Deficits and the Economy: All Deficits Are Not Created Equal

Tatom, John (2005): Deficits and the Economy: All Deficits Are Not Created Equal.

Abstract

Recent academic and popular discussions of budget deficits rely upon a simplistic and, in large part, false conception of their effects. The recent literature ignores the fact that deficit effects depend on their source and on private sector responses to them. It also matters whether budget changes arise passively through the workings of the business cycle and whether deficit-inducing policy actions are permanent or transitory. More often than not, deficits are associated with lower interest rates. One reason is that large movements in budget deficits are principally due to the business cycle. Recessions lower investment and interest rates and also lower capital inflows. The widely popular idea that current account deficits arise from budget deficits is also not correct. Current account movements are related to international capital flows that respond more to incentives for domestic investment than to budgetary developments. Not surprisingly, the key expectations of the simple theory now circulating, especially about interest rates, the current account deficit and the dollar, are precisely opposite to what modern theory and evidence indicate. Investment and asset allocation decisions that rely on the popular misrepresentations of why and how deficits matter do material damage to investor interest.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: Networks Financial Institute at Indiana State University
• Language: English
• Keywords: deficit; twin deficits; interest rates; fiscal policy
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H6 - National Budget, Deficit, and Debt; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook; H - Public Economics > H3 - Fiscal Policies and Behavior of Economic Agents

References

Aschauer, David Alan, “Does Public Capital Crowd Out Private Capital,” Journal of Monetary Economics, September 1989, pp. 171-181.

_________________, “Fiscal Policy and Aggregate Demand,” American Economic Review, March 1985, pp.117-127.

Bailey, Martin J., National Income and the Price Level: A Study in Macroeconomic Theory, 2nd edition, NewYork: McGraw Hill, 1971.

Ball, Laurence and N. Gregory Mankiw, “What Do Deficits Do?” Budget Deficits and Debt, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, 1995, pp. 95-119.

Barro, Robert J., “Output Effects of Government Purchases,” Journal of Political Economy, December 1981.

Barth, James R., George Iden, Frank S. Russek and Mark Wohar, “The Effects of Federal Budget Deficits on Interest Rates and the Composition of National Output,” in Rudolph G. Penner (ed.), The Great Fiscal Experiment, Washington D.C.: Urban Institute Press, pp. 69-129.

Brunner, Karl, “Fiscal Policy in Macro Theory,” in Rik Hafer, ed., The Monetary versus Fiscal Policy Debate: Lessons from Two Decades, Totowa, New Jersey: Rowman and Allanheld Publishers, 1986.

_____________, and Allan H. Meltzer, “An Aggregative Theory for a Closed Economy,” and reply, “The Principal Issues: Areas of Argument and Work Remaining, in Jerome Stein, ed., Monetarism, Amsterdam: North Holland, 1976.

Congressional Budget Office, “Deficits and Interest Rates: Theoretical Issues and Empirical Evidence,” January 1989.

_____________, “The Standardized and Cyclically-Adjusted Budget,” March 2003.

_____________, The Budget and Economic Outlook: An Update, August 2003.

_____________, The Cyclically Adjusted and Standardized-Budget Measures, March 2004.

Engen, Eric M. and R. Glenn Hubbard, “Federal Government Debt and Interest Rates,” paper presented at the American Enterprise Institute, July 9, 2004.

Feldstein, Martin, “Budget Deficits, Tax Rules, and Real Interest Rates,” National Bureau of Economic Research No. 1970, July 1986.

de Serres, Alain and Florian Pelgrin, “The Decline in Private Saving Rates in the 1990s in OECD Countries: How Much Can Be Explained by Non-Wealth Determinants?” OECD Economics Department Working Paper Number 344, December 2002.

Ford, Robert and Pierre Poret, “Infrastructure and Private Sector Productivity,” OECD Working Paper, Jan. 3, 1991.

Gale, William G. and Peter R. Orszag, “The Economic Effects of Long-Term Fiscal Discipline,” Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center Discussion Paper No. 8, April 2003.

Gramlich, Edward M., Infrastructure Investment: A Review Essay,” Journal of Economic Literature 32, No, 8 (Sept. 1994), pp. 1176-96.

Kliesen, Kevin L, “Die Another Day? Budget Deficits and Interest Rates.” National Economic Trends, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, December 2002.

Kliesen, Kevin L. and Daniel L. Thornton, “The Expected Federal Budget Surplus: How Much Confidence Should the Public and Policymakers Place in the Projections?” Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review, March/April 2001, pp. 11-24.

Kormendi, Roger, “Government Debt, Government Spending and Private Sector Behavior,” American Economic Review, December 1983, pp. 994-1010.

________ and Aris Protopapadakis, “Budget Deficits, Current Account Deficits, and Interest Rates: Systematic Evidence on Ricardian Equivalence,” unpublished paper, University of Michigan Business School and University of Southern California, April 2004.

Laubach, Thomas, “New Evidence on the Interest Rate Effects of Budget Deficits and Debt,” Finance and Economics Discussion Series 2003-12. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, May 2003.

Mankiw, N. Gregory, Macroeconomics, Worth Publishers, Inc., 5th edition, 2002.

Mueleisen, Martin and Christopher Towe, “U. S. Fiscal Policies and Priorities for Long-Run Sustainability,” International Monetary Fund, Occasional Paper #27, January 2004.

Mundell, Robert A., “The Public Debt, Corporate Income Taxes, and the Rate of Interest,” Journal of Political Economy 68, (December 1960), pp. 622-26, as adapted in the author’s Monetary Theory, Inflation, Interest and Growth in the World Economy, Pacific Palisades, California,: Goodyear Publishing, 1971.

Rubin, Robert E., Peter R. Orszag and Allen Sinai, “Sustained Budget Deficits: Longer-Run Economic Performance and the Risk of Financial and Fiscal Disarray,” Paper presented at the Annual Meetings of the American Economics Association, January 4, 2004.

Shapiro, Matthew D. and Joel Slemrod, “Consumer Response to Tax Rebates,” National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 8672, December 2001.

Tatom, John A., "Is An Infrastructure Crisis Lowering the Nation's Productivity?" Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review (November/December 1993), pp. 3-21.

Tax Foundation, “The President’s FY 2005 Budget in Perspective: Part I,” Fiscal Facts, February 2, 2004.

West, E. G., Education and the State, A Study in Political Economy, 3rd revised edition, Liberty Fund, 1994.