The Merit Order Effect of Wind Generation on the Irish Electricity Market

O'Mahoney, Amy and Denny, Eleanor (2011): The Merit Order Effect of Wind Generation on the Irish Electricity Market.

Abstract

This paper considers the cost savings arising from wind generation through the merit order effect in gross pool electricity markets, using the Irish electricity market as a case study. The Irish electricity market makes for a good testing ground due to the fact that it is a single market with very little interconnection to other markets, allowing impacts of wind to be more clearly identified than on a more interconnected system. Ireland also has extremely ambitious renewable energy targets, resulting in a high penetration of wind generation. The authors estimate the historic cost savings arising from wind generation in the Irish electricity marketusing an hourly time series OLS regression model for 2009. We find that the value of wind to the market dispatch has resulted in savings of €141 million to the market dispatch. We find that the total costs to the market would have been in the region of 12% higher over the course of the year had no wind output been available. These savings are significantly greater than the subsidy received for wind-generated electricity over this time period, and as a result it can be seen that the positive externalities derived from wind generated electricity outweigh the cost of the subsidy; particularly when one considers the CO2 saving to the market and accepts that all forms of generation impose integration costs to electricity systems.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Electricity Markets; Renewable Energy; Merit Order Effect
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy

References

CAA (2008). Clean Air Act as of 2008, U.S. Government Printing Office.

CER (2006). Public Service Obligation Levy 2007 - A Decision by the Commission for Energy Regulation.

CER (2007). Helicopter Guide to the Single Electricity Market Trading and Settlement Code.

Clifford, E. and M. Clancy (2011). Impact of Wind Generation on Wholesale Electricity Costs in 2011, SEAI, Eirgrid

Dale, L., D. Milborrow, et al. (2004). "Total cost estimates for large-scale wind scenarios in the UK." Energy Policy 32: 1949-1956.

DCENR (2007). Government White Paper: Delivering A Sustainable Energy Future For Ireland

DCENR (2008). All Island Renewable Grid Study - Workstream 2B, “Wind Variability Management Studies”

Denny, E. and M. O'Malley (2006). "Wind generation, power system operation, and emissions reduction." Power Systems, IEEE Transactions on 21(1): 341-347.

Denny, E. and M. O'Malley (2007). "Quantifying the Total Net Benefits of Grid Integrated Wind." Power Systems, IEEE Transactions on 22(2): 605-615.

Denny, E. and M. O'Malley (2009). "The impact of carbon prices on generation-cycling costs." Energy Policy 37(4): 1204-1212.

Devitt, C., S. Diffney, et al. (2008). The Likely Economic Impact of Increasing Investment in Wind on the Island of Ireland, ESRI.

Eirgrid (2011). "Connected Wind Farms - 30 June 2011." EPA. (2009). "Air emissions." from http://www.epa.ie/downloads/pubs/air/airemissions/.

European Commission (2001). "DIRECTIVE 2001/77/EC." Official Journal of the European Union.

European Commission (2009). "DIRECTIVE (2009/28/EC)." Official Journal of the European Union.

European Commission (2009). EU action against climate change: The EU Emissions Trading Scheme

Eurostat. (2011). "Statistics Database." 2010, from http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/portal/page/portal/statistics/search_database.

Felder, F. A. (2011). "Examining Electricity Price Suppression Due to Renewable Resources and Other Grid Investments." The Electricity Journal In Press, Corrected Proof.

Government of Ireland (2008). Building Ireland's Smart Economy - A Framework for Sustainable Economic Renewal. D. o. t. Taoiseach. Dublin.

Holttinen, H., P. Meibom, et al. (2009). Impacts of large amounts of wind power on design and operation of power systems, results of IEA collaboration. 8th International Workshop on Large Scale Integration of Wind Power into Power Systems as well as on Transmission Networks of Offshore Wind Farms, Bremmen.

Indecon (2008). Economic Appraisal of the Potential for Offshore Wind Energy Generation in Ireland.

Kyoto Protocol. (1992). "United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change." Retrieved 30th March 2011, from http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/convkp/kpeng.html.

Milligan, M., E. Ela, et al. (2011). Cost-Causation and integration Cost Analysis for Variable Generation, NREL. Moesgaard, R. and P. E. Morthorst (2008). "The effect of wind power on spot market prices." EWEC.

Murray, B. (2009). Power markets and economics : energy costs, trading, emissions. Chichester, U.K., Wiley.

NERC (2008). Accommodating High Levels of Variable Generation.

NREL (2011). Eastern Wind Integration and Transmission Study.

OFGEM (2011). "Renewables Obligation."

Pöyry (2010). Wind Energy and Electricity Prices - Exploring the 'merit order effect'.

Schneider, M., A. Froggatt, et al. (2011). The World Nuclear Industry Status Report 2010–2011 - Nuclear Power in a Post-Fukushima World, Worldwatch Institute.

SEAI (2009). Energy in Ireland 1990-2008.

SEAI (2010). Renewable Energy in Ireland - 2010 Update.

SEM-O (2010). SEM Trading and Settlement Code.

Sensfuß, F., M. Ragwitz, et al. (2008). "The merit-order effect: A detailed analysis of the price effect of renewable electricity generation on spot market prices in Germany." Energy Policy 36(8): 3086-3094.

Smith, J. C., M. R. Milligan, et al. (2007). "Utility Wind Integration and Operating Impact State of the Art." Power Systems, IEEE Transactions on 22(3): 900-908.

Troy, N., E. Denny, et al. (2010). "Base-Load Cycling on a System With Significant Wind Penetration." Power Systems, IEEE Transactions on 25(2): 1088-1097.

Valeri, L. M. (2009). "Welfare and competition effects of electricity interconnection between Ireland and Great Britain." Energy Policy 37(11): 4679-4688.