SACU tariff policies: Where should they go from here?

Edwards, Lawrence and Lawrence, Robert (2008): SACU tariff policies: Where should they go from here?

Abstract

This paper characterizes the current SACU tariff structure, considers its rationale, proposes and evaluates some alternatives and offers some suggestions for reforming the SACU revenue sharing formula and regional trade strategy. While considerable progress was made until recently in liberalizing and simplifying SACU’s tariff structure, over the past few years such movement appears to have halted. This is unfortunate because, as the paper demonstrates, the tariff structure remains excessively complex, and opaque, continues to taxes exports and provides sectors with very disparate amounts of protection. The differentiation appears mainly to be the result of historical accident and does not appear to be justifiable as efficient job preservation, equitable income distribution or on infant industry grounds. Several alternative tariff structures that use just one or two tariff bands are explored. We demonstrate that it is possible simultaneously to provide benefits to consumers, limit employment dislocation, confer a reasonable degree of effective protection, particularly on finished goods, reduce export taxes, improve transparency and provide a norm against which industrial policy priorities can be set. A major reform of SACU tariffs would also provide the opportunity to renegotiate the SACU revenue-sharing formula, more clearly and rationally separating its aid and tariff-revenue sharing components. The paper also advocates that SACU place primary reliance on free trade agreements rather than new customs unions in its dealing with other trading partners.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Trade policy; South African Customs Union; Liberalisation
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F15 - Economic Integration; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations

References

Anderson, James (1998). “Trade restrictiveness benchmarks”, The Economic Journal 108(449) 1111-1125.

Anderson, James and Peter Neary (1994). “Measuring the restrictiveness of trade policy”, World Bank Economic Review, 8, 151-169.

Arora, Vivek and Vamvakadis Athanasios(2005). “The Implications of South African Economic Growth for the Rest of Africa” South African Journal of Economics vol 73:2 June.

Bell, T. (1993). “Should South Africa Further Liberalise its Foreign Trade?” in M. Lipton and C. Simkins (eds.) State and Market in Post Apartheid South Africa, Witwatersrand University Press, Johannesburg.

Belli P, Finger M, Ballivian A. (1993). “South Africa: A review of trade policies. World Bank Informal Discussion Papers on Aspects of the South African Economy no. 4.” The World Bank Southern Africa Department: Washington DC.

Brenton, Flatters Frank and Kalenga (2005). “Rules of Origin. And SADC: The Case for Change in the Mid-Term Review of the Trade Protocol Africa Region Working Paper Series no 83, The World Bank, June

Buigut, Steven (2006). “Monetary Integration Initiatives in Eastern and Southern Africa (ESA): Sorting the Overlapping Membership” International Finance 9:3 2006, pp.295-315.

Corden, W M (1966). “The Structure of a Tariff System and the Effective Protection Rate”, Journal of Political Economy, 74(3): 221-237.

Daniels, Reza C and Lawrence Edwards (2007). “The Benefit-Incidence of Tariff Liberalisation in South Africa”, Journal for Studies in Economics and Econometrics, 31(2).

Draper, Peter, Durrel Halleson and Phillip Alves (2007). “A CU, Regional Integration and the Overlap Issue in Southern Africa: From Spaghetti to Canneloni?” Trade Policy Report No 15, South African Institute of International Affairs, January 2007.

Edwards, L. (2001). “Globalisation and the skill bias of occupational employment in South Africa”. South African Journal of Economics, 69,1: 40-71.

Edwards, L. and Van de Winkel, T. (2005). “The Market Disciplining Effects of Trade Liberalisation and Regional Import Penetration on Manufacturing in South Africa”. Trade and Industry Strategies Working Paper 1-2005.

Edwards, L. and Morris, M. (2007). “Undressing the Numbers: The Effect of Import Quotas on Clothing and Textile Employment”, Journal of Development Perspectives, 2,2: 121-140..

Edwards, S. and Lederman D. (2002) “The Political Economy of Unilateral Trade Liberalization: The case of Chile”, in J. Bhagwati (ed.) “Going Alone: The Case for Relaxed Reciprocity in Freeing Trade”, MIT Press.

