Risk Premia, diverse belief and beauty contests

Kurz, Mordecai and Motolese, Maurizio (2006): Risk Premia, diverse belief and beauty contests.

Abstract

We present a theoretical and empirical evaluation of the role of market belief in the structure of risk premia. To that end we employ a familiar asset pricing model for which we develop in detail the belief structure. The novelty in this development is the treatment of individual and market beliefs as Markov state variables. Moreover, the market belief is observable and the paper explains how we extract it from the data. The advantage of our formulation is that it permits a closed form solution of equilibrium prices hence we can trace the exact effect of market belief on the time variability of equilibrium risk premia. We present a model of asset pricing with diverse beliefs. We then explore the conditions under which diverse beliefs arise. We then derive the equilibrium asset pricing and the risk premium which the model implies. Since asset prices are affected by the dynamics of market belief, the component of market risk which is determined by the belief of agents is thus termed “Endogenous Uncertainty.” The theoretical conclusions are tested empirically for investments in the futures markets, the bond markets. Our main theoretical and empirical result is that fluctuations in the market belief about state variables are a dominant factor determining the time variability of risk premia. More specifically, we show that when the market holds abnormally favorable belief about future payoffs of an asset the market views the long position as less risky and hence the risk premium on that asset declines. This means that fluctuations in risk premia are inversely related to the degree of market optimism about future prospects of asset payoffs. This effect is very strong and empirically very dominant. The strong effect of market belief on market risk premia offers two additional perspectives. First, it offers an additional way of showing (for those who have any doubt) that fundamental factors affect market dynamics but perceptions have equally important effect on volatility. Second, that market belief is actually an observable data which can be used for a deeper understanding of the basic causes of stochastic volatility and time variability of risk premia.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Risk premium; heterogenous beliefs; market state of belief; asset pricing; Bayesian learning; updating beliefs; Rational Beliefs
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G12 - Asset Pricing ; Trading Volume ; Bond Interest Rates; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D84 - Expectations ; Speculations

