Imachi Nkwu: Trade and the commons

Fenske, James (2012): Imachi Nkwu: Trade and the commons.

Abstract

The conventional view is that an increase in the value of a natural resource will lead private property to emerge. Many Igbo groups in Nigeria, however, curtailed private rights over palm trees in response to the palm produce trade of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. I present a simple game between a property owner and a potential thief in which an increase in the price of a natural resource makes it possible to introduce regulated communal tenure. This makes the property owner better off, leaving the thief as well off as under private property. I use this model along with colonial court records to explain the political economy of property disputes in interwar Igboland.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Property rights, trade, commons, Nigeria, Igbo
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N5 - Agriculture, Natural Resources, Environment, and Extractive Industries > N57 - Africa ; Oceania; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O10 - General

References

@article{abramitzky2008limits, title={The Limits of Equality: Insights from the {I}sraeli Kibbutz}, author={Abramitzky, R.}, journal={The quarterly journal of economics}, volume={123}, number={3}, pages={1111}, year={2008}, publisher={Oxford University Press} }

@article{RefWorks:15, author={Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson}, year={2005}, title={Unbundling Institutions}, journal={Journal of Political Economy}, volume={113}, number={5}, pages={949-995}, url={http://ideas.repec.org/a/ucp/jpolec/v113y2005i5p949-995.html} }

@book{RefWorks:16, author={Omoniyi Adewoye}, year={1977}, title={The judicial system in Southern {N}igeria 1854-1954: law and justice in a dependency}, publisher={Longman}, address={London}, pages={331} }

@article{RefWorks:479, author={AE Afigbo}, year={1966}, title={Revolution and Reaction in Eastern Nigeria: 1900-1929}, journal={Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria}, volume={3}, number={3}, pages={539-557} }

@book{RefWorks:17, author={A. E. Afigbo}, year={1972}, title={The Warrant Chiefs: indirect rule in southeastern Nigeria, 1891-1929}, publisher={Longman}, address={London}, pages={338, 4} }

@article{alchian1973property, title={The property right paradigm}, author={Alchian, A.A. and Demsetz, H.}, journal={The journal of economic history}, volume={33}, number={1}, pages={16--27}, year={1973}, publisher={JSTOR} }

@article{allen2011global, title={Global Economic History: A Very Short Introduction}, author={Allen, R.C.}, journal={OUP Catalogue}, year={2011}, publisher={Oxford University Press} }

@article{RefWorks:478, author={G. Arrighi}, year={1970}, title={Labour supplies in historical perspective: a study of the proletarianization of the {A}frican peasantry in {R}hodesia}, journal={Journal of Development Studies}, volume={6}, number={3}, pages={197-234} }

@article{RefWorks:458, author={J. M. Baland and J. P. Platteau}, year={1999}, title={The ambiguous impact of inequality on local resource management}, journal={World Development}, volume={27}, number={5}, pages={773-788} }

@article{RefWorks:19, author={Jean-Marie Baland and Jean-Philippe Platteau}, year={1998}, month={Aug.}, title={Division of the Commons: A Partial Assessment of the New Institutional Economics of Land Rights}, journal={American Journal of Agricultural Economics}, volume={80}, number={3}, pages={644-650}, isbn={00029092}, url={http://www.jstor.org/stable/1244574} }

@inbook{RefWorks:444, author={J. M. Baland and J. P. Platteau}, year={2003}, title={Economics of common property management regimes}, series={Handbook of Environmental Economics}, publisher={Elsevier}, volume={1}, pages={127-190} }

@article{RefWorks:452, author={J. M. Baland and P. Francois}, year={2005}, title={Commons as insurance and the welfare impact of privatization}, journal={Journal of Public Economics}, volume={89}, number={2-3}, pages={211-231} }

@article{RefWorks:393, author={M. F. Bellemare and C. B. Barrett}, year={2003}, title={An Asset Risk Theory of Share Tenancy}, journal={Working Paper} }

