The role of foreign banks in post-crisis Asia: the importance of method of entry

Montgomery, Heather (2003): The role of foreign banks in post-crisis Asia: the importance of method of entry. Published in: ADB Institute Research Paper No. 51

Abstract

This study examines the role of foreign banks in post-crisis Asia, focusing particularly on the four countries most affected by the Asian Crisis of 1997 - Indonesia, Korea, Malaysia and Thailand.

First, using data on the presence of foreign banks via branching as well as subsidiaries, the study shows that the presence of foreign banks in the four crisis-hit countries is actually much larger than has been previously reported once the presence of foreign branches is accounted for in the data. However, the percentage of assets controlled by foreign banks in Asia is still lower than that of other emerging economies, despite great increases in the post-crisis period. The author reviews regulations on foreign bank entry that may have limited the presence of foreign banks or influenced the method of entry (branching versus subsidiary).

Given recent regulatory changes and the need for bank recapitalization in the region, the presence of foreign banks is expected to increase in the near future, so this study next takes up the policy implications of this trend. To date, foreign banks in most Asian countries appear to perform relatively worse than their domestic counterparts as measured by return on equity, cost to income ratios, and the ratio of problem loans to total loans. This finding contradicts previous research in other emerging economies, and may be due to the fact that foreign bank entry in Asia is still a very recent phenomenon, and has occurred mostly through the takeover of troubled banks in the region.

The second policy issue examined here is the stability of lending by foreign banks relative to domestic banks. Macroeconomic data suggests that foreign bank lending may in some cases be more stable than domestic bank lending, particularly during crisis, but that the stability of foreign bank lending varies greatly by method of entry. Cross border claims of foreign banks are the most volatile, followed by foreign bank branch lending. Lending by foreign bank subsidiaries capitalized in the host country appear to be more stable than domestic lending, perhaps providing much needed capital during times of crisis.

Therefore, foreign banks play an important role in Asia, not only in the traditional ways by providing new services and stimulating competition and efficiency, but also by contributing to stability of the banking sector in the face of macroeconomic fluctuations. However, the mode of foreign entry seems to have important implications for the contributions of foreign banks. Since lending by off-shore banks and foreign bank branches seems to be more volatile than locally capitalized foreign subsidiaries, policy makers in Asia should encourage foreign players to enter via fully-owned subsidiaries or joint ventures and move away from the previous pattern of branch-based entry.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: bank; Asia; foreign
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G18 - Government Policy and Regulation; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G32 - Financing Policy ; Financial Risk and Risk Management ; Capital and Ownership Structure ; Value of Firms ; Goodwill; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G21 - Banks ; Depository Institutions ; Micro Finance Institutions ; Mortgages

References

Aliber R. Z. (1984): “International Banking: Survey,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 16(4), 661.

Aziz, I., W. Bailey, C. X. Mao, F. Siddik, and W. Thorbecke (2002): “Firm Behavior, Economic Vulnerability, and the Credit Crunch: An Analysis of Micro-MacroInteractions,” mimeo. Asian Development Bank Institute.

Barajas, A., R. Steiner and N. Salazar (1999): “Foreign Investment in Colombia’s Financial Sector,” IMF Working Paper 99.

Barth, J. R., G. Caprio, Jr., and R. Levine (2001): “The Regulation and Supervision of Banks Around the World: A New Database,” in R. E. Litan and R. Herring (eds.) Integrating Emerging Market Countries into the Global Financial System. Brookings-Wharton Papers on Financial Services, Brookings Institute Press.

Berger, A., R. D. Young, H. Geney and G. F. Udell (2000): “Globalization of Financial Institutions: Evidence from Cross-Border Banking Performance,” Brookings-Wharton Papers on Financial Services 2000, p. 23.

BIS (2000): “Report of the Working Group on Offshore Financial Centers,” Financial Stability Forum, Bank for International Settlements.

Buch, C. M. (2000): “Why Do Banks Go Abroad-Evidence from German Data,” Financial Markets, Institutions and Instruments, 9(1), 33.

Buch, C. M., and S. Lapp (1998): “The Euro-No Big Bang for European Financial Markets,” Konjunkturpolitik, 47, 11.

Chang, C. E., I. Hasan and W. C. Hunter (1998): “Efficiency of Multinational Banks: An Empirical Investigation,” Applied Financial Economics, 8(6), 1.

Cho, Y. J. (2002): “Towards Stronger Banking Sector: Lessons from Bank Restructuring in Korea after the Crisis,” mimeo., Asian Development Bank Institute.

Claessens, S., and T. Glaessner (1999): “Internationalization of Financial Services in Asia,” in Hanson, J. and S. Kathuria (eds.), India: A Financial Sector For the Twenty-First Century. Washington, D.C.: World Bank, New York, Oxford University Press.

Clarke, G., R, Cull, L. D’Amato and A. Molinari (1999): “The Effect of Foreign Entry on Argentina’s Domestic Banking Sector,” World Bank Working Paper 2158.

Clarke, G., R, Cull, M. S. M. Peria, and S. M. Sanches (2001): “Foreign Bank Entry: Experience, Implications for Developing Countries, and Agenda for Further Research,” mimeo. World Bank.

Crystal, J. S., B. G. Dages and L. Goldberg (2001): “Does Foreign Ownership Contribute to Sounder Banks in Emerging Markets?: The Latin American Experience,” in R. E. Litan, P. Masson, and M. Pomerleano (eds.), Open Doors: Foreign Participation in Financial Systems in Developing Countries. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press.

Demirguc-Kunt, A., Ri. Levine and H. Min (1998): “Opening to Foreign Banks: Issues on Stability, Effciency and Growth,” presented at the Bank of Korea International Conference on the Implication of Globalization of World Financial Markets, Seoul, June 1998.

Denizer, C. (1999): “Foreign Entry in Turkey’s Banking Sector, 1980-1997,” presented at WTO-World Bank Conference on Liberalization and Internationalization of Financial Services, Geneva, May 1999.

DeYoung, R., and D. E. Nolle (1996): “Foreign-owned banks in the United States: Earning Market Share or Buying it?,” Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, 28(4), 622.

Goldberg, L., B. G. Dages and D. Kinney (2000): “Foreign and Domestic Bank Participation in Emerging Markets: Lessons from Mexico and Argentina,” NBER Working Paper 7714.

Goldberg, L., and D. Johnson (1990): “The Determinants of US Banking Activity Abroad,” Journal of International Money and Finance, 9, 123-137.

Goldberg, L., and D. Kinney (2001): “When Is U.S. Bank Lending to Emerging Markets Volatile?,” NBER Working Paper 8209.

Goldberg, L., and A. Saunders (1981): “The Determinants of Foreign Banking Activity in the United States,” Journal of Banking and Finance, 5, 17-32.

Gross, R., and L. G. Goldberg (1991): “Foreign Bank Activity in the United States: An Analysis by County of Origin,” Journal of Banking and Finance, 15, 1093-1112.

Gruben, W., J. K., and R. Moore (1999): “When Does Financial Liberalization Make Banks Risky? An Empirical Examination of Argentina, Canada and Mexico,” Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas CLAE Working Papers 7714.

Hasan, I., and W. C. Hunter (1996): “Efficiency of Japanese Multinational Banks in the United States,” in A. H. Chen, (eds.), Research in Finance: Volume 14. Greenwich, CT and London: JAI Press.

Hasegawa, T. (1993): “Commercial Banking in the United States: Japanese Commercial Bank’s Presence,” Journal of Asian Economics, 4(2), 419-428.

Honohan, P. (2000): “Consequences for Greece and Portugal of the Opening- Up of the European Banking Market,” in S. Claessens and M. Jansen, (eds.), The Internationalization of Financial Services: Issues and Lessons for Developing Countries. Boston: Kluwer Academic Press.

Kiraly, J., B. Majer, L. Matyas, B. Ocsi, A. Sugar and E. Varhegyi (2000): “Experience with Internationalization of Financial Service Providers - Case Study: Hungary,” in S. Claessens and M. Jansen, (eds.), The Internationalization of Financial Services: Issues and Lessons for Developing Countries. Boston.: Kluwer Academic Press.

Levine, R. (1996): “Foreign Banks, Financial Development and Economic Growth,” in C. E. Barfield (ed.), International Financial Markets: Harmonization versus Competition. Washington D.C., American Enterprise Institute Press.

Levine, R. (1999): “Foreign Bank Entry and Capital Control Liberalization: Effects on Growth and Stability,” mimeo. University of Minnesota.

Liu, L. (2002a): “Beyond Sequencing: A Risk Management Approach to Financial Liberalization,” Unpublished manuscript, ADB Institute.

Liu, L. (2002b): “Sequencing PRC’s Banking Sector Reform after the WTO: Options and Strategy,” Unpublished manuscript, ADB Institute.

Mahajan, A., N. Rangan and A. Zardkoohi (1996): “Cost Structures in Multinational and Domestic Banking,” Journal of Banking and Finance, 20(2), 238{306.

