India's FDI Inflows: Trends and Concepts

K, S Chalapati Rao and Dhar, Biswajit (2011): India's FDI Inflows: Trends and Concepts.

Abstract

India’s inward investment regime went through a series of changes since economic reforms were ushered in two decades back. The expectation of the policy makers was that an “investor friendly” regime will help India establish itself as a preferred destination of foreign investors. These expectations remained largely unfulfilled despite the consistent attempts by the policy makers to increase the attractiveness of India by further changes in policies that included opening up of individual sectors, raising the hitherto existing caps on foreign holding and improving investment procedures. But after 2005‐06, official statistics started reporting steep increases in FDI inflows. This paper is an attempt to explain this divergence from the earlier trend. At the outset, the paper dwells on the ambiguities surrounding the definition and the non‐adherence of international norms in measuring the FDI inflows. The study finds that portfolio investors and round-tripping investments have been important contributors to India’s reported FDI inflows thus blurring the distinction between direct and portfolio investors on one hand and foreign and domestic investors on the other. These investors were also the ones which have exploited the tax haven route most. These observations acquire added significance in the context of the substantial fall in the inflows seen during 2010‐11. In most countries, particularly those that have faced chronic current account deficits, obtaining stable long term FDI flows was preferred over volatile portfolio investments. This distinction between long term FDI and the volatile portfolio investments has now been removed in the accepted official definition of FDI. From an analytical point of view, the blurring of the lines between long term FDI and the volatile portfolio investments has meant that the essential characteristics of FDI, especially the positive spill‐overs that the long term FDI was seen to result in, are being overlooked. FDI that is dominated by financial investments, though a little more stable than the portfolio investments through the stock market, cannot deliver the perceived advantages of FDI. The net result is that while much of the FDI cannot enhance India’s ability to earn foreign exchange through exports of goods and services and thus cover the current account gap on its own strength, large inflows of portfolio capital causes currency appreciation and erodes the competitiveness of domestic players. The falling share of manufacturing and even of IT and ITES means that there is less likelihood of FDI directly contributing to export earnings. India seems to have been caught in a trap wherein large inflows are regularly required in order to finance the current account deficit. To keep FDI flowing in, the investment regime has to be liberalised further and M&As are allowed freely.

Even at the global level, the developmental impact of FDI is being given lesser importance notwithstanding the repeated assertions to the contrary in some fora. International data on FDI and its impact has never been unambiguous. If FDI has to deliver, it has to be defined precisely and chosen with care instead of treating it as generic capital flow. India should strengthen its information base that will allow a proper assessment of the impact that FDI can make on its development aspirations.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: FDI; portfolio capital; foreign direct investment; round-tripping; India; benchmark definition; tax havens; private equity; manufacturing
• Subjects: P - Economic Systems > P3 - Socialist Institutions and Their Transitions > P33 - International Trade, Finance, Investment, Relations, and Aid; P - Economic Systems > P4 - Other Economic Systems > P45 - International Trade, Finance, Investment, and Aid; F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F21 - International Investment ; Long-Term Capital Movements; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G24 - Investment Banking ; Venture Capital ; Brokerage ; Ratings and Ratings Agencies

References

“2G scam: ED questions Unitech on fund transfers” at http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/2G-scam-ED-questions-Unitech-on-fund-transfers/articleshow/6940321.cms

“ADRs no substitute for FDI”, The Economic Times, January 31.

“Al-Murjan Exits Bilt”, http://www.financialexpress.com/news/almurjan-exits-bilt/105100/0

“Arms dealer wanted in India major funder of UK Liberal Democrats“, Times of India, May 6.

“ED traces key suspect's 2G money trail to Cyprus, Libya, Mauritius”, at http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/ED-traces-key-suspects-2G-money-trail-to-Cyprus-Libya-Mauritius/articleshow/7080911.cms.

“FIIs taking FDI route face 10% stake cap in local co” at http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/ articleshow/5814523.cms?prtpage=1

“Governance, inflation hit FDI flow”, at http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/Governance-inflation-hit-FDI-flow/articleshow/7428514.cms.

“Gypsy Rover Mystery Deepens” at http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/3830644.cms?prtpage=1.

“India attractive destination despite some slow down: Montek”, at http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics/ nation/india-attractive-fdi-destination-despite-some-slowdown-montek/articleshow/7385709.cms

“Indian mutual funds approach zero tax destinations to raise offshore capital” at http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/5582011.cms?prtpage=1 (last accessed on May 24, 2010).

“Leaks Reveal Cayman Black Money Trail”, Mail Today, January 19, 2011.

“Private Equity in India: An Executive Round Table” at http://content.spencerstuart.com/sswebsite/pdf/lib/PrivateEquityIndia_2007_web2.pdf (Accessed on May 18, 2010).

“Private Equity in India: An Executive Round Table” at http://content.spencerstuart.com/sswebsite/pdf/lib/PrivateEquityIndia_2007_web2.pdf

“Raids reveal Mittal-linked co got huge foreign inflows” at http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Raids-reveal-Mittal-linked-co-got-huge-foreign-inflows-/articleshow/6868740.cm

“RBI Asks Govt to ban automatic FDI in Real Estate“, http://www.indianrealtynews.com/fdi-india/rbi-asks-govt-to-ban-automatic-fdi-in-real-estate.html

“RBI confirms FDI data included PE inflows”Livemint.com, July 9.

“RBI raises alarm over FDI build-up in realty”, http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/ markets/real-estate/realty-trends/rbi-raises-alarm-over-fdi-build-up-in-realty/articleshow/1129254.cms

Bain & Company, India Private Equity Report 2010, available at http://www.bain.com/bainweb/PDFs/cms/Public/India_Private_Equity_Report.pdf

Bajpai, Nirupam and Jeffrey D. Sachs (2000), “Foreign Direct Investment in India: Issues and Problems”, Development Discussion Paper No. 759, Harvard Institute for International Development, March.

Bajpai, Nirupam and Nandita Dasgupta (2004), “What Constitutes Foreign Direct Investment? Comparison of India and China”, CGSD Working Paper No. 1, January, Working Papers Series, Center on Globalization and Sustainable Development, The Earth Institute at Columbia University.

Baker, Dean, Gerald Epstein and Robert Pollin (eds.) (1998), Globalization and Progressive Economic Policy, Cambridge University Press, pp. 97-116.

Balasubramanyam, V.N. and Vidya Mahambare (2002), “Foreign Direct Investment in India”, paper presented at a workshop on Foreign Direct Investment in Developing Countries held at the Lake District, September 13−14.

Blonigen, Bruce A. (2008), “Foreign Direct Investment”, in Steven N. Durlauf and Lawrence E. Blume (eds.), The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, Second Edition, pp. 459-462.

Buckley, Peter J. and Michael Z. Brooke (1992), International Business Studies: An Overview, Blackwell Publishers, Oxford, p. 249.

Business Standard Editorial (2011), “”The External Constraint”, http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/the-external-constraint/420434/

Carkovic, Marica and Ross Levine (2005), “Does Foreign Direct Investment Accelerate Economic Growth?” in Theodore H. Moran, Edward M. Graham and Magnus Blomstrom (eds.), Does Foreign Direct Investment Promote Development?, Centre for Global Development, Washington.

Chandrasekhar, C. P. (2007), Private Equity: A New Role for Finance?, Economic and Political Weekly, March 31,

Chandrasekhar, C. P. and Jayati Ghosh (2007), “Private Equity and India’s FDI Boom”, Business Line, May 1.

Chang, Ha-joon (1998), “Globalization, transnational corporations, and economic development: can the developing countries pursue strategic industrial policy in a globalizing world economy?”, in Dean Baker, Gerald Epstein and Robert Pollin (eds.), Globalization and Progressive Economic Policy, Cambridge University Press, pp. 97-116.

Choi, E. Kwan and James Harrigan (eds.) (2003), Handbook of International trade, Blackwell.

Cohen, Stephen D. (2007), Multinational Corporations and Foreign Direct Investment: Avoiding Simplicity, Embracing Complexity, Oxford University Press, p. 356.

Dhar, Biswajit (1988), “State Regulation of Foreign Private Capital in India”, Corporate Studies Group Working Paper.

Dhar, Biswajit (2010), “Uses and abuses of capital controls”, Mint, October 26.

Direct Investment Technical Expert Group (2004), DITEG Outcome Paper # 2 (Revised version), September 24.

Draft Press Note: “Regulatory Framework of FDI”, issued in December 2009 by the DIPP.

Dunning, John H. (1993), “Trade, location of economic activity and the multinational enterprise: a search for an eclectic approach”, in John Dunning (ed.), The Theory of Transnational Corporations, UN Library on Transnational Corporations, Volume I, Routledge, p. 185.

Dunning, John H. (ed.) (1993), The Theory of Transnational Corporations, UN Library on Transnational Corporations, Volume I, Routledge.

Durlauf, Steven N and Lawrence E. Blume (eds.) (2008), The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, Second Edition.

EMPEA Industry Statistics & PitchDeck available at http://www.empea.net/Main-Menu-Category/Resource-Library/EMPEA-Industry-Statistics-PitchDeck-1H-2010-ppt--Public.aspx

Ernst & Young (2008), “Private Equity in Numbers”, December, a joint publication with Outlook Business magazine.

European Commission (2002), “Concept Paper on the Definition of Investment” WT/WGTI/W/115, 16 April , available at http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2004/july/tradoc_111123.pdf

European Commission, Eurostat (2009), Foreign Affiliates Statistics (FATS) Recommendations Manual, Eurostat’s Methodologies & Working Papers, 2009 Edition, p. 14, available at http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/cache/ITY_OFFPUB/KS-AR-09-014/EN/KS-AR-09-014-EN.PDF.

Fredriksson, Torbjorn (2003), “Forty years of UNCTAD research on FDI”, Transnational Corporations, Volume 12, Number 3, December, pp. 1-39.

Goyal, S.K. et. al. (1995), Foreign Investment Approvals and Implementation Status: A Review (August 1991 – December 1994), Institute for Studies in Industrial Development, March.

Guha, Rajat (2011), “The FDI Trickle”, The Financial Express, January 2.

http://ahmedsk00.blogspot.com/2007/06/mncs-likely-to-delist-names-include-i.html

http://steelguru.com/news/index/Njg5Mjk%3D/ FIPB_approves_Hitech_Infra_investment_in_Krishnapatnam_Port%250D%250A.html (accessed last on May 21, 2010).

http://www.altassets.com/private-equity-glossary.html

http://www.dcmsme.gov.in/publications/reserveditems/reserved2010.pdf

http://www.rediff.com/money/2003/apr/12fdi.htm

Hymer, Stephen (1993), “On multinational corporations and foreign direct investment”, in John Dunning (ed.), The Theory of Transnational Corporations, UN Library on Transnational Corporations, Volume I, Routledge, p. 25.

IMF (1993), Balance of Payments Manual.

IMF (2005), India: Selected Issues, January 7, available at http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/cr0587.pdf.

IMF (2009), Balance of Payment and International Investment Position Manual, Sixth Edition, p. 101.

India, Authority for Advanced Rulings (2010), Authority for Advance Rulings (AAR) No.826 of 2009, dated March 22 2010 available at http://rulings.co.in/it-rulings/uploads/pdf/1269340941_etrade.pdf. DTAC stands for Double Tax Avoidance Convention.

India, Comptroller and Auditor General of India (2005), Report No. 13 of 2005, Direct Taxes. See the relevant chapter of the report available at http://saiindia.gov.in/cag/file/overview-310.

India, Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP), Consolidated FDI Policy (Effective from October 1, 2010) of the, available at http://www.dipp.nic.in/FDI_Circular/ FDI_Circular_02of2010.pdf.

India, Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion, Ministry of Commerce and Industry (2010), Consolidated FDI Policy (Effective from April 1, 2010) available at http://siadipp.nic.in/policy/fdi_circular/fdi_circular_1_2010.pdf.

India, Ministry of Commerce and Industry (2001), Handbook of Industrial Policy and Statistics.

India, Ministry of Finance (2009), Economic Survey 2008-09, para 133.

India, Ministry of Finance (2010), Report of the Working Group on Foreign Investment, 30 July, p. 71. (Chairman: U.K. Sinha)

India, Ministry of Finance (2010), Report of the Working Group on Foreign Investment, 30 July.

India, National Manufacturing Competitiveness Council (2006), The National Strategy for Manufacturing, 2006.

India, Planning Commission (2002), Report of the Steering Group on Foreign Direct Investment, August , p. 22

India, Securities and Exchange Board of India (2010), Report of the Takeover Regulations Advisory Committee, July 19, p. 29. (Chairman: C. Achutan)

Kavaljit Singh (2010), Fixing Global Finance, Madhyam, Delhi and SOMO, Amsterdam.

Lipsey, Robert E. (2003), “Foreign Direct Investment and the Operations of Multinational Firms: Concepts, History, and Data”, in E. Kwan Choi and James Harrigan (ed.), Handbook of International trade, Blackwell, pp. 287-319.

Lipsey, Robert E. (2005), “What do users of FDI data want to learn from them and do the data tell them the truth?”, paper presented at the UNCTAD Expert Meeting on Capacity Building in the Area of FDI: Data Compilation and Policy Formulation in Developing Countries, 12-14 December.

Mohan, T T Ram (2007), “Are FDI flows into India for real?”, The Economic Times, October 5.

Moran, Theodore H., Edward M. Graham and Magnus Blomstrom (eds.) (2005), Does Foreign Direct Investment Promote Development?, Centre for Global Development, Washington.

OECD (2008), Benchmark Definition of Foreign Direct Investment, Fourth Edition.

OECD Workshop on International Investment Statistics (2004), Draft Summary of the Meeting of the prepared by the OECD, October 12-13.

Ostry, Jonathan D. et. al. (2010), “Capital Inflows: The Role of Controls”, IMF Staff Position Note, February 19, 2010, SPN/ 10/04.

Rajan Thillai A and Ashish Deshmukh (2009), On Top of the World; Still Miles to Soar, India Venture Capital and Private Equity Report, Indian Institute of Technology Madras.

Rajan, Thillai A. (2010), “A Life-Cycle Analysis of VC-PE Investments in India”, The Journal of Private Equity, Winter, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 72-82.

Rajan, Thillai A. and Vishal Kamat (2010), “India Venture Capital and Private Equity Report 2010: Contours of Smart Capital”, Indian Institute of Technology, Madras,

Rao, K.S. Chalapati and Biswajit Dhar (2010), “Operation of FDI Caps in India and Corporate Control Mechanisms”, ISID Working paper WP2010/11 available at http://isid.org.in/pdf/WP1011.PDF.

Rao, K.S. Chalapati and M.R. Murthy (2010), “Location of FDI in India: A Discussion of Some Less Explored Aspects”, paper presented in the international seminar The Globalization of Production Models and Innovation in Emerging Economies: Comparative Research on Subnational Industrial Policies, held at the Institute for Studies in Industrial Development, New Delhi, during November 19–20, 2010.

RBI (1957), Report on the Survey of India’s Foreign Liabilities and Assets as on 31st December 1955, p. 10.

RBI (1999), “Finances of Foreign Direct Investment Companies, 1993-94”, RBI Monthly Bulletin, March, p. 245.

RBI (2011), Macroeconomic and Monetary Developments: Third Quarter Review, 2010-11 Chapter III on “The External Economy”, at http://rbidocs.rbi.org.in/rdocs/Publications/PDFs/ 04MD240111F.pdf

Reply to Lok Sabha Starred Question No. 64 dated February 21, 2003.

Rugraff, Eric, Diego Sánchez-Ancochea, Andy Sumner (eds.) (2009), Transnational Corporations and Development Policy: Critical Perspectives, Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 305-306.

Schaffer Richard, Beverley Earle and Filiberto Agusti (1999), International Business Law and Its Environment, 4th Edition, West Educational Publishing Co, Cincinnati, p. 581.

Tandon, Yash, “FDI, globalization, UNCTAD and human development”, available at http://www.twnside.org.sg/title/fdi.htm.

Tata Engineering & Locomotive Co. Ltd (1980), Prospectus dated14th August 1980.

UNCTAD (1997), World Investment Report, Chapter III (Foreign Portfolio Equity Investment).

UNCTAD (2005), World Investment Report.

UNCTAD (2006), World Investment Report.

UNCTAD (2010), World Investment Report.

UNCTAD (2011), “Global and Regional FDI Trends in 2010”, Global Investment Trends Monitor, No. 5, January 17, available at http://unctad.org/en/docs/webdiaeia20111_en.pdf.

VST Tillers Tractors Ltd (2009), Memorandum and Articles of Association of filed on November 10 with the MCA.

Wei, Wenhui (2005), “China and India: Any difference in their FDI performances?”Journal of Asian Economics, 16, pp. 719–736.

Wei, Yingqi and V. N. Balasubramanyam (2004), Foreign Direct Investment: Six Country Case Studies, Edward Elgar Publishing.

World Bank (2009), Global Development Finance, Charting a Global Recovery, I: Review, Analysis, and Outlook, p. 3.

Xiao, Geng (2004), “People’s Republic of China’s Round-Tripping FDI: Scale, Causes and Implications”, July, available at www.hiebs.hku.hk/working_paper_updates/pdf/wp1137.pdf.

Zhan, Jimmy J. (2006), “FDI Statistics: A Critical Review and Policy Implications”, paper prepared for the World Association of Investment Promotion Agencies (WAIPA), Geneva, October.