Absolute poverty and the cost of living: an experimental analysis for italian households

Declich, Carlo and Polin, Veronica (2003): Absolute poverty and the cost of living: an experimental analysis for italian households.

Abstract

Our paper contains an investigation on poverty based on the absolute approach. Actually, absolute poverty has not been totally eliminated, also in developed countries and particularly in Italy. Moreover, this method has poverty levels not depending on income distribution: on the contrary, specific situations of real need are identified. In doing so, different price levels are taken into account, emphasising the possible effects of different costs of living in various geographical areas; for Italy, this issue seems crucial, owing to dramatic economic gaps between Northern and Southern areas. Yet, there are few data available on this, so that only a pioneering study may be carried out. Therefore, we estimate absolute poverty thresholds both for regions and macro areas. General results show a partial narrowing in the geographical gap in favour of the South, with respect to traditional approaches. The analysis is performed using several indicators (i.e. head-count, poverty gap and Sen index). Moreover, income inequalities between regions could turn out to be less obvious by considering different cost of living indices than it is the case if the same level of prices is used. The analysis is based on static micro simulation models that make use of both consumption and income data from ISTAT and Bank of Italy surveys. Thus, several data sources are used: in fact, it is known that income, even though it seems more appropriate in evaluating resources to purchase goods and services, can be sensitive to unexpected and temporary shocks, whereas consumption represents a proxy of the so-called “permanent income”. Finally, some light is also shed on the measurement of the efforts of public policies aimed at poverty alleviation. To this end, it is possible to examine the impact of public taxes and transfers on wellbeing, with particular attention to the effects of a “minimum income” scheme allowing for the different price levels.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Absolute poverty; Cost of living; Minimum income
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I31 - General Welfare, Well-Being; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I32 - Measurement and Analysis of Poverty

References

Atkinson A.B. (1983), The Economics of Inequality, Oxford, Clarendon Press.

Atkinson A.B. (1987), “On the Measurement of Poverty”, Econometrica, n. 55.

Atkinson A.B. (1992), “Measuring Poverty and Differences in Family Composition”, Economica, vol. 59.

Atkinson A.B., Bourguignon F. (1982), “The Comparison of Multidimensioned Distribution of Economic Status”, Review of Economic Studies, n. 12.

Atkinson A.B., Bourguignon F. (1987), “Income Distribution and Differences in Needs”, in Feiwel G.R. (ed.), Arrow and the Foundations of the Theory of Economic Policy, London, Macmillan.

Banca d’Italia (2000), “Indagine sui bilanci delle famiglie italiane nell’anno 1998” Supplementi al Bollettino Statistico, n. 22, Roma.

Barr N. (1993), The Economics of the Welfare State, Stanford, Stanford University Press.

Beckermann W. (1980), “Stime della povertà in Italia nel 1975”, Rivista internazionale di scienze economiche e sociali, n. 2.

Bernstein, J., Brocht, C., Spade-Aguilar, M. (2000), How Much Is Enough? Basic Family Budgets for Working Families, Washington D.C., Economic Policy Institute.

Betson, D. M. (1995), “The Effect of Home Ownership on Poverty Measurement”, Poverty Measurement Working Paper, Washington D.C., Census Bureau.

Bottiroli Civardi M., Chiappero Martinetti E. (1999), “Strutture famigliari e povertà: un raffronto tra diversi metodi di analisi”, in Ricerche quantitative per la politica economica 1997, Atti del Convegno Banca d’Italia-CIDE, Roma, Banca d’Italia.

Bottiroli Civardi M., Chiappero Martinetti E. (2002), “Povertà nei gruppi e povertà tra i gruppi”, in Carbonaro (a cura di), Studi sulla povertà. Problemi di misura e analisi comparative, Milano, Franco Angeli.

Bradbury, B., Jäntti, M., (1999), “Child Poverty across Industrialised Countries”, Innocenti Occasional Paper, Economic and Social Policy Series, N. 71, Florence, UNICEF.

