The determinants of public spending: a survey in a methodological perspective

Facchini, Francois (2014): The determinants of public spending: a survey in a methodological perspective.

Abstract

SURVEY: This article shows that applied econometric is not a way of selecting, from among a plethora of possible explanations of public spending evolution. It lists 19 explanations and 73 explanatory variables and provides evidence of the great confusion in this field and the relative emptiness of quantitative economics. Then it sustains the Mayer’s idea that “given all the weakness of econometric techniques, other ways of testing, such as appeals to qualitative economic history, should not be treated as archaic”.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: public spending, applied econometric and causality
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H1 - Structure and Scope of Government > H10 - General; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H50 - General

References

Acemoglu, D. and Robinson, J.A. 2000. Why did the West extend the franchise? Democracy, inequality and growth in historical perspective, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 115, 4: 1167-1199.

Afonso, Antonio, and Davide Furceri 2010. Government Size, Composition, Volatility and Economic Growth. European Journal of Political Economy 26, 4, 517–532.

Aidt, T., Dutta, J. and Loukoianova, E. 2006. Democracy comes to Europe: Franchise extension and fiscal outcomes 1830-1938, European Economic Review, 50: 249-283.

Agell, J., Lindh, T., & Ohlsson, H. (1997). Growth and the public sector: A critical review essay. European Journal of Political Economy, 13: 33–52.

Alesina, A. and Perotti, R. 1997. The Welfare State and Competitiveness, American Economic Review, 89: 921-937.

Alesina, Alberto and Romain Wacziarg 1998. Openness, Country Size and Government. Journal of Public Economics, 69: 305-321.

Alesina, A. and Glaeser, E. 2004. Fighting Poverty in the U.S. and in Europe: A World of Difference. New York: Oxford University Press.

Alt J, Lassen D 2006. Fiscal Transparency, Political Parties, and Debt in OECD Countries, European Economic, Review, 50, 6: 1403-1439.

Andersen, J. J.2012. Cost of taxation and the size of government, Public Choice, 153: 83-115.

Ashworth, J. 1995. The empirical relationship between budgetary deficits and government expenditure growth: an examination using cointegration, Public Finance, 50,1: 1-18.

Baker, S.H. 1983. The determinants of median voter tax liability: An empirical test of the fiscal illusion hypothesis. Public Finance Quarterly II: 95-108.

Baumol, W. 1967. Macroeconomics of Unbalanced Growth: The Anatomy of Urban Crisis, American Economic Review 57: 415-426.

Baumol, W.J. 2012.The cost disease. Why computer’s get cheaper and health care doesn’t, economist.com/blog/freeexchange.

Baumol, W.J. 1993. Health care, education and the cost disease: a looming crisis for public choice, Public Choice 77: 17-28.

Baumol, W.J., Blackman S., and Wolff, E. 1985. Unbalanced Growth Revisited: Asymptotic Stagnancy and New Evidence, American Economic Review 75: 806-817.

Becker, E. 1996. The illusion of fiscal illusion: unsticking the flypaper effect, Public Choice, 86: 85-102

Becker, G.S. and Mulligan, C.B. 2003.Deadweight Costs and the Size of Government, Journal of Law and Economics, XLVI, October: 293-340.

Bénabou, R. 2000. Unequal societies: income distribution and the social contract. American Economic Review, 90: 96-129.

Bennett, J.T. and Orzechowski, W.P. 1983. The voting behavior of bureaucrats: some empirical evidence, Public Choice, 41: 271-283.

Berggren, N. and Jordahl, H. 2006. Free to trust: Economic Freedom and Social Capital, Kyklos, 59: 141-169.

Bergh, Andreas and Henrekson, M. 2011. Government Size and Growth: A Survey and Interpretation of the Evidence, IFN Working Paper n°858.

Bergh, A. and Bjornskov, C. 2011. Historical Trust Levels Predict the Current Size of the Welfare State, Kyklos, 64: 1-19.

Berry, W.D. and Lowery, D. 1987.Explaining the size of the public sector: responsive and excessive government interpretations, Journal of Politics, 49, 2: 401-440.

