Are active labour market policies effective in activating and integrating low-skilled individuals? An international comparison

Escudero, Veronica (2014): Are active labour market policies effective in activating and integrating low-skilled individuals? An international comparison.

Abstract

This paper examines the effectiveness of active labour market policies (ALMP) in improving labour market outcomes, especially of low-skilled individuals. The empirical analysis consists of an aggregate impact approach based on a pooled cross country and time-series database for 31 advanced countries during the period 1985–2010. A novelty of the paper is that the analysis includes aspects of the delivery system to see how the performance of ALMP is affected by different implementation characteristics. Among the notable results, the paper finds that ALMP matters at the aggregate level. Training, employment incentives, supported employment and direct job creation measures show the most favourable results, both, in terms of reduced unemployment, but also in terms of increased employment and participation. Interestingly, start-up incentives are more effective in reducing unemployment than other ALMP policies. Moreover, the positive effects seem to be particularly beneficial for the low-skilled. In terms of implementation, the paper finds that the most favourable aspect is the allocation of resources to programme administration. Finally, a disruption of policy continuity is associated with negative effects for all labour market variables analysed.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: unemployment, employment, participation rate, active labour market policies, implementation, public employment services, training, start-up incentives.
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy > E24 - Employment ; Unemployment ; Wages ; Intergenerational Income Distribution ; Aggregate Human Capital ; Aggregate Labor Productivity; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H53 - Government Expenditures and Welfare Programs; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J0 - General > J08 - Labor Economics Policies; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers

References

Abbring, J.H., and Heckman, J.J 2007. “Econometric evaluation of social programs, part III: Distributional treatment effects, dynamic treatment effects, dynamic discrete choice, and general equilibrium policy evaluation” in Heckman, J.J. and Leamer, E.E. (eds.): Handbook of econometrics, Vol. 6, pp. 5145–5303.

Anelli, M.; Catania, A.; Basso, G.; Colussi, T.; Monti, P.; Zhelyazkova M.; Eichhorst, W. No date. fRDB-IZA Reforms Database.

Anxo, D.; Carcillo, S.; and Erhel, C. 2001. “Aggregate impact analysis of active labour market policy in France and Sweden: a regional approach”, in de Koning, j. and Mosley, H. (eds.): Labour Market Policy and Unemployment: impact and process evaluations in selected European countries, Edward Elgar, pp. 49–76.

Armingeon, K.; Knöpfel, L.; Weisstanner, D.; Engler, S.; Potolidis, P.; and Gerber, M. 2013a. “Comparative Political Data Set I 1960-2011”. Bern: Institute of Political Science, University of Bern.

Armingeon, K.; Careja. R.; Knöpfel, L.; Weisstanner, D.; Engler, S.; Potolidis, P.; and Gerber, M. 2013b. “Comparative Political Data Set III 1990-2011”. Bern: Institute of Political Science, University of Berne.

Armingeon, K.; and Careja. R. 2007. “Comparative Data Set for 28 Post-Communist Countries, 1989-2007”. Bern: Institute of Political Science, University of Berne.

Baum, C. 2006. An Introduction to Modern Econometrics Using Stata, Stata Press.

Bellmann, L. and Jackman, R. 1996a. “Aggregate Impact Analysis”, in Schmid, G. O’Reilly, J. and Schömann, K. (eds.): International Handbook of Labour Market Policy and Evaluation, Edward Elgar, pp. 143–162.

—. 1996b. “The impact of labour market policy on wages, employment and labour market mismatch”, in Schmid, G. O’Reilly, J. and Schömann, K. (eds.): International Handbook of Labour Market Policy and Evaluation, Edward Elgar, pp. 725–746.

Bellmann, L. and Lehmann, H. 1990. “Active Labour Market Policies in Britain and Germany and Long-term Unemployment: An Evaluation”, paper presented to the Conference of the European Association of Labour Economists, Lund, Sweden.

Bertola, G.; Blau, F.; Kahn, L. 2002. “Labor Market Institutions and Demographic Employment Patterns”, New York: NBER Working Paper No. 9043.

Bjorklund, A. and Holmlund, B. 1991. “The economics of unemployment insurance: the case of Sweden”, in Bjorklund, A. et al. (eds.): Labour Market Policy and Unemployment Insurance, FIEF Studies in Labour Market and Economic Policy, Oxford University Press.

