Veiled Waters: Examining the Jones Act's Consumer Welfare Effect

Lewis, Justin (2013): Veiled Waters: Examining the Jones Act's Consumer Welfare Effect. Published in: Issues in Political Economy , Vol. 22, (2013): pp. 77-107.

Abstract

This paper analyzes how The Jones Act, a maritime law that effectively closes the United States’ coastal shipping routes to foreign firms, impacts the economic welfare of domestic ocean transport consumers. Though it has long been speculated that the Act is economically detrimental to the United States, and some efforts to examine this have been made in the past, the data needed to facilitate precise estimates was not available until very recently. Using an original framework, I apply this new data in generating a better understanding of how the Jones Act’s trade restrictions translate into economic consequences. Section 1 frames the Act within its broader political-economic context and describes the motivation behind my question along with my approach to answering it. Section 2 describes the maritime shipping industry and the Jones Act’s place within it, while Section 3 addresses related findings from past research and how they impel this study. Section 4 details my methodology (along with corresponding economic intuition) and presents the thesis’ finding: that consumers of the domestic maritime transport would be significantly better off (on the order of more than $578 million/year, in monetary terms) if the Jones Act’s restrictions were not in place. Section 5 discusses the potential implications of this result for other sectors of the economy as well as for the direction of future public policy.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Maritime Economics, Jones Act, Cabotage, Transport Regulation
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law > K23 - Regulated Industries and Administrative Law; L - Industrial Organization > L9 - Industry Studies: Transportation and Utilities

References

AP Moller/Maersk. (2007-2012). Annual Report. Retrieved from http://investor.maersk.com/financials.cfm

Bollinger, D. T. (2011, September). Interview by J.S. Lewis [Personal Interview]. Boise Bollinger, President: Bollinger Shipyards., Tulane University, A.B. Freeman School of Business.

CSCL. (2007-2012). Annual Report. Retrieved from http://www.cscl.com.cn/english/investment_annual.asp

Central Intelligence Agency, (2012). Economy Overview: United States (the World Factbook) . Retrieved from CIA website: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/us.html

Eitzen Maritime Services ASA. (2008, 03). Tanker Shipping Review. Retrieved from http://www.tankeroperator.com/pastissues/toreview08lowres.pdf

Euronav. (2007-2012). Annual Report. Retrieved from http://www.euronav.com/page.aspx?id=33

Evergreen Marine Corp. (2007-2012). Annual report. Retrieved from http://www.evergreen-marine.com/tbf1/jsp/TBF1_FinancialReports.jsp

European Conference of Ministers of Transport. (2001). Short Sea Shipping In Europe. Retrieved from http://www.internationaltransportforum.org/IntOrg/ecmt/pubpdf/01ShortSe a.pdf

Europa. (2009, 01 21). Towards a maritime transport area without barriers. Retrieved from http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-09-85_en.htm?locale=en

Eurostat. (04, 2012). Maritime Transport Statistics- Short Sea Shipping of Goods. Retrieved from http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/statistics_explained/index.php/Maritime_transport_statistics_-_short_sea_shipping_of_goods

Francois, J. F., Arce, H. M., Reinert, K. A., & Flynn, J. E. (1996). Commercial Policy and the Domestic Carrying Trade. The Canadian Journal of Economics, 29(1), Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/136158

Federal Trade Commission, (1997). Trucking Deregulation in the United States:Submission by the United States to the Iibero-American Competition Forum . Retrieved from website: http://www.ftc.gov/bc/international/docs/ibero-trucking.pdf

Frontline. (2007-2012). Annual Report. Retrieved from http://www.frontline.bm/IR/reports_2009.shtml

Gray, W. (2008). Performance of major us shipyards in 20th/21st century. Journal of Ship Production, 24(4), 202-213.

Hyundai Merchant Marine. (2007-2012). Annual financial information. Retrieved from http://www.hmm21.com/cms/company/engn/introduce/ir/financial/financial_01/index.jsp

Inter-American Development Bank. (2012). Understanding a Computable General Equilibrium Model. Retrieved from http://www.iadb.org/en/topics/trade/understanding-a-computable-general-equilibrium-model,1283.html

Jackson, Kristine C., and Charles W. McKetta. United States. Dept. of Agriculture. Impacts of the Jones Act on the Alaska Forest Products Trade. US Forest Service, 1986. Print.

