Personal vs. Corporate Goals: Why do Insurance Companies Manage Loss Reserves?

Fiordelisi, Franco and Meles, Antonio and Monferrà, Stefano and Starita, Maria Grazia (2013): Personal vs. Corporate Goals: Why do Insurance Companies Manage Loss Reserves?

Abstract

This study analyses the determining factors of reserve errors in publicly listed property and casualty insurance companies in the U.S. This subject deserves special attention because the previous literature does not control for trade-offs between executive remuneration and other incentives regarding such insurers’ discretionary accounting choices. We find that insurance managers manipulate loss reserves to increase their stock-based remuneration and to achieve corporate goals particularly those goals that relate to reducing tax burdens and obscuring financial weakness. We also observe that enactment of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act has constrained the loss reserve underestimation and changed the structure of reserve error incentives.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: P&C insurers; reserve manipulation; executive compensation
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G22 - Insurance ; Insurance Companies ; Actuarial Studies; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G32 - Financing Policy ; Financial Risk and Risk Management ; Capital and Ownership Structure ; Value of Firms ; Goodwill; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M42 - Auditing

References

Ahmed, A. S., Takeda, C., Thomas, S., 1999. Bank loan loss provisions: a reexamination of capital management, earnings management and signaling effects. Journal of Accounting and Economics 28(1), 1-25.

Ali, A., Hwang, L. S., Trombley, M. A., 2000. Accruals and future stock returns: Tests of the naïve investor hypothesis. Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance 15(2), 161-181.

Altman, E., 1993. Corporate Financial Distress and Bankruptcy. Second Edition. John Wiley & Sons, New York.

Anderson, R.C., Fraser, D.R., 2000. Corporate control, bank risk-taking, and the health of the banking industry. Journal of Banking and Finance 24, 1383–1398.

Ang, A., Chen, J., Xing, Y., 2006. Downside Risk. Review of Financial Studies 19, 1191–1239.

Asquith, P., Gertner, R., Scharfstein, D. S., 1994. Anatomy of Financial Distress: An Examination of Junk-Bond Issuers. Quarterly Journal of Economics 109, 625-658.

Ball, R., Kothari, S. P., Robin, A., 2000. The effect of international institutional factors on properties of accounting earnings. Journal of accounting and economics 29(1), 1-51.

Ball, R., Robin, A., Wu, J.S., 2003. Incentives versus standards: properties of accounting income in four East Asian countries. Journal of accounting and economics 36(1), 235-270.

Baker, T., Collins, D., Reitenga, A., 2009. Incentives and opportunities to manage earnings around options grants. Contemporary Accounting Research 26(3), 649-672.

Bartov, E., 1993. The Timing of Asset Sales and Earning Manipulation. The Accounting Review 68(4), 840-855.

Basak, S., Shapiro, A., 2001. Value-at-risk based risk management: optimal policies and asset prices. Review of Financial Studies 14, 371-405.

Beaver, W. H., McNichols, M. F., Nelson, K. K., 2003. Management of the loss reserve accrual and the distribution of earnings in the property-casualty insurance industry. Journal of Accounting and Economics 35(3), 347-376.

Bergstresser, D., Philippon, T., 2006. CEO incentives and earnings management. Journal of Financial Economics 80, 511–530.

Browne, M.J., Ma, Y., Wang, P., 2009. Stock Option Compensation and Managerial Discretion in the Insurance Industry: Are Reserves Manipulated to Enhance Profitability? Journal of Insurance Regulation 27(4), 35-54.

Burgstahler, D. C., I. D., Dichev, 1997. Earnings, adaptation and equity value. Accounting review 24(1), 187-215.

Burns, N., Kedia, S., 2006. The Impact of Performance-Based Compensation on Misreporting, Journal of Financial Economics 79: 35-67.

Campbell, J. Y., Lettau, M., Malkiel, B. G., Xu, Y., 2001. Have individual stocks become more volatile? An empirical exploration of idiosyncratic risk. Journal of Finance 56, 1-43.

Campbell, J. Y., Hilscher, J., Szilagyi, J., 2008. In search of distress risk. Journal of Finance 63(6), 2899-2939.

Carson, J.M., Hoyt, R.E., 1995. Life insurer financial distress: classification models and empirical evidence. Journal of Risk and Insurance 62, 764–775.

Cohen, D., Dey, A., Lys, T., 2008. Real and Accrual Based Earnings Management in the Pre and Post Sarbanes Oxley Periods. The Accounting Review 83, 757-787.

Daniel, N. D., Denis, D. J., Naveen, L., 2008. Do firms manage earnings to meet dividend thresholds? Journal of Accounting and Economics 45(1), 2-26.

Dechow, P. M., Sloan, R. G., Sweeney, A.P., 1995. Detecting earnings management. Accounting Review 13(1), 193-225.

DeFond, M. L., Park, C. W., 1997. Smoothing income in anticipation of future earnings. Journal of Accounting and Economics 23(2), 115-139.

Degeorge, F., Patel, J., Zeckhauser, R., 1999. Earnings Management to Exceed Thresholds. The Journal of Business 72(1), 1-33.

Denis, D. J., Denis, D. K., 1995. Causes of Financial Distress Following Leveraged Recapitalizations. Journal of Financial Economics 37, 129-157.

Denis, D. J., Hanouna, P., Sarin, A., 2006. Is there a dark side to incentive compensation? Journal of Corporate Finance 12(3), 467-488.

Dichev, I.D., 1998. Is the Risk of Bankruptcy a Systematic Risk? Journal of Finance 53, 1131-1147.

