Fiscal transfers to immigrants in Canada: responding to critics and a revised estimate

Grubel, Herbert and Grady, Patrick (2012): Fiscal transfers to immigrants in Canada: responding to critics and a revised estimate. Published in: Studies in IMMIGRATION & REFUGEE POLICY (15 March 2012): pp. 1-45.

Abstract

In 2011, we estimated that in 2005 Canada’s immigrant selection policies resulted in an average fiscal burden on taxpayers of $6,000 for each immigrant. Later that year, Mohsen Javdani and Krishna Pendakur from the economics department at Simon Fraser University (J&P hereafter) presented an alternative estimate of this fiscal burden of $450.

This study concludes that J&P’s lower estimate is due mainly to their choice of a different immigrant cohort and assumptions about the immigrants’ absorption of government spending on pure public goods, education, and public housing.

After taking into account some new data and some issues raised by J&P, this study presents new estimates that show that the fiscal burden imposed by the average recent immigrants is $6,000, which for all immigrants is a total of between $16 billion and $23 billion per year, figures virtually identical to those found in our earlier study.

This study also rejects arguments made by J&P that immigrants are needed to meet labour shortages, that they bring productivity-increasing economies of scale, and that their children will repay the fiscal burden.

New evidence does not provide any grounds for optimism that the offspring of recent immigrants are going to be able to earn enough to compensate current and future generations of Canadians for the fiscal transfers made to their parents by existing Canadians.

This study also presents new evidence showing that immigrants who were admitted mainly on the basis of pre-arranged jobs have superior economic performance, which supports the policy recommendation made in our 2011 study.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: taxes, benefits, fiscal cost of immigration, recent immigrants to Canada
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H24 - Personal Income and Other Nonbusiness Taxes and Subsidies; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers

References

Akbari, Ather H. (1989). The Benefits of Immigration to Canada: Evidence on Tax and Public Services. Canadian Public Policy, 15, 4: 424-435.

Birrell, Bob, Ernest Healy, Katharine Betts, and Fred T. Smith (2011). Immigration and the Resources Boom Mark 2. Centre for Population and Urban Research, Monash University.

Canada, Citizenship and Immigration Canada (2011). Preliminary tables – Permanent and temporary residents, 2010 Canada - Permanent residents by category, 2006‑2010. Citizenship and Immigration Canada.

Fleury, Dominique (2007). A Study of Poverty and Working poverty among Recent Immigrants to Canada. Human Resources and Social Development Canada.

Grady, Patrick (2010). Recent Immigrants Have Experienced Larger Increases in Unemployment Due to the Recession. Global Economics Limited.

Grady, Patrick (2011). How are the Children of Visible Minority Immigrants Doing in the Canadian Labour Market? Global Economics Limited.

Grubel, Herbert, and Patrick Grady (2011). Immigration and the Welfare State 2011. Fraser Institute Studies in Immigration and Refugee Policy.

Head, Keith, and John Ries (1998). Immigration and Trade Creation: Econometric Evidence from Canada. Canadian Journal of Economics, 31(1): 47-62.

Jackson, Andrew (2011). Recent Immigrants and the Crisis. Blog (October 17). Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives.

Javdani, Mohsen, and Krishna Pendakur (2011). Fiscal Transfers to Immigrants in Canada. Working Paper No. 11. Simon Fraser University.

Makarenko, Jay (2010). Immigration Policy in Canada: History, Administration and Debates, History of Canadian Immigration Policy. Mapleleafweb.

McDonald, James Ted, Casey Warman, and Christopher Worswick (2011). Immigrant Selection Systems and Occupational Outcomes of International Medical Graduates in Canada and the United States. Working Paper No. 1285. Department of Economics, Queen’s University.

Nadeau, Serge (2011). The Economic Contribution of Immigration in Canada—Recent Developments: What do we know? What does it mean for policy? Research Group on the Economics of Immigration.

O’Neil, Peter (2011, December 17). Not taking a tougher line, Kenney says “Everything we’re doing now I just see as a natural extension of our longstanding approach”. Vancouver Sun.

Partridge, Jamie, and Hartley Furtan (2008). Immigration Wave Effects on Canada’s Trade Flows. Canadian Journal of Economics, 34, 2 (June): 193-214.

Picot, Garnett and Arthur Sweetman (2011). Canadian Immigration Policy and Immigrant Economic Outcomes: Why the Differences in Outcomes between Sweden and Canada? Forschungsinstitut zur Zukunft der Arbeit - Institute for the Study of Labor.

Riddell, W. Craig (2011). Assessing Recent Changes in Canada’s Immigration Policy. Presentation. Symposium on Immigration and Citizenship Policies of Canada and Europe, Atlantic Metropolis Centre, Halifax (May 30).

Statistics Canada (2003). Earnings of Immigrant Workers and Canadian-born Workers: 1980-2000. The Daily.

Statistics Canada (2008). Earnings and Incomes of Canadians over the Past Quarter Century, 2006 Census. Catalogue no 97-563-x.

Statistics Canada. Table 075-0001 - Historical statistics, estimated population and immigrant arrivals, annual (persons) (table), CANSIM (database), Using E-STAT (distributor).

United States, Congressional Budget Office (2001). NATO Burdensharing After Enlargement. Congressional Budget Office.

United States, National Science Foundation, Committee on Population (1997). The New Americans: Economic, Demographic, and Fiscal Effects of Immigration. National Science Foundation.

Windsor, Hugh (1990, October 24). McDougall wins battle to increase immigration. Minister sees new source of voters for Conservatives. The Globe and Mail: A1.

Worswick, Christopher (2004). Immigrants’ Declining Earnings: Reasons and Remedies. Backgrounder, 81 (April).