Bradshaw J., (1993), “Budget Standards for the United Kingdom”, Studies in Cash & Care, Avebury, Aldershot.

Bradshaw J., Nolan B., Maitre B., Finch N. (2001), “The Measurement of Absolute Poverty: Final Report to Eurostat”, Social Policy Research Unit Working Paper, University of York.

Brandolini A. (1999), “The Distribution of Personal Income in Post-war Italy: Source Description, Data Quality, and Time Pattern of Income Inequality”, Temi di discussione, n. 350, Roma, Banca d’Italia.

Brandolini A., Cipollone P., Sestito P. (2001), “Earnings Dispersion, Low Pay and Household Poverty in Italy, 1977-1998”, Temi di discussione, n. 427, Roma, Banca d’Italia.

Buhmann B., Rainwater L., Schmaus G., Smeeding T.M. (1988), “Equivalence Scales, Wellbeing, Inequality and Poverty: Sensitivity Estimates across Ten Countries Using the LIS Database”, Review of income and wealth, vol. 34.

Campiglio L. (1996), Il costo del vivere, Bologna, Il Mulino.

Cannari L. (1994), “Povertà e livello dei prezzi”, in Commissione d’Indagine sulla Povertà e sull’Emarginazione, Terzo rapporto sulla povertà in Italia, Roma, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato.

Cannari L., D’Alessio G. (1992), “Mancate interviste e distorsione degli stimatori”, Temi di discussione, n.172, Roma, Banca d’Italia.

Cannari, L., D’Alessio G. (1993), “Non-reporting and Under-reporting in the Bank of Italy’s Survey of Household Income and Wealth”, Proceedings of the 49th Session of the International Statistical Institute, Firenze.

Cannari, L., D’Alessio G., Raimondi G., Rinaldi A. I. (1990), “Le attività finanziarie delle famiglie italiane. Risultati di un’integrazione tra le indagini campionarie condotte dalla Banca d’Italia e dalla Banca Nazionale del Lavoro”, Temi di discussione, n.136, Roma, Banca d’Italia.

Cannari, L., Franco D. (1999), “Poverty among Children in Italy: Dimensions, Characteristics, Policies”, mimeo, paper prepared for the Conference on “Child Well-Being in Rich and Transition Countries”, Luxembourg, 30 September to 2 October, 1999.

Carbonaro G. (1985), “Nota sulle scale di equivalenza”, in Commissione d’Indagine sulla Povertà e sull’Esclusione Sociale, Primo rapporto sulla povertà in Italia, Roma, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato.

Caruso M., Sabbatini R., Sestito P. (1993), “Inflazione e tendenze di lungo periodo nelle differenze geografiche del costo della vita”, Moneta e credito, n. 183, vol. 46. Cebula R.J. (1983), Geographic living-cost differentials, Toronto, Lexington Books.

CENSIS-Scenari Immobiliari (1999), Monitor Immobiliare, Rapporto sui mercati immobiliari italiani 1999, Roma.

Cimino E., Coli A. (1999), “La matrice di contabilità sociale nel sistema dei conti nazionali: riflessioni e proposte alla luce dei risultati ottenuti in un esercizio per il 1990”, mimeo, Report for the research project “Measures and parameters for economic and social policies”, Roma, ISTAT.

Citro C.F., Michael R.T. (eds.) (1995), Measuring Poverty: a New Approach, Washington, National Academy Press.

Coccia G., Colombini S., Masi A. (2002), “Territorial Poverty Analysis: a Comparison of Different Approaches”, in Atti della XLI Riunione Scientifica della Società Italiana di Statistica, 5-7 giugno 2002, Università Milano-Bicocca, CLEUP.

Coli A., Tartamella F. (2000), “L’integrazione tra informazioni tratte da fonti diverse in una matrice di contabilità sociale”, Milano, IRER.

Commissione di Indagine sull’Esclusione Sociale (2000a), La povertà delle donne in Italia: la ricerca, i dati, le metodologie di analisi, Roma, Ministero del Lavoro e delle Politiche Sociali.

Commissione di Indagine sull’Esclusione Sociale (2000b), Le politiche nazionali contro la povertà in Italia, Roma, Ministero del Lavoro e delle Politiche Sociali.

Commissione d’Indagine sull’Esclusione Sociale (2000c), Rapporto sulle politiche contro la povertà e l’esclusione sociale, Roma, Ministero del Lavoro e delle Politiche Sociali.

Commissione d’Indagine sull’Esclusione Sociale (2001), Rapporto annuale sulle politiche contro la povertà e l’esclusione sociale, Roma, Ministero del Lavoro e delle Politiche Sociali.

Commissione d’Indagine sulla Povertà e sull’Emarginazione (1996), Le misure della povertà in Italia: scale di equivalenza e aspetti demografici, Roma, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato.

Commissione d’Indagine sulla Povertà e sull’Emarginazione (1998), La povertà in Italia 1997, Roma, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato.

Cotton C., Bishop K., Michaud S. (2002) “Methodological Issues in the Production of Canada’s Market Basket Measure”, mimeo, paper prepared for the 27th General Conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Stockholm, August 18-24, 2002.

D’Alessio G. (1994), “Alcune considerazioni sulla misurazione della povertà”, in Commissione d’Indagine sulla Povertà e sull’Emarginazione, Terzo rapporto sulla povertà in Italia, Roma, Istituto Poligrafico e Zecca dello Stato.

Di Leo F. (1997), “La revisione degli affitti”, in ISTAT, La revisione della contabilità nazionale annuale, Metodi e norme, nuova serie, n. 1.

Donatiello G., Roberti P. (1998), “Definizioni della povertà e costruzione di una linea di povertà”, in CNEL, Indagine sulla riforma dell’assistenza sociale, n. 5, Analisi delle problematiche, istituzionali, economiche e sociali relative all’introduzione del concetto di “minimo vitale”, Roma, Camera dei Deputati.

Förster M. F. (1994), “Measurement of Low Incomes and Poverty in a Perspective of International Comparisons”, Labour Market and Social Policy Occasional Papers, n. 14, Paris, OECD.

Foster J.E. (1984), “On Economic Poverty: a Survey of Aggregate Measures”, in R.L. Basmann, G.F. Rhodes (eds.), Advances in Econometrics, vol. 3, Greenwich, JAI Press. Foster J.E. (1998), “Absolute versus Relative Poverty”, American Economic Review, vol. 88 n. 2.

Foster J.E., Greer J., Thorbecke E. (1984), “A Class of Decomposable Poverty Indices”, Econometrica, n. 52. ISAE (2000a), “Povertà e disagio: analisi e rimedi” in Rapporto trimestrale ISAE - Priorità nazionali: regolamentazione, competitività, cittadinanza, Roma.

ISAE (2000b), “Differenze di povertà su scala nazionale e internazionale”, Temi dei Rapporti Trimestrali dell’ISAE, Roma.

ISAE (2001), “La progettazione di un nuovo indicatore di benessere della collettività romana”, in OPER, III Rapporto sull’economia romana, Roma, Comune di Roma.

ISTAT (1999), “La povertà in Italia nel 1998”, Nota Rapida, anno 4 n. 9, Roma.

ISTAT (2000), Rapporto annuale: la situazione nel paese 1999, Roma.

ISTAT (2001a), “Indagine sui consumi delle famiglie”, File standard anno 1999, Roma.

ISTAT (2001b), “La povertà in Italia nel 2000”, Nota Rapida, anno 6 n. 3, Roma.

ISTAT (2002), “La povertà in Italia nel 2001”, Nota Rapida, anno 7 n. 2, Roma.

