A Note on Within-group Cooperation and Between-group Interaction in the Private Provision of Public Goods

Hattori, Keisuke (2011): A Note on Within-group Cooperation and Between-group Interaction in the Private Provision of Public Goods.

Abstract

Using a simple two-group model of the private provision of public goods, this paper investigates how endogenous formation of within-group cooperation is affected by different types and degrees of between-group interactions. We show that when between-group interactions are of the same directions and weak (strong), within-group cooperation for providing public goods will (will not) occur in each group for strategic reasons. On the other hand, when between-group interactions are of the opposite directions or unidirectional, within-group cooperation will necessarily occur. In addition, endogenous formation of cooperation is independent of absolute (individual) levels of income as well as income distribution between agents, which corresponds to an extended version of Warr's neutrality theorem. We also show whether endogenous formation of within-group cooperation is beneficial or harmful to each group crucially depends on the degree of between-group interactions. The variation in the interaction degree leads to three different types of games concerning welfare consequences: the Prisoners' Dilemma, Coordination Game, and Invisible Hand.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Private provision; Public goods; Cooperation
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H4 - Publicly Provided Goods > H41 - Public Goods; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C7 - Game Theory and Bargaining Theory > C72 - Noncooperative Games

References

Baik, K.H., Lee, S., (2000) Two-Stage Rent-Seeking Contests with Carryovers, Public Choice 103, 285-296.

Baik, K.H., (2008) Contests with Group-specific Public-good Prizes, Social Choice and Welfare 30, 103-117.

Barrett, S., (2007) Why to Cooperate. The Incentive to Supply Global Public Goods, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Bergstrom, T., Blume, L., Varian, V., (1986) On the Private Provision of Public Good, Journal of Public Economics 35, 53-73.

Bornstein, G., Ben-Yossef, M., (1994) Cooperation in Intergroup and Single-Group Social Dilemmas, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 30, 52-67.

Bornstein, G., Gneezy, U., Nagel, R., (2002) The Effect of Intergroup Competition on Group Coordination: An Experimental Study, Games and Economic Behavior 41, 1-25.

Bruce, N., (1990) Defense Expenditures by Countries in Allied and Adversarial Relationships, Defense Economics 1, 179-195.

Cheikbossian, G., (2008) Heterogenous Groups and Rent-seeking for Public Goods, European Journal of Political Economy 24, 133-150.

Cornes, R., Sandler, T., (1996) The Theory of Externalities, Public Goods, and Club Goods. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Ihori, T., (2001) Defense Expenditures and Allied Cooperation, Journal of Conflict Resolution 44, 854-867.

Harsanyi, J.C., Selten, R., (1988) A Game Theory of Equilibrium Selection in Games, Cambridge, MA, MIT Press.

Kitchen, D.M., Beehner J.C., (2007) Factors Affecting Individual Participation in Goup-level Aggression among Non-human Primates, Behaviour 144, 1551-1581.

Mascarenhas, R., Sandler, T., (2006) Do Donors Cooperatively Fund Foreign Aid?, Review of International Organization 1, 337-357.

Niou, E.M., Tan, G., (2005) External Threat and Collective Action, Economic Inquiry 43, 519-530.

Reuben, E., Tyran, J.R., (2010) Everyone is a Winner: Promoting Cooperation through All-can-win Intergroup Competition, European Journal of Political Economy 26, 25-35.

Salant, S.W., Switzer, S., Reynolds, R.J., (1983) Losses from Horizontal Merger: The Effects of an Exogenous Change in Industry Structure on Cournot-Nash Equilibrium, Quarterly Journal of Economics 98, 185-199.

Sandler, T., (1997) Global Challenges, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.

Sandler, T., Siqueira, K., (2006) Global Terrorism: Deterrence versus Pre-emption, Canadian Journal of Economics 39, 1370-1387.

Tan, J.H.W., Bolle, F., (2007) Team competition and the public goods game, Economics Letters 96, 133-139.

Torsvik, G., (2005) Foreign economic aid; should donors cooperate? Journal of Development Economics 77, 503-515.

Warr, P., (1983) The Private Provision of a Public Good is Independent of the Distribution of Income, Economics Letters 13, 207-211.