Health insurance and precautionary saving: a structural analysis

Hsu, Minchung (2011): Health insurance and precautionary saving: a structural analysis.

Abstract

Starr-McCluer (1996) documented an empirical finding that the US households covered by health insurance saved more than those without coverage, which is inconsistent with the standard consumption-saving theory. This study provides a structural analysis and suggests that institutional factors, in particular, a social insurance (safety net) system and an employment-based health insurance system, can account for this puzzling finding. A dynamic stochastic general equilibrium model is built that incorporates these two institutions with heterogeneous agents making decisions regarding saving, labor supply and health insurance endogenously when they are young. The model, in which agents save in a precautionary manner, can generate Starr-McCluer's empirical finding and it indicates that the empirical finding is not inconsistent with the standard theory of saving under uncertainty. Counterfactual experiments are performed to provide implications for empirical analyses and illustrate the danger of empirical work without a sound theoretical background.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Precautionary Savings, Social Insurance, Employment-based Health Insurance
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy > E21 - Consumption ; Saving ; Wealth

References

Aiyagari, S. Rao (1994). “Uninsured idiosyncratic risk and aggregate saving.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 109:3, 659–684.

Attanasio, O., S. Kitao, and G. Violante (2008). “Financing Medicare: A General Equilibrium Analysis.” In J. B. Shoven (ed.), Demography and the Economy, NBER book, University of Chicago Press, 333 – 366.

Bewley, T.F. (1986). “Stationary monetary equilibrium with a continuum of independently fluctuating consumers.” In: Hildenbrand, W., Mas-Colell, A.(Eds.), Contributions to Mathematical Economics in Honor of Gerald Debreu. North-Holland, Amsterdam, 79–102.

Chatterjee, S., D. Corbae, M. Nakajima, and J.-V. R´ıos-Rull (2007). “A quantitative theory of unsecured consumer credit with risk of default.” Econometrica 75:6, 1525– 1589

De Nardi, M., E. French, and J. B. Jones (2006). “Differential Mortality, Uncertain Medical Expenses, and the Saving of Elderly Singles.” NBER Working Paper No. 12554.

Fronstin, P. (2007). “Employment-Based Health Benefits: Access and Coverage, 1988– 2005.” Employee Benefit Research Institute Issue Briefs, No. 303.

Gruber, J. and A. Yelowitz (1999). “Public health insurance and private savings.” Journal of Political Economy 107:6, 1249–1274.

Guariglia, A. and M. Rossi (2004). “Private medical insurance and saving: evidence from the British Household Panel Survey.” Journal of Health Economics 23:4, 761– 783.

Hansen, G., M. Hsu and J. Lee (2011). “Health Insurance Reform: The impact of a Medicare Buy-In.” Working Paper.

Hsu, M., P. Liao and C. Lin (2011). “Revisiting Private Health Insurance and Precautionary Saving – A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis.” Working Paper.

Hubbard, R. G., J. Skinner and S. P. Zeldes (1995). “Precautionary saving and social insurance.” Journal of Political Economy 103, 360–399.

Huggett, M. (1993). “The risk-free rate in heterogeneous-agent incomplete-insurance economies.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 17:5-6, 953–969.

˙Imrohoro˘glu, A. (1989), “Cost of business cycles with indivisibilities and liquidity constraints.” Journal of Political Economy 97, 13641383.

˙Imrohoro˘glu, A. (1992). “The welfare cost of ination under imperfect insurance.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 16:1, 79–91.

˙Imrohoro˘glu, S. and S. Kitao (2009). “Labor supply elasticity and social security re-form.” Journal of Public Economics 93, 867–878.

˙Imrohoro˘glu, S. and S. Kitao (2010). “Social Security, Benefit Claiming, and Labor Force Participation: A Quantitative General Equilibrium Approach.” Federal Reserve Bank of New York Staff Reports No.436.

Jeske, Karsten and Sagiri Kitao (2009). “U.S. tax policy and health insurance demand: Can a regressive policy improve welfare?” Journal of Monetary Economics 56, 210–221.

Livshits, I., M. Tertilt, and J. MacGee (2007). “Consumer bankruptcy: A fresh start.” American Economic Review 97:1, 402–418.

Kotlikoff, L. J. (1989). “Health expenditures and precautionary savings.” What Determines Savings? by L. J. Kotlikoff, Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press. Monheit, Alan C. (2003). “Persistence in Health Expenditures in the Short Run: Prevalence and Consequences.” Medical Care 41:7, 53–64.

Palumbo, M. G. (1999). “Uncertain medical expenses and precautionary saving near the end of the life cycle.” Review of Economic Studies 66:2, 395–421.

Scholz, J. K., A. Seshadri, and S. Khitatrakun (2006). “Are Americans saving optimally for retirement?” Journal of Political Economy 114:4, 607–643.

Starr-McCluer, Martha (1996). “Health Insurance and Precautionary Savings.” American Economic Review 86:1, 258–295.

Whitehouse, E. (2003). “The value of pension entitlements: A model of nine OECD countries.” OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers No.9.