Creating the missing link: applying collective marks to create clusters

Ghafele, Roya (2009): Creating the missing link: applying collective marks to create clusters. Forthcoming in: Oxford Journal on Intellectual Property Law and Practice , Vol. 1, No. 4 (2009): pp. 57-66.

Abstract

Collective marks guarantee ownership over a community’s intangible wealth and in this sense not only reinforce its branding activities, but set up a new structure in which community business can function. Systems of local innovation may thus be developed through the design of an adequate legal infrastructure, paving the way for the solution of policy concerns, such as rural exodus or unemployment.

Cluster theory argues that, if small and medium sized enterprises intensify their degree of interaction to build up networks, this reduces costs, dependence on large firms, provides access to new markets and helps improve the position of the cluster in the market. All these functions can be reinforced through collective marks, which offer a legal context for the cluster’s governance structure, its standards and quality controls and system of collaboration. These features are particularly of relevance in a sector like tourism, where cooperation is a prerequisite for success. Empirical evidence suggests a certain sense of confusion on the role of trade mark protection in clusters: Individual marks are used as if they were collective marks, collective marks are used without further consideration of the economic aspects or intellectual property protection is altogether ignored.

In practice the wide range of opportunities provided by collective trademarks remains unexploited. Interdisciplinary approaches to IP may help to bridge a gap, observed both within academia and in practice, and thus join the IP law perspective to the evolving management literature on cluster theory.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: cluster creation, community reinforcement, network theory, collective trademarks,
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K0 - General; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M1 - Business Administration > M13 - New Firms ; Startups

References

M Weber, Economy and Society: an outline of Interpretive Sociology. University of California Press [1922] 1978, 730. An excellent overview of Max Weber’s thoughts from the perspective of economic sociology is found in R Swedberg, “The case for an economic sociology of law”. (2003) Theory and Society 2, 1-37.

J Schumpeter, Theorie der Wirtschaftlichen Entwicklung: Eine Untersuchung über Unternehmensgewinn, Kapital, Kredit, Zins und Konjunkturzyklus. Duncker und Humblot [1934] 1964.

H de Soto, The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else, Black Swan [2000] 2001.

D Hume, A Treatise on Human Nature, Oxford University Press [1739-1740] 1978, 496.

R Pitkethly, UK Intellectual Property Awareness Survey 2006, U.K. Intellectual Property Office/ Intellectual Property Institute/ Said School of Business Oxford University Discussion Note 2006.

For further discussion if collective marks and clusters see: R Ghafele and W Santagata, Cultural Tourism and Collective Trade marks: The Case of Byblos and Saida, Lebanon. (2006)Working Paper Dipartimento di Economia “S. Cognetti de Martiis” Universita di Torino 1, 5-7

WIPO, About Intellectual Property, www.wipo.org.

J Cave, C Ryan and C Panakera, “Cultural Tourism Product: Pacific Island Migrant perspectives in New Zealand”, (2007) Journal of Travel Research 45, 436.

C. Ray, Further Ideas about Local Rural Development: Trade, Production and Cultural Capital, (2000)Working Paper University of Newcastle Upon Tyre, Department of Agricultural Economics and Food Marketing 49, 14.

R Ghafele and W Santagata, Cultural Tourism and Collective Trade marks: The Case of Byblos and Saida, Lebanon. (2006)Working Paper Dipartimento di Economia “S. Cognetti de Martiis” Universita di Torino 1, 8-14

R Ghafele and W Santagata, Cultural Tourism and Collective Trade marks: The Case of Byblos and Saida, Lebanon. (2006)Working Paper Dipartimento di Economia “S. Cognetti de Martiis” Universita di Torino 1, 7-11

P Tang and N von Tunzelmann, “Management, Governance and Intellectual Property Electronic Publishing in the UK”., (2000) Journal of Management and Governance 4, 299- 318.

A Smith, The Wealth of Nations, Oxford University Press [1776] 1976, 710.

K Gotham, “Marketing Mardi Gras: Commodification, Spectacle and the Political Economy of Tourism in New Orleans”, (2002) Urban Studies 39/10, 1735-1756. This comment was provided by Professor Robert Brauneis of George Washington University’s Law School. Email exchange from the 5 April 2007.

R Ghafele and W Santagata, Cultural Tourism and Collective Trade marks: The Case of Byblos and Saida, Lebanon. (2006)Working Paper Dipartimento di Economia “S. Cognetti de Martiis” Universita di Torino 1, 20,21 This reference was provided by Professor Robert Brauneis of George Washington University’s Law School. Email exchange from the 5 April 2007, http://www.aseminfoboard.org/content/documents/061107_WG_IntellectualProperty_05LiangSen.pdf .

WIPO, About Intellectual Property, www.wipo.org.

C Le Goffic, “Cancellation of a trade mark based on a prior foreign geographical indication related to different products”, (2008) Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice 3/3, 152-154.

I Kireeva and P Vergano, “WTO Negotiations with Respect to Geographical Indications and Russia’s Position on the Protection of Appellations of Origin”, (2004) Review of Central and East European Law 4, 475-496.

E Meltzer, “Pass the Parmesan? What You Need To Know About Geographical Indications and Trademarks”, (2002) Virginia Lawyers 6, 18-23.

