The impact of the introduction of social welfare schemes in Ireland, (1930s-1950s)

Cousins, Mel (2005): The impact of the introduction of social welfare schemes in Ireland, (1930s-1950s).

Abstract

The relatively few studies of the Irish social welfare system have focused mainly on the forces behind the introduction of social welfare schemes rather than the impact which these schemes had in demographic and labour market terms. This note presents a preliminary examination of the issues and evidence concerning the impact of two significant schemes: the widow’s pension and children’s allowance. Its findings are significantly limited by the non-availability of data concerning, for example, the living arrangements of widows and large families in the relevant period. The main findings are as follows: 1. In those areas for which there is data, albeit imperfect in many cases, there is limited, if any, indication of a significant impact of the introduction of these schemes, for example, in relation to the remarriage rate of widows, the employment rate of married women, the numbers of children in care, levels of fertility or marriage. 2. The one area where there would appear to be an impact is in the employment rate of widows, where the introduction of widow�s pension appears to have accelerated an ongoing decline. 3. In relation to poverty, there is no direct evidence of poverty rates in published data. However, the introduction of widow�s pensions must have improved the financial position of such widows as the introduction of children’s allowance must have improved the financial position of larger families. 4. There is a co-occurrence of the introduction of children’s allowance and the fall in infant mortality. However, despite other studies which suggest a strong link between the two, it is suggested that that the link may be less direct and that it is more likely to reflect concurrent, but as yet, unquantified, improvements in children’s health care staff. This is not to say that the improvement in the financial position of families had no impact on infant mortality. This preliminary study suggests that the published data provides quite limited information on the impact of social welfare schemes, and that in order to investigate this further, examination of original Census material, such as, for example, housing conditions and employment rates by family size would be required.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: Oxford Brookes University
• Language: English
• Keywords: social welfare; Ireland; demograhic and labour market impact
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs

References

Arensberg, C.M. and S.T. Kimball Family and Community in Ireland, CLASP Press, Ennis, 2001 (originally published 1940) Baker, M., E. Hanna and J. Kantarevic �The married widow: married penalties matter!� NBER working paper 9782, 2003 Boldrin, M., M. de Nardi and L.E. Jones �Fertility and Social Security� NBER working paper 11146, 2005 Brien, M.J., S. Dickert-Conlin and D.A. Weaver �Widows waiting to wed? (Re) marriage and economic incentives in social security widow benefits� in Journal of Human Resources, 2004, 39(3), 585-623. Carey, S. �Land, labour and politics: social insurance in post-war Ireland� conference paper, ESPAnet, 2003 Cigno, A., L. Casolaro and F.C. Rosati The Role of Social Security in Household Decisions, CESifo working paper 394, 2000 Clancy Gore, C. �Nutritional Standards of Some Working-Class Families� Journal of the Statistical and Social Inquiry Society of Ireland, 1943-4, xvii, 241. Costa, D.L. �A house of her own: old age assistance and the living arrangements of older nonmarried women� in Journal of Public Economics, 1999, 72, 39-59 (also as NBER working paper 6217). Cousins, M. The birth of social welfare in Ireland, Four Courts Press, Dublin, 2003. Coward, J. �Birth under-registration in the Republic of Ireland during the twentieth century� Economic and Social Review, 1982, 14 (1), 1-27. Dickert-Conlin S. and C. Meghea �The effect of social security on divorce and remarriage behaviour� Centre for Retirement Research working paper 2004-09. Engelhardt, G.V., J. Gruber and C. D. Perry �Social security and elderly living arrangements� NBER working paper no. 8911, 2002. Fahey, T. �Review Article� Economic and Social Review, 1993, 24, 199. Fishback, V.P., M.R. Haines and S. Kantor �The welfare of children during the Great depression� NBER working paper 8902.