The Lame Drain

Dong, Baomin and Fu, Shihe and Gong, Jiong and Fan, Hanwen (2014): The Lame Drain.

Abstract

This paper develops a signaling theory where brain drain as well as the opposite of brain drain, a phenomenon we call “lame-drain” can result. In particular, we assume there are three types of agents according to their intrinsic abilities; education (with endogenous intensity) consists of two stages: undergraduate and graduate. There are two types of jobs: entry level and managerial. It is shown that under some circumstances the equilibrium is semi-pooling where the medium type chooses to work after undergraduate education while (a fraction of) both high and low types pursue graduate studies at home and abroad. Some high and low ability students return to work in the indigenous country in equilibrium. However, our model differs from the traditional brain drain models in that some low ability agents also go abroad in equilibrium and work in the host country after graduation, resulting in the recipient country hiring low ability agents, a phenomenon we call lame-drain. We then provide empirical evidence that lame-drain is indeed happening using U.S. Census data.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Brain Drain; Lame Drain; Signalling
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C7 - Game Theory and Bargaining Theory > C72 - Noncooperative Games; F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F22 - International Migration; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers

References

[1] Beine M, Docquier F, Rapoport H (2001) Brain Drain and Economic Growth: Theory and Evidence. Journal of Development Economics 64:275-289.

[2] Bhagwati J, Hamada K (1974) The Brain Drain, International Integration of Markets for Professional and Unemployment. Journal of Development Economics 1:19-24.

[3] Carrington, William J. and Detragiache, Enrica, (1998). How Big is the Brain Drain? IMF Working paper no. 201.

[4] Commander S, Kangasniemi M, Winters LA (2002) The Brain Drain: Curse or Boon? A Survey of the Literature. International Seminar on International Trade, Stockholm, 24-25 May.

[5] Commander, S., Kangasniemi, M., Winters, L.A., (2003), The brain drain: curse or boom? IZA Discussion Paper, vol. 809.

[6] Fang, H., (2006) Disentangling the university Wage Premium: Estimating a Model with Endogenous Education Choices. International Economic Review 47(4): 1151-1185.

[7] Fan, Simon and Oded Stark, (2007), International migration and educated unemployment, Journal of Development Economics 83: 76-87.

[8] Fan, Simon and Oded Stark, (2011), A Theory of Migration as a Response to Occupational Stigma, International Economic Review. 52(2): 549-571.

[9] Fu, Shihe and Stephen L. Ross, (2013), Wage Premia in Employment Clusters: How Important Is Worker Heterogeneity, Journal of Labor Economics, 31: 271-304.

[10] Gibson, John and David McKenzie, (2011), Eight Questions about Brain Drain, Journal of Economic Perspectives. 25(3): 107-128.

[11] Hamada, Koichi ; Bhagwati, Jagdish N., 1975. Domestic Distortions, Imperfect Information and the Brain Drain. Journal of Development Economics, pp. 265-79.

[12] Hunter, Rosalind S., Andrew J. Oswald and Bruce G. Charlton, (2009), The Elite Brain Drain, The Economic Journal, 119, 231-251.

[13] Jeon, Doh-Shin and Domenico Menicucci, (2008), Money, fame and the allocation of talent: Brain drain and the institution of science, Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 66: 558—581.

[14] Katz E, and Stark O (1987) International Migration under Asymmetric Information. Economic Journal 97:718-726 [15] Kwok, V., and H. Leland (1982), An Economic Model of the Brain Drain, American Economic Review, 72(1): 91-100.

[16] Lee, S. (2007) The timing of signaling to study in high school or in college? International Economic Review, 48(3): 785-807.

[17] Lien D (1987a) Asymmetric Information and Multi-stage Brain Drain. Economics Letters 23: 305-309.

[18] Lien D (1987b) Economic Analysis of Brain Drain. Journal of Development Economics 25:33-53.

[19] Lien D (1988) Appropriate Scientific Research and Brain Drain: a Simple Model. Journal of Development Economics 29:77-87.

[20] Lien, D, and Wang, Y. (2005), Brain drain or brain gain: A revisit. Journal of Population Economics 18, 1, 153-163.

[21] Mattoo, Aaditya, Neagu, Ileana Cristina and Ça˘glar Özden, (2008), Brain waste? Educated immigrants in the US labor market, Journal of Development Economics, 87(2), 255-269.

[22] Miyagiwa, K (1991) Scale Economies in Education and the Brain Drain Problem. International Economic Review 32:743-759.

[23] Mountford, A., (1997), Can a Brain Drain be Good for Economy in the Source Economy? Journal of Development Economics 53:287-303.

[24] OECD, (2001). Trends in International Migration, OECD, Paris.

[25] OECD, (2001b). International Mobility of Highly Skilled, OECD, Paris.

[26] Ortin-Angel, P. and Salas-Fumas, V. (2007) Compensation dispersion between and within hierarchical levels, Journal of Economics and Management Strategy, 16(1): 53—79.

[27] Ostrovsky, Michael; and Schwarz, Michael., (2003) Equilibrium Information Disclosure: Grade Inflation and Unraveling, Working paper, Harvard University, 2003.

[28] Reitz, J.H., (2001), Immigrant skill utilization in the Canadian labor market: implications of human capital research. Journal of International Migration and Integration 2, 347-378.

[29] Rodriguez, C.A., (1975), Brain Drain and Economic Growth: A dynamic model. Journal of Development Economics 223-248.

[30] Spence, Michael. Job Market Signaling, Quarterly Journal of Economics 87,1973: 355-374.

[31] Spence, M. (1974).Market Signaling, Information Transfer in Hiring and Related Processes. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

[32] Spence, M., (1976), Competition in Salaries, Credentials, and Signalling Prerequisites for Jobs, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 90, 51-74.

[33] Stark O, Helmenstein C, Prskawetz A (1997) A Brain Gain with a Brain Drain. Economics Letters 55:227-234.

[34] Stark O, Helmenstein C, Prskawetz A (1998) Human Capital Depletion, Human Capital Formation, and Migration: a Blessing in a "Curse"? Economics Letters 60:363-367.

[35] Stark O, Wang Y (2002) Inducing Human Capital Formation: Migration as a Substitute for Subsidies. Journal of Development Economics 86:29-6.

[36] Steven Ruggles, J. Trent Alexander, Katie Genadek, Ronald Goeken, Matthew B. Schroeder, and Matthew Sobek. (2010) Integrated Public Use Microdata Series: Version 5.0 [Machine-readable database]. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota.

[37] Swinkels, J. M. (1999). Education Signalling with Preemptive Offers. Review of Economic Studies 66: 949-970. [38] Trostel, Philip, IanWalker, and Paul Woolley, (2002), Estimates of the economic return to schooling for 28 countries, Labour Economics 9: 1-16.

[39] Trum C, Uebelmesser S (2003) Brain Gain and the Transferability of Skills. Mimeo, University of Munich 2000, Munich.

[40] Vidal JP (1998) The Effect of Emigration on Human Capital Formation. Journal of Population Economics 11:589-600.

[41] Zhang K (2001) Human Capital Investment and Flows: a Multiperiod Model for China. 6th International Metropolis Conference, Nov 26-30, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.

[42] Zweig, D., S.-F. Chung, and D. Han, (2008), Redefining the Brain Drain: China’s Diaspora Option, Science, Technology and Society 13, 1—33.