@article{RefWorks:7, author={Timothy Besley}, year={1995}, title={Property Rights and Investment Incentives: Theory and Evidence from {G}hana}, journal={Journal of Political Economy}, volume={103}, number={5}, pages={903-37} }

@book{RefWorks:22, author={Ester Boserup}, year={1965}, title={The conditions of agricultural growth: {T}he economics of agrarian change under population pressure.}, publisher={Aldine Pub. Co.}, address={New York}, pages={124} }

@article{RefWorks:242, author={A. S. Brasselle and F. Gaspart and J. P. Platteau}, year={2002}, title={Land Tenure Security and Investment Incentives: Puzzling Evidence from {B}urkina {F}aso}, journal={Journal of Development Economics}, volume={67}, number={2}, pages={373-418} }

@article{RefWorks:212, author={A. F. B. Bridges}, year={1938}, title={Report on Oil Palm Survey in the {I}bo, {I}bibio and {C}ross {R}iver Area}, journal={Rhodes House Library, Oxford: MSS. Afr.s. 679} }

@book{RefWorks:468, author={C. A. Brown}, year={2003}, title={``We were all slaves'': African miners, culture, and resistance at the Enugu government colliery}, publisher={Greenwood Press} }

@book{RefWorks:363, author={J. W. Bruce and S. E. Migot-Adholla}, year={1994}, title={Searching for land tenure security in Africa}, publisher={Kendall/Hunt} }

@article{carpenter2007demand, title={The demand for punishment}, author={Carpenter, J.P.}, journal={Journal of Economic Behavior \& Organization}, volume={62}, number={4}, pages={522--542}, year={2007}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@book{RefWorks:23, author={L. T. Chubb}, year={1961}, title={Ibo land tenure}, publisher={Ibadan University Press}, address={Ibadan}, pages={115} }

@book{RefWorks:24, author={Gloria Chuku}, year={2005}, title={Igbo women and economic transformation in southeastern Nigeria, 1900-1960}, publisher={Routledge}, address={New York}, pages={320}, url={Table of contents http://www.loc.gov/catdir/toc/ecip0421/2004018040.html Table of contentshttp://www.loc.gov/catdir/toc/ecip0421/2004018040.html} }

@article{copeland2009trade, title={Trade, tragedy, and the commons}, author={Copeland, B.R. and Taylor, M.S.}, journal={The American Economic Review}, volume={99}, number={3}, pages={725--749}, year={2009}, publisher={American Economic Association} }

@article{RefWorks:25, author={David de Meza and J. R. Gould}, year={1992}, month={Jun.}, title={The Social Efficiency of Private Decisions to Enforce Property Rights}, journal={The Journal of Political Economy}, volume={100}, number={3}, pages={561-580}, abstract={Costs must be incurred if an owner is to enforce private property rights effectively. We show that, in a perfectly competitive economy, private decisions to enforce rights may result in either more or less enforcement than is socially efficient. Cases of multiple stable equilibria occur, and an equilibrium may be locally, but not globally, efficient. Resources may not be employed in their socially most valuable uses, and enforcement may be accompanied by inefficient investment in resource productivity.}, isbn={00223808}, url={http://www.jstor.org/stable/2138731} }

@book{RefWorks:150, author={H. de Soto}, year={2003}, title={The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else}, publisher={Basic Books} }

@article{RefWorks:26, author={Harold Demsetz}, year={1967}, month={May}, title={Toward a Theory of Property Rights}, journal={The American Economic Review}, volume={57}, number={2}, pages={347-359}, isbn={00028282}, url={http://www.jstor.org/stable/1821637} }

@book{RefWorks:484, author={K. O. Dike}, year={1956}, title={Trade and politics in the Niger Delta, 1830-1885: an introduction to the economic and political history of Nigeria}, publisher={The Clarendon Press} }

@article{falk2006theory, title={A theory of reciprocity}, author={Falk, A. and Fischbacher, U.}, journal={Games and Economic Behavior}, volume={54}, number={2}, pages={293--315}, year={2006}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{RefWorks:211, author={E. M. Falk}, year={1920}, title={Notes on the customs and superstitions of the population of the Aba division}, journal={Nigeria Papers, 1900-1933: Rhodes House, Oxford, MSS. Afr. s. 1000 (1)} }

