Foreign subsidiaries and technology sourcing in Spain

Holl, Adelheid and Rama, Ruth (2012): Foreign subsidiaries and technology sourcing in Spain.

Abstract

Firms acquire external technological knowledge via different channels. In this paper we compare the technology sourcing of foreign subsidiaries and domestic firms looking at domestic R&D outsourcing, international R&D outsourcing, domestic cooperation for innovation and international cooperation for innovation. We use data from the Spanish Technological Innovation Panel (PITEC) for the years 2005-2009 for 10,206 innovative firms operating in Spain. We apply a multivariate probit specification which allows for systematic correlations among the different choices. The results show that the different technology sourcing choices are interdependent and that foreign subsidiaries show a different pattern of external technology sourcing. Compared to affiliated domestic companies, foreign subsidiaries show a smaller propensity for external technology sourcing via R&D outsourcing from independent firms in the host country, for international R&D outsourcing, and for international cooperation for innovation. In contrast, foreign subsidiaries show a greater propensity for domestic cooperation for innovation. However, foreign subsidiaries are not a homogenous group in this respect.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Multinational enterprises, foreign subsidiaries, R&D outsourcing, cooperation for innovation.
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F23 - Multinational Firms ; International Business; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O32 - Management of Technological Innovation and R&D

References

Abramovsky, L., R. Griffith, G. Macartney, & H. Miller. 2008. The location of innovative activity in Europe: The Institute for Fiscal Studies WP08/10.

Ahuja, G. 2000. The duality of collaboration: inducements and opportunities in the formation of interfirm linkages. Strategic Management Journal, 21: 317-43.

Almeida, P. 2004. Subsidiaries and knowledge creation: The influence of the MNC and host country on innovation. Strategic Management Journal, 25: 847-64.

Álvarez, I. & J. Cantwell. 2011. International integration and mandates of innovative subsidiaries in Spain. International Journal of Institutions and Economies, 3: 415-44.

Andersson, U., M. Forsgren, & U. Holm. 2002. The strategic impact of external networks: Subsidiary performance and competence development in the multinational corporation. Strategic Management Journal, 23: 979-96.

Belderbos, R., M. Carree, B. Diederen, B Lokshin, & R. Veugelers. 2004. Heterogeneity in R&D cooperation strategies. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 22: 1237– 63.

Bellak, C. 2004. How domestic and foreign firms differ and why does it matter? . Journal of Economic Surveys, 18(4): 483-514.

Beneito, P. 2006. The innovative performance of in-house and contracted R&D in terms of patents and utility models. Research Policy, 35: 502-17.

Berry, H. 2006. Leaders, laggards, and the pursuit of foreign knowledge. Strategic Management Journal, 27: 151-68.

Boehe, D.M. 2007. Product development in MNC subsidiaries: Local linkages and global interdependencies. Journal of International Management, 13: 488-512.

Cámaras de Comercio. 2008. La subcontratación industrial en España. Tecnología y competitividad. Madrid.

Cantwell, J. & O. Janne. 1999. Technological globalization and innovative centres: the role of corporate technological leadership and locational hierarchy. Research Policy, 28(2-3): 119-44.

Cantwell, J. & E. Kosmopoulou. 2009. Path dependency and coherence in international networks of technological innovation.In Cantwell, J. & J. Molero, editors, Multinational enterprises, innovative strategies and systems of innovation. Cheltenham, UK and Northampton, MA, USA: Edward Elgar 47-80.

Cantwell, J. & R. Mudambi. 2005. MNE competence-creating subsidiary mandates. Strategic Management Journal, 26: 1109-28.

Cantwell, J. & R. Mudambi. 2011. Physical attraction and the geography of knowledge sourcing in multinational enterprises: . Global Strategy Journal, 1(3-4): 206–32.

Cantwell, J.A. 2004. Towards a technology-seeking explanation of US direct investment in the United Kingdom. Journal of International Management, 10: 5-20.

Cappellari, L., & S. P. Jenkins. 2003. Multivariate Probit Regression using Simulated Maximum Likelihood. Stata Journal, 3(3), 278-294.

