Background Paper on Inflation and Unemployment

Grady, Patrick (1985): Background Paper on Inflation and Unemployment.

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to provide background on the trade-off between inflation and unemployment to assist the Commission of Inquiry on Unemployment Insurance in the preparation of its report. The main issues from the point of view of the Commission are the existence of a trade-off between inflation and unemployment and the effects of Unemployment Insurance on the trade-off. To shed light on these issues, the paper reviews the literature on the relationship between the rate of change of wages and the rate of unemployment.

The expectations-augmented Phillips curve paradigm for wage determination is reviewed in the second section of the paper. A full exposition of its theoretical rationale and implications is provided. According to this theory, the rate of increase of wages is a function of the the gap between the actual and non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment, and of the expected rate of price inflation. Other variables such as catch-up for real wage losses and profitablity have also been included in wage equations. An important implication of the extended Phillips curve model, which is emphasized in the paper, is that there is no long run trade-off between higher inflation and permanently lower unemployment, but only a short-run trade-off between higher inflation and temporarily lower unemployment.

The Canadian empirical literature on the relationship between wages on the one hand and unemployment and inflationary expectations (based on the cost of living) on the other is reviewed in the third section of the paper. This review, which focuses on the studies done in the last ten years, includes estimates made using micro-data on wage settlements as well as macro wage equations. The wage sectors of the main Canadian macroeconomic models are also canvassed. Tabular summaries of the key results of the studies are provided.

Estimates of the impact of variables other than labour market tightness and inflation expectations such as productivity, catch-up, and profitability, which are included in wage equations, are also presented.

Three important findings of the literature search on wage behaviour and unemployment, which are of particular interest and which are summarized in tabular form in the third section of the paper, are empirical estimates of:

- the Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of Unemployment (NAIRU) or natural rate of unemployment that is believed to be consistent with the maintenance of a constant rate of inflation;

- the short term trade-off between inflation and unemployment based on the coefficient and lag structure of the unemployment rate in the wage equation; and

- the impact of the 1971 and 1979 changes in Unemployment Insurance on the natural (non-accelerating inflation) rate of unemployment.

The estimates of the impact of changes in the Unemployment Insurance on the natural rate of unemployment should be of particular value in any consideration of further changes to that program.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of Unemployment in Canada,natural rate of unemployment in Canada, impact of unemployment insurance on inflation and unemployment in Canada
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy > E24 - Employment ; Unemployment ; Wages ; Intergenerational Income Distribution ; Aggregate Human Capital ; Aggregate Labor Productivity; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E31 - Price Level ; Inflation ; Deflation

References

Aubrey, Jean-Pierre, Judy DiMillo and Pierre Cloutier (1979) "An Estimation of the Natural Rate of Unemployment in Canada." Research Memorandum RM-79-14. Ottawa: Bank of Canada.

Auld,D.A.L., L.N. Christofides, R. Swidinsky and D.A. Wilton (1979) The Determinants of Negotiated Wage Settlements in Canada (1966-75): A Microeconomic Analysis. Anti-Inflation Board. Ottawa: Supply and Services.

Baily, Martin Neil and James Tobin (1977) "Macroeconomic Effect of Selective Public Employment and Wage Subsidies." Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. 2, pp. 511-544.

Beach, C.M. and S.F. Kaliski (1983) "On the Design of Unemployment Insurance: The Impact of the 1979 Unemployment Insurance Amendments." Canadian Public Policy 9, 164-173.

Bodkin, R.G. and A. Cournoyer (1978) "Legislation and the Labour Market: A Selective Review of Canadian Studies." In H.G. Grubel and M.A. Walker (eds.) (1978) 62-68.

Bodkin, R.G., E.P. Bond, G.L.Reuber and T.R. Robinson (1967) Price Stability and High Employment: the Options for Canadian Economic Policy. Economic Council of Canada. Ottawa: Queen's Printer.

Christofides, L.N., R. Swidinsky and D.A. Wilton (1978) "A Micro Econometric Analysis of the Canadian Wage Determination Process (1976-75)." Paper presented at the Canadian Economics Association annual meeting.

Christofides, Louis N., Robert Swidinsky and David A. Wilton (1980) "A Microeconomic Analysis of the Canadian Wage Determination Process." Economica. 47, 165-178.

Coe, David T. and Francesco Gagliardi (1985) "Nominal Wage Determination in Ten OECD Economies." OECD Economics and Statistics Department Working Papers No.19.

