Evaluating the possible impact of pension reforms on future living standards in Europe

Grech, Aaron George (2012): Evaluating the possible impact of pension reforms on future living standards in Europe. Published in:

Abstract

Successive reforms enacted since the 1990s have dramatically changed Europe’s pensions landscape. This paper tries to assess the impact of recent reforms on the ability of systems to alleviate poverty and maintain living standards, using estimates of pension wealth for a number of hypothetical cases. By focusing on all prospective pension transfers rather than just those at the point of retirement, this approach can provide additional insights on the efficacy of pension systems in the light of increasing longevity.

Our estimates indicate that while reforms have decreased generosity significantly, in most countries poverty alleviation remains strong. However, moves to link benefits to contributions have made some systems less progressive, raising adequacy concerns for certain groups. In particular, unless the labour market outcomes of women and of lower-income individuals change substantially over the coming decades, state pension transfers will prove inadequate, particularly in Eastern European countries. Similarly while the generosity of minimum pensions appears to have either been safeguarded by pension reforms, or improved in some cases, these transfers generally remain inadequate to maintain individuals above the 60% relative poverty threshold throughout retirement. Our simulations suggest that the gradual negative impact of price indexation on the relative adequacy of state pensions is becoming even more substantial in view of the lengthening of the time spent in receipt of retirement benefits.

The consumption smoothing function of state pensions has declined noticeably, strengthening the need for longer careers and additional private saving. When pressed, policymakers, particularly in Western Europe, seem to have been more willing to sacrifice the income smoothing function of pensions rather than its poverty alleviation function. Policymakers in some counties, notably Germany, France and the UK, have sought to refocus state pension systems towards generating better outcomes for people in the bottom half of the income distribution, probably with the insight that middle- to high-income individuals are possibly in a better position to accommodate the effect of state pension reforms by increasing their private saving. However in some cases, notably in Eastern Europe, results suggest that policymakers may not have fully considered the full impact of their policies on those on low incomes, on those with incomplete careers and on women.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Social Security; Public Pensions; Retirement; Poverty; Retirement Policies
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J26 - Retirement ; Retirement Policies

References

Atkinson, Anthony Barnes, Francois Bourguignon, Cathal O’Donoghue, Holly Sutherland and Francesca Utili(2002) “Microsimulation of social policy in the European Union: Case study of a European Minimum Pension”, Economica, 69: 229-243.

Bottazzi, Renata, Tullio Jappelli and Mario Padula (2005) Retirement expectations, pension reforms, and their impact on private wealth accumulation, CEPR Discussion Paper 4882. London: Centre for Economic Policy Research.

Bridgen, Paul and Traute Meyer (2005) Towards a ‘balanced’ approach to pensions reform? Individuals, the state and employers in the restructuring of postretirement income in the UK, Discussion Paper PI-0509. London: Pensions Institute.

Disney, Richard (2000) “Crises in public pension programmes in OECD: What are the reform options?”, The Economic Journal, 110(461): F1-F23.

Dekkers, Gijs, Hermann Buslei, Maria Cozzolino, Raphael Desmet, Johannes Geyer, Dirk Hofmann, Michele Raitano, Viktor Steiner, Paola Tanda, Simone Tedeschi and Frederic Verschueren (2009) What are the consequences of the AWG-projections for the adequacy of social security pensions?, ENEPRI Research Report No.65. Brussels: Centre for European Policy Studies.

Dusek, Libor and Juraj Kopecsni (2008) Policy risk in action: Pension reforms and social security wealth in Hungary, Czech Republic and Slovakia, Discussion Paper PI-0812, London: Pensions Institute.

Economic Policy Committee (2009) The 2009 Ageing Report: economic and budgetary projections for the EU-27 Member States (2008-2060). Brussels: DG Economic and Financial Affairs.

European Commission (2006) The long-term sustainability of public finances in the European Union, European Economy no 4/2006, Brussels: DG Economic and Financial Affairs.

European Commission (2010) Progress and key challenges in the delivery of adequate and sustainable pensions in Europe, European Economy no 71, Brussels: DG Economic and Financial Affairs.

European Commission (2012) An agenda for adequate, safe and sustainable pensions, White Paper, Brussels: EU Commission.

Falkingham, Jane and Paul Johnson (1995) “Funding pensions over the life cycle” in The dynamic of welfare: the welfare state and the life cycle, Jane Falkingham and John Hills (eds). Hemel Hempstead: Prentice Hall/Harvester Wheatsheaf.

