Major League Baseball Anti-Trust Immunity: Examining the Legal and Financial Implications of Relocation Rules

Mark, Nagel and Matt, Brown and Daniel, Rascher and Chad, McEvoy (2006): Major League Baseball Anti-Trust Immunity: Examining the Legal and Financial Implications of Relocation Rules. Published in: Entertainment and Sports Law Journal , Vol. 4, No. 3 (December 2006)

Abstract

Major League Baseball (MLB) rules restrict the movement of any franchise into another’s territory. These territorial rules are designed to protect each team’s potential local revenue sources as well as to provide stability throughout the league. Recently, Major League Baseball approved financial compensation for the Washington Nationals move into the Baltimore Orioles’ territory – primarily because it was in the best interest of MLB even though it hurt the Orioles. However, the Oakland Athletics were unable to even negotiate a potential compensation plan for a move into the San Francisco Giants territory, despite the apparent financial benefit the move could have provided for every other league franchise. The Athletics are already located within 15 miles of the Giants, and their potential 40 mile move to San Jose, California would not add a new team to the San Francisco Bay Area; rather, it would simply be a move of a current team to a different location within the metropolitan area. The refusal of the Giants or MLB to negotiate a potential compromise has kept the Oakland Athletics in a substandard facility and has led to their potential move to Fremont, CA – a less desirable location than San Jose.

This paper investigates the legal, policy, and financial considerations concerning Major League Baseball’s territorial rules. Specifically, it addresses antitrust law as it pertains to American professional sport, relative sport franchise relocation cases, financial arguments why leagues desire to control relocation, financial components of MLB’s current Collective Bargaining Agreement, and the legal and financial impact of a challenge to MLB’s territorial rules – an option the Oakland Athletic initially investigated prior to their decision to pursue a potential move to Fremont.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Antitrust law; Collective Bargaining Agreement; Franchise Relocation; Major League Baseball; Revenue Sharing; Territorial Rights
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law > K21 - Antitrust Law; L - Industrial Organization > L8 - Industry Studies: Services > L83 - Sports ; Gambling ; Restaurants ; Recreation ; Tourism

References

‘A’s seek tax-increment financing’ (2006) Retrieved from <http://www.fieldofschemes.com/news/archives/2006/11/as_to_seek_taxi.html>.

‘Athletics timeline’ (n.d.) Retrieved from <http://oakland.athletics.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/oak/history/timeline4.jsp>.

Bauer J (1993) ‘Antitrust and sports: Must competition on the field displace competition in the marketplace?’ 60 Tennessee Law Review 2.

Blake M (1991). The Minor Leagues (New York: Wynwood Press).

Blum R (2004) Baseball Owners approve Expos move’ Retrieved from <http://newsfindlaw.com/ap/s/2020/12-3-2004/20041203114503_42.html>.

Brown M (2004) ‘The Expos move to DC doesn’t mean the A’s get into San Jose’ Retrieved from <http://businessofbaseball.com/series3.htm>.

Brown M (2006) ‘One Image Explains why Relocation is Difficult’ Retrieved from <http://www.maurybrown.com/?p=116>.

Campbell D (1983) ‘Antitrust analysis in professional sports management cases: The public cries “foul!”’ 25 Arizona Law Review 3.

Fein B (2005) ‘Taking the stand: Baseball’s privileged antitrust exemption’ Retrieved from <http://www.dcbar.org/for_lawyers/washington_lawyer/october_2005/stand.cfm>.

Fisher E (2005a) ‘MLB, Orioles fire back at CSN’ The Washington Times Retrieved from <http://www.washtimes.com/sports/20050614-121302-7663r.htm>.

Fisher E (2005b) ‘TV deal partners Orioles, Nationals’ The Washington Times Retrieved from <http://washingtontimes.com/national/20050401-012526-8027r.htm>.

Freedman W (1987) Professional Sports and Antitrust (New York: Quorum Books).

‘Giants timeline’ (2005) Retrieved from <http://sanfrancisco.giants.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/sf/history/sf_history_timeline_article.jsp?article=22>.

Gietschier S (1995) ‘Go west, young Rams - Cleveland Rams' 1946 move to Los Angeles’ The Sporting News 23 Jan http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1208/is_n4_v219/ai_16218447>.

Gordon J (2004) ‘In San Francisco, the Giants went private for their stadium’ Retrieved from <http://news.minnesota.publicradio.org/features/2004/05/14_gordonj_sanfranpark>.

Hamm A (2005) ‘Baseball to San Jose: “Yer out!”’ Retrieved from <http://sanfrancisco.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/stories/2005/02/07/daily40.html>.

Heath T (2005) ‘O’s get majority of TV deal’ The Washington Post Retrieved from <http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A15731-2005Mar31.html>.

‘History of McAfee Coliseum’ (2005) Retrieved from <http://oakland.athletics.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/oak/ballpark/index.jsp>.

Howard D and Crompton J (2004) Financing Sport (2nd ed.) (Morgantown, WV: Fitness Information Technology, Inc.).

Kaplan D (2003) ‘Selig preaches “turning point” for baseball’ Sports Business Journal Retrieved from <http://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=search.show_article&articleId=29300&keyword=2002,%20MLB,%20collective,%20bargaining,%20agreement>.

King B (2003) ‘Cities officially open their pursuit of Expos’ 5 Sports Business Journal 6.

‘Lap of Luxury’ (2004) Retrieved from <http://www.baseballmusings.com/archives/008184.php>.