Biehl, Dieter (1998). Wagner’s law: an introduction to and a translation of the last version of Adoph Wagner’s text of 1911, Public Finance/Finances Publiques, 53, 1: 102-111.

Bohl, M.T. (1996). Some international evidence on Wagner’s law, Public finance, 51: 185-200.

Boix, C. 2001. Democracy, development, and the public sector, American Journal of Political Science 45, 1: 1-17.

Borcherding, Thomas E. 1977. On hundred years of public expenditure 1902-1970 in Borcherding ed. Budget and Bureacrats: The Sources of government growth Duke University Press, Durham, NC.

Borcherding, T.E. 1985. The Causes of Government Expenditure Growth: a Survey of the U.S. Evidence, Journal of Public Economics 28: 359-382.

Breeden, C.H. and Hunter, W.J. (1985) Tax Revenue and Tax Structure, Public Finance Quarterly, 13: 216-224.

Brennan, G. and Buchanan, J.M. 1980. The Power to Tax: Analytical Foundations of a Fiscal Constitution, Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.

Buchanan, J. 1954. Social Choice, Democracy and Free Markets, Journal of Political Economy, 62, 2: 114-123.

Bush, W.C. and Denzau, A.T. 1977. The voting behavior of bureaucrats and public sector growth, in Thomas E. Borcherding (ed.) Budgets and Bureaucrats: The Sources of Government Growth, Durham: Duke University Press.

Calmfors, L. and Driffill, J. 1988.Centralization of wage bargaining and macroeconomic performance.Economic Policy,6: 13–61.

Carter, J. 2012. The Displacement Effect of Interstate War, Department of Political Science. The University of Mississipi, September 27, annual meeting of the International Studies Association.

Clotfelter, C.T. 1976. Public spending for higher education: an empirical test of two hypotheses, Public Finance/Finances Publiques, 31: 177-195.

Courant, Paul N., Gramlich, E.M. and Rubinfield, D.L. 1979.Public employee, Market power and the level of Government spending, American Economic Review, 69, 5: 806-817.

Courant, P., Gramlish, E. and Rubinfield D. 1980. Why voters support tax limitation amendments: the Michigan Case, National Tax Journal, 33:1-20.

Cowen, T. 1996. Why I Do not Believe in the Cost-Disease, Comment on Baumol, Journal of Cultural Economics 20: 207-214.

Craigwell, Roland 1991. Government deficits and spending in Barbados: An empirical test of the Buchanan-Wagner hypothesis, Public Finance/Finances Publiques, n°3.

Craswell, R. 1975. Self-generating growth in public programs, Public Choice 21, spring: 91-97.

Crouch, C. (1990). Trade Unions in the Exposed Sector: Their Influence on Neo-corporatist Behaviour. Labour Relations and Economic Performance.Brunetta and Dell’Aringa, International Economic Association.

Cullis, J.G. and Jones, P.R. 1984. The economic theory of bureaucracy, X-inefficiency and Wagner’s law: a note, Public Finance/ Finances Publiques, 2: 191-201.

Cullis, J.G. and Jones P.R. 1987. Fiscal Illusion and excessive budgets: some indirect evidence, Public Finance Quarterly 15, 2: 219-228.

Cuzan, A.G. and Heggen R.J. 1985. Expenditures and votes: in search of downward-sloping curves in the United-States and Great Britain, Public Choice, 45, 1: 19-34.

Da Empli, D. 2002. The theory of fiscal illusion in a constitutional perspective, Public Finance Review, 30, 5: 377-384.

Dell'Anno, Roberto, and Paulo Mourao. 2012. Fiscal Illusion around the World: An Analysis Using the Structural Equation Approach, Public Finance Review 40: 270-99.

Dell’Anno, R. and Dollery, B. 2012. Comparative fiscal illusion: a Fiscal Illusion Index for the European Illusion, Online at http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/42537/MPRA Paper No. 42537, posted 11. November 2012 07:43 UTC

Delorme, Charles D., Cartwright, Philipp A. and Kespohl, Elke 1988.The effect of temporal aggregation on the test of Wagner’s law, Public Finance/ Finances Publiques, n°3, 373-387.