Ferraresi, Pier Marco and Chiara Monticone (2009) A semi-aggregate model for social expenditure projections, ENEPRI Research Report No.62. Brussels: Centre for European Policy Studies.

Flood, Lennart, Anders Klevmarken and Andreea Mitrut (2006) The income of the Swedish Baby Boomers, IZA Discussion Paper No. 2354. Bonn: Institute for the Study of Labour.

Fonseca, Raquel and Thepthida Sopraseuth (2006) Welfare effects of Social Security reforms across Europe: The case of France and Italy, CSEF Working Paper No.138, Naples: Centre for Studies in Economics and Finance.

Fultz, Elaine and Silke Steinhilber (2003) “The gender dimensions of social security reform in the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland”, in The Gender Dimensions of Social Security Reforms in Central and Eastern Europe: Case Studies of the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland, Elaine Fultz, Markus Ruck and Silke Steinhilber (eds). Budapest: ILO Sub-regional Office for Central and Eastern Europe.

Fultz, Elaine (2006) Pension reform in the Baltic States. Budapest: ILO Sub-regional Office for Central and Eastern Europe.

Goodman, Alissa, Mike Brewer, Carl Emmerson, Alastair Muriel, James Browne, and Gemma Tetlow (2007) Pensioner poverty over the next decade: what role for tax and benefit reform. London: Institute for Fiscal Studies.

Grech, Aaron G. (2010) Assessing the sustainability of pension reforms in Europe, CASE Paper 140. London: Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion.

Hauner, David, Daniel Leigh and Michael Skaarup (2007) Ensuring fiscal sustainability in G-7 countries, IMF Working Paper No. 07/187. Washington D.C.: International Monetary Fund.

Hering, Martin (2006) “The politics of structural pension reform in Western Europe: Does the EU matter?”, Paper presented at the Fifteenth International Conference of the Council for European Studies, March 29–April 2, 2006, Chicago:www.ces.columbia.edu/pub/papers/Hering.pdf

Howse, Kenneth (2004) “What has fairness got to do with it? Social justice and pension reform”, Ageing Horizons, 1: 3-16.

Indicators Sub-Group (2009) Updates of current and prospective theoretical pension replacement rates 2006-2046. Brussels: European Commission.

Kotlikoff, Laurence J., Ben Marx and Pietro Rizza (2006) Americans’ dependency on Social Security, MRRC Working Paper WP 2006-126. Michigan: University of Michigan.

Martin, John P. and Edward Whitehouse (2008) Reforming retirement-income systems: Lessons from the recent experiences of OECD countries, Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers, DELSA/ELSA/WD/SEM (2008)3. Paris: OECD.

OECD (2007) Pensions at a glance 2007: Public policies across the OECD. Paris: OECD.

OECD (2009) Pensions at a glance 2009: Retirement-income systems in OECD. Paris:OECD

Orban, Gabor and Daniel Palotai (2005) The sustainability of the Hungarian pension system: A reassessment, Magyar Nemzeti Bank Occasional Paper No. 40. Budapest: Magyar Nemzeti Bank.

Peaple, Nick (2004) European pension reform and private pensions: An analysis of the EU’s six largest countries. London: Association of British Insurers.

Soede, Arjan J., Cok Vrooman, Pier Marco Ferraresi and Giovanna Segre (2004) Unequal welfare states: Distributive consequences of population ageing in six European countries. The Hague: Social and Cultural Planning Office.

Schneider, Ondrej (2009) Reforming pensions in Europe: Economic fundamentals and political factors, CESifo Working Paper No. 2572. Munich: CESifo Group.

Sutherland, Holly, Ruth Hancock, John Hills and Francesca Zantomio (2009) “Failing to keep up? The long-term effects of current benefit and tax uprating policies”, Benefits, 17(1): 47-56.

Van de Coevering, Clement, Daniel Foster, Paula Haunit, Cathal Kennedy, Sarah Meagher and Jennie van den Berg (2006) Estimating economic and social welfare impacts of pension reform, Pensions Technical Working Paper. London: Department for Work and Pensions.

World Bank (1994) Averting the Old-Age crisis: Policies to protect the old and promote growth. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

World Bank (2007) Pensions panorama: Retirement-income systems in 53 countries. Washington D.C.: The World Bank.

Zaidi, Asghar and Grech, Aaron G. (2007) “Pension policy in EU25 and its impact on pension benefits”, Benefits: The journal of poverty and social justice, 15(3): 229-311.

Zaidi, Asghar, Aaron G Grech and Michael Fuchs (2006) Pension policy in EU25 and its possible impact on elderly poverty, CASEpaper No 116. London: Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion.