Competition policy and development: key issues for developing countries – a briefing

Singh, Ajit and Dhumale, Rahul (1999): Competition policy and development: key issues for developing countries – a briefing. Published in: South Letter , Vol. 2, No. 36 (1 January 2000): pp. 1-31.

Abstract

This paper provides a briefing for developing countries to apprise them of the main issues which are relevant for development and social welfare in relation to the present and prospective discussions on competition policy in the WTO, UNCTAD, OECD and other fora. Although this is the immediate backdrop for an examination of competition policy in relation to economic development, the topic is urgent and important in its own right, because of important new developments in the world economy and because of significant structural changes within developing countries themselves.

The main analytical conclusions for developing countries which emerge from the theoretical and empirical analysis of competition policy and economic development in this paper may be summarized as follows:

1)It is important for developing countries to have a competition policy which is designed to take appropriate account of their level of development and the long term objective of sustained economic growth. This is in part due to the potential effects of the international merger movement and also because of privatization, deregulation and liberalization which have occurred in the domestic economies of most developing countries.

2)A distinction is made in this analysis, between, on the one hand, countries at low levels of development and with meagre institutional capacity and, on the other, semi-industrial countries with greater institutional capabilities. The paper concludes that the types of competition policies adopted by the US and the UK are not appropriate for either group of developing countries.

3)If the concerns of developing countries with respect to competition policy are to be addressed seriously, this paper suggests that the concepts used in the current WTO/OECD/UNCTAD discourse on the subject need to be replaced with new concepts. Specifically, in considering competition policy from a developmental perspective, the paper reaches the following analytical conclusions:

• emphasis should be placed on dynamic rather than static efficiency as the main objective of competition policy for developing countries;

• there should be a concept of ‘optimal degree of competition’ (rather than of maximum competition) to promote long term growth of productivity;

• there should be a related concept of ‘optimal combination of competition and co-operation’ between firms so that developing countries can achieve fast long term economic growth;

• the critical need to maintain the private sector’s propensity to invest at high levels requires a steady growth of profits; for this to occur there is need for government co-ordination of investment decisions which in turn requires close co-operation between government and business;

• there should be recognition of the concept of ‘simulated competition’, which involves contests among those seeking state support and which can be as powerful as real market competition;

• there should be recognition of the importance for developing countries of industrial policy and hence the need for coherence between industrial and competition policies.

However, the paper suggests that the concepts or principles outlined above appear ‘new’ only in relation to the current discussions on competition policy and economic development in the international agencies mentioned earlier. These concepts are fully grounded in modern economic analysis and a number of them are in fact implicit in WTO Agreements themselves but in which they have in fact been used to the advantage of developed countries.

It is argued here that these same principles are also crucial for competition policy in developing countries in order to promote their economic development. For developing countries, the paper recommends they should institute domestic competition policies suited to their stage of development.

The paper also recommends the establishment of an international competition authority, to prevent restrictive business practices and competition-reducing actions of large multinationals which are acquiring even greater market power as a consequence of the current huge wave of mergers and takeovers, both national and international.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Competition, competition policy, economic development, developed and developing countries
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D0 - General; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O2 - Development Planning and Policy

References

Bibliography

Amsden, A.H., (1989)Asia’s Next Giant: South Korea and Late Industrialization, Oxford University Press, New York

Amsden, A. and Singh, A., (1994) The optimal degree of competition and dynamic efficiency in Japan and Korea, in European Economic Review, Vol. 38, Nos. 3/4, p.940–951

Baumol, W. and J.Ordover, (1992) Antitrust: Source of dynamic and static inefficiencies,in Jorde and Teece, p.82-97

Caves,R.E. and M. Uekusa, (1976)Industrial Organization in Japan, The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC

Chang, H.J., (1994)The Political Economy of Industrial Policy,St.Martins Press, New York

Correa, C., (1999)Competition Law and Development Policies, Paper presented at Zurich Seminar on Issues of International Competition Law

Dumont, B., and Holmes, P., (1999) The breadth of intellectual property rights and their interface with competition law and policy: divergent paths to the same goal, in International Conference: Innovation, Appropriation Strategies, and Economic Policy, Paris. Financial Times, October 25, 1999

Economist, January 5-12, 1999

Fox, E., (1999) Can we control Merger control? -- An experiment, Policy Directions for Global Merger Review in Global Competition Review

Golbe, D., and White, L., (1988) A Time Series Analysis of Mergers and Acquisitions in the U.S. Economy, in Corporate Takeovers: Causes and Consequences, ed., Auerbach, A., University of Chicago Press, Chicago

Graham, E., and Richardson, J., (1997)Competition Policies for the Global Economy, Institute for International Economics, Washington

Howes, C. and Singh, A., eds., Competitiveness Matters: Industry and Economic Performance in the US, Forthcoming September 1999, University of Michigan Press: Ann Arbor

