Economic crisis and taxation in Europe

Luigi, Bernardi (2011): Economic crisis and taxation in Europe. Forthcoming in: Rivista di diritto finanziario e scienza delle finanze No. 2011/2

Abstract

The recent economic crisis and taxation in the advanced countries - especially in the European nations - are linked in several ways. The tax systems may have exacerbated the crisis, and this raises the question of the need for a better system of taxation in certain economic sectors, especially in the banking sector. It is worthwhile examining the various different effects of the crisis on different kinds of tax revenue, as a result of both the automatic stabilizers and the discretional measures which were adopted to sustain the economies. We are going to show that while the former have had a relatively substantial impact, the latter have been of negligible effect. The paper initially offers a critical overview of the just mentioned topics. The European countries are now faced with a difficult trade - off between further tax reductions to sustain economic recovery, and the raising of taxes in order to help stabilize public budgets and debts. Broadly speaking, the most suggested solution consists in the idea of raising taxes whilst making them more growth - friendly. With this in mind, the paper then reconsiders and compares the latest, authoritative proposals for tax reform which in recent years have been proposed not only by international economic organizations, but also by studies in the field. The longstanding principles of broadening the tax base, reducing rates and simplifying the tax system still appear to be at the order of the day. The idea of shifting the tax burden away from labour and capital, whilst increasing taxes on consumption, properties and environmental resources, has also received large support. It is again suggested that efficiency - induced neutrality should characterize the design of the main taxes. While those political factors that have impeded reforms in recent years are still at work, we should remember that tax systems also have other targets than that of favouring neutrality - efficiency, and that in some countries (including Italy) the most urgent, radical reform required is the downsizing of an abnormal level of tax evasion.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Economic Crisis, Taxation, Europe
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H20 - General; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H25 - Business Taxes and Subsidies; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H24 - Personal Income and Other Nonbusiness Taxes and Subsidies

References

AGELL, J., SOERENSEN, P.B. (EDS), 2006, Tax Policy and Labour Market Performance, Cambridge, Mass.: The MIT Press.

ALESINA, A. AND ARDAGNA, S., 2009, Large changes in fiscal policy: Taxes versus spending, paper presented at the Tax Policy and the Economy Conference.

ARNOLD, J., 2008, Do tax structures affect aggregate economic growth? Empirical evidence from a panel of OECD countries, Economic Department WP No 643, Paris: The OECD.

BALDACCI, E. ET AL., 2010, Restoring debt sustainability after crises: implications for the fiscal mix, IMF WP/10/232, Washington, DC: The IMF.

BEBCHUK, J. ET AL., 2010, The wages of failure, Harvard: J.M. Centre for Law, Economics and Business, DP No 641.

BECK, T. AND DEMITGUK-KUNT, A., 2009, Financial institutions and markets across countries and over time, World Bank Policy Research WP No 4943, May.

BERNARDI, L., 2004, “Rationale and Open Issues for More Radical Reforms”, BERNARDI, L. and P. PROFETA (EDS), 2004: 30-54.

BERNARDI, L., 2009, “Le tasse in Europa dagli anni novanta”, Economia Italiana, 3: 769-808.

BERNARDI, L. AND PROFETA, P., (EDS), 2004, Tax Systems and Tax Reforms in Europe, London & New York: Routledge.

BETTENDORF, L., ET AL, 2010, “Corporate tax consolidation and enhanced cooperation in the European Union”, Fiscal Studies, 31 (4): 453-479.

CARONE, G. ET AL., 2004, Indicators of unemployment and low-wage traps: Marginal effective tax rates on employment income, OECD Social Employment and Migration WP No 18, Paris: The OECD.

CERIANI, V., 2009, The tax system and the financial crisis, mimeo.

COPENHAGEN ECONOMICS, 2007, Study on Reduced Vat to Goods and Services in the Member States of the European Union, TAXUD WP No 6503, Brussels: The European Commission.

CORREIA, I., 2010, “Consumption taxes and redistribution”, American Economic Review, 100 (4): 1673-1694.

CREEDY, J. AND GEMMEL, N., 2010, Modelling corporate tax revenue, Cheltenham & Northampton: Edward Elgar.

DARBY, J. AND MELITZ, J., 2007, Labour market adjustment, social spending and the automatic stabilizer in the OECD, DP No 6230, London: CEPR.

DE MOJI, R.A. AND DEVEREUX, M.P., 2009, Alternative Systems of Business Tax in Europe: An applied Analysis of ACE and CBIT Reforms, TAXUD WP No 12247, Brussels: The EU Commission.

DEVEREUX, M.P., AND FUEST, A., 2009, “Is the corporate tax an effective automatic stabilizer?”, National Tax Journal, 62: 429-37.

DEVEREUX, M.P. AND LORETZ, S., 2008, Increased Efficiency trough Consolidation and Formula Apportionment in the European Union?, Oxford: University Centre for Business taxation.

DOLLS, M. ET AL., 2010, Automatic stabilizers and economic crisis: US vs. Europe, NBER WP No 16275.

EDDINS, S., 2009, Tax arbitrage feedback theory, SSRN Paper, ID=1356159.

EU COMMISSION, 2010a, Taxation Trends in the European Union. 2010 Edition, Brussels: The EU Commission.

EU COMMISSION, 2010b, “Monitoring Tax Revenues and Tax Reforms in Member States 2010. Tax Policy after the crisis”, European Economy, 6/2010.

EU COMMISSION, 2010c, Government Finance Statistics. Summary Tables - 2/2010, Brussels: The EU Commission.

EU COMMISSION, 2010d, “Public finances in EMU 2010”, European Economy, 4/10, Brussels: The European Commission.

FUEST, A. ET AL., 2008, “Is a Flat Tax Reform Feasible in a Grown-up Democracy of Western Europe?”, International Tax and Public Finance, 15: 620-636.

GENSER, B. AND REUTTER, A., 2007, “Moving toward dual income taxation in Europe”, FinanzArchiv, 63 (3): 436-456

GIROUARD, N. AND ANDRE’, C., 2005, Measuring cyclically adjusted budget balances for European countries, Economic Department WP No 434, Paris: The OECD.

HAU, H., 2006, “The role of transactions costs for financial volatility”, Journal of European Economic Association, 4 (4): 862-890.

HEADY, C. ET AL., 2009, Tax policy for economic recovery and growth, University of Kent, School of economics DP No 0925.

HEMMELGAN, T. AND NICODEME, G., 2010, The 2008 financial crisis and taxation policy, EU Commission Taxation Papers, WP No. 20-2010, Brussels: The EU Commission.

HUINZAGA, H., 2002, “Financial services VAT”, Economic Policy, 17: 499-534.

HUINZAGA, H. ET AL., 2008, “Capital structure and international debt shifting”, Journal of Financial Economics, 88(1): 80-118.

IFS - Institute for Fiscal Studies, 2010, The Mirrless Review. Reforming the tax system for the 21st century, http://www.ifs.org.uk/mirrleesReview, forthcoming at Oxford University Press.

IMF, 2009, Debt bias and other distortions: Crisis related issues in tax policy, Washington, DC: The IMF.

IMF, 2010, A fair and substantial contribution by the financial sector, Final report for the G-20, June, Washington, DC: the IMF.

JENSEN, T.S., 2008, Effects of flat tax reforms on economic growth in the OECD countries, Bergen: Norges Handelshoskole,

JOHANSSON, A. ET AL., 2008, Taxation and Economic Growth, Economic Department WP No 620, Paris: The OECD.

KAPLOW, L. 2011, The theory of taxation and public economics, 2nd pbk ed., Princeton & Oxford: Princeton University Press.

KEEN, M., ET AL., 2008, “The Flat tax(es): Principles and Experiences”, International Tax and Public Finance, 6: 712-751.

KEEN, M., KLEMM, A AND PERRY, V., 2010, “Tax and the crisis”, Fiscal Studies, 31 (1): 43-79.

MATHESON, T., 2011, Taxing financial transactions: Issues and evidence, IMF WP/11/54, Washington, DC, The IMF.

MONTI, M., 2010, A new strategy for the single market, Report to the President of the European Commission J.M. Barroso, May 9th.

MYLES, G.D., 2009, Economic growth and the role of taxation, OECD Economic Department WP No 714, Paris: The OECD.

OECD, 2009, Taxing Wages, 2008-2009, Paris: The OECD.

OECD, 2010a, Revenue Statistics, 1965-2009, Paris: The OECD.

OECD, 2010b, Tax Policy Reform and Economic Growth, Paris: The OECD.

OECD, 2010c, OECD Tax Database, Paris: The OECD.

PEROTTI, R., 2011, The effects of tax shocks on output: not so large but not small either, CEPR discussion paper, No 8252, www.cepr.org/pubs/dps/DP8252.asp.

PODDAR, S. AND ENGLISH, M., 1997, “Taxation of financials services under a Value-Added tax: Applying the Cash-flow method”, National Tax Journal, 50: 89-111.

PROFETA. P., 2004, “Public finance and political economy in tax design and reforms”, in BERNARDI, L. and P. PROFETA (EDS), 2004: 55-75.

ROEGER, W. AND ‘T VELD, J., 2010, “Fiscal stimulus and exit strategy in the EU: A model - based analysis”, European Economy Economic Papers No. 426, September.

1978, “A proposal for international monetary reform”, Eastern Economic Journal, 3-4: 153-159.

VAN DEN NOORD, P. AND HEADY, C., 2001, Surveillance of Tax Policies: A Synthesis of Findings in Economic Surveys, OECD W.P. ECO/WKP(2001)29, Paris: The OECD.

VAN DEN NOORD, P: 2005, “ Tax incentives and house prices volatility in the Euro area: Theory and evidence”, Economie Internationale, 101: 28-45.

VEERMEND, W. ET AL., 2009, Taxes and the economy, pbk ed, Cheltenham & Northampton, Edward Elgar.

ZAGLER, M. (ED), 2010, International tax coordination. An interdisciplinary perspective on virtues and pitfalls, London & New York: Routledge.