Challenges of Liberalization. The Case of Polish Electricity and Gas Sector

Nowak, Bartlomiej (2009): Challenges of Liberalization. The Case of Polish Electricity and Gas Sector. Published in: Yearbook of Antitrust and Regulatory Studies , Vol. 2, No. 2 (2009): pp. 141-168.

Abstract

This paper applies the general insights of liberalization of the electricity and gas market to the market conditions of a particularly important new Member State in the EU, Poland. To this end the aim of this paper is to explain the Polish experience of liberalizing its energy market by reviewing those developments that produced its current shape. In fact there are two possible scenarios Polish policy makers can follow in liberalizing its energy sector. One would involve the UK approach that encompasses: ownership unbundling, less market concentration, less public ownership and more private capital in the industry. The second scenario follows the continental model: more concentration and vertical integration and more State or public ownership in the energy field (for instance, the French model). These two widely diverging approaches reflect different energy consumption patterns, energy mixes, sources of supply and natural resources of various countries. Having these differences in mind this research reviews developments that have produced the current state of liberalization of the electricity and gas sectors in Poland and discusses the prospects for further progress towards an integrated, competitive and liberalized European electricity and gas market in the light of the challenges that remain. These challenges include uneven unbundling, discriminatory third party access, insufficient independency of national regulator, consolidation and anti-competitive behaviour of incumbents or abuse of one’s dominant position on the market.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: electricity, gas, liberalization, competition, unbundling, third party access, regulation
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law > K21 - Antitrust Law

References

“Cztery firmy bez wydzielonej dystrybucji prądu” [“Four firms without a separation of electricity distribution”] Gazeta Prawna, 1 June 2007.

Elżanowski F., Polityka energetyczna. Prawne instrument realizacji [Energy Policy. Legal Instruments of Its Implementation], Warszawa 2008.

European Commission, Report on Progress in Creating the Internal Gas and Electricity Market, SEC(2005) 1448.

European Commission Staff Working Document. Implementation Report – SEC(2006) 1709, page 136. Accompanying document to the Communication from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament – Prospects for the internal gas and electricity market – COM(2006) 841 final. Available at: http://ec.europa.eu/energy/energy_policy/doc/10_internal_market_country_reviews_en.pdf

Goldberg S., “Recent developments in the European Union energy sector” (2008) European Energy Review published by Herbert Smith LLP in association with Gleiss Lutz and Stibbe.

Hoff W., Prawny model regulacji sektorowej [The Legal Model of Sector-specific Regulation], Warszawa 2008.

Hoff W., Polish energy regulation in its European setting, LKAEM Publishing House, Warszawa 2007.

Joskow P., “Lessons Learned From Electricity Market Liberalization” (2008) The Energy Journal, Special Issue. The Future of Electricity: Papers in Honour of David Newbery IAEE.

Majone G., Surdej A., “Regulatory Agencies in Economic Governance. The Polish case in a comparative perspective” (2006) 5 KICES working papers, Koszalin Institute of Comparative Administrative Studies.

Majone G., Regulating Europe, London 1996.

“New Gas Reserve Act gives PGNIG even stronger control over the Polish market” (2007) Gas Matters, Platts.

Nowak B., “Rozdział przedsiębiorstw zintegrowanych pionowo w sektorze energii elektrycznej i gazu na podstawie Dyrektyw Elektroenergetycznej i Gazowej” [“Separation of Vertically Integrated Undertakings in Electricity and Gas Sector Based on Electricity and Gas Directives”] (2007) 8 Przegląd Ustawodawstwa Gospodarczego.

Nowak B., Wewnętrzny Rynek Energii w Unii Europejskiej [Internal Energy Market in the European Union], Warszawa 2009.

Olejnik M., “National Approaches to implementation – Poland” [in:] Cameron P. (ed.), Legal Aspects of EU Energy Regulation. Implementing the New Directives on Electricity and Gas Across Europe, Oxford University Press 2005.

“Poland’s power producers to terminate PPAs” (2007) 116 Energy in East Europe.

Roggenkamp M., “Gas Liberalization in the Netherlands: Ownership Unbundling and the Reorganization of Gasunie” [in:] Hammer U., Roggenkamp M. (eds.), European Energy Law Report III, Intersentia, Antwerpen-Oxford 2006.

Skoczny T., “Państwowe monopole handlowe w prawie wspólnotowym” [“State Monopolies of Commercial Character”] (1997) 3 Studia Europejskie.

Skoczny T., “Energetyka” [“Energy Industry”] [in:] Barcz J. (ed.), Prawo Unii Europejskiej. Prawo Materialne i Polityki [European Union Law. Substantive Law and Policies], Warszawa 2003.

Szydło M., “Unbunbdling własnościowy (ownership unbundling) jako instrument regulacyjny w sektorze energetycznym (część I)” [“Ownership Unbundling as an Instrument of Regulation in Energy Sector (Part I)”] (2007) 2 Przegląd Ustawodawstwa Gospodarczego.

Szydło M., “Unbunbdling własnościowy (ownership unbundling) jako instrument regulacyjny w sektorze energetycznym (część II)” [“Ownership Unbundling as an Instrument of Regulation in Energy Sector (Part II)”] (2007) 3 Przegląd Ustawodawstwa Gospodarczego.

Taylor S., “Energy unbundling faces switch-off” European Voice 14–21 June 2007.

Żukowski Z., “Umowę dostawy energii będzie można wypowiedzieć” [“Energy Supply Contract Can be Terminated”], Gazeta Prawna 15 June 2007.