Martingale properties of self-enforcing debt

Bidian, Florin and Bejan, Camelia (2011): Martingale properties of self-enforcing debt.

Abstract

Not-too-tight (NTT) debt limits are endogenous restrictions on debt that prevent agents from defaulting and opting for a specified continuation utility, while allowing for maximal credit expansion (Alvarez and Jermann, 2000). For an agent facing some fixed prices for the Arrow securities, we prove that discounted NTT debt limits must differ by a martingale. Discounted debt limits are submartingales/martingales under an interdiction to trade/borrow, and can be supermartingales under a temporary interdiction to trade. With high interest rates and borrowing limited by the agent's ability to repay debt out of his future endowments, nonpositive NTT debt limits are unique. With low interest rates, bubbles limited by the size of the total martingale components in debt limits can be sustained in equilibrium. Bubbles arise in response to debt limits more restrictive (at the prevailing interest rates) than the total amount of self-enforcing debt allowed by the underlying enforcement limitations.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: rational bubbles, endogenous debt limits, not-too-tight constraints, self-enforcing debt, limited enforcement
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E0 - General; G - Financial Economics > G0 - General

References

\harvarditem[Alvarez and Jermann]{Alvarez and Jermann}{2000}{AlvarezJermann2000} \textsc{Alvarez, F., {\small and} U.~J. Jermann} (2000): ``Efficiency, Equilibrium, and Asset Pricing with Risk of Default,'' \emph{Econometrica}, 68(4), 775--797.

\harvarditem[Alvarez and Jermann]{Alvarez and Jermann}{2001}{AlvarezJermann2001} \textsc{\BySame{}} (2001): ``Quantitative Asset Pricing Implications of Endogenous Solvency Constraints,'' \emph{Review of Financial Studies}, 14(4), 1117--1151.

\harvarditem[Antinolfi, Azariadis, and Bullard]{Antinolfi, Azariadis, and Bullard}{2007}{AntinolfiAzariadis2007} \textsc{Antinolfi, G., C.~Azariadis, {\small and} J.~B. Bullard} (2007): ``Monetary policy as equilibrium selection,'' \emph{Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review}, July, 331--342.

\harvarditem[Azariadis and Kaas]{Azariadis and Kaas}{2008}{AzariadisKaas2008} \textsc{Azariadis, C., {\small and} L.~Kaas} (2008): ``Endogenous credit limits with small default costs,'' mimeo, Washington University.

\harvarditem[Bejan and Bidian]{Bejan and Bidian}{2012}{BejanBidian2011injec} \textsc{Bejan, C., {\small and} F.~Bidian} (2012): ``Limited enforcement, bubbles and trading in incomplete markets,'' mimeo, Rice University and Georgia State University.

\harvarditem[Bidian]{Bidian}{2011}{Bidian2011} \textsc{Bidian, F.} (2011): ``Essays on Asset Price Bubbles,'' Ph.D. thesis, University of Minnesota.

\harvarditem[Bidian and Bejan]{Bidian and Bejan}{2012}{BejanBidian2011suppl} \textsc{Bidian, F., {\small and} C.~Bejan} (2012): ``Supplement to ``Martingale Properties of Self-Enforcing Debt'','' mimeo, Rice University and Georgia State University.

\harvarditem[Bloise and Reichlin]{Bloise and Reichlin}{2011}{BloiseReichlin2011} \textsc{Bloise, G., {\small and} P.~Reichlin} (2011): ``Asset prices, debt constraints and inefficiency,'' \emph{Journal of Economic Theory}, 146(4), 1520--1546.

\harvarditem[Bulow and Rogoff]{Bulow and Rogoff}{1989}{BulowRogoff1989} \textsc{Bulow, J., {\small and} K.~Rogoff} (1989): ``Sovereign Debt: Is to Forgive to Forget?,'' \emph{American Economic Review}, 79(1), 43--50.