Diamond, J. 1989.A note on the public choice approach to the growth in public expenditures.Public Finance Quarterly, 17:373-81.

Dickson, V. and Yu, W. 2000.Revue Structures. The Perceived Price of Public Expenditures, Public Finance Review, 28: 48-65.

Di Lorenzo, T.J. 1982. Utility profits, fiscal illusion and local public expenditures, Public Choice 38, 243-252.

Downs A. (1957), An Economic Theory of Democracy, New York: Harper.

Downs, A. (1960). Why the Government is too small in democracy, World Politics 13, 541-563.

Durevall, Dick and Henrekson, Magnus 2011. The Futile Quest for a Grant Explanation of Long-Run Government expenditure, Journal of Public Economics, 95, 7/8: 708-722.

Facchini, F. and Melki, M. (2013). Efficient Government Size: France in the 20th Century, European Journal of Political Economy, 31: 1-14.

Flora, P., Alber, J. Eichenberg, R., Krausm, J.K.F., Pfenning, W. and Seebohm, K. 1983.State, Economy and Society 1815-1975, Campus Verlag, Frankfurt Germany.

Fölster, Stefan, and Magnus Henrekson. 2001. Growth Effects of Government Expenditure and Taxation in Rich Countries. European Economic Review, 45, 8 : 1501–1520.

Frey, B.S. and Pommerehne, W. 1982. How powerful are public bureaucrats as voters?, Public Choice 38, 253-262.

Gallarotti, G.M. (1989). « Legitimacy as a capital asset of the State », Public Choice, 63 : 43 – 61.

Gamkhar, Shama and Anwar Shah, 2007. The Impact of Intergovernmental Fiscal Transfers: A Synthesis of the Conceptual and Empirical Literature," in Robin Boadway and Anwar Shah, eds., Intergovernmental Fiscal Transfers: Principles and Practice, The World Bank. Gandhi, V. P. 1971. Wagner's Law of Public Expenditure: Do Recent Cross-Section Studies Confirm it?, Public Finance, 26, 44-56.

Garand, J.C. 1988. Explaining Government Growth in the U.S. States, The American Political Science Review, 82, 3, 837-849

Garrett, G and Way, C. 1999. Public Sector Unions, Corporatism, and Macroeconomic Performance".Comparative Political Studies, 32, 4: 411 - 434

Goffman, I.J. 1968. On the Empirical testing of Wagner’s law: a technical note, Public Finance, 23, 359-364.

Green, K. and Munley, V.G. 1979.Generating growth in public expenditures: the role of employee and constituent demand, Public Finance Quarterly, 7, 1: 92-109.

Gupta, S. 1967. Public expenditure and economic growth: a time series analysis, Public Finance, 22, 423-461.

Hempel, C.G. 1942. The function of general law in history, Journal of Philosophy, 39, 35-48.

Henrekson, M. and Lybeck, J.A. 1988. Explaining the growth of government in Sweden: a disequilibrium approach, Public Choice 57: 213-232.

Hettich, W. and Winer, S. (1984). A positive model of tax structure, Journal of Public Economics, 24, 67-87.

Holcombe R.G. 1993. Are there Ratchets in the Growth of Federal Government Spending? Public Finance Review January, 21, 1: 33-47

Holcombe, R.G. and Mills, J.A. 1995. Politics and deficit finance, Public Finance Quarterly, 23, 4, October: 448-466.

Holcombe, R. 2002. Political Entrepreneurship and the Democratic Allocation of Economic Resources, The Review of Austrian Economics, 15, 2/3: 143-160.

Holcombe, R.G. 2005. Government Growth in the twenty-first century, Public Choice, 124: 95-114. Hoover, K.D. 2008. Causality in economics and econometrics, New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, Palgrave, macMillan, 719-726.

Hooghe M., Reeskens, T., Dietlind, S. and Trappers, A. 2009. Ethnic Diversity and Generalized Trust in Europe, A Cross-National Multilevel Study, Comparative Political Studies, 42, 2: 198-223

Husted, T.A. and Kenny, L.W, 1997. The Effect of the Expansion of the Voting Franchise on the Size of Government, Journal of Political Economy, University of Chicago Press, 105, 1: 54-82.

Inman, R.P. 2008. The Flypaper Effect, NBER Working Paper 14579 (December). Cambridge, MA.

Jaarsma, B.., Schram, A. and Winden, F. van 1986. On the voting participation of public bureaucrats, Public Choice, 48: 183-187.

Kalt, J.P. and Zupan, M.A. 1984. Capture and Ideology in the Economic Theory of Politics, American Economic Review, 74: 279 – 300.

Karavitis, N. 1987. The Causal Factors of Government Expenditure Growth in Greece, 1950-80, Applied Economics, 19, 789-807.

Katsimi, M. 1998. Explaining the Size of the Public Sector, Public Choice 96, 1-2: 117-144.

Khan, A.H. 1988. Public spending and deficits: evidence from a developing economy, Public Finance/ Finances Publiques, 43: 396-402. Kindleberger, C.P. 1951. Group Behavior and International Trade, The Journal of Political Economy, pp. 30-46.

Knight, B.G. 2000. Super-majority voting requirements for tax increases: evidence from the states. Journal of Public Economics, 76: 41-67.

Kumlim, S. and Rothstein, B. 2005. Making and Breaking Social Capital: The Impact of Welfare-State Institutions, Comparative Political Studies, 38: 339-365.

Lewis-Beck, M.S. & T.W. Rice 1985. Government Growth in the United States, Journal of Politics, 47, 1: 2-30.

Lybeck.J.A. and Hcnrekson.M. (1989).Explaining the growth of government.Amsterdam: North Holland Publishing.

Larkey, P.D., Stolp, C. and Winner 1981.Theorizing about the growth of government: A research assessment Journal of Public Policy 1, 2: 157 – 220.

Leamer, E.E. 2010. Tantalus on the Road to Asymptopia, Journal of Economic Perspective, 24, 2: 31-46.

Lewis, A. 1982. The Psychology of taxation, Oxford, England: Martin Robertson.

Lizzeri, A. and Persico, N. 2001. The provision of public goods under alternative electoral incentives, American Economic Review 91, 1: 225-239.

Lott, J.R. and Kenny, L.W. 1999. Did Women’s suffrage change the size and scope of government? Journal of Political Economy, 107: 1163-1198.

Lowery, D. and Berry W. 1983. The growth of Government in the United States: An empirical assessment of competing explanations, American Journal of Political Science, 27: 665-694.

Lybeck, J.A. and Henrekson, M. 1988.Explaining the growth of government. Amsterdam: North-Holland.

Magazino, C. 2012. Wagner’s Law and Augmented Wagner’s Law inEU-27. A Time-Series Analysis on Stationarity, Cointegration and Causality, International Research Journal of Finance and Economics, issue 89, http://www.internationalresearchjournaloffinanceandeconomics.com

Marlow, M.L. and Orzechowski, M.L. 1996. Public sector unions and public spending, Public Choice 89, 102: 1-16.

Marshall, L. 1991. New evidence of fiscal illusion: the 1986 Tax, American Economic Review, 81, 6: 1336-1344.

Matakos, K. and Xefteris, D. 2012. Electoral Fragmentation and Government Spending: Reversing the Causal link with Evidence from Greece, CAGE Workshop at Warwick University.

McCarty, T.A. 1993. Demographic Diversity and the Size of the Public Sector, Kyklos 46, 2: 225-240.

Mello de L. and Tiongson, E.R. 2006. Income Inequality and Redistributive Government Spending, Public Finance Review, 34, 3:282-305.

Milesi-Ferretti, G.M., Perotti, R. and Rostagno, M. 2002. Electoral systems and public spending, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, may: 609-657.

Mises, L. 1962. Le fondement ultime de la science économique. Préface Prof. Israel Kirzner, Institut Charles Coquelin, Paris (french translation).

