Weather insurance design with optimal hedging effectiveness

Kapphan, Ines (2011): Weather insurance design with optimal hedging effectiveness.

Abstract

I construct index-based weather insurance contracts with optimal hedging effectiveness for the insured or maximal profits for the insurer. In contrast to earlier work, I refrain from imposing functional form assumptions on the stochastic relationship between weather and yield and from restricting attention to (piecewise) linear contracts. Instead, I derive the shape of the optimal weather insurance contracts empirically by non-parametrically estimating yield distributions conditional on weather. I find that the optimal pay-off structure is non-linear for the entire range of weather realizations. I measure risk reduction of optimal weather insurance contracts for different weather indices and levels of risk aversion. Considering profit-maximizing contracts, I find that at modest levels of risk aversion (coefficient of relative risk aversion around 2), a loading factor of 10% of the fair premium is possible such that the insurance contract remains attractive for the insured. With higher levels of risk aversion, loading of more than 50% becomes possible.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: agricultural insurance, optimal insurance design, weather derivatives, weather risk, hedging effectiveness, loading of premium
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D81 - Criteria for Decision-Making under Risk and Uncertainty

References

Berg, A., and P. Quirion, B. Sultan, (2009), Can Weather Index Drought Insurance Benefit to Least Developed Countries Farmers? A Case Study on Burkina Faso, Weather, Climate and Society, Vol.1, No.1, pp:71-84

Goodwin, B., (2001), Problems with Market Insurance in Agriculture, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol.83, No.3, pp:643-649

Hazell, P. and J. Skees, (2005), Insuring against Bad Weather: Recent Thinking, GlobalAgRisk

Ibarra, H., and J. Skees, (2007), Innovation in Risk Transfer for Natural Hazards Impacting Agriculture, Environmental Hazard, Vol.7, pp:62-69

Leblois, A. and P. Quirion, (2011), Weather-Index Drought Insurance for Millet Growers in Niger: An Ex-Ante Evaluation, Working Paper

Mahul, O. (1999), Optimum Area Yield Crop Insurance, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol.81, pp:75-82

Mahul, O., (2000), Optimum Crop Insurance under Joint Yield and Price Risk, Journal of Risk and Insurance, Vol.67, No.1, pp:109-122

Mahul, O. (2001), Optimal Insurance against Climatic Experience, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol.83, No.3, pp:593-604

Mahul, O., and B. Wright, (2003), Designing Optimal Crop Revenue Insurance, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol.85, pp:580-589

Martin, S., and B. Barnett, K. Coble, (2001), Developing and Pricing Precipitation Insurance, Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, Vol.26(1), pp:261-274

Musshoff, O., and M. Odening,W. Xu, (2009), Management of Climate Risks in Agriculture - WillWeather Derivatives Permeate?, Applied Economics, Vol.1, pp:1-11

Osgood, D. and M. McLaurin, M. Carriquiry, A. Mishra, F. Fiondella, J. Hansen, N. Peterson, M. Ward, (2007), Designing Weather Insurance Contracts for Farmers in Malawi, Tanzania, and Kenya, IRI Technical Report, No. 07-02, Final Report to the Commodity Risk Management Group, ARD,World Bank,Washington, D.C.

Skees, J., and J. Black, B. Barnett, (1997), Designing and Rating an Area Yield Crop Insurance Contract, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol.79, pp:233-242

Skees, J., and B. Barnett, (1999), Conceptual and Practical Considerations for Sharing Catastrophic/Systemic Risks, Review of Agricultural Economics, Vol.21, pp:424-441

Torriani, D., and P. Calanca, M. Lips, H. Ammann, M. Beniston, J. Fuhrer, (2007), Maize Yield Behavior and Production Risk Under Climate Change, Regional Environmental Change, Vol.7, pp:209-221

Torriani, D., and P. Calanca, S. Schmid, M. Beniston, J. Fuhrer, (2007a), Potential Effects of Changes in Mean Climate and Climate Variability on the Yield of Winter and Spring Crops in Switzerland, Climatic Research, Vol.34:, pp:59-69

Vedenov, D., and B. Barnett, (2004), Efficiency ofWeather Derivatives as Primary Crop Insurance Instruments, Journal of Agricultural Research Economics, Vol.29, pp:387-403