Universal Service Obligation and Loyalty Effects: An Agent-Based Modelling Approach

Bakhtieva, Dilyara and Kiljański, Kamil (2012): Universal Service Obligation and Loyalty Effects: An Agent-Based Modelling Approach. Published in: Yearbook of Antitrust and Regulatory Studies , Vol. 5(7), No. 2012 (2012): pp. 125-141.

Abstract

In network industries, a Universal Service Obligation (USO) is often seen as a burden on an incumbent, which requires compensation for the net cost of such service provision. This paper estimates the effects of consumer loyalty as an intangible benefit of USO in the postal sector. In doing so, the agent-based modelling (ABM) approach is applied, which makes it possible to model the behaviour of boundedly rational consumers and is thus particularly appropriate for taking into account intangibles considerations. The analysis shows that loyalty is crucial to whether the USO uniform pricing constraint results in loss-making or profitability. Under certain conditions and in the presence of a loyalty parameter, uniform pricing gives a USO provider an advantage, when the size of the rural area is sufficiently big and a disadvantage, if its size is too small. This finding is counterintuitive as USO providers in countries with sparsely populated areas are typically expected to incur a significant net cost of USO.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: agent-based modelling; liberalisation of the postal markets; postal sector; Universal Service Obligation (USO); USO provider
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law > K21 - Antitrust Law

References

Burns P., Carslake I., Houpis G., ‘Brand Loyalty and Limited Entry in Postal Markets’, [in:] Postal and Delivery Services. Delivering on Competition, Boston 2002.

Barkatullah N., Ramada P., ‘Quantification of USO benefits for the USP’, mimeo presented at the 10th CRRI Conference on Postal and Delivery Economics, Potsdam, 2002.

Calzada J., ‘Universal Service Obligations in the Postal Sector: the Relationship between Quality and Coverage’ (2009) 21(1) Information Economics and Policy.

Cigno M., Monaco D., Pearsall E., ‘An Operational Measure of the Cost of Universal Service as a Cross-subsidy’, [in:] Heightening Competition in the Postal and Delivery Sector, 2010.

Cirillo R., Thimmapuram P., Veselka T. D., Koritarov V., Conzelmann G., Macal C., Boyd G., North M., Overby T., Cheng X, Evaluating the Potential Impact of Transmission Constraints on the Operation of a Competitive Electricity Market in Illinois. Argonne National Laboratory, University of Illinois, Illinois Commerce Commission, 2006, (available at http://www.dis.anl.gov/pubs/56153.pdf).

Crew M.A., Kleindorfer P.R., ‘Efficient Entry, Monopoly, and the Universal Service Obligation in Postal Service’ (1998) 14(2) Journal of Regulatory Economics.

De Donder Ph., Cremer H., Dudley P., Rodriguez F., ‘Welfare and Pricing of Mail in a Communications Market’ (2011) 10(3) Review of Network Economics.

Fratini A., ‘The Universal Postal Service after the Lisbon Treaty: a True Step Forward?’ (2011) 10(3) Review of Network Economics.

Jaag Ch., Koller M., Trinkner U., ‘Calculating the Cost of the Universal Service Obligation: the Need for a Global Approach’, [in:] Progress in the Competitive Agenda in the Postal and Delivery Sector, 2009.

Jaag Ch., Trinkner U., ‘The Interaction between Universal Service Costing and Financing in the Postal Sector: a Calibrated Approach’ (2011) 39(1) Journal of Regulatory Economics.

London Economics, Benefits of Universal Service Provision to Consignia, Postwatch, London 2002.

Macal M. C., North M. J., Tutorial on Agent-based Modeling and Simulation. WSC ‘05 Proceedings of the 37th conference on Winter Simulation, 2005.

Modis Th., Predictions: Society’s Telltale Signature Reveals the Past and Forecasts the Future, Simon & Schuster, New York 1992.

Postcomm, An Assessment of the Costs and Benefits of Consignia’s Current Universal Service Provision. A Discussion Document, 2001.

Remondino M., ‘Reactive and Deliberative Agents Applied to Simulation of Socio-Economical and Biological SystemsReactive and Deliberative Agents Applied to Simulation of Socio-Economical and Biological Systems’ (2005) 6 International Journal of SIMULATION: Systems, Science & Technology.

Rodriguez F., Smith S., Storer D., ‘Estimating the Cost of the Universal Service Obligation in Posts’, [in:] Crew M.A., Kleindorfer P.R. (eds.), Emerging Competition in Postal and Delivery Services, Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1999.

Rodriguez F., Storer D., ‘Alternative Approaches to Estimating the Cost of the USO in Posts’ (2000) 12(3) Information Economics and Policy.

Twomey P., Cadman R., ‘Agent-based Modelling of Customer Behaviour in the Telecoms and Media Markets’ (2002) 4(1) Info.