Jäntti M., Danziger S. (2000), “Income Poverty in Advanced Countries”, in Atkinson A.B., Bourguignon F. (eds.), Handbook on Income Distribution, Amsterdam, North-Holland.

Lanjouw J.O. (1999), Demystifying Poverty Lines, UNDP Poverty Related Publications.

Livi Bacci M., Cialfa E., Masselli M. (1997), “Studio di fattibilità per la definizione di un paniere minimo di beni e servizi”, mimeo, paper prepared for the seminar “New Approaches in the Analysis of Poverty and Social Exclusion”, Roma, ISTAT, July 14, 1997.

Maasoumi E. (1986), “The Measurement and Decomposition of Multidimensional Inequality”, Econometrica, n. 54.

Marenzi, A. (1996), “Evasione fiscale”, in N. Rossi (ed.), Competizione e giustizia sociale - 1994-1995, Terzo rapporto CNEL sulla distribuzione e redistribuzione del reddito in Italia, Bologna, Il Mulino.

Nolan B., Whelan C. (1996), Resources, Deprivation and the Measurement of Poverty, Oxford, Clarendon Press.

Orshansky M. (1963), “Children of the poor”, Social Security Bulletin, n. 26(7).

Orshansky M. (1965), “Counting the poor: another look at the poverty profile, Social Security Bulletin, 28(1).

Parker H. (ed.) (1999), Low Cost but Acceptable: a Minimum Income Standard for the UK: Family with Young Children, Bristol, Policy Press.

Parker H. (ed.) (2000), Low Cost but Acceptable Incomes for Older People: A Minimum Income Standard for Households Aged 65-74 Years in the UK, Bristol, Policy Press.

Ravallion M. (1994), Poverty Comparisons, Chur, Harwood.

Ravallion M. (1996), “Issues in Measuring and Modelling Poverty”, Economic Journal, n. 106.

Rowntree S., (1901), Poverty: A Study of Town Life, London, Macmillan.

Ruggles P. (1990), Drawing the Line: Alternative Poverty Measures and their Implications for Public Policy, Washington D.C., Urban Institute Press.

Sarpellon G. (1982), La povertà in Italia, Milano, Franco Angeli.

Saunders P. (1998), “Towards a Better Poverty Measure”, Focus, vol. 19, n. 2.

Saunders P., Bradshaw J., Hirst M. (2000), “Using Expenditure Data in the Measurement of Poverty: a Comparison of Australia and the United Kingdom”, mimeo, paper prepared for the 26th General Conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Cracow, Poland, 27 August to 2 September, 2000.

Sen A.K. (1976), “Poverty: an Ordinal Approach to Measurement”, Econometrica, n. 46.

Sen A.K. (1981), Poverty and Famines: an Essay on Entitlement and Deprivation, Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Sen A.K. (1996), Inequality Re-examined, Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Sen A.K. (1999), Development as Freedom, Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Short K. (2001), Experimental Poverty Measures: 1999, Washington D.C., Census Bureau.

Short K., Garner T.I., Johnson D., Doyle P. (1999), Experimental Poverty Measures: 1990 to 1997, Washington D.C., Census Bureau.

Slesnick D.T. (1993) “Gaining Ground: Poverty in the Post-war United States”, Journal of Political Economy, vol. 101, n. 1.

Toso S. (2000), “Distribuzione personale del reddito e tassazione progressiva”, in Bosi P. (a cura di), Corso di scienza delle finanze, Bologna, Il Mulino.

Townsend P. (1962), “The Meaning of Poverty”, British Journal of Sociology, n. 8.

Townsend P. (1979), Poverty in the United Kingdom, London, Allen Lane & Penguin.

UNDP (1999), Human Development Report 1999, New York, Oxford University Press.

UNDP (2000), Human Development Report 2000, New York, Oxford University Press.

World Bank (2000), Making Transition Work for Everyone - Poverty and Inequality in Europe and Central Asia, Washington D.C., World Bank.