.

Steinberg, R.B. and Walker, D.E., (1997), “The AICPA National Conference on SEC Developments”, The CPA Journal, Vol. LXVII, May.

The Star, 29 April 2006.

Turner, L., (2006), “In the Public Interest: Regulating with a Customer Focus”, The CPA Journal, March, available online at http://www.cpajournal.com/

Utusan Malaysia, (2004), "MEF: Sistem Pendidikan Negara Gagal", 9 September, Malaysia.

Wa, J. and Selva, M., (1993), “The Audit Expectation Gap in Hong Kong”, paper presented to Fifth Annual Conference of Accounting Academics, Hong Kong, 7-8 April, pp. 549-557.

Woolf, E., (1985), “We Must Stern the Tide of Litigation”, The Accountant, April 1985, pp 18-19.

Yoshimi, H., (n.d), “Audit Expectation Gap in Japan: A Comparative Analysis with Britain”, Discussion Paper Series A, No.28, Faculty of Economics, Hokkaido University.