Family Intertemporal Fiscal Incidence: A new Methodology for Assessing Public Policies

Polin, Veronica and Sartor, Nicola (2009): Family Intertemporal Fiscal Incidence: A new Methodology for Assessing Public Policies.

Abstract

A correct assessment of public policies requires the analysis of deliberate and involuntary redistribution. Redistributive policies have an interpersonal as well as an intrapersonal dimension. To assess the latter, the entire lifetime of individuals and families has to be taken into consideration. Traditionally, redistribution is analysed with static tax-benefit microsimulation models or on stylised individuals/households. Such tools are inadequate to estimate intrapersonal redistribution. The paper proposes a new methodology for evaluating the lifetime incidence of budgetary policy on families. To do so, the definition of a “family unit” proposed by Ermish and Overton (1985) is used. By explicitly considering jointly all tax and spending programs, including in kind transfers and the supply of public services, the new methodology allows to estimate the overall redistribution of the public budget. Moreover, this approach provides an essential tool for examining in detail how the existing tax-benefit system influences the net fiscal position of different family kinds along their lifecycle. As a first application, the new methodology is applied to Italy to investigate lifetime public support to dependants. Empirical results show that public support is not negligible, representing on average 10 percent of family expenditures. However, support is mainly geared to “old” family types - characterised by an absence of major economic problems and by low female labour market participation. The second part of the research explores the hypothesis that the current low demographic scenario can be characterised by “demographic free-riding”. Conclusions are such that the free-riding hypothesis is accepted. However, the scenario resembles the “positive externality” case more than that of “pure public good”.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Lifetime fiscal incidence; Child support and fertility
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H20 - General; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J18 - Public Policy

References

Ando A. and S. Nicoletti Altimari (2004), “A Micro Simulation Model of Demographic Development and Households' Economic Behaviour in Italy”, Temi di discussione Banca d'Italia n. 533.

Auerbach A.J., Gokhale J. and L.J. Kotlikoff (1991), “Generational Accounts: A Meaningful Alternative to Deficit Accounting”, in D. Bradford (ed.), Tax Policy and the Economy, Cambridge, MA, Vol. V, 55-110.

Boadway R. and M. Keen (1998), “Redistribution”, in A. Atkinson and F. Bourguignon (eds) Handbook of Income Distribution, vol. 1, 677-789.

Bourguignon F. and A. Spadaro (2006), “Microsimulation As A Tool for Evaluating Redistribution Policies”, Journal of Economic Inequality, 4(1), 77-106.

Bovenberg A.L. (2008), “The Life-course Perspective and Social Policies: An Overview of the Issues”, CESifo Economic Studies, 54(4), 593-641.

Cardarelli R. and N. Sartor (2000), “Generational Accounting for Italy”, in Banca d’Italia (ed.), Fiscal Sustainability, Perugia, SADIBA, 501-557.

Cigno A. (1995), “Risparmio, fecondità e previdenza sociale: un approccio basato sulla nuova economia della famiglia”, Rivista italiana di economia, october, 49-64.

De Santis G. and M. Maltagliati (2001), “Child-cost estimates: the great leap forward”, paper presented at the Workshop Low fertility in Italy: between economic constraints and value changes, Firenze 8-9 november.

Ermisch J. (1988), “An Economic Perspective on Household Modelling”, in Keilman N., Kuijsten A. and A. Vossen (eds.), Modelling household formation and dissolution, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 23-40.

Ermisch J. and E. Overton (1985), “Minimal Household Units: A New Approach to the Analysis of Household Formation”, Population Studies, 39(1), 33-54.

Gomes F.J., Kotlikoff J. and L.M. Viceira (2008), “Optimal Life-cycle Investing with Flexible Labor Supply: A Welfare Analysis of Life-Cycle Funds”, National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper, n. 13966, april.

Hakim C. (2003), “A New Approach to Explaining Fertility Patterns: Preference Theory”, Population and Development Review, 29(3), 349-374.

Harding A. and A. Gupta (Eds) (2007), Modelling our Future: Population Ageing, Social Security and Taxation, Elsevier Science.

Immervoll H., Lietz C., O’Donoghue C., Verbist G., Levy H., Mantovani D. and H. Sutherland (2005), “Household Incomes and Redistribution in the European Union: Quantifying the Equalising Properties of Taxes and Benefits”, IZA Discussion Paper, n. 1824.

Immervoll H., H.J. Kleven, Kreiner C.T. and E. Saez (2007), "Welfare Reform in Europe: A Micro-simulation Analysis", Economic Journal, 117(516), 1-44.

ISTAT (2001), Conti ed aggregati economici delle Amministrazioni Pubbliche. Anni 1999-2000, Roma.

ISAE (2001), “Politiche fiscali e famiglie in Italia: una prospettiva di Contabilità Generazionale”, in Rapporto trimestrale Finanza pubblica e redistribuzione, october, 93-131.

Kuijsten A.C. (1996), “Changing Family Patterns in Europe: A Case of Divergence?”, European Journal of Population, 12(2), 115-143.

Lesthaeghe R. and J. Surkyn (1988), “Cultural Dynamics and Economic Theories of Fertility Change”, Population and Development Review, 14(1), 1-45.

OECD (2005), “Taxing Working Families. A Distributional Analysis”, OECD Tax Policy Studies.

Orcutt G. (1957) “A New Type of Socio-economic System”, Review of Economics and Statistics, 39(2), 116-123.

Palomba R. (1995), “Italy: The Invisible Change”, in H. Moors and R. Palomba, Population, Family and Welfare, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 158-177.

Perali F. (1999), “Stime delle scale di equivalenza utilizzando i bilanci familiari ISTAT 1985-1994”, Rivista internazionale di Scienze sociali, 107(4), 481-542.

Polin V. (2004), “Il costo dei figli: una stima svincolata dal benessere”, Rivista internazionale di Scienze sociali, 112(1), 79-108.

Polin V., Tommasi N. and A. Roveda (2008), “Conti generazionali familiari: aspetti dinamici”, in AA.VV. (eds.) Instabilità familiare: aspetti causali e conseguenze demografiche, economiche e sociali, Atti del Convegno “Instabilità familiare: aspetti causali e conseguenze demografiche, economiche e sociali”, Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Roma, 20-21 september 2007, 253-269.

Sandmo A. (1999), “The Public Economics of Redistribution and the Welfare State”, Review of Population and Social Policy, n. 8, 139-154.

Sartor N. (2001), “The Long-run Effects of the Italian Pension Reforms”, International Tax and Public Finance, 8(1), 83-111.