M Porter, “Clusters and the New Economic Competition”, (1998) Harvard Business Review 76, 77-90;

C M Hall, “Rural Wine and Food Tourism Cluster and Network Development” in D Hall, I Kirkpatrick and M Mitchell (eds), Rural Tourism and Sustainable Business (Channelview Press 2005), 149-164;

C Ham and M Hill, Tourism and Public Policy, Routledge 1995;

I Konosolas, The Competitive Advantage of Greece: An Application of Porter’s Diamond, Ashgate Publishing Company 2002;

R A W Rhodes, Understanding Governance Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity and Accountability, Open University Press 1997;

M Novelli, B Schmitz and T. Spencer, “Networks, Clusters and Innovation in Tourism: A UK Experience”, 2006 Tourism Management 27, 1141-1153 (contains a comprehensive review of research on cluster theory in tourism).

M Rutten, “Cooperation and Differentiation: Social History of Iron Founders in Central Java” in M Rutten and C Upadhya (eds), Small Business Entrepreneurs in Asia and Europe: Towards a Comparative (Sage 1997), 173- 210.

N Sheehan, Address to the pacific economic symposium, Manukau Auckland, August 16-18 2002.

D Buhalis, “Marketing the Competitive Destination in the Future”, (2000) Tourism Management 21/1, 97–116.

L Dwyer, P Forsyth and P Rao (2000), “The Price Competitiveness of Travel and Tourism: A Comparison of 19 Destinations”, (2000) Tourism Management 21/1, 9–12.

L Dwyer and C W Kim, “Destination Competitiveness: A Model and Indicators”, (2002) Current Issues in Tourism, 6/5, 369–414; F Go and R Govers, “Integrated Quality Management for Tourist Destinations: A European Perspective on Achieving Competitiveness”, (2000) Tourism Management, 21/1, 79–88; B Ritchie and G Crouch, “The Competitive Destination: A Sustainability Perspective”. (2000) Tourism Management, 21/1, 1–7

B Svensson, B S Nordin, and A Flagestad, “A Governance Perspective on Destination Development – Exploring Partnerships, Clusters and Innovations Systems”, (2002) Tourism Review, 60/2, 32–37.

K A Paskaleva-Shapira, “New Paradigms in City Tourism Management: Redefining Destination Promotion, ” (2007) Journal of Travel Research 46, 108.

F Higgins-Desbiolles, “More than an “Industry”: The Forgotten Power of Tourism as a Social Force”, (2005) Tourism Management 27, 1192-1208.

R Ghafele and W Santagata, Cultural Tourism and Collective Trade marks: The Case of Byblos and Saida, Lebanon. (2006)Working Paper Dipartimento di Economia “S. Cognetti de Martiis” Universita di Torino 1, 14-16

Y Weiss and S Sharir, “A Composite Good Theorem for Simple Sum Aggregates”, (1978) Econometrica 46, 1499- 1501

R Ghafele and W Santagata, Cultural Tourism and Collective Trade marks: The Case of Byblos and Saida, Lebanon. (2006)Working Paper Dipartimento di Economia “S. Cognetti de Martiis” Universita di Torino 1, 7-11.

G Richards and J Wilson, “Developing creativity in tourist experiences: A solution to the serial reproduction of culture?” (2006) Tourism Management 27/6, 1214.

H de Balzac, Scenes de la Vie de Province: Le Lys dans la Vallee, La Nouvelle France [1871-1880] 1946

R Ghafele, “Leveraging collective marks in tourism. Internal (unpublished) note of Washington University.” January 25 2007

E Kirtsogglou and D Theodossopoulos, “They are Taking our Culture Away: Tourism and Culture. Commodification in the Garifunal Community of Roatan”, (2004) Critique of Anthropology 24, 135-157. While this article stresses the role that community tourism may take to counteract this trend, it ignores the intellectual property aspect of the argument.

R Ghafele, “Leveraging collective marks in tourism. Internal (unpublished) note of Washington University.” January 25 2007. St. Moritz allows to download its logo from its website. http://www.heidiland.ch http://www.stmoritz.ch/pdf/HPD_CV_de.pdf http://www.suesskind.ch, http://www.stmoritz.ch http://www.stmoritz.ch/pdf/Marketing-Konzept2003-2006.pdf http://www.stmoritz.ch/pdf/Marke_konzept.pdf http://www.stmoritz.ch/pdf/030402_Strategie.pdf

Telephone interview with Dr Danuser, July 2007. Permission to use the logo was granted from the City municipalities of Venice. http://www.comune.venezia.it/flex/cm/pages/ServeBLOB.php/L/EN/IDPagina/7318

http://www.veniceword.com/venicelogo.html. http://www.comune.venezia.it/flex/cm/pages/ServeBLOB.php/L/EN/IDPagina/7847/GP/5#g http://www.comune.venezia.it/flex/cm/pages/ServeBLOB.php/L/EN/IDPagina/7791/GP/0#gallery

http://www.veneziapoint.com.

http://www.findlaw.com.au/article/6332.htm.

http://www.tq.com.au/tqcorp_06/fms//tq_corporate/destinations/queensland/brand_queensland_guidelines/Queessland%20logos%203.pdf.

R Ghafele, “Leveraging collective marks in tourism. Internal (unpublished) note of Washington University.” January 25 2007, permission was given from the trademark owner to use the logo in this publication.

http://www.vatc.org/pr/factslogan.htm

http://www.ibtimes.com/articles/20080404/apple-geenyc-ipod-iphone.htm

http://www.nationalheritagecorridor.org.uk/collective.htm

http://www.nationalheritagecorridor.org.uk/overview.htm

http://sme12.ph/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=186&Itemid=67 http://sme12.ph/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=186&Itemid=67