Leahy P (2000) ‘Baseballs Revenue Gap: Pennant for Sale?’ Retrieved from <http://leahy.senate.gov/press/200011/001121.html>.

‘Los Angeles Dodgers’ (2005) Retrieved from <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_Angeles_Dodgers>.

Masteralexis, L (2001) ‘Antitrust and labor law: Professional sport applications’ in Cotton D, Wolohan, J and Wilde T Law for Recreation and Sport Managers (2nd ed.) (Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt).

‘MLB, Orioles reach compensation agreement’ (2005) Retrieved from <http://www.allsports.com/cgi-bin/showstory.cgi?story_id=53608>.

‘MLB revenue sharing in 2002 and 2003’ (2004) Retrieved from http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=1803536>.

Moynihan D (1980) ‘North American Soccer League v. National Football League: Applying “rule of reason” analysis under the Sherman Act to private bans on cross ownership’ 15 New England Law Review 3.

Newhouse D (2004a) ‘A’s fans now owe Schott, Hoffman 100 million cheers’ Tri-Valley Herald, p. S1 & S8.

Newhouse D (2004b) ‘Piccinini remains right man for A’s’. Tri-Valley Herald, p. S1 & S6.

‘New York Yankees year by year results’ (2005) Retrieved from <http://newyork.yankees.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/nyy/history/year_by_year_results.jsp>.

Neyer R (2002) ‘Who are the six contractions candidates?’ Retrieved from <http://espn.go.com/mlb/columns/neyer_rob/1394440.html>.

Neyer R. (2003) ‘When it all shakes out, expect Expos to move to D.C.’ Retrieved from <http://espn.go.com/mlb/columns/neyer_rob/1506813.html>.

‘Oakland Athletics attendance’ (2005) Retrieved from <http://www.baseball-almanac.com/teams/athlatte.shtml >.

O’Keefe M (2002) ‘Yankees voice concerns’ Retrieved from <http:www.nydailynews.com/sports/v-pfriendly/story/12292p-11630c.html>.

‘Orioles timeline’ (2005) Retrieved from <http://mlb/mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/bal/history/timeline1.jsp>.

Ostrom, M., and Lynch A. (2006) ‘A’s move to Fremont built on Wolff’s vision’ Retrieved from <http://www.contracostatimes.com/mld/cctimes/sports/baseball/mlb/oakland_athletics/16052342.htm>.

‘Owners approve Nationals sale’ (2006). Retrieved from http://www.cbc.ca/news/story/2006/05/18/mlb-nationals-sale.html>.

Pappas D (2002a) ‘Inside the Major League rules’ Retrieved from <http://roadsidephotos.sabr.org/baseball/02-4rules.htm>.

Pappas D (2002b) ‘The Numbers (Part Six)’ Retrieved from <http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=1333&mode=print>.

‘Relocation process expos-ed’ (2004) 7 Sports Business Journal 21.

‘Reports: Athletics will build stadium in Fremont’ (2006) Retrieved from <http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=2652436>.

Rosenbaum T (1987) ‘The antitrust implications of professional sports leagues revisited: Emerging trends in the modern era’ 41 University of Miami Law Review 4.

Ross S (2000) ‘Myths, realities, and creative approaches to antitrust and franchise relocation issues’ Spring Antitrust 57.

‘San Francisco Giants attendance’ (2005) Retrieved from <http://www.baseball-almanac.com/teams/sfatte.shtml>.

‘San Jose would like to land A’s’ (2004) Retrieved from <http://sports.go.com/print?id=1891783&type=story>.

Shea J (2003) ‘Commish knows A’s have money problem’ Retrieved from <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/chronicle/archive/2003/02/07/SP240358.DTL>.

Snel, A (1999) ‘Safeco Field will make M’s a valued member of Major League Baseball’ Retrieved from < http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/safeco/game/safe02.shtml>.

Stark J (2004) ‘MLB lays out incentive plan for Angelos’ Retrieved from <http://sports.go.com/mlb/columns/story?columnist=stark_jayson&id=1888266>.

Steele D (2004) ‘Making sausage ain’t pretty’ Retrieved from <http://sports.go.com/mlb/columns/story?id=1940526>.

‘Summary of the [2002] collective bargaining agreement’ Retrieved from http://www.businessofbaseball.com/summary2002cba.htm>.

‘USA Today salaries databases’ (n.d.). Retrieved from <http://asp.usatoday.com/sports/baseball/salaries/totalpayroll.aspx?year=2005>.

Veeck B (1962) Veeck as in Wreck (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).

Weiner E (2006) Daily radio commentary – January 25, 2006.

Weiler P and Roberts G (1993) Cases, Materials and Problems on Sports and the Law (St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Co.).

Witt B (2005) ‘For A’s, way to San Jose paved with uncertainty’ Retrieved from <http://siliconvalley.com/mld/mercurynews/news/10948133.htm>.

Wolohan, J (2007). ‘Antitrust law: Amateur sport applications’ in Cotton D and Wolohan J Law for Recreation and Sport Managers (4th ed.) (Dubuque, IA: Kendall-Hunt Publishing Company).

Wittenmyer G (2006) ‘Twins laying off threats, for now’ Retrieved from <http://www.freewebs.com/twincities/news/feb2006/press_0220061.html>.

‘Yankees receive $11.8 million luxury tax bill’ (2005). Retrieved from <http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2003/baseball/mlb/12/24/luxury.tax.ap/>.

Zimbalist A (1992) Baseball and Billions: A Probing Look into the Big Business of our National Pastime. (New York: Basic Books).