Eckles, D. L., Halek, M., 2010. Insurer Reserve Error and Executive Compensation. Journal of Risk and Insurance 77(2), 329-346.

Eckles, D. L., Halek, M., He, E., Sommer, D. W., Zhang, R., 2011. Earnings Smoothing, Executive Compensation, and Corporate Governance: Evidence From the Property–Liability Insurance Industry. Journal of Risk and Insurance 78(3), 761–790.

Fiordelisi, F., Marques-Ibanez, D., 2013. Is default risk systematic? Journal of Banking and Finance 37, 2000-2010.

Gaivoronski, A., Pflug., G. C., 2004. Value-at-Risk in Portfolio Optimization: Properties and Computational Approach. Journal of Risk 7(2), 1-31.

Gaver, J., Gaver, K., Austin, J., 1995. Additional evidence on bonus plans and income management. Journal of Accounting and Economics 19, 3-28.

Gaver, J. J., Paterson, J. S., 1999. Managing insurance company financial statements to meet regulatory and tax reporting goals. Contemporary Accounting Research 16, 1–40.

Gaver, J. J., Paterson, J. S., 2004. Do insurers manipulate loss reserves to mask solvency problems? Journal of Accounting and Economics 37(3), 393-416.

Goldman, E. Slezak, S., 2006. An equilibrium model of incentive contracts in the presence of information manipulation. Journal of Financial Economics 80, 603-626.

Grace, E. V., 1990. Property-Liability Insurer Reserve Errors: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis. Journal of Risk and Insurance 57(1), 28-46.

Grace, M. F., Leverty, J. T., 2010. Political Cost Incentives for Managing the Property-Liability Insurer Loss Reserve. Journal of Accounting Research 48, 21-49.

Grace, M. F., and J. T. Leverty, 2011, Property-Liability Insurer Reserve Error: Motive, Manipulation, or Mistake. Journal of Risk and Insurance 79, 351-380.

Guidry, F., Leone, A. J., Rock, S., 1999. Earnings-based bonus plans and earnings management by business-unit managers. Journal of Accounting and Economics 26, 113-142.

Harrington, S. E., Danzon, P. M., 1994. Price Cutting in Liability Insurance Markets. Journal of Business 67(4), 511-538.

Healy, P. M., 1985. The Effect of Bonus Schemes on Accounting Decisions. Journal of Accounting and Economics 7, 85-107.

Hopper, G., 1996. Value at risk: A new methodology for measuring portfolio risk. Business Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, July/August, 19–29.

Holthausen, R., Larcker, D., Sloan, R., 1995. Annual bonus schemes and the manipulation of earnings. Journal of Accounting and Economics 19, 29–74.

Hunt, A., Moyer, S.E., Shevlin, T., 1996. Managing interacting accounting measures to meet multiple objectives: A study of LIFO firms. Journal of Accounting and Economics 21(3), 339-374.

Iliev, P., 2010. The effect of SOX Section 404: Costs, earnings quality, and stock prices. The Journal of Finance 65(3), 1163-1196.

Johansson, F., Seiler, M. J., Tjarnberg, M., 1999. Measuring Downside Portfolio Risk. Journal of Portfolio Management 26(1), 96-106.

Jones, J., 1991. Earnings management during import relief investigations. Journal of Accounting Research 29(2), 193–228.

Kazenski, P. M., Feldhaus, W. R., Schneider, H. C., 1992. Empirical Evidence for Alternative Loss Development Horizons and the Measurement of Reserve Error. Journal of Risk and Insurance 59(4), 668-681.

Koenker, R., Bassett, G., 1978. Regression quantiles. Econometrica 46, 33– 50.

Lang, H. H. P., Stulz, R. M. 1992. Contagion and Competitive Intra-Industry Effect of Bancruptcy Announcements. Journal of Financial Economics 32, 45-60.

Leuz, C., Nanda, D., Wysocki, P.D., 2003. Earnings management and investor protection: an international comparison. Journal of financial economics 69(3), 505-527.

Nelson, K. K., 2000. Rate Regulation, Competition, and Loss Reserve Discounting by Property-Casualty Insurers. The Accounting Review 75(1), 115-138.

Opler, T.C. Titman, S., 1994. Financial Distress and Corporate Performance. Journal of Finance 49, 1015-1040.

Pathan, S., 2009. Strong boards, CEO power and bank risk-taking. Journal of Banking and Finance 33(7), 1340-1350.

Petroni, K. R., 1992. Optimistic Reporting in the Property-Casualty Insurance Industry. Journal of Accounting and Economics 15(4), 485-508.

Petroni, K., Beasley, M., 1996. Errors in Accounting Estimates and Their Relation to Audit Firm Type. Journal of Accounting Research 34(1), 151-171.

Phillips, J., Pincus, M., Rego, S.O., 2003. Earnings management: New evidence based on deferred tax expense. The Accounting Review 78(2), 491-521.

Roychowdhury, S., 2006. Earnings management through real activities manipulation. Journal of Accounting and Economics 42(3), 335-370.

Saunders, A., Strock, E., Travlos, N. G., 1990. Ownership Structure, Deregulation, and Bank Risk Taking. Journal of Finance 2, 643-654.

Smith, B., 1980. An Analysis of Auto Liability Loss Reserves and Underwriting Results. Journal of Risk and Insurance 47(2), 305-320.

Vassalou, M., Xing, Y., 2004. Default Risk in Equity Returns. Journal of Finance 59(2), 831-868.

Weiss, M., 1985. A Multivariate Analysis of Loss Reserving Estimates in Property-Liability Insurers. Journal of Risk and Insurance 52(2), 199-221.