@article{RefWorks:377, author={G. Feder and R. Noronha}, year={1987}, title={Land rights systems and agricultural development in sub-saharan {A}frica}, journal={The World Bank Research Observer}, volume={2}, number={2}, pages={143-169} }

@article{RefWorks:157, author={G. Feder and T. Onchan}, year={1987}, title={Land Ownership Security and Farm Investment in {T}hailand}, journal={American Journal of Agricultural Economics}, volume={69}, number={2}, pages={311-320} }

@article{fehr2000fairness, title={Fairness and retaliation: The economics of reciprocity}, author={Fehr, E. and G\"{a}chter, S.}, journal={The Journal of Economic Perspectives}, volume={14}, number={3}, pages={159--181}, year={2000}, publisher={JSTOR} }

@article{ferreira2007trade, title={Trade policy and natural resource use: the case for a quantitative restriction}, author={Ferreira, S.}, journal={Environmental and Resource Economics}, volume={37}, number={2}, pages={361--376}, year={2007}, publisher={Springer} }

@article{ferreira2004deforestation, title={Deforestation, property rights, and international trade}, author={Ferreira, S.}, journal={Land Economics}, volume={80}, number={2}, pages={174}, year={2004} }

@article{RefWorks:406, author={E. Field}, year={2007}, title={Entitled to Work: Urban Property Rights and Labor Supply in {P}eru}, journal={Quarterly Journal of Economics}, volume={122}, number={4}, pages={1561-1602} }

@article{foster2003economic, title={Economic Growth And The Rise Of Forests}, author={Foster, A.D. and Rosenzweig, M.R.}, journal={Quarterly Journal of Economics}, volume={118}, number={2}, pages={601--637}, year={2003}, publisher={MIT Press} }

@article{fudenberg2010unobserved, title={Unobserved punishment supports cooperation}, author={Fudenberg, D. and Pathak, P.A.}, journal={Journal of Public Economics}, volume={94}, number={1-2}, pages={78--86}, year={2010}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@book{RefWorks:482, author={H. A. Gailey}, year={1970}, title={The road to Aba: a study of British administrative policy in Eastern Nigeria}, publisher={New York University Press} }

@article{RefWorks:3, author={M. Goldstein and C. Udry}, year={2008}, title={The Profits of Power: Land Rights and Agricultural Investment in {G}hana}, journal={Journal of Political Economy}, volume={116}, number={6}, pages={981-1022} }

@article{RefWorks:27, author={Francisco M. Gonzalez}, year={2007}, month={11}, title={Effective property rights, conflict and growth}, journal={Journal of Economic Theory}, volume={137}, number={1}, pages={127-139}, abstract={This paper shows how the interaction between conflict and growth can give rise to a nonmonotone relationship between property rights and social welfare. This interaction is illustrated in a model of endogenous growth in which equilibrium diversion of resources is the cost of securing effective property rights. A symmetric equilibrium allocation associated with more secure property rights and faster growth can be Pareto dominated by one associated with poorer property rights and slower growth. Faster growth can exacerbate the problem of diversion whenever property rights are sufficiently poor. These results call for caution before a society decides to pursue economic growth independently of the institutional structure of property rights. Furthermore, if this structure is inappropriate piecemeal reform might not be in the interest of society, and a substantial reform might be necessary if it is to be welfare-improving.}, keywords={Property rights; Conflict; Diversion; Investment; Growth} }

@article{RefWorks:446, author={G. W. Grantham}, year={1980}, title={The Persistence of Open-Field Farming in Nineteenth-Century France}, journal={Journal of Economic History}, volume={40}, number={3}, pages={515-531} }

@book{RefWorks:29, author={M. M. Green}, year={1964}, title={Ibo village affairs}, publisher={Praeger}, address={New York}, pages={262} }

@article{RefWorks:28, author={M. M. Green}, year={1941}, title={Land tenure in an Ibo village: in south-eastern Nigeria}, journal={Monographs on social anthropology}, volume={6}, pages={44} }

@article{greif1993contract, title={Contract enforceability and economic institutions in early trade: The {M}aghribi traders' coalition}, author={Greif, A.}, journal={American economic review}, volume={83}, number={3}, pages={525--525}, year={1993}, publisher={American Economic Association} }

@article{RefWorks:31, author={Herschel I. Grossman and Minseong Kim}, year={1995}, month={Dec.}, title={Swords or Plowshares? {A} Theory of the Security of Claims to Property}, journal={The Journal of Political Economy}, volume={103}, number={6}, pages={1275-1288}, abstract={This paper develops a general equilibrium model of the allocation of resources among appropriative and productive activities. The model emphasizes the distinction between offensive weapons, which are the instruments of predation, and fortifications, which provide defense against predation. The analysis of this model shows how the equilibrium security of claims to property is determined. The analysis focuses on the possibility of a nonaggressive equilibrium, in which no resources are allocated to offensive weapons and claims to property are fully secure. We also analyze the complex relation between economic welfare and the security of claims to property. We find, for example, that a relatively poor agent could be better off in an equilibrium with less secure claims to property.}, isbn={00223808}, url={http://www.jstor.org/stable/2138711} }

@article{RefWorks:33, author={Catherine Hafer}, year={2006}, month={01/01}, title={On the Origins of Property Rights: Conflict and Production in the State of Nature}, journal={Review of Economic Studies}, volume={73}, number={1}, pages={119-143}, url={http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1467-937X.2006.00371.x} }

@article{RefWorks:442, author={G. Hardin}, year={1968}, title={The tragedy of the commons}, journal={Science}, volume={162}, number={3859}, pages={1243-1248} }

@article{hotte2000international, title={International trade with endogenous enforcement of property rights}, author={Hotte, L. and Long, N.V. and Tian, H.}, journal={Journal of Development Economics}, volume={62}, number={1}, pages={25--54}, year={2000}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{RefWorks:480, author={O. Ikime}, year={1966}, title={The anti-tax riots in Warri Province, 1927-1928}, journal={Journal of the Historical Society of Nigeria}, volume={3}, number={3}, pages={559-573} }

@article{RefWorks:37, author={G. I. Jones}, year={1949}, month={Oct.}, title={Ibo Land Tenure}, journal={Africa: Journal of the International African Institute}, volume={19}, number={4}, pages={309-323}, abstract={Système Foncier des ibo. L unité de tenure de la terre, dans la société iboenne, est constituée par plusieurs villages groupés dans une seule communauté autonome locale. Trois étapes peuvent être distinguées dans l histoire du développement de ces groupes: (a) la colonisation; (b) la consolidation; (c) la désintégration et la réorganisation. Les terres appartenant au groupe de villages sont classées comme terrains pour habitations et terrains agricoles; l allocation des parcelles et l emploi et le transfert des terrains sont contrôlés par la communauté. Autrefois, très peu de restrictions étaient imposées sur le transfert des terrains, soit entre les membres de la communauté, soit aux étrangers, mais l augmentation de la population et la pénurie de terrains, surtout de terrains agricoles, qui en a résultée, ont abouti, dans beaucoup de régions, à une interdiction de transferts. Diverses méthodes de céder, affermer et nantir des terrains sont décrites. Le système foncier parmi les Ibo est fondé sur certains principes qui sont tenus fermement, et même passionnément; (a) la terre appartient à la communauté; (b) aucun membre de la communauté ne devrait être sans terre; (c) chaque personne devrait avoir une tenure assurée. Le système qui convenait bien aux conditions anciennes, est mal approprié aux circonstances actuelles; une répartition inégale de la population s ensuit, l amélioration des méthodes de cultivation et la colonisation de nouvelles régions sont empêchées, et, dans certaines régions, les groupes de villages ont été transformés de communautés agricoles à de simples réserves de main-d œuvre.}, isbn={00019720}, url={http://www.jstor.org/stable/1156406} }