Cousineau, Jean-Michel and Robert Lacroix (1977) "L'impact de la politique canadienne de controle des prix et des revenues sur les ententes salariales." Document no. 95 (Ottawa: Economic Council of Canada).

Department of Finance (1978) Canada's Recent Inflation Experience (Ottawa).

Dungan, D. Peter, and T.A. Wilson (1979) "Notes on the Equilibrium Unemployment Rate."

Foot, David and Jeanne Li (1984) "The Demographic Determinants of Unemployment in Canada." a paper presented at a Conference "Unemployment: Can It Be Reduced? An International Perspective," sponsored by the Centre for IndustrialRelations, University of Toronto, Toronto, November 28-30,1984.

Fortin, Pierre and Keith Newton (1982) "Labour Market Tightness and Wage Inflation in Canada." In Martin Neil Bailey, ed.,Workers, Jobs and Inflation Washington,D.C.:Brookings Institution),243-278.

Fortin, Pierre and Louis Phaneuf (1979) "Why is the Unemployment Rate So High in Canada?" paper presented at the Canadian Economics Association annual meeting. (Also Universite Laval Cahier 8115).

Freedman, Charles (1976) "The Phillips Curve in Canada." unpublished study, Bank of Canada.

Friedman, Milton (1968) "The Role of Monetary Policy." American Economic Review. 58, 1-17.

Gosselin, Michel (1980) "Modification apportees a l'equation des salaires et estimation du taux de chomage natural." Research Memorandum RM-80-39. Ottawa: Bank of Canada.

Grady, Patrick (1985) "The State of the Art in Canadian Macroeconomic Modelling." a report prepared for the Economic Forecasting Division, Department of Finance.

Green, Christopher and Jean-Michel Cousineau (1976) Unemployment in Canada, The Impact of Unemployment Insurance (Ottawa: Economic Council of Canada).

Grubel, H.G. and D. Maki (1979) "What is Full Employment?" Simon Fraser University Discussion Paper 79-1-1.

Grubel, H.G. and M.A. Walker (eds.) (1978) Unemployment Insurance: Global Evidence of its Effects on Unemployment. Vancouver: Fraser Institute.

Grubel, Herbert, Dennis Maki and Shelly Sax (1975a) "Real and Insurance Induced Unemployment in Canada." Canadian Journal of Economics 8, no.2, 174-191.

Grubel, Herbert, Dennis Maki and Shelly Sax (1975b) "Real and Insurance Induced Unemployment in Canada." Canadian Journal of Economics 8, no.4, 603-605.

Guindon, Denis and Louis Grignon (1981a) "Changes in the Cyclical and Structural Components of Unemployment Rates: Their Implications for the Measurement of Labour Market Tightness." unpublished paper, Fiscal Policy and Economic Analysis Division, Department of Finance.

Guindon, Denis and Louis Grignon (1981b) "The Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of Unemployment in Canada: A Re-examination." unpublished paper, Fiscal Policy and Economic Analysis Branch, Department of Finance.

Helliwell, J.F., et al. (1971) The Structure of RDX2 Revised and Estimated to Q472_, Bank of Canada Technical Report 5 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada).

Jump, Gregory and Samuel A. Rea Jr. (1975) "The Impact of the Unemployment Insurance Act on Work Incentives and the Aggregate Labour Market." Toronto: Institute for Policy Analysis.

Kaliski, S.F. (1972) The Trade-off between Inflation and Unemployment: Some Explorations of the Recent Evidence for Canada. Special Study No.22, Economic Council of Canada. Ottawa: Information Canada.

Kaliski, S.F. (1975) "Real and Insurance Induced Unemployment in Canada: A Reply." Canadian Journal of Economics 8, no.4, 600-603.

Kaliski, S.F. (1976) "Unemployment and Unemployment Insurance: Testing Some Corollaries." Canadian Journal of Economics 9, no.4, 705-712.

Kaliski, S.F. (1985) "Trends, Changes, and Imbalances: A Survey of the Canadian Labour Market." In Work and Pay: the Canadian Labour Market. vol. 17 prepared for the Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada (Toronto: University of Toronto Press).

Kierzkowski, Henryk (1977) "Short-Run Inflation-Unemployment Trade-offs and the Natural Rate of Unemployment." Ottawa: Bank of Canada.

Lazar, Fred (1978) "The Impact of the 1971 Unemployment Insurance Revisions on Unemployment Rates: Another Look." Canadian Journal of Economics 11, 559- 570.

Lipsey, Richard G. (1960) "The Relationship between Unemployment and the Rate of Change of Money Wage Rates in the United Kingdom, 1862-1957: A Further Analysis." Economica. 27,456-87.