Blanchard, O. and Diamond, P. 1989. “The Beveridge Curve”, in Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Vol. 20, Issue 1, pp. 1–76.

Blöndal, S. and Scarpetta, S. 1998. “The retirement decision in OECD countries”, Paris: OECD Economics Department Working Papers No. 202.

Blundell, R. and Costa Dias, M. 2000. “Evaluation methods for non‐experimental data”, in Fiscal studies Vol. 21, Issue 4, pp. 427–468.

Blundell, R., Costa Dias, M., Meghir, C., and van Reenen, J. 2004. “Evaluating the employment effects of a mandatory job search program” in Journal of the European Economic Association, Vol. 2, Issue 4, pp. 569–606.

Bourguignon, F.; Bussolo, M.; and Pereira da Silva, L. 2008. eds. The impact of macroeconomic policies on poverty and income distribution: macro-micro evaluation techniques and tools. World Bank.

Büttner, T. and Prey, H. 1997. “Does Active Labour Market Policy Affect Structural employment? And Empirical Investigation for West German Regions, 1986 to 1993”, CILE Discussion Paper No. 42, Universität von Konstanz.

Cahuc, P. and Carcillo, S. 2011. “Is Short-Time Work a Good Method to Keep Unemployment Down?” IZA Discussion Paper No. 5430.

Caliendo, M. and Künn, S. 2013. “Regional Effect Heterogeneity of Start-Up Subsidies for the Unemployed”, IZA Discussion Paper No. 7460.

Calmfors L. 1994. “Active Labour Market Policy and Unemployment – A Framework for the Analysis of Crucial Design Features”, in OECD Economic Studies, No. 22.

Calmfors, L. and Skendinger, P. 1995. “Does active labour market policy increase employment? – Theoretical considerations and some empirical evidence from Sweden”, Seminar Paper No. 590, Institute for International Economic Studies, Stockholm University.

Calmfors L. and Lang H. 1995. “Macroeconomic effects of active labour market programmes in a Union Wage-Setting Model”, in The Economic Journal, Vol. 105, No. 430, pp. 601–619.

Carpenter, H. 2006. Repeat Jobseeker’s Allowance spells, Research Report No. 394, Department for Work and Pensions, London.

Cebrián, I.; Moreno, G.; and Toharia, L. 2011. “La Estabilidad Laboral y los Programas de Fomento de la Contratación Indefinida”, in Hacienda Pública Española/Revista de Economía Pública, Vol. 198, pp. 103–127.

Clasen, J. and Clegg, D. 2006. “Beyond Activation: Reforming European Unemployment Protection Systems in Post‐Industrial Labour Markets”, in European Societies, Vol. 8, Issue 4, pp. 527–553.

Dauth, W.; Hujer, R. and Wolf, K. 2010. “Macroeconometric Evaluations of Active Labour Market Policies in Austria”, IZA Discussion Paper No. 5217.

Davia, M.; García-Serrano, C.; Hernanz, V.; Malo, M.A.; and Toharia Cortés, L. 2001. “Do active labour market policies matter in Spain?”, in de Koning, J. and Mosley, H. (eds.): Labour Market Policy and Unemployment: impact and process evaluations in selected European countries, Edward Elgar, pp. 78–114.

Dawson, J. F. 2014. “Moderation in management research: What, why, when and how”, Journal of Business and Psychology, Vol. 29, pp. 1–19.

de Koning, J. 2007. “Is the changing pattern in the use of active labour market policies consistent with what evaluations tell us about their relative performance?”, in de Koning, J. (ed.): The Evaluation of Active Labour Market Policies. Measures, Public Private Partnerships and Benchmarking, Edward Elgar, pp. 23–45.

—. 2001. “Aggregate impact analysis of active labour market policy: A literature review”, in International Journal of Manpower, Vol. 22, Issue 8, pp. 707–735.

—. 1993. “Measuring the placement effects of two wage-subsidy schemes for the long-term unemployment”, in Empirical Economics, Vol. 18, Issue 3, pp. 447–468.

de Koning, J. and Arents, M. 2001. “The impact of active labour market policy on job hirings and unemployment in the Netherlands”, in de Koning, J. and Mosley, H. (eds.): Labour Market Policy and Unemployment: impact and process evaluations in selected European countries, Edward Elgar, pp. 78–114.

—. 1997. “The impact of active labour market policy on the transition from unemployment to employment”, paper prepared for the 9th EALE Conference, Aarhus: 25–29 September.

de Koning, J. and van Nes, P.J. 1991. “A quantitative approach to process evaluation: the case of the Vermeend-Moor Act”, in Government and Policy, Vol. 9, pp. 111–118.

den Butter, F.A.G and van Ours, J.C. 1990. “Stock and Flows in the Dutch Labour Market: a quarterly simulation model”, in Serie Research Memoranda, No. 0059, VU University Amsterdam, Faculty of Economics, Business Administration and Econometrics.

Driehuis, W. 1978. “Labour Market Imbalances and Structural Unemployment”, in Kyklos, Vol. 31, Issue 4, pp. 638–661.

Drukker, D.M. 2003. “Testing for Serial Correlation in Linear Panel-Data Models”, in Stata Journal, Vol. 3, pp. 168–177.

Eichhorst, W. and Konle-Seidl, R. 2008. “Contingent Convergence: A Comparative Analysis of Activation Policies”, IZA Discussion Paper, No. 3905.

Ernst, E. and Rani, U. 2011. “Understanding unemployment flows”, in Oxford Review of Economic Policy, Vol. 27, No. 2, pp. 268–294.

European Commission. 2003. Green paper entrepreneurship in Europe.

—. 1996. Employment in Europe, Directorate-General for Employment and Social Affairs.

Eurostat. 2013a. Qualitative report: Austria 2011, Labour market policy statistics.

García-Pérez, J.I. and Rebollo, Y. 2009. “The Use of Permanent Contracts across Spanish Regions: Do Regional Wage Subsides Work?”, in Investigaciones Económicas, Vol. 33, pp. 97–130.

Graversen, B.K. and van Ours, J.C. 2008. “How to help the unemployed find jobs quickly: Experimental evidence from a mandatory activation program”, in Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 92, Issue 10–11, pp. 2020–2035.

Harper, I.R. 1980. “The Relationship between Unemployment and Unfilled Vacancies in Australia, 1952–1978”, in The Economic Record, Vol. 56, Issue 154, pp. 231–342.

Haveman, R. and Hollister, R. 1991. “Direct job creation: economic evaluation and lessons for the United States and Western Europe”, in Bjorklund, A. et al. (eds.): Labour Market Policy and Unemployment Insurance, FIEF Studies in Labour Market and Economic Policy, Oxford University Press.

Heckman, J.J.; Lochner, L.; and Taber, C. 1998. “General equilibrium treatment effects: A study of tuition policy”. NBER Working Paper No. 6426.

Hujer, R.; Rodrigues, P; and Wolf, K. 2009. “Estimating the macroeconomic effects of active labour market policies using spatial econometric methods”, in International Journal of Manpower, Vol. 30, Issue 7, pp. 648–671.

Imbens, G.M., and Wooldridge, J.M. 2008. “Recent developments in the econometrics of program evaluation”, in Journal of Economic Literature 47, No. 1, pp. 5–86.

Johnson, G.E. and Layard, R. 1986. “The natural rate of unemployment: explanation and policy”, in Ashenfelter, O. and Layard, R. (eds.): Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 2, pp. 921–999.

Lalive, R.; van Ours, J.C.; and Zweimüller, J. 2005. “The Effect of Benefit Sanctions on the Duration of Unemployment”, in Journal of the European Economic Association, Vol. 3, Issue 6, pp. 1386–1417.

Layard R. and Nickell S. 1986. “Unemployment in Britain”, in Economica, New Series, Vol. 53, No. 210, Supplement: Unemployment (1986), pp. S121–S169.

Layard R.; Nickell S. and Jackman R. 2009. Unemployment: Macroeconomic Performance and the Labour Market, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

—. 1991. Unemployment: Macroeconomic Performance and the Labour Market, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Lee, D. 2005. “An estimable dynamic general equilibrium model of work, schooling, and occupational choice”, in International Economic Review, Vol. 46, Issue 1, pp. 1–34.

Lee, D., and Wolpin, K.I. 2006. “Intersectoral labor mobility and the growth of the service sector”. In Econometrica, Vol. 74, Issue 1, pp. 1–40.