References

Allen, F., Morris, S., Shin, H.S. (2006) : “Beauty Contests and Iterated Expectations in Asset Markets.” Review of Financial Studies, 19, 719-752. Batchelor, R. and Dua, P. (1991): “Blue Chip Rationality Tests.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 23, 692 - 705. Blanchard, O. J., and Kahn, C. M. (1980): “The Solution of Linear Difference Models Under Rational Expectations.” Econometrica, 48, 1305 - 1311. Bliss, R. R., (1997): “Testing Term Structure Estimation Methods.” In Boyle, P., Pennacchi, G., Ritchken, P., (Ed.), Vol. 9, Advances in Futures and Options Research, JAI Press, Greenwich, Conn. 197 - 231. Brown, D. and Jennings, R. (1989): “On Technical Analysis.” Review of Financial Studies, 2, 527-551. Brunnermeier, M.K., (2001): Asset Pricing Under Asymmetric Information. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Campbell, J. and Shiller, R. J. (1991): “Yield Spreads and Interest Rate Movements: A Bird’s Eye View.” Review of Economic Studies, 58, 495 - 514. Cochrane, J., and Piazzesi, M., (2005): “Bond Risk Premia.” American Economic Review 95, 138 - 160. Detemple, J., Murthy S.(1994): “Intertemporal Asset Pricing with Heterogeneous Beliefs.” Journal of Economic Theory 62, 294-320. Fama, E.F. and Bliss, R.B., (1987): “The Information in Long-Maturity Forward Rates.” American Economic Review, 77, 680-692. Fan, M., (2006): “Heterogeneous Beliefs, the Term Structure and Time-Varying Risk Premia.” Annals of Finance, 2, 259-285. Grundy, B. and McNichols, M. (1989): “Trade and Revelation of Information Through Prices and Direct Disclosure.” Review of Financial Studies, 2, 495-526. Hansen, L.P. and Hodrick, R.J., (1988): “Forward ExchangeRates as Optimal Predictors of Future Spot Rates: An Econometric Analysis.” Journal of Political Economy, 88, 829-853. Harris, M., Raviv, A. (1993) : “Differences of Opinion Make a Horse Race.” Review of Financial Studies 6, 473-506 Harrison, M. and Kreps, D.(1978): “Speculative Investor Behavior in a Stock Market with Heterogenous Expectations.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 92, 323-336. He, H. and Wang, J. (1995): “ Differential Information and Dynamic Behavior of Stock Trading Volume.” Review of Financial Studies, 8, 914 - 972. Hodrick, R.J., (1992): “Dividend Yields and Expected Stock Returns: Alternative Procedures for Influence and Measurement.” Review of Financial Studies, 5, 357-386. Kurz, M.(1974): “The Kesten-Stigum Model and the Treatment of Uncertainty in Equilibrium Theory.” In Balch, M.S., McFadden, D.L., Wu, S.Y., (ed.) Essays on Economic Behavior Under Uncertainty. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 389-399. Kurz, M. (1994): “On the Structure and Diversity of Rational Beliefs.” Economic Theory 4, 877 - 900 . (An edited version appears as Chapter 2 of Kurz, M. (ed.) (1997) ). Kurz, M. (ed) (1997a): Endogenous Economic Fluctuations: Studies in the Theory of Rational Belief. Studies in Economic Theory, No. 6, Berlin and New York: Springer-Verlag. Kurz, M. (1997b): “On the Volatility of Foreign Exchange Rates.” Chapter 12 in Kurz, M. (ed.) (1997a) Endogenous Economic Fluctuations: Studies in the Theory of Rational Belief. Studies in Economic Theory, No. 6, Berlin and New York: Springer-Verlag, 317 -352. Kurz, M. (2005): “Diverse Beliefs, Forecast Errors and Central Bank Policy.” Working Paper, Stanford University, July, 2005. Kurz, M. (2006): “Beauty contests under private information and diverse beliefs: How different?” Working Paper, Stanford University, August, 2006. (Forthcoming in the Journal of Mathematical Economics). Kurz, M., Beltratti, , A. (1997): “The Equity Premium is No Puzzle.” Chapter 11 in Kurz, M. (ed.) (1997a) Endogenous Economic Fluctuations: Studies in the Theory of Rational Belief. Studies in Economic Theory, No. 6, Berlin and New York: Springer-Verlag, 283 -316. Kurz, M., Jin, H., Motolese, M. (2005a): “Determinants of Stock Market Volatility and Risk Premia.” Annals of Finance, 1, 109-147. Kurz, M., Jin, H., Motolese, M. (2005b): “The Role of Expectations in Economic Fluctuations and the Efficacy of Monetary Policy.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 29, 2017 - 2065. Kurz, M., Motolese, M. (2001): “Endogenous Uncertainty and Market Volatility.” Economic Theory, 17, 497 - 544. Kurz, M., Schneider, M.(1996): Coordination and Correlation in Markov Rational Belief Equilibria. Economic Theory 8, 489 - 520. (Appears as Chapter 10 of Kurz, M. (ed.) (1997a) ) Kurz, M., Wu, H.M. (1996): “Endogenous Uncertainty in a General Equilibrium Model with Price Contingent Contracts.” Economic Theory, 8, 461 -488. (Appears as Chapter 2 of Kurz, M. (ed.) (1997a) ). Motolese, M. (2001): “Money Non-Neutrality in a Rational Belief Equilibrium with Financial Assets.” Economic Theory, 18, 97 - 16. Motolese, M. (2003): “Endogenous Uncertainty and the Non-Neutrality of Money.” Economic Theory, 21, 317 - 345. Nielsen, K. C. (1996): “Rational Belief Structures and Rational Belief Equilibria.” Economic Theory, 8, 339 - 422 . Nielsen, K. C. (2003): “Floating Exchange Rates vs. A Monetary Union Under Rational Beliefs: The Role of Endogenous Uncertainty.” Economic Theory, 21, 347 - 398. Piazzesi, M. and Swanson, E., (2004): “Futures Prices as Risk-Adjusted Forecasts of Monetary Policy.” NBER Working Paper 10547, June. Saari, D. (2006): “Parts, Whole, and Evolution”, Lecture notes, University of California at Irvine. Stambaugh, R.F., (1988): “The Information in Forward Rates: Implications for Models of the Term Structure.” Journal of Financial Economics, 21, 41 -70. Stock, H. J., Watson, W. M. (1999): “Forecasting Inflation.” Department of Economics, Princeton University. Stock, H. J., Watson, W. M. (2001): “Forecasting Output and Inflation: The Role of Asset Prices.” Department of Economics, Princeton University, February. Stock, H. J., Watson, W. M. (2002): “Macroeconomic Forecasting Using Diffusion Indexes.” Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, The American Statistical Association, 20, 147-162. Stock, H. J., Watson, W. M. (2005): “An Empirical Comparison of Methods for Forecasting Using Many Predictors.” Department of Economics, Harvard University, January. Toukan, A. (2006): “Privately Held or Publicly Owned? Evolutionary Game Theoretic Analysis.” Working Paper, University of California at Irvine. Varian, H.R. (1985): “Divergence of Opinion in Complete Markets: A Note.” Journal of Finance 40, 309-317 Varian, H.R. (1989) : “Differences of Opinion in Financial Markets.” In Financial Risk: Theory, Evidence and Implications, Proceeding of the 11th Annual Economic Policy Conference of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, Stone, C.C. ed. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers. Wang, J. (1994): “A Model of Competitive Stock Trading Volume.” Journal of Political Economy, 102, 127 - 168. Wu, H.M., Guo, W.C. (2003): “Speculative Trading with Rational Beliefs and Endogenous Uncertainty.” Economic Theory, 21 , 263 292. Wu, H.M., Guo, W.C. (2004): “Asset Price Volatility and Trading Volume with Rational Beliefs.” Economic Theory, 23 , 461- 488.