Lane, M. (2011, October). Interview by J.S. Lewis [Personal Interview]. Merritt Lane, President: Canal Barge Co., Tulane University, A.B. Freeman School of Business.

Library of Congress. (2012). Bill summary & status 111th congress (2009 - 2010) s.3525 all congressional actions. Retrieved from http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d111:SN03525:@@@X

Li, Y. (2002). The Economic Effects of Surface Transport Deregulation. (Unpublished master's thesis) Retrieved from http://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/34527

Magee, Kathleen. "U.S. Cabotage Laws: Protective or Damaging?." Monterey Institute of International Studies. (2002): n. page. Print.

Merchant Marine Act of 1920; (46 App U.S.C. 889 (2002)). MISC Berhad. (2007-2012). Annual report. Retrieved from http://www.misc.com.my/invest_financial_annual.php

Mitsui O.S.K. Lines. (2007-2012). Annual Report. Retrieved from http://www.mol.co.jp/ir-e/library/ar-e2011s.html

NYK Group. (2007-2012). Business Performance: Annual Data. Retrieved from http://www.nyk.com/english/ir/financial/highlights/

OECD. Liberalisation in the Transportation Sector in North America. Paris: OECD, 1997. Print.

Papazivas, C., & Gardner, B. E. (2009). Is the Jones Act Redundant?. U.S.F. Maritime Law Journal, 21(1), Retrieved from http://winston.com/siteFiles/Publications/15 Papavitzas_Gardner 21.1.pdf

Piggott, Nicholas C. "Economic Impact of a Repeal of the Jones Act for North Carolina Soybean Producers." NC State Economist. 09 2001: n. page. Print.

Platts. (2012, 10 07). Marine shipping news- fuel transportation rates, maritime markets and charts. Retrieved from http://www.platts.com/Shipping/Home

PriceWaterhouseCoopers, . United States. Maritime Administration of the Dept. of Transportation. Study of the Impediments to US-Flag Registry: Final Report. Washington, D.C.: Department of Transportation, 2011. Print.

Risk Management Association. "Transportation- Coastal and Great Lakes Freight." Customized Industry Report (2011): eMentor. Database. 25 Jan 2012. <www.rma-ementor.org>.

Sharda (MarineInsight). (2011, 09 18). 10 largest container shipping companies in the world. Retrieved from http://www.marineinsight.com/marine/10-largest-container-shipping-companies-in-the-world/

Smith, Richard A. The Jones Act: An Economic and Political Evaluation. Boston: MIT Dept. of Ocean Engineering, 2004. Print.

Stopford, Martin. Maritime Economics. 2nd. London: Routledge, 1997. Print.

Teekay Corporation. (2007-2012). Annual Report. Retrieved from http://www.teekay.com/investors/financials/quarterly-and-annual-reports/default.aspx

United States. International Trade Commission. Economic Effect of Significant U.S. Import Restraints. Washington, D.C.: USITC, 2002. Print.

United States. Maritime Administration of the Dept. of Transportation. Comparison of U.S. and Foreign Flag Operating Costs . Washington, D.C.: US Dept. of Transportation, 2011. Print.

United States. Maritime Administration of the Dept. of Transportation. U.S. Water Transportation Statistical Snapshot. Washington, D.C.: Office of Policy and Plans, 2011. Print.

US Army Corps of Engineers, Institute for Water Resources. (2012). Waterborne Commerce of the United States: Calendar year 2010, part five. Retrieved from website: http://www.ndc.iwr.usace.army.mil//wcsc/wcsc.htm

Whitehurst, Clinton. Defining America‟s Military Sealift Capability: US or Foreign Flag. Clemson, SC: Strom Thurmond Institute of Govt. and Public Affairs, 2001. Print.

Whitehurst, Clinton. Last Clear Chance for an Enduring Maritime Policy. Clemson, SC: Strom Thurmond Institute of Govt. and Public Affairs, 1998. Print.

Whitworth, Jonathan. "The State of the Jones Act." Washington, D.C.: Maritime Cabotage Task Force, 2007. Print.

Winston, Clifford., Corsi, Thomas., Grimm, Curtis., Evans, Carol. The Economic Effects of Surface Freight Deregulation (Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 1990), p. 28.

Ying, John. "The Inefficiency of Regulating a Competitive Industry: Productivity Gains in Trucking Following Reform," in Review of Economics and Statistics, 72(1990).