Maki, Dennis R. (1977) "Unemployment Benefits and the Duration of Claims in Canada." Applied Economics 9, 227-236.

McCallum, John (1985) "Fiscal Policy and Unemployment." A paper prepared for the Symposium on Policies for Full Employment sponsored by the Social Planning Council of Ottawa-Carleton.

Merrett, Daryl L . (1979) "The Process of Wage Determination: A Survey of Some Recent Work." Technical Report 19 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada).

O'Reilly, Brian (1976) "An Attempt to Adjust the Unemployment Rate for Institutional and Demographic Changes over the Period 1953-1975." Research Memorandum RM-76-192. Ottawa: Bank of Canada.

Phelps, Edmund S. (1967) "Phillips Curves, Expectations of Inflation, and Optimal Unemployment over Time." 34, 254-281.

Phelps, Edmund S. et al. (1970) Microeconomic Foundations of Employment and Inflation. New York: Norton.

Phillips, A.W. (1958) "The Relationship between Unemployment and the Rate of Change of Money Wages in the United Kingdom, 1861-1957." Economica. 25, 283-299.

Rea, Samuel A. (1977) "Unemployment Insurance and Labour Supply: A Simulation of the 1971 Unemployment Insurance Act. Canadian Journal of Economics 10, 263-278.

Reid, Frank (1978) "The Effect of Controls on the Rate of Change of Real and Money Wages in Canada." Paper presented at the Canadian Economics Association annual meeting.

Reid, Frank and Noah Meltz (1979) "Causes of Shifts in the Unemployment- Vacancy Relationship."Review of Economics and Statistics. 61, pp.470-475.

Riddell, W. Craig (1979) "Estimates of the Natural Unemployment Rate for Canada, Ontario and Newfoundland." unpublished. Ottawa: Economic Council of Canada.

Riddell, W.C. (1979) "The Empirical Foundation of the Phillips Curve: Evidence from Canadian Wage Contract Data." Econometrica. 47, 1-24.

Riddell, W.C. and P.M. Smith (1982) "Expected Inflation and Wage Changes in Canada." Canadian Journal of Economics 15, 377-94.

Rowley, J.C.R. and D.A. Wilton (1973) "Quarterly Models of Wage Determination: Some New Efficient Estimates." American Economic Review.

Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada (1985) Report (Ottawa: Supply and Services Canada).

Samson, Lucie (1985) "A Study of Sectoral Shifts on Aggregate Unemployment in Canada." Canadian Journal of Economics. XVIII, no.3, 518-513.

Santomero, Anthony M. and John J. Seater (1978) "The Inflation-Unemployment Trade-off: A Critique of the Literature." Journal of Economic Literature

Seidule, Tom, Nick Skoulas, and Keith Newton (1975) "The Impact of Economy- wide Changes on the Labour Force." unpublished. Ottawa: Economic Council of Canada.

Siedule, Tom and Keith Newton (1979) " The Unemployment Gap in Canada, 1961- 1978." Discussion Paper No. 145. Ottawa: Economic Council of Canada.

Taylor, L.D., S.J. Turnovsky and T.A. Wilson (1972) The Inflationary Process in North American Manufacturing. A study for the Prices and Incomes Commission. Ottawa: Information Canada.

Turnovsky, S.J. (1972) "The Expectations Hypothesis and the Aggregate Wage Equation: Some Empirical Evidence for Canada." Economica. 39, no. 153, pp.1-17.

Vanderkamp, J. (1972) "Wage Adjustment, Productivity and Price Change Expectations." Review of Economic Studies. 39(1), no. 117, pp.61-70.

Vanderkamp, John and Jerry Wilson (1980) "The Effects of Unemployment Insurance on Unemployment, Employment and Participation Rates." unpublished , Department of Economics, University of Guelph.

Wilson, T.A. and Frank Reid (1979) Wage and Price Behaviour in Canadian Manufacturing: An Econometric Analysis. A study prepared for the Anti- Inflation Board. Ottawa: Supply and Services.

Wilson, T.A. and G.V. Jump (1978) "The Influence of the Anti-Inflation Program on Aggregate Wages and Prices: A Simulation Analysis." unpublished paper, Institute for Policy Analysis.

Wilton, D.A. (1980) Wage Inflation in Canada, 1955-1975. A study prepared for the Economic Council of Canada (Ottawa: Supply and Services Canada).

Wilton, D.A. (1985) "Public Sector Wage Compensation." A paper prepared for the Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada.