Nexus between aid and security: the case of Pakistan

Ahmed, Vaqar and Wahab Siddiqui, Abdul (2010): Nexus between aid and security: the case of Pakistan.

Abstract

Pakistan being a frontline state in the war against terrorism has also remained one of the highest recipients of foreign aid. This paper analyses foreign assistance through four main facets namely: the link between aid, security and growth with special reference to Pakistan, general equilibrium impact of foreign resource inflow on economic growth and poverty, aid effectiveness in Pakistan, and priorities for aid policy reform in the country. The empirical literature on the impact of aid on economic development in Pakistan is inconclusive due to aid being fragmented and volatile. The donors have remained poorly coordinated with a weak follow up mechanism. Pakistan for its part has seen mixed experiences in aid absorption. While a decade long nation-wide social action program could not translate into improved social and welfare indicators, there are some success stories such as: rural support networks, microfinance opportunities, cluster approach for earthquake relief and recovery. While the economic implications of prolonged reliance on aid indicate Dutch disease effects at the macroeconomic level in Pakistan, there are more concerning effects at that micro level where society has started to perceive aid as a compensation (and not assistance) for Pakistan’s involvement in wars led by developed nations. This behaviour besides corrupting the elite also promotes rent seeking where agents gaining from war have a vested interest in keep the conflict intensified. Pakistan along with its development partners has taken measures to move towards the directions indicated in Paris Declaration. The EAD is in the process of finalizing Foreign Assistance Policy Framework which is governed by principles that ensure compatibility and convergence of aid with national plans and improve quality, effectiveness and efficiency of foreign assistance. Having a national aid policy is all the more important at this stage when Pakistan is in the process of seeking assistance from the FoDP consortium and Kerry – Lugar arrangement with US. The improved mechanism should include appropriate amendments based upon the lessons learnt from past experiences. Finally as the reconstruction work takes off in the war-torn areas, there will be increased need for regular quantitative and qualitative analytical work by both government and donors. The research dissemination should then translate in to a process of effective dialogue between all stakeholders.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Aid, Pakistan, Economic Growth
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance > F35 - Foreign Aid

References

Adams R. H. (1995), “Sources of Income Inequality and Poverty in Rural Pakistan”. Research Report 102, IFPRI, Washington D.C.

Ahmed, Viqar and Rashid Amjad (1984) The Management of Pakistan’s Economy 1947 – 82. Oxford University Press.

Ahmed, Vaqar and Cathal O’ Donoghue (2010) Global Economic Crisis and Poverty in Pakistan. International Journal of Microsimulation. (2010) 3(1) 127-129.

Ahmed, Vaqar and Cathal O’ Donoghue (2010b) Tariff Reduction in a Small Open Economy. Seoul Journal of Economics. Volume 23, Number 2 (Summer 2010).

Ahmed, Vaqar and Cathal O’ Donoghue (2010c) Welfare Impact of External Balance in Pakistan: CGE – microsimulation analysis. The Lahore Journal of Economics, 15 : 1 (Summer 2010): pp. 45-90.

Alavi, H. and A. Khusro (1970) Pakistan: The Burden of US Aid, in Imperialism and Under-development – A Reader, edited by R. I. Rhodes, Monthly Review Press, 1970, pp. 65 – 6.

Alesina, A. and B. Weder (1999) Do Corrupt Governments Receive Less Foreign Aid? NBER Working Paper Series, Working Paper 7108, May 1999.

Ashraf, S. (2009) The Kerry – Lugar Bill: Difficult Choices for Pakistan. Institute of South Asian Studies (ISAS) brief No. 131 – Date: 5 October 2009. National University of Singapore.

Baqai, M. The Role of Foreign Aid in Pakistan’s Economic Planning. In eds. M. Baqai and I. Brecher: Development Planning and Policy in Pakistan. National Institute of Social and Economic Research. Karachi, Pakistan.

Boyce, J. K. (2002) Aid Conditionality as a Tool for Peacebuilding: Opportunities and Constraints. Development and Change 33(5): 1025-1048 (2002).

Brecher, I. and S.A. Abbas (1972) Foreign Aid and Industrial Development in Pakistan. Cambridge University Press.

Burnside, Craig and David Dollar. (2000) “Aid, Policies, and Growth.” American Economic Review. September, 90:4, pp. 847–68.

Carment, D., Y. Samy, and S. Prest (2008) State Fragility and Implications for Aid Allocation: An Empirical Analysis. Conflict Management and Peace Science, 25:349–373, 2008.

Chong A., Gradstein M., Calderon C. (2009), “Can foreign aid reduce income inequality and poverty?” Springer Science & Business Media Vol: 140: pp 59–84

Chowdhury and Garonna (2007) “Effective Foreign Aid, Economic Integration and Subsidiarity : Lessons From Europe” Discussion paper United Nations Economic Commission For Europe, Geneva, Switzerland No. 2007.2

DAC (2008) Service Delivery in Fragile Situations. OECD Journal On Development 2008, Vol. 9/3 OECD 2009.

DAC (2008b) Concepts and Dilemmas of State Building in Fragile Situations. OECD Journal On Development 2008, Vol. 9/3 OECD 2009.

Ehrenfeld, D., S. Y. Kogut, H. Hove (2003) Aid Conditionality and the Peace Process: An Analysis of its Implementation. International Journal of World Peace. Vol. XX No. 4 December 2003.