Carboni, O.A. 2013. Heterogeneity in R&D cooperation: an empirical investigation Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 25: 48-59.

Cassiman, B. & R. Veugelers. 2006. In Search of Complementarity in the Innovation Strategy: Internal R&D and External Knowledge Acquisition. Management Science, 52(1): 68-82.

Contractor, F. J. 1981. The role of licensing in international strategy. Columbia Journal of World Business, 16(4): 73-83.

Chib S & Greenberg E. 1998. Analysis of multivariate probit models. Biometrika 85:347–361.

Chun, H. & S.-B. Mun. 2011. Determinants of R&D cooperation in small and medium sized enterprises. Small Business Economics, DOI 10.1007/s11187-010-9312-5.

Dachs B. & B. Ebersberger. 2009. Does foreign ownership matter for the innovative activities of enterprises? International Economics and Economic Policy, 6(1): 41-57.

Dachs, B., B. Ebersberger, & H. Lööf. 2008. The innovative performance of foreign-owned enterprises in small open economies. Journal of Technology Transfer, 33: 393-406.

Dhont-Peltrault, E. & E. Pfister. 2011. R&D cooperation versus R&D subcontracting: empirical evidence from French survey data. Econ. Innov. New Techn., 20(4): 309-41.

Dunning, J.H. & S.M. Lundan. 2009. The internationalization of corporate R&D: A review of the evidence and some policy implications for home countries. Review of Policy Research, 26(1-2): 13-34.

Ebersberger, B. & S.J. Herstad. 2012. Go abroad or have strangers visit? On organizational search spaces and local linkages. Journal of Economic Geography, 12: 273-95.

Ebersberger, B., S.J. Herstad, E. Iversen, E. Kirner, & O. Som. 2011. Analysis of innovation drivers and barriers in support of better policies. Economic and market intelligence on innovation. Open innovation in Europe: effects, determinants and policy. Oslo: European Commission. Enterprise and Industry.

Edler, J. 2008. Creative internationalization: widening the perspectives on analysis and policy regarding international R&D activities. Journal of Technology Transfer, 33: 337-52.

EUROSTAT. 2008. Europe in figures.In Eurostat, editor, Eurostat yearbook Luxembourg: European Comission.

Faria, P. & T. Schmidt. 2012. International cooperation on innovation: firm-level evidence from two European countries. Innovation: Management, Policy & Practice 14 (3): 304 - 324.

García-Vega, M. & E. Huergo. 2011. Determinants of international R&D outsourcing: the role of trade. Review of Development Economics, 15(1): 93-107.

Hagedoorn, J. & R. Narula. 1996. Choosing organizational modes of strategic technology partnering: International and sectorial differences. Journal of International Business Studies, 27(2): 265-84.

Hagedoorn, J. 2002. Inter-firm R&D partnerships: an overview of major trends and patterns since 1960. Research Policy, 31: 477–492.

Herstad, S.J., C. Bloch, Ebersberger. B., & E. van de Velde. 2010. National innovation policy and global open innovation: exploring balances, tradeoffs and complementarities. Science and Public Policy, 37(2): 113-24.

Hitt, M.A., H. Lee, & E. Tucel. 2002. The importance of social capital to the management of multinational enterprises: Relational networks among Asian and Western firms. Asia Pacific J Management, 19: 353-72.

Holl, A., R. Pardo, & R. Rama. 2012. Comparing outsourcing patterns in domestic and FDI manufacturing plants: empirical evidence from Spain. European Planning Studies, 20(8): 1335-57.

Hsuan, J. & V. Mahnke. 2011. Outsourcing R&D: a review, model and research agenda. R&D Management, 41(1): 1-7.

Jabbour, L. & M.P. Zuniga. 2009. Drivers of the offshore outsourcing of R&D: empirical evidence from French manufacturers, Research Paper Series. Globalisation, Productivity and Technology, The University of Nottinhgham. Leverhulme Centre Research Paper 2009/04, p.26.

Knell, M. & M. Srholec. 2006. Innovation cooperation and foreign ownership in the Czech Republic. Paper presented at The Online Proceedings of The First Conference on Micro Evidence on Innovation and Development (MEIDE).

