Informal regionalism in Central Asia: subnational and international levels

Libman, Alexander (2008): Informal regionalism in Central Asia: subnational and international levels.

Abstract

While the poor quality of governance is widely accepted as a main factor hampering economic development in Central Asia, one of the main ways to solve this problem is often connected with changing the allocation of authorities, shifting them to the supranational (regional integration) or subnational (decentralization) levels. Both aspects have been widely discussed, but the progress remains extremely limited. This paper claims however, that in spite of deficit of formal institutions, informal decentralization and regional integration have been important factors with a profound impact on economic and social development of Central Asia. However, the impact of informal shifts of authority on institutional development is not unambiguous.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: informal regionalism; decentralization; regionalization
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F15 - Economic Integration; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P26 - Political Economy ; Property Rights

References

Abalkina, A. (2007): Bankovskoe Sotrudnichestvo v Stranakh EvrAzES kak Predposylka Ikh Integracii. Kontinent Partnerstva (10)

Abalkina, A., Golovnin, M., and A. Libman (2007): Perspektivy Razvitiya Integracionnoi Gruppirovki EvrAzEs. Moscow: IE RAS

Aidt, T., Dutta, J., and V. Sena (2008): Governance Regimes, Corruption, and Growth: Theory and Evidence. Journal of Comparative Economics 36

Alesina, A., and E. Spolaore (2003): The Size of Nations. MIT Press

Ananyin, O.I. (2005): Struktura Ekonomiko-Teoreticheskogo Znaniya: Metodologicheskiy Analiz. Moscow: Nauka

Badykova, N. (2006): Regional Cooperation in Central Asia: A View from Turkmenistan. Problems of Economic Transition 48(8)

Bahry, D. (2003): Novyi Federalizm i Paradoksy Regional’nogo Suvereniteta v Rossii. Kazanskii Federalist (2)

Beck, U. (2002) Macht und Gegenmacht im globalen Zeitalter. Frankfurt a.M., Surkampf Verlag

Bednar, J. (2004): Authority Migration in Federations: A Framework for Analysis. PS: Political Science & Politics. June

Bell, J.H.J., and J.M. Pennings (1996): Foreign Entry, Cultural Barriers and Learning. Strategic Management Journal

Bohr, A. (2004): Regionalism in Central Asia: New Geopolitics, Old Regional Order. International Affairs 80(3)

Breslin, S. (2004): Foreign Direct Investment in China: What the Figures Don't Tell Us. Mimeo

Chebankova, E. (2008): Adaptive Federalism and Federation in Putin’s Russia. Europe-Asia Studies 60(6)

Crane, K., Peterson, D.J., and O. Oliker, (2005): Russian Investments in the Commonwealth of Independent States. Eurasian Geography and Economics 46(6)

Cummings, S.N. (2000): Kazakhstan: Centre-Periphery Relations. L.: Royal Institute of International Affairs

Dabla-Norris, E., Martines-Vasquez, J., and J. Norregaard (2000): Making Decentralization Work: The Case of Russia, Ukraine and Kazakhstan. Andrew Young School of Policy Studies ISP Working Paper No. 9

Davidson, W. (1980): The Location of Foreign Direct Investment Activity: Country Characteristics and Experience Effects. Journal of International Business Studies 11(2)

De Sousa, J., and O. Lamotte (2007): Does Political Disintegration Lead to Trade Disintegration? Evidence from Transition Countries. Economics of Transition 15(4)

Djankov, S., and C. Freund (2002): Trade Flows in the Former Soviet Union. Journal of Comparative Economics 30(1)

Djankov, S., and C. Freund (2002a): New Borders: Evidence from the Former Soviet Union. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv 138(3)

Dobson, W., and C.S. Yue (eds., 1997): Multinationals and East Asian Integration. Ottawa: IDRC/ISEAS

Dreher, A., and M. Gassebner (2007): Greasing the Wheels of Entrepreneurship? Impact of Regulation and Corruption on Firm Entry? CESifo Working Paper No. 2013

Ekspert Kazakhstan (2007): Strana na Nitochkakh. Ekspert Kazakhstan, December 3

Elborg-Woytek, K. (2003): Of Openness and Distance: Trade Developments in the Commonwealth of Independent States, 1993-2002. IMF Working Paper WP/03/207

Evers, H.D., and M. Kaiser (2000): Two Continents, One Arena: Eurasia. Bielefeld Sociology of Development Research Centre Working Paper No. 328

Farrant, A. (2006): Mission Impossible: The Politico-Geographic Engineering of Soviet Central Asia’s Republican Boundaries. Central Asian Survey 25(1-2)

Fidrmuc, J., and J. Fidrmuc J. (2001): Disintegration and Trade. ZEI Working Paper, B24

Furman, D. (2007): Obshee i Osobennoe v Razvitii Postsovetskikh Gosudarstv. In: Lipman, M., and A. Ryabov (eds.): Puti Rossiyskogo Postkommunisma. Moscow: R. Elinin

Gibson, E.L., and T.G.Falleti (2004): Unity by the Stick: Regional Conflict and the Origins of Argentine Federalism. In: Gibson, E.L. (eds.) Federalism and Democracy in Latin America. Baltimore

Gleason, G. (2001): Inter-State Cooperation in Central Asia: from the CIS to the Shanghai Forum. Europe-Asia Studies 53(7): 1077-1095

Grafe, C., Raiser, M., and T. Sakatsume (2005): Beyond Borders: Reconsidering Regional Trade in Central Asia. EBRD Working Paper No. 95

Greif, A. (2006): Institutions and the Path to the Modern Economy: Lessons from Medieval Trade. Cambridge University Press

Gutovnik, M. (2006): Decentralization Reforms in Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan: Slowly and Unsteady, International Assessment and Strategy Center, Working Paper

Havrylyshin, O. (2007): Fifteen Years of Transformation in the Post-Communist World: Rapid Reformers Outperformed Gradualists. CATO Institute Development Policy Analysis No. 4

Ivakhnyuk, I. (2006): Migration in the CIS Region: Common Problems and Mutual Benefits. Mimeo

Jones Luong, P. (2000): Sources of Institutional Continuity: The Soviet Legacy in Central Asia. Mimeo

Jones Luong, P. (2004): Economic Decentralization in Kazakhstan: Causes and Consequences. In: Jones Luong, P. (ed.): The Transformation of Central Asia, Ithaca: Cornell University Press

Kaiser, M. (2002): Evraziya: Social’naya Real’nost’ ili Mif. Zhurnal Sociologii i Social’noi Antropologii (4)

Kawai. M. (2005): East Asian Economic Regionalism: Prospects and Challenges. Journal of Asian Economics 16(1)

Kerber, W. and Budzinski, O. (2004). “Towards a Differentiated Analysis of Competition of Competition Laws.” Journal of Competition Law, 1:411--48.

Kordonskiy, S. (1995): Postperestroechnoe Ekonomicheskoe Prostranstvo: Transformacii Administrativnogo Rynka. In: Chernyshev, S. (ed): Inoe: Hrestomatiya Novogo Rossiiskogo Samosoznaniya. Moscow

Kosals, L. (2006): Interim Outcome of the Russian Transition: Clan Capitalism. Kyoto Institute of Economic Research Working Paper No. 610

Kuz’min, N. (2007): Nursultan Nazarbaev Predlozhil Kirgizii Ekonomicheskuyu Pomoshch i Investicii Kazakhskikh Kompaniy. Ekspert Kazakhstan (17)

Kuz’min, N. (2008): Soyz Nesoglasnykh. Ekspert (18) Kuznetsov, A.V. (2007): Internacionalizatsiya Rossiiskoi Ekonomiki: Investicionnyi Aspekt. Moscow: KomKniga

Lake, D. (2007): Escape from the State of Nature: Authority and Hierarchy in World Politics. International Security 32(1)

Landry, P. F. (2004): Adaptive Authoritarianism in Asia: Decentralization, Regulation, and Promotion. Mimeo

Lavrov, A. (2004, ed.): Evroaziatskoe Budzhetnoe Prostranstvo: Vyzovy Integracii. Moscow: Editorial URSS

Leipold, H. (1997) “Der Zusammenhang zwischen dem Entstehen und dem Wettbewerb von Ordnungen.“ In: von Delhaes K., Fehl U. (Hrsg.) Dimensionen des Wettbewerbs. Stuttgart: Lucius&Lucius Verlag.

Leschenko, N., and M. Troschke (2006): Fiscal Decentralization in Centralized States: The Case of Central Asia. Osteuropa-Institut Munich Working Paper No. 261

Libman, A. (2007): Institutional Competition in the Post-Soviet Space. MPRA Paper No. 10936

Libman, A. (2007a): Politicheskaya Logika Formirovaniya Ekonomicheskikh Institutov v Rossii. In: Ryabov, A., and M. Lipman (eds.): Puti Rossiiskogo Postkommunizma. Moscow: R. Elinin

Libman, A., and B. Kheyfets (2006): Ekspansiya Rossiiskogo Kapitala v Strany SNG. Moscow: Ekonomika

Libman, A., and L.P. Feld (2008): Strategic Tax Collection and Fiscal Decentralization: The Case of Russia. Mimeo

Litwack, J.M. (2002): Central Control of Regional Budgets: Theory with Applications to Russia. Journal of Comparative Economics 30

Mansfield, E.D., Milner, H.V., and B.P. Rosendorff (2002): Why Democracies Cooperate More: Electoral Control and International Trade Agreements. International Organization 56(3)

McMann, K.M. (2006): Economic Autonomy and Democracy: Hybrid Regimes in Russia and Kyrgyzstan. Cambridge University Press

Meager, K. (1997): Informal Integration or Economic Subversion? Parallel Trade in West Africa. In: Regional Integration and Cooperation in West Africa: A Multidimensional Perspective. Ottawa: IDRC

Melvin, N.J. (2001): Patterns of Centre-Regional Relations in Central Asia: The Cases of Kazakhstan, the Kyrgyz Republic, and Uzbekistan. Regional and Federal Studies 11(3)

Mogilevsky, R. (2004): Role of Multilateral and Regional Trade Disciplines: Kyrgyzstan’s Experience. CASE Studies and Analyses No. 278

Mummert, A. and Mummert, U. (2000). “Institutioneller Wettbewerb in Entwicklungsländern im institutionellen Wettbewerb.” Max-Planck Institut zur Erforschung von Wirtschaftssystemen Diskussionsbeitrag No. 03-00.

Nasledie Evrazii (2007): Russkiy Yazyk v Novykh Nezavisimykh Gosudarstvakh. Moscow

Noori, N. (2006): Delegating Coercion: Linking Decentralization to State Formation in Uzbekistan. PhD Dissertation, Columbia University

Ogilvie, S. (2007): “Whatever Is, Is Right?” Economic Institutions in Pre-Industrial Europe. CESifo Working Paper No. 2066

Olcott, M.B. (2005): Vtoroi Shans Central’noi Azii. Moscow, Wash.: Carnegie Center

Olcott, M.B., and A. Malashenko (eds., 2000): Mnogomernye Granitsy Central’noi Azii. Moscow: Carnegie Center

Olimov, M., and S. Olimova (2001): Etnicheskiy Faktor i Mestnoe Samoupravlenie v Tadzhikistane. In: Tishkov, V. (ed.): Mestnoe Upravlenie Mnogoetnichnymi Soobshestvami v Stranakh SNG. Moscow

Olimova, S., Kurbonov, S., Petrov, G., and Z. Kahhorova (2006): Regional Cooperation in Central Asia: A View from Tajikistan. Problems of Economic Transition 48(9)

Paarmann, B. (2007): Evolving Centre-Periphery Relations in Transition Countries: The Case of Kazakhstan. MPhil Dissertation, University of Cambridge

Paneyakh, E. (2008): Ekonomika i Gosudarstvo: Podhody Social’nykh Nauk. Mimeo

Peng, D. (2000): Ethnic Business Networks and the Asia-Pacific Economic Integration. African and Asian Studies 35(2)

Rafi Khan, S., Shaheen, F.H., Yusuf, M., and A. Tanveer (2007): Regional Integration, Trade and Conflict in South Asia. IISD Working Paper

Sadovskaya, E. (2006): Mezhdunarodnaya Trudovaya Migraciya i Denezhnye Perevody v Respublikakh Central’noi Azii: Strategiya Vyzhyvaniya ili Strategiya Razvitiya? In: Iontsev, V.A. (ed.): Mezhdunarodnya Migraciya: Ekonomika i Politika. Moscow: TEIS

Sasse, G. (2002): The “New” Ukraine: A State of Regions. Regional and Federal Studies 11(3)

Schneider, F. (2007): Shadow Economies and Corruption all over the World: New Estimates for 145 Countries. Mimeo

Sheng, Y. (2007): Global Market Integration and Central Political Control: Foreign Trade and Intergovernmental Relations in China. Comparative Political Studies 40(4)

Solnick, S.L. (2002): Federalism and State-Building: Post-Communist and Post-Colonial Perspectives. In: Reynolds, A. (ed.): The Architecture of Democracy: Constitutional Design, Conflict Management, and Democracy. Oxford University Press

Spechler, M.C. (2000): Regional Cooperation in Central Asia: Promises and More Promises. PRAXIS – The Fletcher Journal of Development Studies 16

Starr, S.F. (2006): Clans, Authoritarian Rulers, and Parliaments in Central Asia. Silk Road Paper, John Hopkins University

Taneja, N. (2001): Informal Trade in SAARC Region. Economic and Political Weekly, March 17

Taylor, N.Z. (2007): Political Decentralization and Technological Innovation: Testing the Innovative Advantages of Decentralized States. Review of Policy Research 24(3)

Thurston, A.F. (1998): Muddling Towards Democracy: Political Change in Grassroot China. U.S. Institute of Peace Peaceworks No. 23

Treisman, D.S. (2007): The Architecture of Government: Rethinking Political Decentralization. Cambridge University Press

Turovskiy, R. (1999): Sravnitel’nyi Analiz Tendencii Regional’nogo Razvitiia Rossii i Ukrainy. POLIS (6)

Tyuryukanova, E. (2005): Denezhnye perevody migrantov v rossiiskom kontekste. Pro et Contra, 9(1)

Ufer, H., and M. Troschke (2006): Fiskalische Dezentralisierung und regionale Disparitaeten in Kazachstan. Osteuropa-Institut Munich Working Paper No. 262

UNDP (2005): Uzbekistan – 2005 Human Development Report: Decentralization and Human Development. Tashkent

UNDP (2006): Regional Cooperation in Central Asia: A View from Kyrgyzstan. Problems of Economic Transition 48(8)

Vahtra, P. (2005), ‘Russian Investments in the CIS – Scope, Motivation and Leverage’, Manuscript of the Pan-European Institute, Turku School of Economics, no. 9

Vanberg, V. (2000). “Globalization, Democracy and Citizens' Sovereignty: Can Competition Among Governments Enhance Democracy?” Constitutional Political Economy, 11:87-112

Vaubel, R. (2008): A History of Thought on Institutional Competition, in: Bergh, A., and R. Höijer (eds.): Institutional Competition, Elgar: Cheltenham

Vinokurov, E. (2007): Financing Infrastructure in Central Asia: Water and Energy Nexus. World Finance Review, Spring

Vinokurov, E. (2007a): Sotrudnichestvo Atomno-Energeticheskikh Kompleksov Kazakhstana i Rossii: Est’ li Potencial Integracii? Mimeo

Way, L.A. (2002): The Dilemmas of Reform in Weak States: The Case of Post-Soviet Fiscal Decentralization. Political Theory 30(4)

Zhang, Y. (2006): Explaining the Sources of De Facto Federalism in Reform China: Intergovernmental Decentralization, Globalization, and Central-Local Relations. Japanese Journal of Political Science 7(2)