Easterly, William, Ross Levine and David Roodman. (2003) “New Data, New Doubts: A Comment on Burnside and Dollar’s ‘Aid, Policies, and Growth’ (2000).” American Economic Review. Forthcoming.

Easterly, William (2003), “Can Aid Buy Growth?” Journal of economic perspective- Vol. 17, No. 3-pp. 23-48.

Faisal Cheema (2004), “Macroeconomic Stability of Pakistan: The Role of the IMF and World Bank (1997–2003)” ACDIS Occasional Paper ACDIS CHE:1.2004

Guillaume De Spoelberch and Robert D’ Arcy Shaw (1987) A model: The Aga Khan Rural Support Program. Interview published in Challenge – January 1987.

Goodhand, J., and M. Sedra (2007) Bribes or Bargains? Peace Conditionalities and ‘Post-Conflict’ Reconstruction in Afghanistan. International Peacekeeping, Vol.14, No.1, January 2007, pp.41–61.

Hamid, N. (1970) A Critical Appraisal of Foreign Aid Strategy. Pakistan Economic and Social Review. Vol. VIII, No. 2, December 1970, pp. 149 – 51.

Hansen, Ketil Fred and Axel Borchgrevink (2006) The European Journal of Development Research, Vol.18, No.4, December 2006, pp.622–641.

Husain, I. (2002) “Pakistan and the IMF: 1988-2002” A case study. State Bank of Pakistan.

Husain, Ishrat (1992) External Debt and Foreign Aid to Pakistan. In editor: Anjum Nasim, Financing Pakistan’s Development in the 1990s. OUP and LUMS.

Ishfaq M. (2004) “Aid effectiveness debt capacity and debt management in Pakistan” Department of Economics, PHD thesis

Ibrahim, A. (2010) United States Aid to Pakistan: United States Taxpayers have Funded Pakistani Corruption. The DISAM Journal, March 2010.

ILO (1996) “Wage Workers in Agriculture: Conditions of Employment and Work”. International Labour Office, Geneva, 1996.

Iqbal Z. (1997) “Foreign Aid and the Public Sector: A Model of Fiscal Behaviour in Pakistan” The Pakistan Development Review, 36: 2 (Summer 1997) pp. 115—129

Jones, S. G. (2007) Pakistan’s Dangerous Game. Survival, 49:1(2007), p.20 Nawaz, S. (2010) A Formula to Fix America's Pakistan Policy. The Wall Street Journal. June 29, 2010.

Keefer, Philip E., Ambar Narayan and Tara Vishwanath (2005) Decentralization in Pakistan: Are Local Politicians Likely to be More Accountable? http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTINVTCLI/Resources/decentralizationinPakistan.pdf

Kfir, I. (2009) U.S. Policy Toward Pakistan And Afghanistan Under The Obama Administration. Middle East Review of International Affairs, Vol. 13, No. 4 (December 2009).

Kole, J.W. (1971) House Votes to Knockout Aid for Pakistan, Greece. The Milwaukee Journal. 4th August 1971.

Khan S. Rafi (1997), “Has Aid Helped Pakistan” Pakistan Development Review. 36:4 Part II pp. 947-957

Khan N. Z., and Rahim E. (1993) “Foreign Aid, Domestic Saving and Economic Growth, 1960–1988”. The Pakistan Development Review 32:4 1157–1167.

Khan and Ahmed (2007) “Foreign Aid—Blessing or Curse: Evidence from Pakistan” Pakistan development review Vol. 46 No. 3 PP 215-240

Muhammad, S. D. (2010) Microfinance Challenges and Opportunities in Pakistan. European Journal of Social Sciences – Volume 14, Number 1 (2010).

Masud, N. and Yontcheva .B (2005), “Does Foreign Aid reduce Poverty? Empirical Evidence from Nongovernmental and Bilateral Aid” IMF Working paper C25, F35

OECD (2007) “The Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness and the Accra Agenda for Action”. OECD

Pack H., and Pack J. Rothenberg (1993) “Foreign Aid and the Question of Fungibility” The Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 75, No. 2), pp. 258-265

Pasha, H. A. and A.F. Aisha Ghaus (1996) “Sustainability of Public Debt in Pakistan” Sustainable Policy Development Center(SPDC), Conference Paper No.21.

Paris, J. (2010) Prospects for Pakistan. LEGATUM Institute. January 2010.

Padawangi, Rita (2010) Community-driven development as a driver of change: water supply and sanitation projects in rural Punjab, Pakistan. Water Policy 12 Supplement 1 (2010) 104-120.

Pakistan poverty reduction strategy paper II (PRSP-II), Ministry of Finance.

Rodriguez, McGillivray and Morrissey (1998) “Aid and the Public Sector in Pakistan: Evidence with Endogenous Aid” World Development, July 1998, v. 26, iss. 7, pp. 1241-50

Shah, I. A. (2009) People's Participation in Rural Development Projects in the North-West Frontier Province of Pakistan: A Comparative Review and Analysis of Sarhad Rural Support Programme (SRSP) and Integrated Rural Development Project (IRDP). African and Asian Studies 8 (2009) 175-184.

Svensson, J. (2000) Foreign aid and rent-seeking. Journal of International Economics 51 (2000) 437–461.

Suhrke, A. and J. Buckmaster (2005) Post-war aid: patterns and purposes. Development in Practice, Volume 15, Number 6, November 2005.

Vos, R. (1998) Aid Flows and “Dutch Disease” in a General Equilibrium Framework for Pakistan. Journal of Policy Modeling, Volume 20, Issue 1, February 1998, Pages 77-109.