\harvarditem[Forno and Montrucchio]{Forno and Montrucchio}{2003}{Forno2003} \textsc{Forno, A.~D., {\small and} L.~Montrucchio} (2003): ``Optimality Conditions and Bubbles in Sequential Economies and Bounded Relative Risk-Aversion,'' \emph{Decisions in Economics and Finance}, 26(1), 53--80.

\harvarditem[Hellwig and Lorenzoni]{Hellwig and Lorenzoni}{2009a}{HellwigLorenzoni2009} \textsc{Hellwig, C., {\small and} G.~Lorenzoni} (2009a): ``Bubbles and Self-Enforcing Debt,'' \emph{Econometrica}, 77(4), 1137--1164.

\harvarditem[Hellwig and Lorenzoni]{Hellwig and Lorenzoni}{2009b}{HellwigLorenzoni2009sup} \textsc{\BySame{}} (2009b): ``Supplement to ``Bubbles and Self-Enforcing Debt'','' \emph{Econometrica Supplementary Material}.

\harvarditem[Huang and Werner]{Huang and Werner}{2000}{HuangWerner2000} \textsc{Huang, K. X.~D., {\small and} J.~Werner} (2000): ``Asset Price Bubbles in Arrow-Debreu and Sequential Equilibrium,'' \emph{Economic Theory}, 15(2), 253--278.

\harvarditem[Kehoe and Levine]{Kehoe and Levine}{1993}{KehoeLevine1993} \textsc{Kehoe, T.~J., {\small and} D.~K. Levine} (1993): ``Debt-Constrained Asset Markets,'' \emph{Review of Economic Studies}, 60(4), 865--888.

\harvarditem[Kehoe and Levine]{Kehoe and Levine}{2001}{KehoeLevine2001} \textsc{\BySame{}} (2001): ``Liquidity Constrained Markets versus Debt Constrained Markets,'' \emph{Econometrica}, 69(3), 575--598.

\harvarditem[Kocherlakota]{Kocherlakota}{1992}{Kocherlakota1992} \textsc{Kocherlakota, N.~R.} (1992): ``Bubbles and Constraints on Debt Accumulation,'' \emph{Journal of Economic Theory}, 57(1), 245--256.

\harvarditem[Kocherlakota]{Kocherlakota}{1996}{Kocherlakota1996-RES} \textsc{\BySame{}} (1996): ``Implications of Efficient Risk Sharing without Commitment,'' \emph{Review of Economic Studies}, 63(4), 595--609.

\harvarditem[Kocherlakota]{Kocherlakota}{2008}{Kocherlakota2008} \textsc{\BySame{}} (2008): ``Injecting Rational Bubbles,'' \emph{Journal of Economic Theory}, 142(1), 218--232.

\harvarditem[Kopp]{Kopp}{1984}{Kopp1984} \textsc{Kopp, P.} (1984): \emph{Martingales and stochastic integration}. Cambridge University Press.

\harvarditem[Krueger and Perri]{Krueger and Perri}{2006}{KruegerPerri2006} \textsc{Krueger, D., {\small and} F.~Perri} (2006): ``Does Income Inequality Lead to Consumption Inequality? Evidence and Theory,'' \emph{Review of Economic Studies}, 73(1), pp. 163--193.

\harvarditem[Leroy and Werner]{Leroy and Werner}{2001}{WernerLeRoy2001} \textsc{Leroy, S., {\small and} J.~Werner} (2001): \emph{Principles of financial economics}. Cambridge University Press, 1 edn.

\harvarditem[Santos and Woodford]{Santos and Woodford}{1997}{SantosWoodford1997} \textsc{Santos, M.~S., {\small and} M.~Woodford} (1997): ``Rational Asset Pricing Bubbles,'' \emph{Econometrica}, 65(1), 19--57.

\harvarditem[Woodford]{Woodford}{1990}{Woodford1990} \textsc{Woodford, M.} (1990): ``Public Debt as Private Liquidity,'' \emph{American Economic Review}, 80(2), 382--88.