Mitchell, B.R. 2007. International Historical Statistics: Europe, 1750-1993, 4th Edition. Macmillan, Basinstoke, UK.

Moene, K. O. and Wallerstein, M. 2001. Inequality, Social Insurance, and redistribution, American Political Science Review, 95, 4: 85974

Mourão P. 2008. Towards a Puviani’s Fiscal Illusion Index.Hacienda Publica Espanola 187, 4: 49-86.

Mueller, D.C. 1987. The Growth of Government : A Public choice Perspective, Staff Papers – International Monetary Fund, 24, 1: 115- 149.

Mueller Dennis C. 2003, Public Choice III, Cambridge University Press.

Mueller, D.C., Facchini, F., Foucault, M., François, A., Magni-Berton, R. et Melki, M. 2010. Choix Publics. Analyse économique des décisions publiques, deBoeck, translation and adaptation, Mueller Dennis, C. (2003).

Musgrave, R.A. 1969, Fiscal System, New Haven: Yale University Press.

Niskanen W.J. 1975. Bureaucrats and Politicians, Journal of Law and Economics, December, 18: 617 – 643.

Niskanen, W.A. 1978. Deficits, government spending and Inflation: What is the evidence? Journal of Monetary Economics, 4: 591-602.

Niskanen W.J. 1994. Bureaucracy and public economics, contient “Bureaucracy and representative government”, 1971, “The Peculiar economics of bureaucracy”, 1968, “Bureaucrats and politicians”, 1975, “A reassessment”, 1993, John Locke series, Aldershort Hants England E. Elgar Pub; 1994.

Nordhaus, W. D. 2006. Baumol's Diseases: A Macroeconomic Perspective, Working Paper 12218, NBER, Cambridge, MA.

Nupia, O. 2007. Bargaining In Legislature: Number of Parties and Ideological Polarization.Documentos.CEDE, 10. Universidad de Los Andes, Facultad de Economia.

Oates, W.E., 1988. On the Nature and Measurement of Fiscal Illusion: A Survey,in G. Brennan, ed., Taxation and Fiscal Federalism: Essays in Honor of Russell Mathews, Sydney: Australian National University Press, pp. 65-82.

Peacok, A.R. and Wiseman, J. 1961.The growth of public expenditures in the United Kingdom.Princeton University Press.

Peacock A.T. and Scott A., 2000. The Curious Attraction of Wagner’s Law, Public Choice, 102, 1-2: 1-17.

Persson T. and Roland, G. and Tabellini, G. 1997.Comparative politics and public finance, Working Paper, n0114, Milan IGIER.

Persson, T., Roland, G. And Tabellini, G. 1998. Towards Micropolitical Foundations of Public Finance, European Economic Review, 42: 685-694.

Persson, T. & G. Tabellini 1999. The Size and Scope of Government: Comparative Politics with Rational Politicians, European Economic Review 43, 4-6: 699-735.

Persson, T., Roland, O. and Tabellini, G. 2000. Comparative politics and public finance, Journal of Political Economy, 108: 1121-1161.

Persson, T. and Tabellini, G. 2004.Constitutional rules and Fiscal Policy Outcomes, The American Economic Review, 94: 25-45.

Persson, T., Roland, G. and Tabellini, G. 2007. Electoral rules and government spending in parliamentary democracies, Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 2: 155-188. Pommerehn, W.W. and Schneider, F. 1978. Fiscal illusion, political institutions, and local public spending, Kyklos, 31: 381-408.

Provopoulos, G.A. 1982. Public Spending and Deficits: The Greek Experience, Public Finance/Finances Publiques, 37: 422-427.

Pryor, Frederick L. 1968.Public Expenditure in Communist and Capitalist Nations (London: George Allen and Unwin).

Puviani, A. 1903. Teoria dell’Illusione Finanziana, 1st ed. Palermo, Milano: Instituto Editoriale Internazionale 1973.

Rodrik, D. 2007. One Economics, Many Recipes: Globalisation, Institutions, and Economic Growth, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Rodrik, D. (2008). The New Development Economics : We Shall Experiment, but how shall we Learn ?, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University.