Erasmus, Hennie, Frank Flatters and Robert Kirk, (2004). “Rules of Origin as Tools of Development? Some Lessons from SADC.” pdf available at http://qed.econ.queensu.ca/faculty/flatters/writings/ff&he&rmk_roo&dev_idb_final.pdf

Feenstra, Robert (1995). “Estimating the effects of trade policy”, in Gene Grossman and Kenneth Rogoff, eds., Handbook of International Economics, vol. 3, Elsevier, Amsterdam.

Fedderke, J. (2005). “Technology, Human Capital and Growth.” Mimeo.

Fedderke, J., Kularatne, C. and Mariotti, M., 2006. “Mark-up Pricing in South African Industry”, Journal of African Economies, 16, 1: 28-69.

Flatters, F. (2005). Rules of Origin and SADC: The Case for Change in the Mid Term Review of the Trade Protocol”, Africa Region Working Paper Series No.83 June 2005

Flatters, F. (2002) “From Import Substitution to Export Promotion: Driving the South African Motor Industry” http://qed.econ.queensu.ca/faculty/platters/main/writings.html.Queens University, Canada.

Flatters, Frank and Matthew Stern (2006). “SACU Revenue Sharing: Issues and Options”, Queens University, Pdf available at http://qed.econ.queensu.ca/faculty/flatters/writings/ff&ms_sacursf_2006.pdf

GATT (1994). Trade Policy Review: South Africa, General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, Geneva.

Gibb, Richard (2006). “Rationalization or Redundancy? Making Eastern & Southern Africa’s Regional Trade Units Relevant” Brenthurst Discussion Papers 3/2006.

Harding, Torfinn and Jørn Rattsø (2005). “The barrier model of productivity growth: South Africa,” Trade and Industry Policy Strategies Working Paper 5 – 2005.

Hausmann, Ricardo and Baily Klinger (2006). “Structural Transformation and Patterns of Comparative Advantage in Product Space” Working Paper No 128. Center for International Development, John F Kennedy School,

Hausmann, Ricardo, Hwang, Jason and Dani Rodrik (2005). “What You Export Matters” Cambridge: NBER Working Paper No. W11905 December

Hiau Looi Kee, Alessandro Nicita, Marcelo Olarreaga (2006). “Estimating Trade Restrictiveness Indices.” World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3840, February 2006

Hiau Looi Kee, Alessandro Nicita, Marcelo Olarreaga (2004). “Import Demand Elasticities and Trade Distortions”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3452

Holden, M. and Casale, D. (2002). “Endogenous Protection in a Trade Liberalizing Economy: The Case of South Africa”, Contemporary Economic Policy, 20(4): 479 – 489.

Jakobeit Cord et. al. “SADC/EAC/Comesa and EPA Negotiations: Trade Policy Options to Overcome the Problem of Multiple Memberships: Political, Legal Economic Perspective

Jonsson, Gunnar and Arvind Subramanian, A (2001). “Dynamic gains from trade: Evidence from SA,” IMF Staff Papers, 48, 1: 197-224.

Kaplan, D. (2003). “Manufacturing Performance and Policy in South - A Review”. Paper Prepared for the TIPS/DPRU Forum 2003.

Lall, Sanjaya, with Erika Kraemer-Mbula (2005). “Is African Industry Competing?” Queen Elizabeth House Working Paper Series QEHWPS122 Working Paper Number 121 January

Panagariya, Arvind and Dani Rodrik (1991). “Political-Economy Arguments for A Uniform Tariff” International Economic Review, August 1993.

Rodrik, Dani (2006). “What’s so Special about China’s Exports?” Cambridge: NBER Working Paper No. 11947

Siphambe, Happy Kufigwa (2004). “Botswana’s economy and labour market: are there any lessons for SADC regional integration?” Development South Africa, volume 21, no 2, June 2004.

S.M. Shafaeddin (2005). Trade Liberalization and Economic Reform in Developing Countries: Structural Change or De-Industrialization UNTAD Discussion Paper No 179 April 2005

World Bank Independent Evaluation Group (2006). “Assessing World Bank Support for Trade: 1987-2004” Washington DC: World Bank