Mathieson, D. J., and J. Roldos (2001): “The Role of Foreign Banks in Emerging Markets,” in R. E. Litan, P. Masson, and M. Pomerleano (eds.), Open Doors: Foreign Participation in Financial Systems in Developing Countries. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press.

McCauley, R. N., and S. Yeaple (1994): “ How Lower Japanese Asset Prices Affect Pacific Financial Markets,” Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Quarterly Review. Spring.

Meltzer, A. M. (1998): “Financial Structure, Saving and Growth: Safety Nets, Regulation, and Risk Reduction in Global Financial Markets,” presented at the Bank of Korea International Conference on the Implication of Globalization of World Financial Markets, Seoul, June 1998.

Miller S. and A. Parkhe (1998): “Patterns in the Expansion of U.S. Banks’ Foreign Operations,” Journal of International Business Studies, 29(2), 359{390.

Nolle, D. E., and R. Seth (1996): “Do Banks Follow Their Customers Abroad?,” Federal Reserve Bank of New York Working Paper 9620.

Palmer, D. E. (2000): “U.S. Bank Exposure to Emerging-Market Countries During Recent Financial Crisis,” Federal Reserve Bulletin, (February 2000), 81{96.

Park, W. (1996): “Financial Liberalization: The Korean Experience,” in T. Ito and A. Krueger (eds.), Financial Deregulation and Integration in East Asia. Chicago: University Chicago Press.

Park, Y. C. (2002): “Financial Liberalization and Economic Integration in East Asia,” mimeo. Asian Development Bank Institute.

Peek, J., E. Rosengren, and F. Kasirye (1998): “The Poor Performance of Foreign Bank Subsidiaries: Were the Problems Acquired or Created,” Federal Reserve Bank of Boston Working Paper 98.

Peek, J., and E. Rosengren (1997): “The International Transmission of Financial Shocks: The Case of Japan,” American Economic Review, 87(4), 495{505.

Peek, J., and E. Rosengren (1998): “Japanese Banking Problems: Implications for Southeast Asia,” presented at the Second Annual Conference of the Central Bank of Chile: Banking, Financial Integration, and Macroeconomic Stability, Santiago, Chile, September 1998.

Peek, J., and E. Rosengren (2000a): “Collateral Damage: Effects of the Japanese Bank Crisis on real Activity in the United States,” American Economic Review, 90(1), 30{45.

Peek, J., and E. Rosengren (2000b): “Implications of the Globalization of the Banking Sector: The Latin American Experience,” Federal Reserve Bank of Boston New England Economic Review September/October 2000.

Peria, M. S. S., and L. S. Serio (2001): “Do Depositors Punish Banks for Bad Behavior? Market Discipline, Deposit Insurance, and Banking Crisis,” Journal of Finance, 56(3), 1029-1051.

Pigott, C. A. (1986): “Financial Reform and the Role of Foreign Banks in Pacifc Basin Nations,” in H. S. Cheng (eds.), Financial policy and reform in Pacifc Basin countries. Lexington, Lexington Books.

Pomerleano, M., and G. J. Vojta (2001): “What Do Foreign Banks Do in Emerging Markets?: An Institutional Study,” in R. E. Litan, P. Masson, and M. Pomerleano (eds.), Open Doors: Foreign Participation in Financial Systems in Developing Countries. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press.

Sabi, M. (1988): “An Application of the Theory of Foreign Direct Investment to Multinational Banking LDCs,” Journal of International Business Studies, 19, 433-447.

Sagari, S. B. (1992): “United States Foreign Direct Investment in the Banking Industry,” Transnational Corporations, pp. 93-123.

Santiprabhob, V. (2002): “Lessons Learned from Thailand’s Experience with Financial Sector Restructuring,” mimeo. Asian Development Bank Institute.

Seth, R., and A. Quijano (1991): “Japanese Banks’ Customers in the United States,” Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Quarterly Review Spring.

Suehiro, A. (2002): “Restructuring and Re-engineering of Local Commercial Banks in Thailand From Family-owned Bank to Universal Bank,” mimeo. Asian Development Bank Institute.

Terrell, H. (1979): “U.S. Banks in Japan and Japanese Banks in the United States: An Empirical Comparison,” Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, Economic Review. Summer.

Terrell, H. (1986): “The Role of Foreign Banks in Domestic Banking Markets,” in H.S. Cheng (eds.), Financial policy and reform in Pacific Basin countries. Lexington,Lexington Books.

Yamori, N. (1998): “A Note on the Location Choice of Multinational Banks: The Case of Japanese Financial Institutions,” Journal of Banking and Finance, 22, 109-120.