Rodrik, D. (2012). Why We Learn Nothing from Regressing Economic Growth on Policies, Seoul Journal of Economics, 25, 2, 137-151.

Romer T. 1975. Individual Welfare, Majority Voting, and the Properties of a Linear Income Tax, Journal of Public Economics 4, February: 16385.

Rowley, C. and Tollison, R. (1994). Peacok and Wiseman on the growth of public expenditure, Public Choice 78: 125-128.

Yamamura, E. 2010. Government size and trust, Review of Social Economy, 70, 1: 31-56.

Ross, J.M. and Yan, W. 2013. Fiscal Illusion from Property Reassessment? An Empirical test of the Residual View, National Tax Journal, 66, 1: 7-32.

Shelton, C.A. 2007. The Size and Composition of Government Expenditure, Journal of Public Economics, 91, 11: 2230-2260.

Shelton, C.A. 2008. The aging population and the size of the welfare state: Is there a puzzle? Journal of Public Economics 92: 647 – 651.

Sims, C.A. 2010. But Economics Is Not on Experimental Science, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 24, 2: 59-68.

Sinn, H.W. 1996. Social Insurance, incentives and risk taking, International Tax and Public Finance 3: 259-280.

Stichnoth, H. and Van der Straeten, K. 2013. Ethnic Diversity, Public Spending, and Individual Support for the Welfare State: A review of the empirical literature, Journal of Economic Surveys, 27, 2: 364-389.

Stigler, G. 1970. General Economic conditions and national elections, American Economic Reviewx, 63: 160-167.

Storr, V.H. 2010. The Facts of the social sciences ar what people believe and think, in Peter J. Poettke eds Handbook on Contemporary Austrian Economics, Edward Elgar.

Summers, L., Gruber, J. and Vergara, R. 1993. Taxation and the structure of labor markets: The case of corporatism. Quarterly Journal of Economic, 108: 385–411.

Tridimas, G. 1992. Budgetary deficits and government expenditure growth: toward a more accurate empirical specification, Public Finance Quarterly, 20, 3275 – 3297.

Triplett, Jack E. and Bosworth, Barry P. 2003. Baumol’s disease has been cured: it and multifactor productivity in U.S. services industries, Federal Reserve Bank of New York Economic Policy Review FRBNU Economic Policy Review, September, 23-33.

Tullock, G. 1959. Problems of Majority Voting, Journal of Political Economy, 67: 571-579

Tullock, G. 1972. Review of Niskanen’s Bureaucracy and representation government, Public Choice, 12: 119-124.

Uslaner, E.M. and Rothstein, B. 2005. All for One Equality, Corruption and Social Trust, World Politics, 58: 41-72.

Van der Ploeg, Frederick 2007. Sustainable social spending and stagnant public services: Baumol’s cost disease revisited, FinanzArchiv / Public Finance Analysis, Vol. 63, No. 4 (December 2007), pp. 519-547.

West, Edwin G. 1991. Secular cost changes and the size of government. Towards a generalized theory, Journal of Public Economics 45, 363-381.

Wagner, R. 1976. Revenue structure, fiscal illusion and budgetary choice, Public Choice, 25: 45-61.

Wagner, R.E., and W.E. Weber 1977. Wagner’s Law, Fiscal Institutions and the Growth of Government, National Tax Journal, 30, 59-68.

Wang, S. (2002). The political logic of the fiscal transfer system in China, Strategy and Management, 3: 47-54.

Weingast, B. R., Shepsle, K. A., and Johnsen, C. 1981, The Political Economy of Benefits and Costs: A Neoclassical Approach to Distributive Politics. The Journal of Political Economy, 89, 4: 642-664.

Winer, S. 1983.Some evidence on the effects of the separation of the spending and taxing decisions, Journal of Political Economy, 91:126-140.

Winer, S., Tofias, M., Grofman, B. and Aldrich, J. H. 2008.Trending economic factors and the structure of Congress in the growth of government, 1930-2002, Public Choice, 135:415-448.

Woodward, J. 2003. Making Things Happen, New York, Oxford University Press.