South Africa urgently needs a ‘social compact / dialogue’: are there any historical lessons to learn from Irish system of social compacts?

Gwaindepi, Abel (2014): South Africa urgently needs a ‘social compact / dialogue’: are there any historical lessons to learn from Irish system of social compacts?

Abstract

In the face of sluggish economic growth, debilitating triangle of unemployment, poverty and inequality the South African policy makers are at their wit’s end. Recognisably, most stake holders are evoking the need to forge a ‘Social Compact/ dialogue’ if South Africa will make significant strides in solving its problems. The latest contested policy framework, the National Development Plan (2012), also revoke the need for “A social compact to reduce poverty and inequality, and raise employment and investment.” Ireland provides some lessons for the needed social compacts in South Africa since it managed to pursue the route of policy negotiations when it was hit by an economic crisis in 1987. The Irish compacts were without problems and there is no consensus as to the real effects of the social compacts implemented in Ireland. This paper argues that Social compacts in South Africa are a possibility albert with huge challenges to be overcome before they can be achieved and the Irish case illuminates such challenges.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Social compacts, unions,partnerships, the state, development, Irish social compacts,
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations

References

ALLEN, K. (2000). The Celtic Tiger: The Myth of Social Parnership in Ireland Reviews http://cdj.oxfordjournals.org/content/37/1.

BACCARO, L and SIMONI, M. (2004). The Irish social partnership and the “Celtic tiger” phenomenon. International Labor Organization (International Institute for Labour Studies. BACCARO, L and SIMONI, M. (2007). Centralized Wage Bargaining and the “CelticTiger” Phenomenon: Industrial Relations 46, (3): 426-455.

BARTOLOMEO, G ACOCELLA, N, and TIRELLI, P. (2005). The macroeconomics ofsocial pacts http://dipeco.economia.unimib.it.

CALMFORS, L. and DRIFFILL, J. (1988). Bargaining structure, corporatism, and macroeconomic performance, Economic Policy 6: 14–61.

CAWSON, A. (1982). Corporatism and Welfare : Social Policy and State intervention in Britian. Heinemann Educational Books London.

CAWSON, A. (1985), “Introduction. Varieties of corporatism: the importance of the meso-level of interest intermediation”. In Alan Cawson (ed.), Organized Interests and the State. Studies in Meso-Corporatism. London, Sage Publication.

CHANG, HJ. (2007). Bad Samaritans : The Gulty Secrets of Rich Nations and The Threat to Global Prosperity. Random House Business Books, London Britain.

D’ART, D and TURNER, T. (2003). Union recognition in Ireland: one step forward or two steps back? Industrial Relations Journal 34 (3): 226-240.

D’ART, D and TURNER, T. (2011). Irish trade unions under social partnership: a Faustian bargain? Industrial Relations Journal 42(2): 157–173.

DONAGHEY, J. and TEAGUE, P. (2007). The Mixed Fortunes of Irish Unions: Living with the Paradoxes of Social Partnership. Journal of Labour Research,28(1):19-41.

DONAGHEY, J. and TEAGUE, P. (2009). Social Partnership and Democratic Legitimacy in Ireland. New Political Economy, 14 (1):49-69.

DORGAN, S. (2006). How Ireland Became the Celtic Tiger: The Heritage Foundation No 1945 http://www.heritage.org/research/reports.

FINN, D. (2011). Ireland on The turn? : Political and Economic Consequences of the Crash. New Left Review, 67:5-39.

FRAILE,L. (2010). Blunting Neoliberalim : Tripartism and Economic Reforms in the Developing World. International Labour Organisation and Palgrave Macmillan.

GEARY, J. (2008). Do Unions Benefit from Working in Partnership with Employers? Evidence from Ireland. Industrial Relations, 47 (4):530-568.

HARDIMAN, N. (2002): From Conflict to Co-ordination: Economic Governance and Political Innovation in Ireland, West European Politics, 25(4): 1-24.

HONOHAN, P. (2009). What Went Wrong in Ireland? : Prepared for the World Bank-Trinity College Dublin.

HOUSE, D. and McGRATH, K. (2004). Innovative Governance and Development in the New Ireland: Social Partnership and the Integrated Approach. An International Journal of Policy, Administration, and Institutions, 17(1): 29-58.

HUDSON, M. (2012). How the Banks Broke the Social Compact, Promoting their Own Special Interests. http://www.globalresearch.ca.

KELLY, E. MCGUINNESS, S and O’CONNELL, P J. (2010). The Impact of Wage Bargaining Regime on Firm-Level Competitiveness and Wage Inequality: The Case of Ireland. Industrial relations,49 (4): 593-615.

KIRBY, P. and MURPHY, M. (2011). Globalisation and Models of State: Debates and Evidence from Ireland .http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs.

KIRBY, P. (2012). When Banks Cannibalize The State: Responses to Ireland’s Economic Collapse. http://www3.ul.ie/peadarkirby/kirbypublications.

Lehmbruch, G. (1979). Liberal corporatism and party government, in Schmitter,P and Lehmbruch, G (eds.), Trends toward corporatist intermediation (pp. 147–183)Sage publication London.

McDONOUGH, T.and DUNDON, T.(2010). Thatcherism delayed? The Irish crisis and the paradox of social partnership. Industrial Relations Journal, 41 (6): 544‐562.

MURPHY, M.(2010). What future lies ahead for the Irish welfare state: Department of Sociology, National University of Ireland, Maynooth.

MURPHY, M.(2012). Social compacting :The Irish Story. Social Policy Seminar Rhodes University.

O’DONNELL, R. (20010. The Future of Social Partnership in Ireland. A Discussion Paper Prepared for the National Competitiveness Council.

O’DONNELL, R and O’REARDON, C. (2000). Social Partnership in Ireland’s Economic Transformation. European Trade Union Institute.

O’DONNELL, R. (2001). The Role of Social Partnership. An Irish Quarterly Review, Vol. 90, (357): 47-57.

OECD LEED Forum on Partnerships and Local Governance handbooks. http://www.oecd.org/cfe/leed/45204566.pdf.

O'HAGAN, J. (1992). Distributional Aspects of Ireland's Fiscal Adjustment: A Comment: The Economic and Social Review, 23 (3): 343-345.

REGAN, A. (2011). The Political Economy of Social Pacts in the EMU: Irish Liberal Market Corporatism in Crisis. New Political Economy DOI:10.1080.

REGINI, M. (2003) Tripartite Concertation and Varieties of Capitalism. European Journal of Industrial Relations, 9(3):251-263.

SCHIMITTER, P. (1974). Still the Century of Corporatism? The Review of Politics, 36 ( 1): 85-131.

SIAROFF, A. (1999). Corporatism in 24 industrial democracies: Meaning and measurement. European Journal of Political Research 36: 175–205.

TEAGUE, P and DONAGHEY, J. (2007). The Mixed Fortunes of Irish Unions: Living with the Paradoxes of Social Partnership: Journal of Labor Research 18(1): 19-41.

TEAGUE, P and DONAGHEY, J. (2009). Why has Irish Social Partnership Survived: British Journal of Industrial Relations 47, (1): 55-78.

THE ECONOMIST (2010). The cruelty of compassion: Social cohesion has become an excuse for avoiding necessary reforms in Europe. http://www.economist.com/node/1539396.

THE PNR (1987). THE PROGRAMME FOR NATIONAL RECOVERY (PNR), The Irish Government Publication .

VISSER, J. (2006). Union Membership Statistics in 24 Countries: University of Amsterdam, Netherlands: http://digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/key.

WALSH, B. (2003). When Unemployment Disappears: Ireland in 1990S: CESIFO Conference on in Europe. Working Paper no. 856.

WATKINS, T. (2012). The Economic System of Corporatism. http://www.sjsu.edu/faculty/watkins/corporatism.htm.

WHITE, R. (2010). Years of high income largely wasted: Irish Macro comment. http://www.davy.ie/content/pubarticles/economy20100219.

WILLIAMSON, PJ. (1989). Corporatism in Perspective: An introductory guide to corporatist theory. SAGE publication ltd London.

WOLDENDORP, J. (2011). Corporatism in small North-West European countries 1970-2006: Business as usual, decline, or a new phenomenon? Working Paper Series Department of Political Science .VU University Amsterdam.