The Proliferation of Fiscal Incentives and the Nicaraguan State as a Manager of Rents: A Political Economy Perspective on Nicaraguan Industrial Policy Since 1990

Maas, Hauke (2006): The Proliferation of Fiscal Incentives and the Nicaraguan State as a Manager of Rents: A Political Economy Perspective on Nicaraguan Industrial Policy Since 1990.

Abstract

This paper finds that the proliferation of fiscal incentives in the form of tax exemptions in Nicaragua since 1990 represents the indiscriminate allocation of monopoly rents to interest groups. While theory suggests some rents can encourage productive investments, Nicaragua’s tax incentives are merely “assistentialist” and lack effectiveness. For a dynamic industrial policy, opportunity costs would need to be taken into account and rents would need to be performance contingent, which requires selectivity and increased transparency.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Nicaragua; industrial policy; political economy; fiscal incentives; tax incentives; monopoly rents; rent-seeking
• Subjects: P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P16 - Political Economy; H - Public Economics > H3 - Fiscal Policies and Behavior of Economic Agents > H32 - Firm; L - Industrial Organization > L5 - Regulation and Industrial Policy

References

• Corporación de Zonas Francas, Opportunities in free zone manufacturing: Nicaragua, Managua: Corporación de la Zona Franca, 1997 • Foreign Investment Advisory Service, Nicaragua – Competitividad, Atracción de inversiones extranjeras directas y rol de la política de competencia, FIAS,2003 • Gitli, E. (ed.), La política de promoción de exportaciones de Nicaragua en los años noventa, Managua: MEDE/MIFIN, 1996 • Martínez Piva, J. M. & Cortes, E., Competitividad centroamericana, Mexico: CEPAL, 2004 • Nicaraguan Government, Propuesta de plan nacional de desarrollo: mañana es demasiado tarde, Managua: Gobierno, 2003 • Sobrino, L. J., Competitividad y distribución territorial de las actividades económicas en Nicaragua: impacto del Plan Nacional de Desarrollo, Managua: Presidency of the Republic, Secretariat for Coordination and Strategy and United Nations Population Fund, 2004 • Acevedo Vogl, A. J., Para Una Salida Nacional, Y Mucho Más Equitativa, A La Crisis, Nicaraguan Academic Journal, December 2003 • Albalá, M. A., Impacto de la liberalización financiera en el sistema bancario nicaragüense, Managua: Nitlapán, 1998 • Artana, D. & Gasparini, L., The Distributional Impact of the Nicaraguan Fiscal Equity Law, The World Bank, PSIA of Nicaragua’s Fiscal Equity Law (“Ley de Equidad Fiscal”), 2003 • Báez Cortés, J. F. & Báez Cortés, T., Las tentaciones del poder: legalidad y tributación, Managua: Imprimatur, 1994 • Blankenburg, S. & Khan, M. H., The Political Economy of Industrial Policy in Asia and Latin America, unpublished paper, 2005 • Borner, S., Brunetti, A. & Weder, B., Policy Reforms and Institutional Uncertainty: The Case of Nicaragua, Kyklos, Vol. 48, No. 1, 1995 • Catalán Aravena, O., Una década de ajuste structural en Nicaragua, Encuentro, No. 59, 2001 • Chang, H.-J. & Cheema, A., Conditions for Successful Technology Policy in Developing Countries – Learning Rents, State Structures, and Institutions, The United Nations University Institute for New Technologies Discussion Paper Series #2001-8, December 2001 • Chang, H.J., Kicking Away the Ladder – Development Strategy in Historic Perspective, London: Anthem Press 2002 • Dijkstra, A. G., Technocracy Questioned: Ideology and Interests in Nicaragua’s Economic Policies, Working Paper Series No. 213, Institute of Social Studies, The Hague, March 1996a • Dijkstra, A. G., The Impact of Structural Adjustment Programs on Manufacturing: Lessons from Nicaragua, World Development, Vol. 24, No. 3, 1996b • Dye, D. R., La democracia a la deriva: la política caudillista de Nicaragua, Brookline, MA.: Hemisphere Initiatives, 2004 • Jomo, K. S. & Khan, M. H. (eds.), Rents, Rent-Seeking and Economic Development : Theory and the Asian Evidence, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000 • Kay, C., Why East Asia overtook Latin America: agrarian reform, industrialisation and development, Third World