@article{lopez1997environmental, title={Environmental externalities in traditional agriculture and the impact of trade liberalization: the case of {G}hana}, author={Lopez, R.}, journal={Journal of Development Economics}, volume={53}, number={1}, pages={17--39}, year={1997}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{lopez1998tragedy, title={The tragedy of the commons in {C}ote d'{I}voire agriculture: empirical evidence and implications for evaluating trade policies}, author={Lopez, R.}, journal={The World Bank Economic Review}, volume={12}, number={1}, pages={105}, year={1998}, publisher={World Bank} }

@book{RefWorks:38, author={Martin Lynn}, year={1997}, title={Commerce and economic change in West Africa: The palm oil trade in the nineteenth century}, publisher={Cambridge University Press}, address={Cambridge}, pages={270} }

@book{RefWorks:40, author={Susan M. Martin}, year={1988}, title={Palm oil and protest: an economic history of the Ngwa region, south-eastern Nigeria, 1800-1980}, publisher={Cambridge University Press}, address={Cambridge}, pages={209} }

@article{masclet2003monetary, title={Monetary and nonmonetary punishment in the voluntary contributions mechanism}, author={Masclet, D. and Noussair, C. and Tucker, S. and Villeval, M.C.}, journal={The American Economic Review}, volume={93}, number={1}, pages={366--380}, year={2003}, publisher={JSTOR} }

@article{mccarthy2001common, title={Common Pool Resource Appropriation under Costly Cooperation}, author={McCarthy, N. and Sadoulet, E. and de Janvry, A.}, journal={Journal of Environmental Economics and Management}, volume={42}, number={3}, pages={297--309}, year={2001}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{mccloskey1975economics, title={The economics of enclosure: a market analysis}, author={McCloskey, D.N.}, journal={European Peasants and Their Markets: Essays in Agrarian Economic History}, pages={123--60}, year={1975} }

@article{mccloskey1975persistence, title={The persistence of {E}nglish common fields}, author={McCloskey, D.N.}, journal={European peasants and their markets: essays in agrarian economic history}, pages={92--120}, year={1975}, publisher={Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press} }

@article{mccloskeyopenfields, author={McCloskey, D.}, year={1976}, title={English Open Fields as Behavior towards Risk}, journal={Research in Economic History}, volume={1}, pages={124-170}, }

@article{nafziger2010peasant, title={Peasant communes and factor markets in late nineteenth-century Russia}, author={Nafziger, S.}, journal={Explorations in Economic History}, volume={47}, number={4}, pages={381--402}, year={2010}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{RefWorks:447, author={R. M. Netting}, year={1976}, title={What {A}lpine peasants have in common: {O}bservations on communal tenure in a {S}wiss village}, journal={Human Ecology}, volume={4}, number={2}, pages={135-146} }

@book{RefWorks:443, author={D. C. North}, year={1990}, title={Institutions, institutional change and economic performance}, publisher={Cambridge university press} }

@article{RefWorks:589, author={D. Northrup}, year={1979}, title={Nineteenth-Century Patterns of Slavery and Economic Growth in Southeastern {N}igeria}, journal={International Journal of African Historical Studies}, volume={12}, number={1}, pages={1-16} }

@book{RefWorks:483, author={D. Northrup}, year={1978}, title={Trade without rulers: pre-colonial economic development in south-eastern {N}igeria}, publisher={Clarendon Press} }

@article{RefWorks:460, author={G. U. Nwokeji}, year={2000}, title={The {A}tlantic Slave Trade and Population Density: A Historical Demography of the {B}iafran Hinterland}, journal={Canadian Journal of African Studies}, volume={34}, number={3}, pages={616-655} }

@book{RefWorks:48, author={Samuel Nwankwo Chinwuba Obi}, year={1963}, title={The Ibo law of property}, publisher={Butterworths}, address={London}, pages={239} }

@book{RefWorks:457, author={M. Olson}, year={1965}, title={The logic of collective action} }

@article{RefWorks:326, author={J. Oriji}, year={2007}, title={The End of Sacred Authority and the Genesis of Amorality and Disorder in {I}gbo Mini States}, journal={Dialectical Anthropology}, volume={31}, number={1}, pages={263-288} }

@book{RefWorks:50, author={John Nwachimereze Oriji}, year={1991}, title={Ngwa history: a study of social and economic changes in Igbo mini-states in time perspective}, publisher={P. Lang}, address={New York}, pages={176} }

@book{RefWorks:789, author={E. Ostrom}, year={1991}, title={Governing the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective action}, publisher={Cambridge University Press} }

@book{RefWorks:486, author={C. Perrings}, year={1979}, title={Black Mineworkers in Central Africa}, publisher={Heinemann} }

@book{RefWorks:11, author={Anne Phillips}, year={1989}, title={The Enigma of Colonialism: British Policy in West Africa}, publisher={Indiana University Press} }

@article{RefWorks:328, author={J. P. Platteau}, year={1996}, title={The Evolutionary Theory of Land Rights as Applied to Sub-{S}aharan {A}frica: A Critical Assessment}, journal={Development and Change}, volume={27}, number={1}, pages={29-86} }

@article{RefWorks:449, author={C. F. Runge}, year={1986}, title={Common Property and Collective Action in Economic Development}, journal={World Development}, volume={14}, number={5}, pages={623-635} }

@article{RefWorks:415, author={R. A. Shaban}, year={1987}, title={Testing between Competing Models of Sharecropping.}, journal={Journal of Political Economy}, volume={95}, number={5}, pages={893-920} }

@article{tarui2007inequality, title={Inequality and outside options in common-property resource use}, author={Tarui, N.}, journal={Journal of Development Economics}, volume={83}, number={1}, pages={214--239}, year={2007}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{taylor1997international, title={International trade and open-access renewable resources: the small open economy case}, author={Taylor, M.S. and Brander, J.A.}, journal={Canadian Journal of Economics}, volume={30}, number={3}, pages={526--552}, year={1997} }

@book{RefWorks:52, author={Northcote Whitridge Thomas}, year={1913}, title={Anthropological report on the Ibo-speaking peoples of Nigeria.}, publisher={Harrison and Sons}, address={London} }

@article{RefWorks:53, author={Aaron Tornell}, year={1997}, month={09/01}, title={Economic Growth and Decline with Endogenous Property Rights}, journal={Journal of Economic Growth}, volume={2}, number={3}, pages={219-250}, abstract={This article introduces endogenous institutional changeinto a neoclassical growth model. For some parameter values,all Markov perfect equilibria involve a shift from common propertyto private property followed by a shift back to common property.Even in the presence of a linear production technology, thissequence of switches generates growth rates that are increasingat low levels of capital and decreasing at high levels of capital.This result rationalizes the hump-shaped growth path followedby some countries through history, as well as the conditionalconvergence observed in postwar data. For other parameter values,there are also equilibria in which common property prevails forever.This result rationalizes the low-growth traps in which many poorcountries find themselves.}, url={http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/A:1009749908420} }

@article{RefWorks:466, author={V. C. Uchendu}, year={1965}, title={The {I}gbo of Southeastern {N}igeria}, journal={Fort Worth, TX: Holt, Reinhart and Winston} }

@book{RefWorks:481, author={R. K. Udo}, year={1975}, title={Migrant Tenant Farmers of Nigeria}, publisher={African Universities Press}, address={Lagos} }

@book{RefWorks:477, author={E. J. Usoro}, year={1974}, title={The Nigerian oil palm industry}, publisher={Ibadan University Press, Ibadan} }

@article{RefWorks:456, author={R. Wade}, year={1987}, title={The management of common property resources: collective action as an alternative to privatisation or state regulation}, journal={Cambridge Journal of Economics}, volume={11}, number={2}, pages={95-106} }