Hughes, A., (1992) Competition Policy and the competitive process: Europe in the 1990s, in Metroeconomica, Vol. 43, No. 1-2, p.1-50

Hughes, A. and Singh, A., (1980) Mergers, concentration and competition in advanced capitalist economies: An international perspective, in The Determinants and Effects of Mergers: An International Comparison, Oelgeschlager, Gunn and Hain: Cambridge, MA

International Monetary Fund (1998) World Economic Outlook, October 1998

Jenny, F., (1999) International Merger Control, in Policy Directions for Global Merger Review in Global Competition Review

Johnson, C., Tyson, L., and Zysman, J., (1989) Politics and Productivity: How Japan’s Development Strategy Works Harper Business: New York

Jorde, T. and D.Teece, eds., (1992)Antitrust, innovation and competitiveness,Oxford University Press, New York

Khemani, S., and Schone, R., (1998) International Competition Conflict Resolution, in PSD Occasional Paper No. 33,World Bank: Washington

Khemani, S., (1999) International Mergers Activity: Some Concerns for Developing and Emerging Economies, in Policy Directions for Global Merger Review in Global Competition Review

Laffont, J., (1998) Competition, Information, and Development, in Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics, World Bank, Washington

Nolan, P., (1998) Globalization, big business, and industrial policy in developing countries, Judge Institute of Management Studies, Cambridge

OECD, (1986),The OECD Guidelines for Multinational Entreprises, OECD, Paris

Okimoto, D. I., (1989)Between the MITI and the market, Stanford University Press:Stanford

Radelet, S., and Sachs, J., (1998)The East Asian Financial Crisis: Diagnosis, Remedies, and Prospects, HIID, Massachusetts

Scherer, F., (1994)Competition Policy for an Integrated World Economy,Brookings Institution, Washington, DC

Scherer, F., and Ross, D., (1990)Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance,Houghton Mifflin, Boston

Singh, A., (1971)Takeovers: Their Relevance to the Stock Market and the Theory of the Firm,Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

Singh, A., (1992) Corporate takeovers, in The New Palgrave Dictionary of Money and Finance, edited by Eatwell, J., Milgate, M., and Newman, P., Macmillan: London and New York

Singh, A., (1993) Regulation of mergers: A new agenda, in Industrial Economic Regulation: A Framework and an Exploration, Sugden, Roger ed., Routledge, London

Singh, A., (1995a), Corporate Financial Patterns in Industrialising Economies: A Comparative International Study, IFC Technical Paper No. 2, World Bank, Washington, DC., ISBN 0-8213-3231-7

Singh, A., (1995b) Institutional requirements for full employment in advanced economies, in International Labour Review,Vol. 135, No. 4–5

Singh, A., (1996)Expansion of trading opportunities to the year 2000 for Asia-Pacific Developing countries: Implications of the Uruguay Round and Adaptation of Export Strategies,UNCTAD, New York, Geneva

Singh, A., (1998) Savings, investment and the corporation in the East Asian miracle, Journal of Development Studies, Vol. 34, No. 6, pp. 112-137

Singh, A., (1999a) Global Unemployment, Long-run Economic Growth and Labour Market Rigidities: A Commentary, A Special Contribution in Perspectives on Globalization and Employment, Dibroy, B. (ed.), Office of Development Studies Discussion Paper Series, UNDP, p. 50 - 69

Singh, A., (1999b) Asian capitalism and the financial crisis, in Global Instability and World Economic Governance, Grieve-Smith, J., and Michie, J., eds.,Routledge, London

Singh, A. and Weisse, B., (1999) The Asian model: A crisis foretold? In International Social Science Journal,No. 160, p.203-215

Stiglitz, J., (1999)Two principles for the next round, or how to bring developing countries in from the cold, Speech, Geneva, September 1999

Tsuru, S., (1993)Japan’s Capitalism: Creative defeat and Beyond,Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

UNCTAD (1995)Trade and Development Report,United Nations, New York, Geneva

UNCTAD (1999)Trade and Development Report,United Nations, New York, Geneva

US Council of Economic Advisors (1999)Economic Report of the President

Waverman, L.,Comanor, W., and Goto, A., (1997)Competition Policy in the Global Economy: Modalities for Co-operation, Routledge Studies in the Modern World Economy: London

World Bank, (1991)The Challenge of Development: World Development Report,World Bank:Washington, DC

World Bank, (1998)Global Economic Prospects,World Bank, Washington, DC

World Trade Organization (1997)Annual Report,WTO, Geneva

World Trade Organization (1998)Report of the working group on the interaction between trade and competition policy to the general council,WTO, Geneva

World Trade Organization (1999)Report of the working group on the interaction between trade and competition policy to the general council, WT/WGTCP/3 WTO, Geneva