Quarterly, Vol. 23, No. 6, 2002 • Khan, M. H., Corruption and Governance in Early Capitalism: World Bank Strategies and their Limitations, in Pincus, J. & Winters, J. (eds.), Reinventing the World Bank, Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2002a • Khan, M. H., State Failure in Developing Countries and Strategies of Institutional Reform, Draft Paper for ABCDE Conference, Oslo 24-26 June 2002b • Khan, M. H., What is a “Good Investment Climate”?, Berlin Workshop Series 2005, IBRD/World Bank, 2005 • Krueger, A. O., The Rent-Seeking Society, American Economic Review, Vol. 64, No. 3, 1974 • Lacayo, J., Micro, Pequeña y mediana empresa en Nicaragua, Managua, 1998 • Larios, F. & Cordero, M., La reforma tributaria de febrero de 1992 en Nicaragua: ¿Incentivos a la producción y el crecimiento?, Managua: INCAE, Programa de Gestión Pública, 1992 • Medal, J. L., La Reforma Tributaria En Nicaragua – Una reforma para el desarrollo – Part 1, in Nicaraguan Academic Journal, December 2002 • Medal, J. L., La Reforma Tributaria En Nicaragua – Una reforma para el desarrollo – Part 2, in Nicaraguan Academic Journal, Vol. 4, No. 1, May 2003 • Mendoza, R. & Kuhnekath, K., Tratados de libre comercio, Plan Nacional de Desarrollo y Clusters: ¿Cambio de ruta o más de lo mismo?”, Encuentro, No. 67, 2004 • Navarro Medal, K., A quienes representan y para quienes legislan los diputados?: crisis de representatividad en la Asamblea Nacional, Managua: Imprimatur, 2004 • Neira Cuadra, O., Reforma Económica y consenso social, in Cuadra Lira, E. (ed.), Orden social y gobernabilidad en Nicaragua, 1990-1996, Managua: CRIES, 1998 • Núñez Soto, O., La otra estrategia, Managua: CIPRES, 2003 • Olson, M., The Rise and Decline of Nations, London: Yale University Press, 1982 • Porter, M., On Competition, Boston: Harvard Business Review Book, 1996 • Rocha, J. L., Rasgos culturales y desarrollo de las PYMES, Encuentro, No. 50, 1999 • Stiglitz, J. E., Wither Socialism?, Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 1996 • Strachan, H. W., Family and other business groups in economic development: the case of Nicaragua, New York: Praeger, 1976 • Streeten, P., Markets and States: Against Minimalism, World Development, Vol. 21, No. 8, 1993 • Vilas, C. M., Redes de Familia, Democracia y Modernización Política en Centroamérica, Revista de Historia, No. 8, Instituto de Historia de Nicaragua y de Centroamérica, UCA, 1995 • Báez Cortés, J. F., The Problem Isn’t Lack of Resources; It’s Fiscal Inequity and Legalized Pillage, Envío, Number 296, May 2006 • Confidencial, "Grandes retenedores" de impuestos, Confidencial, No. 388, 16 - 22 May 2004 • Confidencial, Las críticas al esquema AGRICORP, Confidencial, No. 338, 11 - 17 May 2003 • Cruz, A., Sector privado no ha recuperado su músculo institucional, Confidencial, No. 196, 18 - 24 June 2000 • El Nuevo Diario, “Enorme volumen de exoneraciones está afectando la economía”, El Nuevo Diario, December 2nd, 2005 • IMF Survey, Developing Countries Face Range of Challenges in Devising effective tax strategy, IMF Survey, No. 29, Vol. 13, 2000 • Lacayo, M. I., Empresarios tienen que involucrarse más en política, Confidencial, No. 196, 18 - 24 June 2000 • Olivares, I., AN demanda a Hacienda dictamen sobre ley BIT, Confidencial, No. 494, 16 - 22 July 2006 • Olivares, I., Arroz: Agricorp pone "las reglas", Confidencial, No. 338, 11 - 17 May 2003 • Olivares, I., Danza millonaria de exoneraciones y evasión fiscal, Confidencial, No. 465, 4 - 10 December 2005 • Pronicaragua - Tras una porcion del pastel de las inversiones, Negocios y Turismo, no. 5, San Salvador: Editorial Alejandría, 2004 • CEPAL, 2005, Statistical Yearbook for Latin America and the Caribbean 2005, [http://websie.eclac.cl/anuario_estadistico/anuario_2005/eng/index.asp], accessed September 2006 • Núñez Soto, O., 2005, Estafa tributaria y neoliberalismo en la Asamblea Nacional, [http://www.cipres.org/institucion/actualidad/articulo_67.asp], accessed September 2006 • SIDA, 2005, Nicaragua: Cambio y Continuidad, Evaluación de Estrategias de Reducción de Pobreza en América Latina 2004, [http://www.sida.se/shared/jsp/download.jsp?f=SIDA4562es_Nicaragua+web. pdf&a=3425], accessed August 2006