Kuemmerle, W. 1999. Foreign direct investment in industrial research in the pharmaceutical and electronics industries- results from a survey of multinationals. Research Policy, 28: 179-93.

Lenz-Cesar, F. & Heshmati, A. 2012. An econometric approach to identify determinants of cooperation for innovation among firms. Applied Economics Letters, 19:3, 227-235.

Lööf, H. 2009. Multinational enterprises and innovation: firm level evidence on spillover via R&D collaboration. Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 19: 41-71.

Lopez, A. 2008. Determinants of R&D cooperation: Evidence from Spanish manufacturing firms. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 26: 113-36.

López, A. 2011. The effect of microaggregation on regression results: an application to Spanish innovation data. MPRA Munich paper no. 30403.

Love, J.H. & S. Roper. 2009. Organizing the innovation process: Complementarities in innovation networking. Industry and Innovation, 16(3): 273-90.

Meyer, K.E., R. Mudambi, & R. Narula. 2011. Multinational enterprises and local context: the opportunities and challenges of multiple embeddedness. Journal of Management Studies, 48(2).

Molero, J. & J. Heijs. 2002. Differences of innovative behaviour between national and foreign firms: measuring the impact of foreign firms on national innovation systems. Int.J.Entrepreneurship and Innovation Management, 2(2/3): 122-45.

Molero, J., J. Portela, & I. Álvarez. 2009. Innovative MNEs' subsidiaries in different domestic environments. ICEI. Madrid( WP01/09): 7-20.

Nachum, L. & D. Keeble. 2003. MNE linkages and localised clusters: foreign and indigenous firms in the media cluster of Central London. Journal of International Management, 9: 171-912.

Pfaffermayr, M., & C. Bellak. 2002. Why foreign-owned firms are different: a conceptual framework and empirical evidence for Austria, in: Jungnickel, R. (ed.). Foreign-Owned Firms - Are They Different?, Palgrave Macmillan, Houndmills, pp13-57.

Phelps, N.A. 1993. Branch plant and the evolving spatial division of labour: a study of material linkage change in the Norther Region of England. Regional Studies, 27(2): 87-101.

Pittaway, L., M. Robertson, K. Munir, D. Denyer, & A. Neely. 2004. Networking and innovation: a systematic review of the evidence. International Journal of Management Reviews, 5/6(384): 137-38.

Schmidt, T. 2008. Motives for innovation cooperation? Evidence from the Canadian Survey of Innovation. http://hdl.handle.net/10419/24570, ZEW Discussion Papers no.08-018.

Schmiedeberg, C. 2008. Complementarities of innovation activities: an empirial analysis of the German manufacturing sector. Research Policy, 37: 1492-503.

Segarra-Blasco, A. & J.M. Arauzo-Carod. 2008. Sources of innovation and industry-university interaction: evidence from Spanish firms. Research Policy, 37(8): 1283-95.

Srholec, M. 2011. Understanding the heterogeneity of cooperation on innovation: Firm-level evidence from Europe, Working Papers on Innovation Studies 2011/1201Centre for Technology, Innovation and Culture: University of Oslo.

Srholec, M. . 2009. Does Foreign Ownership Facilitate Cooperation on Innovation? Firm-level Evidence from the Enlarged European Union European Journal of Development Research, 21: 47-62.

Teirlinck, P., M. Dumont, & A. Spithoven. 2010. Corporate decision-making in R&D outsourcing and the impact on internal R&D employment intensity. Industrial and Corporate Change, 19(6): 1741-68.

UNCTAD, editor. 2001. World Investment Report 2001. Promoting Linkages. New York and Geneva: United Nations Conference on Trade and Development.

UNCTAD. 2011. World Investment Report 2011. New York and Geneva.

Vega-Jurado, J., A. Gutiérrez-Garcia, & I. Fernández-de-Lucio. 2009. Does external knowledge sourcing matter for innovation? Evidence from the Spanish manufacturing industry. Industrial and Corporate Change, 18(4): 637-70.

Veugelers, R. & B. Cassiman. 2004. Foreign subsidiaries as a channel of international technology diffusion: Some direct firm level evidence from Belgium. European Economic Review, 48: 455-76.