Lusinyan, L.; and Bonato, L. 2007. “Work Absence in Europe”, in IMF Staff Papers, Vol. 54, No. 3.

Marshal, M.G.; Gurr, T.; Jaggers, K. 2013. “Political Regime Characteristics and Transition, 1800-2012 – PolityTM IV Project”, Center for Systemic Peace and Societal-Systems Research Inc.

Martin, J.P.; and Grubb, D. 2001. “What works and for whom: a review of OECD countries’ experience with active labour market policies”, in Swedish Economic Policy Review, Vol. 8, No. 2, pp. 9–56.

Neumark, D. 2011. “Policies to Encourage Job Creation: Hiring Credits vs. Worker Subsidies”, NBER Working Paper No. 16866.

Nickel, S. and Bell, B. 1997. “Would cutting payroll taxes on the unskilled have a significant impact on unemployment?”, in Snower, D. J. and de la Dehesa, G. (eds.): Unemployment Policy: Government Options for the Labour Market, CEPR: pp. 296–328.

OECD. 2012. Education at a Glance 2012: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Table A7.1b.

—. 2011. Education at a Glance 2011: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Table A7.1b.

—. 2010. Education at a Glance 2010: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Table A6.1b.

—. 2009. Education at a Glance 2009: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Table A6.1b.

—. 2008. Education at a Glance 2008: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Table A8.1b.

—. 2007. Education at a Glance 2007: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Table A8.1b..

—. 2006. Education at a Glance 2006: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Table A8.1b.

—. 2005. Education at a Glance 2005: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Table A8.1b.

—. 2004. Education at a Glance 2004: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Table A10.2a.

—. 1994. “Job Study”, Evidence and explanations, Paris.

—. 1993. “Active labour market policies: Assessing macroeconomic and microeconomic effects”, in Employment Outlook, Chapter 2, Paris.

Ohlsson, H. 1995. “Job Creation Programmes as Stabilisation Policy Measures”, in J. Johannesson and E. Wadensjö (eds.): Labour Market Policy at the Crossroad, Expert Group for Labour Market Policy Evaluation Studies (EFA), Ministry of Labour, Report No. 34, pp. 29–55.

Pissarides, C. 1990. Equilibrium Unemployment Theory, Blackwell.

Phelps, E.S. 1970. “Money wage dynamics and labour market equilibrium”, in Phelps, E.S. et al. (eds.): Micreconomic Foundations of Employment and Inflation Theory, Macmillan.

Román, C.; Congregado, E.; and Millán, J.M. 2013. “Start-up incentives: Entrepreneurship policy or active labour market programme?”, in Journal of Business Venturing, Vol. 28, Issue 1, pp. 151–175.

Roodman, D. 2006. “How to Do xtabond2: An Introduction to “Difference” and “System” GMM in Stata”, Working Paper 103, Center for Global Development, Washington.

Rosholm, M. and Svarer, M. 2008. “The Threat Effect of Active Labour Market Programmes”, in Scandinavian Journal of Economics, Vol. 110, Issue 2, pp. 385–401.

Schmid, G.; Speckesser, S.; and Hilbert, C. 2001. “Does active labour market policy matter? An aggregate impact analysis for Germany”, in de Koning, J. and Mosley, H. (eds.): Labour Market Policy and Unemployment: impact and process evaluations in selected European countries, Edward Elgar, pp. 78–114.

Schmid, G. 1996. “New Public Management of Further Training”, in Schmid, G. O’Reilly, J. and Schömann, K. (eds.): International Handbook of Labour Market Policy and Evaluation, Edward Elgar, pp. 725–746.

UNESCO. 1997. International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED), November 1997.

Visser, J. 2011. Data Base Institutional Characteristics of Trade Unions, Wage Setting, State Intervention and Social Pacts, 1960–2010 (ICTWSS), version 3.0, Amsterdam Institute for Advanced Labour Studies AIAS, University of Amsterdam.

Warren, R. 1980. “Unemployment and Unfilled Vacancies in U.S. Manufacturing: a Search Turn-over View”, in Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 62, pp. 292–95.

Wooldridge, J.M. 2002. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data, Cambridge, Massachusetts, MIT Press.